SWC Forums

Pull up a chair...let's talk fishing.

Notifications
Clear all

Where have the red drum gone...??

101 Posts
30 Users
0 Reactions
4,224 Views
icecreamman
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 21 years ago
Posts: 2017
 

I watch a man and his wife the other day keep 14 flounders that was between 8 to 13 inch explain how that's right and a nets are wrong.I've had the best year for flounder I've ever had rod and reel and nets same with the drum.

They are wrong, also.
If we had better enforcement of the regulations that exists would help.
But unfortunately DMF needs gas / fuel to run boats without imposed limitations that are keeping them off the water. ..... ICM



   
ReplyQuote
Chris McCaffity
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 15 years ago
Posts: 1424
 

Being in fishery management and as a wildlife biologist, it pains me to see the solution for a lot of people today being "fish stocking." I am not disagreeing with the fact that fish stocking works to improve numbers and populations. HOWEVER I am disagreeing with the fact that stocking fish in an ocean environment is absolutely NOT a viable option. For those that cant see why stocking red drum, flounder or any species for that matter in the ocean will not work, let me run through some scenarios for you.

Scenario #1 freshwater fish example

Where are our trout going???? We need to start stocking this area!

This can be done, and quite successfully. Why?? There are no natural predators to feed on them. yes, you have some that get eaten by birds, some get eaten by crayfish and some eaten by other fish. in a trout stream environment however, once a trout gets to be 3-4" in length they are pretty much top of the food chain. This is why stocking trout can be done successfully.

Scenario #2 saltwater fish stocking

Where are our red drum going???? We need to start stocking!

Here is the problems with that.

Stocking fish as frye (fingerlings, hatchlings, minnows, etc):

#1) EVERYTHING and I do mean EVERYTHING in the ocean is out to get them. this last indefinitely. not like trout or bass etc, as to when they get to be a certain size they are safe. they will never be safe until they hit teenagers in weight and even then they still are not out of the safe zone. Lets say for instance it cost $2 per fish to raise into frye for release into the big pond. you have now spent $10,000 to raise 5,000 fish. of those 5,000 fish conservatively 500 of those fish will die within the first 24 to 48 hours just from environmental stress alone. now we have 4500. of that 4500, crabs, smaller, birds and other predators will take half before reaching 6-8" in length. now we are left with 2250 fish. of that 2250, half become victims of bigger predators, gill nets, trawlers, rec fisherman throat hooks etc. now we are left with 1125 that have made it to slot limit. these fish have survived it all now we can catch them! but wait...imagine going to a pond 10 acres big averaging 20 foot deep and throwing 1 fish in it to catch. this is essentially what your left with. 1125 fish in the ocean is like finding a needle in a haystack. your cost per fish also just went up to $9 each.

#2) stocking fish as "puppys" so to speak. The amount of food, manpower and electricity alone to get these fish to this size makes this an inviable option as well when you look at the cost to survival ratio. your talking about a migratory species, that schools. 1 trawler in the right place at the right time just took eliminated a school 0f 300 fish. examples could go on forever. Long story short, proper management of the species is what solves the problem. not stocking. stocking is never and will never be a FIX to the problem

Those are good arguments that explain some problems we should address. Stocking would work best as part a comprehensive fishery management/food production plan that looks at the big picture. Feeding a growing population and supporting more recreational pressure are two important issues we need to consider. Simply managing naturally occurring stocks with more restrictions will not increase seafood production. It will create more voluntary and regulatory discards.

Hatcheries can boost stock sizes for minimal cost if we focus on stocking the right seafood at the right size at the right time in the right location. Seafood such as crabs and herring could easily be stocked by the billions at minimal expense and benefit everything that eats them, including people.

I understand the desire to only manage natural stocks, but the reality is that we have already changed nature in ways that reduce fecundity, survival rates, and the overall biomass different areas can support. Hatcheries and habitat enhancement can allow seafood stocks to thrive at historically high levels even as we harvest more. The alternative is more regulation and industrial fish farming in coastal waters. I think securing freedom and a sustainable supply of wild-caught seafood for future generations is a better option than restricting their individual liberties and making them dependent on a few multi-national corporations for their food.



   
ReplyQuote
Scaramucci
(@)
Honorable Member
Joined: 12 years ago
Posts: 588
 

I watch a man and his wife the other day keep 14 flounders that was between 8 to 13 inch explain how that's right and a nets are wrong.I've had the best year for flounder I've ever had rod and reel and nets same with the drum.

Did you watch them for 3 days???? Smells like fake news....



   
ReplyQuote
jonathan
(@jward87)
Estimable Member
Joined: 14 years ago
Posts: 120
 

No one day



   
ReplyQuote
David Mcfadyen
(@)
Reputable Member
Joined: 14 years ago
Posts: 269
 

All I know is I fished two days this week and nothing. I would love to wactch someone catch 14 flounder just to know they are still there. It's dry out there and anyone I talk too says the same.



