SWC Forums

Pull up a chair...let's talk fishing.

Notifications
Clear all

Where have the red drum gone...??

101 Posts
30 Users
0 Reactions
4,225 Views
Chris McCaffity
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 15 years ago
Posts: 1424
 

One of the reasons I oppose JEA is that it is needed to implement the Catch Share scam that would hurt recreational and independent commercial fishermen.

My vision for Hatchery Supported Quotas is that both sectors would have the option of funding an equal share of what could be stocked. Then each sector could decide how their fair share would be managed. This would give recreational fishermen the freedom to catch and keep more fish.

Any costs to commercial fishermen would ultimately be passed on to the consumer which is why I like the idea of a 1% restocking fee on seafood sales. This would give the consumers that vastly outnumber recreational and commercial fishermen a stake in preserving their freedom to access local seafood.

Coastal colleges and universities along with NC Aquariums could help with stocking efforts.

Just because other states have or haven't done something doesn't mean we should or shouldn't. We should think about how to deal with our reality in ways that provide as many positive benefits and few negative impacts as possible for all NC citizens. We should set an example for how to wisely use enhancement tools that increase recreational opportunity and seafood production. We should also set an example for making full use of all harvested seafood by processing scraps into feed for land based aquaculture.



   
ReplyQuote
Jamie Cole
(@olsaltydog)
Trusted Member
Joined: 15 years ago
Posts: 83
 

Ok just so I could understand what you are promoting. Say recs pay to stock 100k fish and com's pay to stock 100k also. How would this work in your scenario. Would these quotas you speak of be 100k only or the 100k plus additional wild caught fish.



   
ReplyQuote
Davis Barnes
(@)
Eminent Member
Joined: 13 years ago
Posts: 19
 

Chris,
Sorry,but I am still confused about the right of consumers to fresh wild caught local seafood. Can you help me out? Where does this right come from? Is it different than the rights of other consumers in other states? Does it supersede the importance of maintaining a public resource in a responsible manner?

Just because something has not been done in other states does not mean it should or should not be done here. It is useful to know if something has been successful,and whether it might be applicable in any given situation.

The use of quotas and hatcheries may be useful, however a simple and effective fix is available. It will not be possible to fix at all if something is not done soon. Other states have survived these changes, and I don't doubt NC can as well.



   
ReplyQuote
george mc donald
(@)
Reputable Member
Joined: 17 years ago
Posts: 374
 

Ok just so I could understand what you are promoting. Say recs pay to stock 100k fish and com's pay to stock 100k also. How would this work in your scenario. Would these quotas you speak of be 100k only or the 100k plus additional wild caught fish.

So answer me this ;if recs pay for 100k fish and comms pay for 100k fish we'll be even steven , but by method of harvesting recs can only remove lets say 20% while comms can continue to harvest limitless #s if left with no additional restrictions or methods , which also does nothing to address the by-catch loss which is hugh under current situation :wall:



   
ReplyQuote
Jamie Cole
(@olsaltydog)
Trusted Member
Joined: 15 years ago
Posts: 83
 

Well 12ga, that is why I am asking. Either I am not following the process he is laying out or I am following it and I see this proposal as really being only beneficial to commercial fisherman. I'm open to his ideas but I cannot support them in any capacity but maybe if I am misunderstanding it, then some light being shed won't hurt.



   
ReplyQuote
Tim Coggins
(@)
Estimable Member
Joined: 11 years ago
Posts: 124
 

We all eat chickens, cows, pigs, etc raised on a farm. We need to eat seafood raised on a farm. It does not seem right that you are allowed to eat wild seafood if you do not go out and catch it or have someone give it to you. If you want to eat a deer you go out and shoot it or have someone do it for you. Most all wildlife is not for sale and that is the way it should be with wild seafood. If we did this our fishery would be great with the correct limits. Our limits where to high back years ago. We all kept to many fish. If it got to be to many fish then do something to keep it good, not go out and remove most all of them. We are all killing our fishery. Maybe we all need to stay off the water for 3 to 5 years and change the way we do things. It is not working the way we are doing it. It has been getting worse each decade and is just about gone in NC. When you tell young guys we use to catch 5 to 10 limits of fish and show photos on most of our fishing trips they just shake there heads at how it is now.



