SWC Forums
Pull up a chair...let's talk fishing.
I would have to argue that many rec angler don't just want more to keep and eat. A large portion of the outcry for better management is just people that want more fish in the water. Most recs would sacrifice keeping and eating these fish, if it would better the resource. As Tom Roller said in the WRAL Documentary, Net Effect, "This isn't about me wanting to have more fish to keep, this is about me wanting to have more fish in the water."
What Allen is saying is totally right. Keeping the gears that are doing the most damage in the water and just trying to solve the problem by stocking programs and changing mesh sizes, minimum size limits will do nothing.
It does not matter what I say about how a gill net can be used responsibly. Those who HATE nets will NEVER be happy until they are banned. As I said before, those who choose to use gill nets can defend them.
Why let some people's perception of perfection keep us from doing things that are proven to benefit everyone? Salmon stocking seems to be very popular with netters, consumers, and even recreational anglers. Should we stop stocking salmon because gill nets are used to harvest them for consumers?
Maybe commercial fishermen and consumers should be funding 90% of the striper stocking program if consumers are eating 90% of what is stocked. Would that end the complaints about recreational dollars paying for people to eat stripers?
Regulatory discards would not increase if Hatchery Supported Quotas allow for higher possession limits. It would be stupid to increase the numbers of fish with hatcheries without increasing how many can be kept.
Most guides that focus on catch and release along with anglers who can fish regularly may not care about keeping more fish. The average Joe who only gets to fish a few times each year would like to keep enough seafood to somewhat justify the expense.
Squid:
The problem is that compared to 30 yrs ago, there are more people chasing fish, and there are fewer fish to chase.
The sins of 30 yrs ago are affecting what we do today. Pictures of people with 50 redfish in the boat rotting in the sun...a dozen sailfish on the dock...that kinda junk. Recs and commercials were both guilty of it.
The schism comes now because perception is *most* rec anglers do it for sport and want to take a few fish home for dinner. Nobody brings in a dead billfish out of fear of stink eye. I used to be worse about catching fish, cleaning, packaging, throwing it in the freezer until it spoiled...but now I probably give most of it away to friends while its fresh and best. I despise waste.
Most rec anglers see commercial folk as people who make a living at it and therefore don't give a crap about how they take care of the resource because it matters not if they delay harvest on something now for rebound in the future. They gotta pay the bills *now*. (disclaimer - I think this is perception, and not necessarily reality).
My thoughts: I've got no problem with commercial fishing, but nets (and pots) make me sick because they indiscriminately kill. I wish they made commercial fishing be hook and line / troll and pole / spearfishing....
whatever such that you only got what you were after. It surely wouldn't be as efficient, the price of seafood would go up, but the amount of waste would pretty much disappear.
I've told it many a times on here, but my biggest sickness ever and what made me angrier than ever was surf fishing in Nags Head, having some jerk in a truck and boat come 100 yards past me, then drive his net out in the surf 200 yds and drop it. Leave it, come back the next day, pull it in and piss and moan about how he "didn't get nothing good" out of it. Meanwhile, he's got jumping mullet, bluefish, spots, needlefish, menhaden, and assorted other fish all dead. I spend good money to go the beach, get oceanfront, get nice weather...and some *$^&*$# drops a net beside me, kills all the fish swimming through and then complains about it. Wanna know how to not help your cause from a rec angler? Do that.
And if I see one more damn fish market in NC try to tell me that the grouper and red snapper they're peddling is local caught (at this time of year), I'm gonna strangle the guy behind the counter. But I digress.
Bilzo
Thanks for that detailed reply, but I am going to disagree with one part of your assessment and that is where you mention that most recs want to keep a few for the table and enjoy the sport (paraphrased of course)
I think most recs are out to fill coolers but most recs that participate in online forums are more into the sport aspect of it.
I base this on seeing the number of NC license plates up in VA every year during the croaker run and the number of boats in the water during the spot run. These folks are trying to fill cooler after cooler. Or the guys on the pier or in the surf that keep everything they catch.
Now that does nothing to address the issue, I know but figured I would point that out.