   
ReplyQuote
Nick
 Nick
(@seapro180)
Honorable Member
Joined: 11 years ago
Posts: 543
 

All I know is I fished two days this week and nothing. I would love to wactch someone catch 14 flounder just to know they are still there. It's dry out there and anyone I talk too says the same.

You must not be fishing out of morehead. We easily do 14 on just an average day. The problem we have is not finding them. Its finding the ones that hit the 15 inch mark. They all seem to be about a 1/4 to 1/2 inch short :wall:



   
ReplyQuote
george mc donald
(@)
Reputable Member
Joined: 17 years ago
Posts: 374
 

I'm gonna make this one last pitch and I hope it sinks in a little , i'm getting too old to be affected by the results either way much longer. An analogy of something i told my two boys 30 odd years ago seems to fit .Tried to tell them to try to organize and fight this evolution in state house,ect,ect ,,they didn't so here goes the story.....
Here in up state back then there was litterly thousands of acres of public lands to hunt but also a growing population of new hunters venturing to these lands.. Little by little the lands started to be pulled out of the public domain by clubs willing to pay landowners a higher lease , next came out of state clubs willing to pay an even higher price to the extent even the local clubs were struggling to keep their leases . Now only the most wealthy ones can maintain their land and the public lands are now 1/10 of what used to be!!
Today;as an example: most of the waters are a public resource ,,little by little your waters are vanishing to agencies that sell those fishing leases to the highest bidder "sounding familiar" (catch shares) are being doled out without input from the owners of the resource... The fish you target are behing long lines of netted off areas or regulated as to catch #'s and size slots , with seasons set by these special owners of your resource....Sorta like us paying for the fat man to dance... Yall remember this post cause it's a repeat in sorts of the first part of this post , although some of you will cry foul and say it ain't true and won't happen until it kicks them in the ass and it's too late to stop it!!!!!!!!!!1 :wall: :wall: :wall: :wall: :wall: :wall: :wall: :wall: :wall: :wall: :wall: :wall:



   
ReplyQuote
Chris McCaffity
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 15 years ago
Posts: 1424
 

I'm gonna make this one last pitch and I hope it sinks in a little , i'm getting too old to be affected by the results either way much longer. An analogy of something i told my two boys 30 odd years ago seems to fit .Tried to tell them to try to organize and fight this evolution in state house,ect,ect ,,they didn't so here goes the story.....
Here in up state back then there was litterly thousands of acres of public lands to hunt but also a growing population of new hunters venturing to these lands.. Little by little the lands started to be pulled out of the public domain by clubs willing to pay landowners a higher lease , next came out of state clubs willing to pay an even higher price to the extent even the local clubs were struggling to keep their leases . Now only the most wealthy ones can maintain their land and the public lands are now 1/10 of what used to be!!
Today;as an example: most of the waters are a public resource ,,little by little your waters are vanishing to agencies that sell those fishing leases to the highest bidder "sounding familiar" (catch shares) are being doled out without input from the owners of the resource... The fish you target are behing long lines of netted off areas or regulated as to catch #'s and size slots , with seasons set by these special owners of your resource....Sorta like us paying for the fat man to dance... Yall remember this post cause it's a repeat in sorts of the first part of this post , although some of you will cry foul and say it ain't true and won't happen until it kicks them in the ass and it's too late to stop it!!!!!!!!!!1 :wall: :wall: :wall: :wall: :wall: :wall: :wall: :wall: :wall: :wall: :wall: :wall:

What is the difference between some permit holders colluding with EDF to seize control of our public resources and some sportsmen colluding with the CCA to seize control of them?



   
ReplyQuote
Robert Gilliam
(@coastwx)
Honorable Member
Joined: 22 years ago
Posts: 430
 

All I know is I fished two days this week and nothing. I would love to wactch someone catch 14 flounder just to know they are still there. It's dry out there and anyone I talk too says the same.

It's been the worst stretch of fishing for me in some time. Since a few sea mullet in early April I've only been able to catch 1- 8" flounder, a couple small croaker and 2-3 undersize black drum. This is fishing every other Thu-Sun, so approx. 24 days fishing. Most of those average 3 hours a day. Using gulps, topwater and sinking mirrolures, mud minnows and shrimp. Most of that time was spent under the old Oak Island bridge fishing the falling tide. Will have the boat working this weekend, so plan to try something different. Luckily, it's enjoyable to just be out there trying for a few hours until we hang on the beach in the afternoon.



