SWC Forums

Pull up a chair...let's talk fishing.

Notifications
Clear all

Inshore Nets

205 Posts
52 Users
0 Reactions
8,045 Views
Will
 Will
(@)
Eminent Member
Joined: 11 years ago
Posts: 35
 

The Mississippi River is polluted to another order of magnitude when compared to our waters here, yet there are plenty of trout, flounder and drum in LA. Water quality is not the issue. Nothing is happening in NC on a scale as large as the Lake O discharges in Florida. There, it is the entire agricultural industry's runoff and discharge from Lake O through just two narrow rivers straight to the East and West coast instead of allowing the water to slowly make its way to the Gulf of Mexico, Florida bay and Atlantic Ocean through the Everglades system. Nowhere in NC have we experienced something to that scale.



   
ReplyQuote
Jim Bickerstaff
(@sobachka)
Estimable Member
Joined: 18 years ago
Posts: 222
 

This is an enlightening discussion and it is easy to have empathy for both sides. I am a rec fisherman myself but have tried my hand at "playing" com fisherman in my lifetime and I can state without reservation that nobody ever chose to get on a shrimp boat to make easy money. It is as hard a day as any I have ever worked.

There are solutions and compromises that must be found before we are all out there fighting over one fish. There is no doubt that some species are severely depleted but if you think we can't recover, take a look at the redfish. I know com gigger friends that complain about too many red schools clouding up the good flounder flats. That fish was almost gone from southern waters when I was in my 20s.

I submit we stop looking in the past, searching for who is to blame. We all own a piece of this problem and all of us owning a piece of the solution is the only way we get it fixed. As a rec, I am willing to go with a limit of 1 or 2 flatties or trout for a few years, a few spots or VA mullet. I would even consider a few years of catch and release on over-fished species. I would not like it because we eat our catch in my family but I am willing to literally take food off the plates of my family if that is what it takes. That is a consistent position of the com community, that limiting commercial fishing methods takes food off the plates of their families and it is a valid argument. It may also be a necessary evil if we ever want to return to some version of "plenty for all."

-------------------------

I want to add that I believe every one of us took up fishing somewhere deep in our souls ... maybe it was the thrill of watching a bluegill tug a cork under water or possibly the frustration of setting the hook too early on a doormat flounder and ending up with a scaled finger mullet who was thrilled to be back in the boat with you. (yes, they are all doormats when they get away). There is a brotherhood* in that genesis that outweighs the bounty in any net or cooler. I feel that pull every time I set out on the water at dawn and the sun is rising over the marshes, having the freedom to turn my boat right or maybe left, with nobody to tell me I can't. And knowing that whatever I brought home was obtained solely on where I chose to stop and drop my bait ... along with a little luck!

* and sisterhood



   
ReplyQuote
Will
 Will
(@)
Eminent Member
Joined: 11 years ago
Posts: 35
 

We as recs already have taken a huge decrease in our limits. I don't care to keep much, but I don't blame recs that do. No reason to decrease rec limits further seeing that the rec portion of the harvest is much much less. Nets need to go, they harvest more than half of the fish and have the worst waste. The fishery is unmanageable with them in the water... Too many problems with the gear and the system.



   
ReplyQuote
Chris McCaffity
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 15 years ago
Posts: 1424
 

We as recs already have taken a huge decrease in our limits. I don't care to keep much, but I don't blame recs that do. No reason to decrease rec limits further seeing that the rec portion of the harvest is much much less. Nets need to go, they harvest more than half of the fish and have the worst waste. The fishery is unmanageable with them in the water... Too many problems with the gear and the system.

Recs have had too many bag limit reductions and don't need any more. That doesn't mean that consumers shouldn't have equal access to our public resources. Isn't it wasteful for thousands of sportsmen to collectively catch and discard hundreds of thousands of fish using baits with names like D.O.A or having multiple barbed hooks? What about all the undersized or oversized fish discarded in the middle of summer when mortality rates skyrocket due to high water temps and low oxygen levels? Wildcard wisely warned about creating a monster to remove nets because it WILL turn on you eventually. Hatcheries and habitat enhancement are the only solutions that allow everyone to keep more while protecting the resource for future generations. The path we are on now will only lead to the continued erosion of everyone's freedom to fish and eat American seafood until nobody can harm any marine life for food or fun.



   
ReplyQuote
Capt. Chris Medlin
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 23 years ago
Posts: 1073
 

Chris you seem to have a "Chicken Little" mentality. Can you show anywhere that the above scenario has happened? Nets have been banned in Florida, Louisiana, Texas. Other states have extremely restricted them. All of those states have a thriving recreational and commercial industry. Florida, louisiana and texas all send more seafood to market than NC.



   
ReplyQuote
Will
 Will
(@)
Eminent Member
Joined: 11 years ago
Posts: 35
 

Chris, you must think that nobody will be able to eat seafood if gill nets are banned? LOL We can harvest all the flounder we need commercially with sustainable gigs and pounds. Also what about commercial hook and line harvest? It's done in other states and is very successful.

Your argument about recs discarding fish... Yes proper handling of fish is very important, but do you see TX, LA, AL, MS, FL, GA or SC having issues? They have lots of recs catching lots of fish and no nets. They also have better fisheries.

Also, fish entangled in gill nets sit there for anywhere from hours to a whole day or more BEFORE they are even handled by the fisherman. Thinking that rec discard mortality even touches that of gill net discard mortality is ridiculous.

Where on Earth did you come up with the idea that banning nets would take away someone's "right" to eat seafood?



   
ReplyQuote
Will
 Will
(@)
Eminent Member
Joined: 11 years ago
Posts: 35
 

Sorry I know some of those states have limited gill netting so stating that they all have ZERO nets is false, of course. No other southeastern state has gill netting on a scale that touches what we have here in NC.



   
ReplyQuote
Kenneth
(@matador)
Famed Member
Joined: 17 years ago
Posts: 3641
 

Fisheries "chicken littles" and global warming "chicken littles" are functionally the same.



   
ReplyQuote
Chris McCaffity
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 15 years ago
Posts: 1424
 

The slow erosion of our freedom to fish and eat American seafood takes time. Florida started with a net ban and gamefish status for some seafood. That was not enough for some sportsmen, now they want sportsfish status to make it illegal for even recreational anglers to eat some of the fish they catch. Once the food value is taken from fish, it will not be long before groups like PETA start pushing for a ban on catching and discarding fish just for fun. NOAA has already declared that many recreational fisheries will only be catch and release within the next decade due to projected dead discards.

My previous post was not about defending nets as much as a response to BountyHunter's assertion that it was a bad thing for consumers to eat half the fish that are landed. Are nets really what you guys have a problem with or the perception that American citizens eat more NC seafood than you want them to? Why not just make more seafood for everyone to enjoy if there is not enough for everyone now?

As for the chicken little claim, who would have thought there would be a push to ban all bottomfishing from 98' of water out to 200 miles offshore? Don't think there aren't powerful people out there who want to ban almost all fishing just as bad as some of you want to ban nets.



   
ReplyQuote
Duane
(@rdnkvet)
Noble Member
Joined: 16 years ago
Posts: 1403
 

Hatcheries and habitat enhancement are the only solutions that allow everyone to keep more while protecting the resource for future generations.

Your solutions have merit. However, you can not enhance the habitat if there is a net sitting there in the nurseries to kill the juvenile fish that you are trying to "enhance" and call it "bycatch". Move the nets out into the ocean if you must net. Continuing to allow nets to be used in the current manner is destroying the resource for EVERYONE, rec and comm! I don't find the argument that tactics the recs use to catch fish are just as damaging to the resource. Many more survive those tactics than survive a net. At least a fish has a "choice" to bite that hook or not.



   
ReplyQuote
Will
 Will
(@)
Eminent Member
Joined: 11 years ago
Posts: 35
 

Where did I say that it is "a bad thing for consumers to eat half the fish that are landed?" What people like me want is abundant fisheries. I don't care if someone wants to eat a flounder, as long as the fishery is in good shape... Right now the problem is our fisheries are NOT in good shape. The most effective thing we can do is remove unsustainable, destructive gear!

It's not about me or others like me wanting to prevent people from eating a flounder fillet... It's about us wanting to have fish in the water for generations to come...



   
ReplyQuote
Will
 Will
(@)
Eminent Member
Joined: 11 years ago
Posts: 35
 

It seems that you are trying to draw a connection between wanting to remove gill nets from the fishery and eroding our freedom to eat seafood. That is not what we want. By reading your argument, I suppose you would agree with the Seagull that a gill net ban is a failure of fisheries management?



   
ReplyQuote
Bryce
(@)
Trusted Member
Joined: 18 years ago
Posts: 79
 

You can't think that most of the fish served in our restaurants is from NC.
It's farm raised or imported.
To think that recreational fishing is more destructive than commercial fishing is comical. Please go out in the Pamlico sound and find a shrimp boat and watch them bring the nets in. That's a month worth of recreational waste in one haul. I don't hate commercial fishing, but to think this is a sustainable resource with current practices is just not true. In the end this will end badly for the mom and pop fishing operations, and the Styrons and Daniels of the world will just move the operations to South America and continue to make millions.



   
ReplyQuote
zigzag
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 22 years ago
Posts: 1863
 

Where did I say that it is "a bad thing for consumers to eat half the fish that are landed?" What people like me want is abundant fisheries. I don't care if someone wants to eat a flounder, as long as the fishery is in good shape... Right now the problem is our fisheries are NOT in good shape. The most effective thing we can do is remove unsustainable, destructive gear!

It's not about me or others like me wanting to prevent people from eating a flounder fillet... It's about us wanting to have fish in the water for generations to come...

we need to end all indiscriminate fishing, the commercial side should be allowed to hook and line, 2 years, you'd see a big difference.



   
ReplyQuote
Will
 Will
(@)
Eminent Member
Joined: 11 years ago
Posts: 35
 

Zigzag... you sir, understand! Definitely would only take a couple years. 5-10 years, without a doubt the fishing would be phenomenal compared to what it is now!



   
ReplyQuote
Page 9 / 14
Share: