SWC Forums
Pull up a chair...let's talk fishing.
I have no problem with denying "seafood consumers" access to our public trust resources, myself included, if it's what is right for the resource. Aside from us fortunate enough to live at the coast, most of our state does not have access to them anyways. We ship most of our seafood out of state for wholesale prices, and leave the imported crap for those west of highway 17.
Nobody in NC is "feeding the masses" through commercial fishing, but a few are feeding their wallets at the expense of the rest of us.
Fish alive in the water for future generations are more important than fish on anyone's plate today.
I have no problem with denying "seafood consumers" access to our public trust resources, myself included, if it's what is right for the resource. Aside from us fortunate enough to live at the coast, most of our state does not have access to them anyways. We ship most of our seafood out of state for wholesale prices, and leave the imported crap for those west of highway 17.
Nobody in NC is "feeding the masses" through commercial fishing, but a few are feeding their wallets at the expense of the rest of us.
Fish alive in the water for future generations are more important than fish on anyone's plate today.
You make a good point about people living west of 17 not having as much access to local seafood as they should. That is something I personally try to help with by being part of a co-op that connects inland consumers to seafood harvested by independent commercial fishermen. That concept along with some Community Seafood Processing Facilities would help keep more NC seafood in NC. Those processing facilities could also clean recreational catches and make full use of all scraps.
As for fish being alive in the water for future generations, establishing quotas to avoid overfishing achieves that goal.
Hatcheries and habitat enhancement along with improved processing and distribution capabilities could provide much more seafood for NC citizens while supporting more recreational pressure. Fishermen could help "feed the masses" in NC when something disrupts our corporate food supply if we plan ahead.
We can have healthy fisheries and local seafood forever if we practice proven solutions and the Golden Rule.
I agree with RonJon. I just hope something changes. Look at the SC, GA, and FL. Do they have this problem? No
But as for the folks who can't find any drum, you might want to hire guides to take you as there seem to be lots of them around and the problem might be you suck at fishing.
I don't suck at fishing & am having a hard time catching Reds.
Sight fish for them, maybe 3 times a week, sometimes more.
Found a large school of Reds one day the, the next day there's a netter all over them.
Have found small dead sharks with net marks in the same area. And have not seen that school again.
Coincident? I don't think so. ....... ICM
Since everyone around you is having a great year catching drum when they try, you might want to investigate teaming up with them or a guide.
There are some bad actors when it comes to nets and I see them as well on occasion. I do find it fascinating that folks find large schools of fish during times of the year when they aren't schooling and I always wonder why a netter targets a species that he has to have large numbers of other fish to claim his bycatch allotment
All these guys are not having great years here in NC. They are talking out there A$$. I have friends on the Gulf that catch 80 to 100 reds in 1/2 day. Others catch 200 specks per boat. Some 25 to 30" specks. Guys say they are doing good with 15 to 20 flounder. I took one trip to Virginia and caught 90 flounder over 17" in 5 hours in my boat and had never fished the spot before. A great day is catching 8 to 10 times your limit. Does not happen here in NC much. All you guys are talking yourself into saying you had a great day. It use to be good here 25 to 30 years ago. Back then a good day fishing was 30 or more keepers of any fish. I remember days when you could go out and catch 30 to 40 specks over 20" long and go king fishing and catch 30 to 40 a day. I see some of our best guides here in NC fish all day and come in with 8 to 10 specks, 2 drum, 8 or 10 flounder. Guides in other states catch that many in 1 hour. Our guides are just as good as them but when the fish are not in the water you cannot put them in the boat. WE DO NOT HAVE FISH LIKE THEY DO. WAKE UP NC!!!!!
25 years ago catching 4 or 5 of each species was the norm for an amateur fisherman today getting skunked is the norm. Those with nets will ....never mind.
All these guys are not having great years here in NC. They are talking out there A$$. I have friends on the Gulf that catch 80 to 100 reds in 1/2 day. Others catch 200 specks per boat. Some 25 to 30" specks. Guys say they are doing good with 15 to 20 flounder. I took one trip to Virginia and caught 90 flounder over 17" in 5 hours in my boat and had never fished the spot before. A great day is catching 8 to 10 times your limit. Does not happen here in NC much. All you guys are talking yourself into saying you had a great day. It use to be good here 25 to 30 years ago. Back then a good day fishing was 30 or more keepers of any fish. I remember days when you could go out and catch 30 to 40 specks over 20" long and go king fishing and catch 30 to 40 a day. I see some of our best guides here in NC fish all day and come in with 8 to 10 specks, 2 drum, 8 or 10 flounder. Guides in other states catch that many in 1 hour. Our guides are just as good as them but when the fish are not in the water you cannot put them in the boat. WE DO NOT HAVE FISH LIKE THEY DO. WAKE UP NC!!!!!
X2. I'm not a guide, but I fish alot, and this is what I see.
25 years ago catching 4 or 5 of each species was the norm for an amateur fisherman today getting skunked is the norm. Those with nets will ....never mind.
I've fished every other weekend this summer. Not hard all day fishing, but generally 2 hours or so Fri-Sun. This highlight has been an 18" flounder. Zero reds. Zero keeper trout. I do think part of that is fishing during the day, but still. With that said, I got up at 3 am and could not get back to sleep, so going to try here in a few just before dawn at high tide.
Do you guys who are making a good point about the lack of some fish in NC waters think setting consumer and recreational quotas at levels that avoid overfishing would be a fair solution? This seems to work well in federal waters.
If the fishery is failed, no one gets to eat wild caught fish...
I get out once a week or so, definitely no guide, but I'm not a complete hack either. Fishing here is slow... undersized flounder, croaker, lizardfish, and small blues make up the majority of what is caught. I accept that I have plenty more to learn, but the areas I get to fish almost seem sterile at times.
I have no problem with denying "seafood consumers" access to our public trust resources, myself included, if it's what is right for the resource. Aside from us fortunate enough to live at the coast, most of our state does not have access to them anyways. We ship most of our seafood out of state for wholesale prices, and leave the imported crap for those west of highway 17.
Nobody in NC is "feeding the masses" through commercial fishing, but a few are feeding their wallets at the expense of the rest of us.
Fish alive in the water for future generations are more important than fish on anyone's plate today.
You make a good point about people living west of 17 not having as much access to local seafood as they should. That is something I personally try to help with by being part of a co-op that connects inland consumers to seafood harvested by independent commercial fishermen. That concept along with some Community Seafood Processing Facilities would help keep more NC seafood in NC. Those processing facilities could also clean recreational catches and make full use of all scraps.
As for fish being alive in the water for future generations, establishing quotas to avoid overfishing achieves that goal.
Hatcheries and habitat enhancement along with improved processing and distribution capabilities could provide much more seafood for NC citizens while supporting more recreational pressure. Fishermen could help "feed the masses" in NC when something disrupts our corporate food supply if we plan ahead.
We can have healthy fisheries and local seafood forever if we practice proven solutions and the Golden Rule.
Aren't striped bass stocked? Last I heard the inshore stock had some issues to be addressed.
There is a limited striper stocking program funded mostly by the Dingell/Johnson tax on tackle. This fund is intended to enhance recreational opportunity. Consumers and commercial fishermen should have the option of funding an equal amount of striper stocking so we all share equally in the cost and benefit. This would instantly double the recreational opportunity for catching and keeping striped bass without denying consumers access to that local seafood. The Saltonstall/Kennedy tax on imported seafood that is supposed to be used for enhancing the domestic supply of seafood would be a great place to secure matching consumer funds for striper stocking. The $400 commercial license fee could also provide funding for hatcheries.
We should utilize proven management tools that can turn today's disappointing reality into what we want to see our fisheries look like. We could make NC one of the world's greatest recreational fishing destinations and seafood producers if we will focus on enhancing our fisheries and food supply.
I've said it so many times i'm tired of the subject ....Until some severe restrictions are put in place to stop/limit the rape and depletion of our inshore waters by the uncontrolled netting our fishery will not recover..Most of the states that boast of such fantastic catches long ago prohibited/limited inshore netting as we see it today... It isn't rocket science just common sense that is pretty well documented....Another problem is the mortality rate of the big breeders being mishandled by the fishermen that are here complaining that the fishing sucks as they hold large reds/ect,ect by gill plates and out of water for pics until they dry up and suffacate...... just sayin ,,Again
I've said it so many times i'm tired of the subject ....Until some severe restrictions are put in place to stop/limit the rape and depletion of our inshore waters by the uncontrolled netting our fishery will not recover..Most of the states that boast of such fantastic catches long ago prohibited/limited inshore netting as we see it today... It isn't rocket science just common sense that is pretty well documented....Another problem is the mortality rate of the big breeders being mishandled by the fishermen that are here complaining that the fishing sucks as they hold large reds/ect,ect by gill plates and out of water for pics until they dry up and suffacate...... just sayin ,,Again
Alaska has a great fishery with nets still being widely used to harvest seafood. The difference is quotas and hatcheries. Educating fishermen about the best way to release unwanted or illegal fish is also important.
I've said it so many times i'm tired of the subject ....Until some severe restrictions are put in place to stop/limit the rape and depletion of our inshore waters by the uncontrolled netting our fishery will not recover..Most of the states that boast of such fantastic catches long ago prohibited/limited inshore netting as we see it today... It isn't rocket science just common sense that is pretty well documented....Another problem is the mortality rate of the big breeders being mishandled by the fishermen that are here complaining that the fishing sucks as they hold large reds/ect,ect by gill plates and out of water for pics until they dry up and suffacate...... just sayin ,,Again
Alaska has a great fishery with nets still being widely used to harvest seafood. The difference is quotas and hatcheries. Educating fishermen about the best way to release unwanted or illegal fish is also important.
I think you are exaggerating the usage of gillnets in Alaska. The major users or gillnets in Alaska are subsistence users and are used predominately in very remote areas. NC doesn't have remote areas like Alaska. Let's also remember those rec users are limited to 60 yard limits between June 15 and Aug sometime. So do you really want to implement what they have or are you just trying to find something else to say hey they have fillets.
PS. Talking with Alaskan biologist and those I was with while up there this past June have said even with stocking the Salmon fishery has been seeing a decline in last decade or so requiring more attention.
I am not trying to defend nets as much as the public's freedom to access local wild-caught seafood. I am also trying to promote proven solutions that benefit everyone and the resource.
How good would Alaska's salmon fisheries be without hatcheries? Stocking should not be the only solution, it should be part of an eco-system based fishery management plan that helps our fisheries thrive at historically high levels.