SWC Forums
Pull up a chair...let's talk fishing.
Your promoting solutions and giving examples to areas where those solutions are not working the way you believe they are. Stocking is a great tool, but it has not worked well when used in areas subjected to two user groups. I would like to believe it would be a solution but reality says it will do more to cover issues then resolve issues in our fisheries.
Your promoting solutions and giving examples to areas where those solutions are not working the way you believe they are. Stocking is a great tool, but it has not worked well when used in areas subjected to two user groups. I would like to believe it would be a solution but reality says it will do more to cover issues then resolve issues in our fisheries.
Are you suggesting that the solution is only allowing one user group to access our public resources? If so, which group and why?
No, my view is to resolve the issues first. Then we can concern ourselves with methods of enhancement, not utilize methods of enhancement to resolve our current visible issue.
If i was ever to propose our resources going to one user group it would obviously be to the recs. The same reasoning our wildlife managers did away with market hunters, but I am not recommending that. Poundnets/giggers are sufficient for flounder fisheries inshore and Shrimp trawling in the ocean. These are not draconian measures by any means but are often faught against as if they are the end of the world.
Wouldn't appropriate quotas for each sector be the first step to stabilizing the fishery and resolving that issue before working on enhancement?
Nope, quotas are only good for guaranteeing users a portion of harvest. It does nothing to make the fishery cleaner, more selective, or efficient. It only addresses one species at a time with adjustments made to the quotas for that individual species. We need resolutions that consider not just primary targeted species but bycatch species as well.
Recs need more accurate data, commercials need more selective and efficient gear. Quantity of harvest, which is quotas, should not be an objective.
Salty ; I agree , only additional things i'd like to see is a much greater LEO presence and much harsher penalties on both Rec. and Comm . violators...
No pain,no fear== no compliance and eventually no fishery. 😡
6 hours last weekend I fished 1 small red. Slow trolled four flounder rigs two miles up and down icw.. then 1/2 mile up and down my favorite creek 4 times Hope these storms will go away so I can head to morehead next weekend. Soon I hope the spots and mullet start running. On a lighter note I have done good with the black drum for a couple of weeks. Kinda got tired of them
Looks like the choice is clear. We can use proven management tools to secure more fish, food, and freedom for future generations or go with stricter enforcement of more arbitrary regulations without clear goals and industrial fish farming in public waters.
Option 1 sounds good, but it is a lie. Option 2 is also a lie but uses fear tactics to elicit a response towards option 1.
Option 1 sounds good, but it is a lie. Option 2 is also a lie but uses fear tactics to elicit a response towards option 1.
You really don't think we could enhance our fisheries and food supply in a way that promotes freedom?
You really don't think we could see federalized LEOs enforcing more laws that are written without clear goals or global corporations farming fish in public waters?
Both are very real possibilities. Why shouldn't we at least try the path that leads to more food and freedom first?
Enhance our food supply in a way that promotes Freedom? I'm sorry, it sounds good but that cannot in any way be a reality. If freedom to you is charging more in taxes or other fees then we have two distinct definitions. By all means if there is a way to enhance the fishery while costing citizens nothing then I am all ears. Anything more than that is not promoting freedom. It is disguising itself among the guise of freedom of choice.
Are you talking about JEA agreement?
I also don't agree with allowing Cooke aquaculture to come in and set up shop either, look what they just did up in the pacific. But I have no issue with expanding bottom leasing permits to those growing and harvesting oysters, clams, etc. I would also like to see much more investments made by the state to expand on land based aquaculture farms.
I am not sure how NC allowing an outdated and harmful method of fishing is equated with Freedom. There are times when change is necessary, and people need to change their ways, find better, less destructive methods of doing their jobs, or find different jobs. Freedom to abuse our resource is not guaranteed.
I am not sure where this idea that people have a right to "Fresh Local Seafood" comes from. Is North Carolina responsible for ensuring this right by allowing methods of fishing that have been outlawed in all other states (with the exception of Miss.)?
I am not sure the politicians in this state are capable of making the correct choices for the majority of users of this resource. It seems there are some powerful interests that have a hold on the decision making process.
I am sure that the number or Red Drum I catch is dramatically reduced by the nets that got up in the intercoastal bays and creeks.
I am sure that until the recreational fishermen find a way to come together and take some form of action there will not be any change.
Wouldn't state investments in land based aquaculture require tax dollars?
The consumer share of Hatchery Supported Quotas could be funded with commercial license fees and Saltonstall/Kennedy grants along with a realignment of management priorities.
I was referring to JEA in regards to federalizing LEOs.
I am not saying we shouldn't look for better ways of harvesting seafood.
I am sure recs could catch more drum if it was illegal for the largest user group to eat them, even if they only get a small portion of the Total Allowable Catch.
I am simply saying recreational and commercial fishermen along with seafood consumers could all benefit from focusing more on enhancing our fisheries and food supply than restricting the public's freedom to access them.
Thats one of the issues I have with your proposal. Don't get me wrong I think you are doing what you think is best for everyone and I commend you for that and wish you the best.
My issue is that the only individuals who gain from hatcheries are the commercial fisherman. You can increase their fees 10 fold but they will pass the cost increases off to the customers no different then farmers and others do when they see increased fees. They are never actually the ones to pay the fee, they pass it off to the customer. So what your saying is, the people buying seafood will spend more on local caught seafood, while recreational fisherman will spend more to catch them, and coms go about their business. That is not freedom, that's playing the same user unfriendly model the farming industry has been using.
I have supported JEA since it was initially discussed, many other have as well. The State has not, and many commercial opposed it as well. We are the only state without it, and I get why some are against it, but it is actually needed.
State can invest in many ways without increasing taxes or other fees. Giving tax breaks to companies moving into aquaculture is one method they could use. Give grants that are already being giving to colleges like Carteret Community, NC State, and others that are already involved in programs teaching about aquaculture to team up with individuals looking to start these operations would be another avenue. Not only could you grow a field that is increasing in demand, but you are also benefiting schools, students and future employees who will undoubtedly return that investment to the state in no time.
Chris, I am not sure if you are responding to my post, but I don't understand "the largest user group" concept. The amount of seafood supplied by gill netters is a drop in the bucket for consumers (which is what I think you are calling "The largest user group"), but the whole bucket for recreational fishermen. The largest user group will also be without that catch when the resource has been destroyed.
You are saying we shouldn't look for better ways of harvesting. Doing away with gill nets and other harmful techniques is a step in the right direction, and little can be done without that step. It is not restricting anyone's "freedom "to make changes in rules that are beneficial to the resource, if we don't make changes, it won't matter, the resource will be gone, and everyone will have the freedom to look for a different way to make a living.
What states have gone down the path of "enhancing our fisheries and food supply", rather than restructuring rules and regulations to benefit consumers, commercial and recreational fishermen? Have they been successful?