Chris - I have used gill nets inshore and have pulled shrimp nets too. Yes, it was a long time ago, but I still have done it. The ICW and small bodies of water in the southern part of the state just can't handle the efficiency of the gear. Discards are a problem, but just keeping everything caught until the quota is caught is not the answer either. As someone else mentioned it floods the market, drives down the prices and then the fishermen just move on to the next target.
I support the idea of a hook and line fishery for striped bass especially in the ocean. The ocean trawl fishery is one of the most wasteful there is.
Redfish are abundant to the point that even I can catch them so someone on the water with rod and reel could harvest them commercially too. No waste, clean fishery. This is a win-win for everyone involved.
Specks - I have no idea about them. I only catch them by accident the two or three times per year I fish inside
Flounder - pound nets, gigs and ocean trawling can supply all the flounder the seafood consumers of NC can consume.
I can't support the idea of spending the money on hatcheries to supplant commercial landings. If hatcheries are to be used, just raise the fish to the point where they are saleable and farm them.
Anyway, no disrespect intended. This is just my opinion.
Squid - that's fair. I say most. Nothing can be a blanket statement, but it's quite possible you see far more abuse than I do of people taking far more than they need.
Has anyone else noticed the huge increase in boats over the last few decades? So many that the the old private owned single mom & pop ramps, have been replaced with State owned "super ramps". Top of the line boats, gear, ninja faced operators, delivered by super sized diesel chariots. The advent of super electronic (chart plotters, chirp sounders, side scan, interphased this and that) rigged super sleds, has made "captains" out of anyone that can afford them. Go to any fish.com site and the conversation is pretty much always, "how can I catch more". The same "secret spots" (now gone because of google earth and super electronics mentioned previously)and bottom get pounded by way more recreational fishermen than ever before. Am I to accept the notion, that hasn't had a detrimental effect on stocks? An honest look at the time frame of stock reductions coincide with the boom of the tupperware fleet. I have been here for many, many years fishing in different capacities in these waters. Never before has the sheer volume of fish (inshore and offhore), been more accessable and caught by the pure recreational sector. Add with that the loss of nursery habitat, run off issues from domestic and agrcultural intrests that end up right here in the same waters. Many of the same fishermen that trash the commercial guy, want to buy that same commercial license to supplement their rec fishing habit. It Will Never be way it was before, for many reasons. Who is willing to be the first sell their rig and quit fishing all together, to help bring the fishing utopia back ? The "winds of change" (in the name of fisheries management) are coming rapidly to the recreational population, the same arguements will be used very effectively against them. Seriously folks, its coming. Be very careful about what you wish for and the monster you create to get it. Not speaking hate here, just the truth.
Has anyone else noticed the huge increase in boats over the last few decades? So many that the the old private owned single mom & pop ramps, have been replaced with State owned "super ramps". Top of the line boats, gear, ninja faced operators, delivered by super sized diesel chariots. The advent of super electronic (chart plotters, chirp sounders, side scan, interphased this and that) rigged super sleds, has made "captains" out of anyone that can afford them. Go to any fish.com site and the conversation is pretty much always, "how can I catch more". The same "secret spots" (now gone because of google earth and super electronics mentioned previously)and bottom get pounded by way more recreational fishermen than ever before. Am I to accept the notion, that hasn't had a detrimental effect on stocks? An honest look at the time frame of stock reductions coincide with the boom of the tupperware fleet. I have been here for many, many years fishing in different capacities in these waters. Never before has the sheer volume of fish (inshore and offhore), been more accessable and caught by the pure recreational sector. Add with that the loss of nursery habitat, run off issues from domestic and agrcultural intrests that end up right here in the same waters. Many of the same fishermen that trash the commercial guy, want to buy that same commercial license to supplement their rec fishing habit. It Will Never be way it was before, for many reasons. Who is willing to be the first sell their rig and quit fishing all together, to help bring the fishing utopia back ? The "winds of change" (in the name of fisheries management) are coming rapidly to the recreational population, the same arguements will be used very effectively against them. Seriously folks, its coming. Be very careful about what you wish for and the monster you create to get it. Not speaking hate here, just the truth.
As always very well said.
You just put my thoughts into understandable words
And with the increased number of boats, improved technology, better ramps, etc. the rec. bag limits have taken a severe nose dive.
Wildcard, i understand what you are saying but there is a huge flaw. The states south of us have even more pressure and more "ninja" faced super boats than we have here. They do not have the problem we have here. This problem here was not caused by the rec. Sector. And since it is illegal to comm harvest speck/reds/stripers and sell with a rod and reel, who are these ninja faces warriors selling their catches? You argument while well thought out, does not hold water.
Wildcard, i understand what you are saying but there is a huge flaw. The states south of us have even more pressure and more "ninja" faced super boats than we have here. They do not have the problem we have here. This problem here was not caused by the rec. Sector. And since it is illegal to comm harvest speck/reds/stripers and sell with a rod and reel, who are these ninja faces warriors selling their catches? You argument while well thought out, does not hold water.
There was more to my post than ninjas. Did you happen to see the part about urban and agricultural run off, or loss of nursery area. Will not get into a pissing match with you, I know where you stand as well as you know where I stand. I cannot speak for your backyard, but the Pamlico, Albermarle, not to mention coastal and offshore area I have fished in for the last few weeks has suffered from all of the above that I stated. I know there has always been and will be groups that say "not me". Try being objective and not defensive Capt, there in lays the problem.
Just for conversation, look at the uproar surrounding The Army Corps of Engineers releasing brown sugar water into the Gulf and East coast of Florida. Thats pretty much what has been happening in this huge nursery/esturine system for many years now. My point is that its not, just one thing. The truth is that some areas that cause damage to an overall fishery will not be condemed (much less stopped by the powers that be), fishermen regardless of rec/comm are the easiest group to regulate and control. By doing that those powers that be, keep their career/agenda wheels greased.
Seeing how my point of view won't hold water, has there ever been a time when more wahoo, dolphin, cobia, king makeral, Spanish makeral, etc...... Have been caught in our Coastal waters? If you don't think the powers that be aren't taking note, read about the recent push for cobia closures. There has been in the last few years talk about dolphin and wahoo reductions. We had our blueline tile fishery shut down last year (just like black seabass), just because. Its an overall picture I am trying to convey. No arguement, just thought (it's what happens when the weather is nasty and I can't fish).
I agree on the runoff, but the whole more boat thing does not hold water at all. I see 4x more boats in the other states I fish and the fishing is a lot better. Sorry if post come off offensive/defensive. Recs are the problem here with our fisheries, hook and line is not the problem.
Specifically talking inshore problems here. You don't have to look at Florida either, look at what is happening here in NC at Blounts creek.
Wildcard, i understand what you are saying but there is a huge flaw. The states south of us have even more pressure and more "ninja" faced super boats than we have here. They do not have the problem we have here. This problem here was not caused by the rec. Sector. And since it is illegal to comm harvest speck/reds/stripers and sell with a rod and reel, who are these ninja faces warriors selling their catches? You argument while well thought out, does not hold water.
There was more to my post than ninjas. Did you happen to see the part about urban and agricultural run off, or loss of nursery area. Will not get into a pissing match with you, I know where you stand as well as you know where I stand. I cannot speak for your backyard, but the Pamlico, Albermarle, not to mention coastal and offshore area I have fished in for the last few weeks has suffered from all of the above that I stated. I know there has always been and will be groups that say "not me". Try being objective and not defensive Capt, there in lays the problem.
The problem with fishing in North Carolina is not runoff or fishing ninjas...... Being objective to scientific data and research is just being ignorant or maybe saying nothing to see here, move along. Unfortunately our DMF is setup to sustain commercial fishing, NOT to sustain fish in NC waters like it should be doing.
Allen, it's all good here. Blounts Creek and the Pamlico/Tar River are a great case in point.
Heelsfan, scientific data and fish studies mean nothing, when you are looking at a huge area of dead flounders that were killed because of a chemical spill. By the way, the scientists didn't show up back then or for future reported events. Turning a "blind eye" is not in my DNA. Its a shame when you can look at a problem (and dead fish caused by that problem) and just because you are a "stupid fisherman" your concerns aren't heard. I have been told to move along quite abit by the powers that be over the last 35 years or so. Pretty hard to argue with a guy that lives out there and see's it, unless you just like to argue for whatever reason. Like I stated before, not hate, truth.