   
ReplyQuote
Tim Coggins
(@)
Estimable Member
Joined: 11 years ago
Posts: 124
 

We all eat chickens, cows, pigs, etc raised on a farm. We need to eat seafood raised on a farm. It does not seem right that you are allowed to eat wild seafood if you do not go out and catch it or have someone give it to you. If you want to eat a deer you go out and shoot it or have someone do it for you. Most all wildlife is not for sale and that is the way it should be with wild seafood. If we did this our fishery would be great with the correct limits. Our limits where to high back years ago. We all kept to many fish. If it got to be to many fish then do something to keep it good, not go out and remove most all of them. We are all killing our fishery. Maybe we all need to stay off the water for 3 to 5 years and change the way we do things. It is not working the way we are doing it. It has been getting worse each decade and is just about gone in NC. When you tell young guys we use to catch 5 to 10 limits of fish and show photos on most of our fishing trips they just shake there heads at how it is now.



   
ReplyQuote
Chris McCaffity
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 15 years ago
Posts: 1424
 

Ok just so I could understand what you are promoting. Say recs pay to stock 100k fish and com's pay to stock 100k also. How would this work in your scenario. Would these quotas you speak of be 100k only or the 100k plus additional wild caught fish.

There should be two separate quotas. One Naturally Occurring Quota and one Hatchery Supported Quota for each species and sector.

The first step should be to establish Naturally Occurring Quotas that end overfishing.

The next step should be for fishery managers to determine how many of each species can be stocked and what percentage of releases at various sizes could be harvested as adults. This would be the potential Hatchery Supported Quotas that should be independent of Naturally Occurring Quotas. The recreational and commercial sectors would each have the option of funding half of potential HSQs. The commercial sector could not harvest recreational quota and recs couldn't exceed their quotas. If we stock drum, flounder, trout, spot, herring, and crabs along some other species, we will have much better fisheries in a few years. Stocking seafood lower on the food chain would benefit everything up the chain that eats them.

Think about how much land it would take to produce the amount of seafood that nature makes. Our coastal and offshore waters could produce much more than they do now if we make wise use of hatcheries and habitat enhancements. This could be the perfect blend of open-water aquaculture and wild-caught seafood that lives free and self-sufficient until harvested. We could create more recreational opportunity while helping to sustainably feed a growing population in an environmentally friendly way.



   
ReplyQuote
Jamie Cole
(@olsaltydog)
Trusted Member
Joined: 15 years ago
Posts: 83
 

I am sorry Chris, but it looks like it would be more beneficial to not only the wild resource but the seafood consumer to just take your idea and apply it as aquaculture operations in the state.

Doesn't take that much more land to produce food in land than in the water. The technology has been growing and being refined for years with closed circulation systems being used to reduce facility footprint. Like it or not, our nation, our world, is going to see a ever increasing demand for aquaculture with growth rates that very few industries are seeing. Do we as a state rich in history of providing seafood standby and let places like TN, KY, OK, and other states with not even a drop of saltwater to their name pass us by or do we jump into the arena and continue to lead by growing our own aquaculture industry and technology?

About the only thing we agree on is getting a hand on our resources now before it is too late. We may disagree on how to get there but nothing is going to change my view. I want to see gillnets gone, I want to see trawlers gone from our inshore waters. I want to see recs pull into a boat ramp with several fish in the cooler and them not each be a different species because they can only keep one of each. Recs, first and foremost are the active owners of the public resource because they are from the public, consumers are merely inactive recs without a current license.



   
ReplyQuote
george mc donald
(@)
Reputable Member
Joined: 17 years ago
Posts: 374
 

Roger that on the nets and trawlers Salty..Was fishing up a winding creek on Oak Is. years ago and as tide was about 1/2 going out I decided to head to ICW only to find that while i'm out of sight up the creek a netter spread the entire mouth of creek. 😡 Another time on topsail is. some netters launched a skiff from surf and encircled my dad and uncle and me. 😡 again!!! Miles of beach and they had to launch where we were already set up :huh:



   
ReplyQuote
Chris McCaffity
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 15 years ago
Posts: 1424
 

I started fishing at a young age with an older neighbor who would tell me about how great the fishing was when he was young. His stories made me wish it could be that way again. It can be better without hurting other people. I am not defending the bad behavior of some commercial fishermen but there are many good people who's families would suffer from drastic actions aimed at destroying their jobs. We should have compassion for our fellow man even if they don't deserve it. All of us have fallen short at times and don't really deserve to be as blessed as we are. Please don't let anger harden your hearts and think about how you would like to be treated if the roles were reversed. Thank you for the polite discussion even if we will have to respectfully agree to disagree.



   
ReplyQuote
Jamie Cole
(@olsaltydog)
Trusted Member
Joined: 15 years ago
Posts: 83
 

Don't act as if we have animosity towards these men and their families. We don't, but we are not going to keep allowing these individuals to operate in a system that has a negative impact on our resources. Poor resources negatively affects us all, not just them and getting them switched to another gear, another industry now, not later, when they are capable instead of being nickle and dimed to death by decimated stocks later is the best and most compassionate option. Industries change all the time, there is no reason to hold onto the past just because some refuse to change.

My job is a contractor and we do 5 years contracts. Guess what, every 5 years when the contracts come up for negotiation I don't know if I will have a job or not two or three weeks down the line. I don't now if I will be making the same money as I do now or if I will have my pay cut in half. I don't know if my benefits will still be company provided or not (there not now since last contract change). We all have uncertainty, jobs are not guaranteed, but the will and determination to face uncertainty and continuing to do what must be done for my family separates myself from many others. These individuals have my sympathy, but that sympathy does not change my views.



   
ReplyQuote
jonathan
(@jward87)
Estimable Member
Joined: 14 years ago
Posts: 120
 

Does anyone of yall even know how a gillnet work my God yall think everything that swims gets killed in a gillnet. I see so many people complain theyes can't catch a fish, they in to learn how to fish I saw a man at sunset beach in the middle of the icw like he was bass fishing. There is less commercial fisherman now than there was 30 years ago, and probably 20 times as many recreational fisherman. I gillnet for flounder and I can't tell you how many times we catch a 10 to 13 inch flounder with gig holes in him if you commercial fishing you can look and tell how big a flounder is. Yall complain about gillnet blocking the mouth of creeks what's the difference in a dock being in the channel if anyone from tubbs inlet the new dock they built you know what I'm talking about.



   
ReplyQuote
glenn shivar
(@)
Reputable Member
Joined: 14 years ago
Posts: 245
 

Please move this thread to the fisheries tab. This thread never was a fishing report.



   
ReplyQuote
Nick
 Nick
(@seapro180)
Honorable Member
Joined: 11 years ago
Posts: 543
 

Does anyone of yall even know how a gillnet work my God yall think everything that swims gets killed in a gillnet. I see so many people complain theyes can't catch a fish, they in to learn how to fish I saw a man at sunset beach in the middle of the icw like he was bass fishing. There is less commercial fisherman now than there was 30 years ago, and probably 20 times as many recreational fisherman. I gillnet for flounder and I can't tell you how many times we catch a 10 to 13 inch flounder with gig holes in him if you commercial fishing you can look and tell how big a flounder is. Yall complain about gillnet blocking the mouth of creeks what's the difference in a dock being in the channel if anyone from tubbs inlet the new dock they built you know what I'm talking about.

Oh look everyone!! All of us idiots must have missed the memo about gill nets. Aparently, they have signs on them for the fish to read that lets them know that the particular net they swim up to is not intended for them. Drum swims up to a net intended for trout, reads sign that says, "INTENDED FOR TROUT ONLY. ALL OTHER SPECIES TURN AROUND NOW" hmmm, i guess i have been wrong this whole time :duh:

To your comment about gill nets blocking an entire creek mouth, you compared a dock blocking the channel. Hahaha :wtf: you clearly missed something. The two have nothing in common unless docks are now catching fish too. Must have missed that memo as well. He was saying the net occupies the whole creek which makes it virtually impossible for anything to escape unless to small to get caught in the net. Has nothing to do with navigation...

I have set and used gill nets with the state and federal gvt for research purposes more times than i care to think and am very well educated on them and how they work. Obviously we dont think they kill everything that swims like you said we do. So with your absolutely usless bantering comment, please explain to us idiots why you think gill nets have no affect on our fisheries. Please do so with some kind of backing or an actual reason that even somewhat makes sense unlike your last post which was pure banter.



   
ReplyQuote
Page 6 / 7
Share: