SWC Forums
Pull up a chair...let's talk fishing.
Ya know... Fundamental disagreement not an actual problem...
Rec gigs also closes on Oct 16. The group that harvests 10% of southern flounder are being punished.
Cap1, that is precisely while an overwhelming majority net inshore only to supplement their income. It is not sustainable enough to scratch a living out.
Agreed allenj. I have said it before on these threads and will say it again -
modern fisheries practices have far outpaced the ability of the resources to sustain themselves. (We can argue whether or not gill nets are modern or not, but that is not the point here.)
I wish no one would lose their jobs in fisheries reform in NC. BUT, (NC) commercial fishermen will deny to the last fish they had anything to do with the demise of a species.
It's an election year - GO VOTE.
Wow, that was an interesting read that reminds me why I usually don't defend nets. There are a few things in all those posts that I will respond to.
1. Recreational fishermen should NOT be punished with any closure for gigging or catching flounder on a hook and line.
2. Commercial fishermen and seafood consumers SHOULD fund our fair share of stocking efforts.
3. While I would LOVE to take my grandkids to set a spot net later in life, I will leave it to netters to defend their chosen gear. I will continue fighting for our freedom to eat commercially harvested flounder, trout, or any other seafood some may want to make gamefish.
One more thing, hatcheries and habitat enhancement could make our fisheries at least as good as they are in Florida or Louisiana, with or without nets.
Maybe we could follow the model for longlining Golden Tilefish by allowing nets to harvest trout with higher possession limits until 75% of the quota has been landed and then go to a hook and line fishery. This would greatly reduce regulatory discards.
Would you support stocking if we had quotas or only if nets are banned even if the same amount of fish are eaten?
There is a fundamental problem with this type of scenario. Flood the market with as many fish as everyone can catch as quick as possible, and watch the price drop to next to nothing. Why sell our precious resource for pennies on the dollar? So a few guys can make some extra bucks? Nobody's livelihood can survive on that (unless you're surviving without commercial fishing and just supplementing your bank account).
The fact is that most of this fish never end up being consumed by NC residents. I'm all for all citizens having access to fresh seafood, and understand the role commercial fishing plays in that. But the idea that the inshore netters are "feeding the masses" and providing the average NC citizen with food is an absolute farce.
I enjoy reading these threads because of the different opinions and proposed solutions. But the one thing really stands out to me is that everyone has a different idea of a solution, but no one has really identified what the problem is.
Is the problem that there are not enough flounder or trout or reds or stripers?
Is the problem that there are not enough because too many are being killed? Is the problem that too many are being wasted and landings are not accurately reflected?
Is the problem that there are too many people killing too many fish that the population can't keep up?
Is the problem a user group conflict and there are actually plenty of fish?
Step one is clearly identifying what the problem is.
Banning nets, establishing quotas, amping up stocking...all those ideas are attempts at solutions, but until the problem is clearly defined any solution is going to fail.
Make America great again!
Squid Row, I think there are also many different ideas of what the "problem" is..
I think most of the thought behind "get rid of nets" is related to the bycatch/waste issues and the tremendous cost of managing a fishery that requires observers for endangered species interactions.
Another problem is the lack of enforcement in relation to our fisheries. DMF simply doesn't have the manpower or resources to enforce the laws. Plenty of people follow the regulations (both sides), but there are also a few bad apples that know the risk of getting caught is low. Penalties are essentially a slap on the wrist and a small fine, which some have accepted as a cost of doing business. Whats a few hundred dollar fine when the reward for ignoring the law is thousands of dollars? The bust in Wilmington last year is a prime example. Blatant disregard of the law in the name of a profit, and those guys are still fishing today. Does anyone really think they got caught the one and only time they pulled something like that?
Our trip ticket system is outdated and really makes me question the numbers we use in decision making. The only fish counted are the ones sold and recorded through legal, honest transactions. We have no idea what is kept for personal consumption (rec and com) and anything potentially sold off the books. WRC has a pretty modern system for reporting big game harvest that could easily be adopted for our marine fisheries, but there seems to be resistance to this. One can only speculate the reasons..
An interesting read for anyone that hasn't seen it:
https://ncseagrant.ncsu.edu/ncseagrant_docs/products/2010s/supply_chain_analysis_nc_commercial_fishing.pdf
We simply aren't getting the most "bang for our buck" from our fisheries, and I truly believe there is a solution that could benefit both sides.
Icg8978 spot on. The problems you speak of are the reason why the fishery is simply unmanageable with the gill nets in the water. The system is broken. ChrisMcCaffity I agree with most of what you say, but would disagree that we could reach a healthy fishery similar to FL and LA with the nets in the water (unless reduced to an insignificant level like some states). I also believe we should be free too eat fresh seafood. The gill nets don't need to be in the water to do so. We can afford to take all the southern flounder we need with Gigs and Pounds. Why keep allowing the gill nets when they are so destructive and unsustainable?
The provisions passed in the flounder supplement were a step in the right direction, but still the nets are staying in the water. They have to go, they have no place in a modern inshore fishery.
Cantgitright,
Who are you trying to blow smoke at? I know every inshore hole in those same areas you spoke of and to say you still have the same results you had ten years ago is a lie that same commit going back 30 years is a straight to hell lie. The spot runs alone over the last 5 years will tell you that. The limits 30 years ago on flounder were what? See if you can get their now anyone and I mean anyone that has spent that amount of time on the water and can say that things are still the same are nuts. Allen is right and to be honest going back 30 years north of the cape fear had always been better fishing.. The cape fear had larger flounder on avarage but in part I think that was because environment.
Lol prime example why I try not to join you gentlemen in these not catching fish "discussions".... Really not sure any other why to say it David? Just remember as a kid never having a problem catching flounder, and we still don't have any problem catching our limit in this area. As far as spots go,can't speak on them, haven't tried to fish for them since the kids got bigger and got burnt out on fishing for them. Hahaha but believe me friend you won't have to worry about me ''Blowing any more smoke''.... Tight lines
I enjoy reading these threads because of the different opinions and proposed solutions. But the one thing really stands out to me is that everyone has a different idea of a solution, but no one has really identified what the problem is.
Is the problem that there are not enough flounder or trout or reds or stripers?
Is the problem that there are not enough because too many are being killed? Is the problem that too many are being wasted and landings are not accurately reflected?
Is the problem that there are too many people killing too many fish that the population can't keep up?
Is the problem a user group conflict and there are actually plenty of fish?
Step one is clearly identifying what the problem is.
Banning nets, establishing quotas, amping up stocking...all those ideas are attempts at solutions, but until the problem is clearly defined any solution is going to fail.
Great questions Squid Row. Unfortunately, the answer could be yes to all of them at times. Not enough fish and regulatory discards seem to be the biggest issues. What I have learned through many conversations with recreational anglers is that most of them would like to catch and keep more fish. Consumers would like more access to wild-caught American seafood. Quotas, hatcheries, and habitat enhancement are solutions that solve these problems in ways that benefit everyone and the resource.
Cantgitright,
Who are you trying to blow smoke at? I know every inshore hole in those same areas you spoke of and to say you still have the same results you had ten years ago is a lie that same commit going back 30 years is a straight to hell lie. The spot runs alone over the last 5 years will tell you that. The limits 30 years ago on flounder were what? See if you can get their now anyone and I mean anyone that has spent that amount of time on the water and can say that things are still the same are nuts. Allen is right and to be honest going back 30 years north of the cape fear had always been better fishing.. The cape fear had larger flounder on avarage but in part I think that was because environment.
How can anyone north of Wilmington say they are catching fish the same way they did 10-25 years ago?
While I agree the gill nets are destructive the real problem we face is the inshore shrimp trawlers. This is whats killing juvenile fish.
Chris, can please explain how to ethically and responsibly set large mesh flounder net and strike trout as mentioned above?
Discarding patterns are influenced by catch compositions, which in turn are determined by environmental factors, such as recruitment of small fish into the fishery, and social factors, such as limit regulation, CHOICE OF FISHING GEAR and fishermen's behaviour. There have been numerous studies on the scale of discarding. Just contact UNCW, NCSU and even NCDMF.
Why we have "regulatory" discards is that inshore, the gill net is too efficient. These discards are undersized fish, non target species and "regulatory" as in the case of the red drum. Why not go to a hook and line which benefits the population and can sustain a great economical fishery for those that are truly vested? More fish in the water is good for everyone. More fish in the water via hatcheries will never work for ANYONE. Why? Discards. More fish in the water just equates to even more discards via your vision Chris. As it is now, a gentleman puts his large mesh out, goes to bed, picks it up in the morning and goes to work. In most parts of the state right now he can leave nets 24 hours a day, so he can check when he gets off of work. We need gear change in this state, not more gear management. It is time for the gear management and politics to leave the realm of management in NC. Again I ask you to Contact NCWRC and ask them where the hatchery released stripers are going. Again over 90% are being harvest or killed via gill nets. There is your hatchery idea, and it is not working with destructive gear in the water.
Discards are the portion of a catch of fish which is not retained on board during commercial fishing operations and is returned, often dead or dying, to the sea. The practice of discarding is driven by economic and political factors; fish which are discarded are often unmarketable species, individuals which are below minimum landing sizes and catches of species which fishermen are not allowed to land, for instance due to quota restrictions. Discards form part of the bycatch of a fishing operation, although bycatch includes marketable species caught unintentionally. Discarding can be highly variable in time and space as a consequence of changing economic, sociological, environmental and biological factors.[1]