   
ReplyQuote
Bruce
(@)
Estimable Member
Joined: 12 years ago
Posts: 138

   
ReplyQuote
Scaramucci
(@)
Honorable Member
Joined: 12 years ago
Posts: 588
 

I'm gonna make this one last pitch and I hope it sinks in a little , i'm getting too old to be affected by the results either way much longer. An analogy of something i told my two boys 30 odd years ago seems to fit .Tried to tell them to try to organize and fight this evolution in state house,ect,ect ,,they didn't so here goes the story.....
Here in up state back then there was litterly thousands of acres of public lands to hunt but also a growing population of new hunters venturing to these lands.. Little by little the lands started to be pulled out of the public domain by clubs willing to pay landowners a higher lease , next came out of state clubs willing to pay an even higher price to the extent even the local clubs were struggling to keep their leases . Now only the most wealthy ones can maintain their land and the public lands are now 1/10 of what used to be!!
Today;as an example: most of the waters are a public resource ,,little by little your waters are vanishing to agencies that sell those fishing leases to the highest bidder "sounding familiar" (catch shares) are being doled out without input from the owners of the resource... The fish you target are behing long lines of netted off areas or regulated as to catch #'s and size slots , with seasons set by these special owners of your resource....Sorta like us paying for the fat man to dance... Yall remember this post cause it's a repeat in sorts of the first part of this post , although some of you will cry foul and say it ain't true and won't happen until it kicks them in the ass and it's too late to stop it!!!!!!!!!!1 :wall: :wall: :wall: :wall: :wall: :wall: :wall: :wall: :wall: :wall: :wall: :wall:

What is the difference between some permit holders colluding with EDF to seize control of our public resources and some sportsmen colluding with the CCA to seize control of them?

The only difference I see is that most commercial fishermen publicly oppose catch shares while most recreational fishermen silently support taking away their fellow citizen's freedom to eat wild-caught NC seafood.

Disappointing Chris. When protecting natural resources becomes a " us against them" fight, we are all screwed. I always thought you were one guy above that Chris. Disappointing.



   
ReplyQuote
Chris McCaffity
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 15 years ago
Posts: 1424
 

I'm gonna make this one last pitch and I hope it sinks in a little , i'm getting too old to be affected by the results either way much longer. An analogy of something i told my two boys 30 odd years ago seems to fit .Tried to tell them to try to organize and fight this evolution in state house,ect,ect ,,they didn't so here goes the story.....
Here in up state back then there was litterly thousands of acres of public lands to hunt but also a growing population of new hunters venturing to these lands.. Little by little the lands started to be pulled out of the public domain by clubs willing to pay landowners a higher lease , next came out of state clubs willing to pay an even higher price to the extent even the local clubs were struggling to keep their leases . Now only the most wealthy ones can maintain their land and the public lands are now 1/10 of what used to be!!
Today;as an example: most of the waters are a public resource ,,little by little your waters are vanishing to agencies that sell those fishing leases to the highest bidder "sounding familiar" (catch shares) are being doled out without input from the owners of the resource... The fish you target are behing long lines of netted off areas or regulated as to catch #'s and size slots , with seasons set by these special owners of your resource....Sorta like us paying for the fat man to dance... Yall remember this post cause it's a repeat in sorts of the first part of this post , although some of you will cry foul and say it ain't true and won't happen until it kicks them in the ass and it's too late to stop it!!!!!!!!!!1 :wall: :wall: :wall: :wall: :wall: :wall: :wall: :wall: :wall: :wall: :wall: :wall:

What is the difference between some permit holders colluding with EDF to seize control of our public resources and some sportsmen colluding with the CCA to seize control of them?

The only difference I see is that most commercial fishermen publicly oppose catch shares while most recreational fishermen silently support taking away their fellow citizen's freedom to eat wild-caught NC seafood.

Disappointing Chris. When protecting natural resources becomes a " us against them" fight, we are all screwed. I always thought you were one guy above that Chris. Disappointing.

I am not making this an "us against them" fight. Simply pointing out that it is wrong for any group to seize control of our public resources. I know most recreational fishermen don't really support the radical CCA agenda, but their disappointing silence does.



   
ReplyQuote
Chris McCaffity
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 15 years ago
Posts: 1424
 

Recreational Fishermen, I am sorry for the way this statement was phrased.

"The only difference I see is that most commercial fishermen publicly oppose catch shares while most recreational fishermen silently support taking away their fellow citizen's freedom to eat wild-caught NC seafood."  

I did not intend to imply that most recreational fishermen actually support denying consumer's access to local seafood. I was wrong for wording it that way and will edit it out of the post.



   
ReplyQuote
Bruce
(@)
Estimable Member
Joined: 12 years ago
Posts: 138
 

"The only difference I see is that most commercial fishermen publicly oppose catch shares while most recreational fishermen silently support taking away their fellow citizen's freedom to eat wild-caught NC seafood."

And what do you base this little tidbit of knowledge on?



   
ReplyQuote
Chris McCaffity
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 15 years ago
Posts: 1424
 

"The only difference I see is that most commercial fishermen publicly oppose catch shares while most recreational fishermen silently support taking away their fellow citizen's freedom to eat wild-caught NC seafood."

And what do you base this little tidbit of knowledge on?

The fact that most commercial fishermen oppose catch shares when they come up and very few recreational fishermen are willing to speak out against things like designating gamefish which would make it illegal for consumers to eat that seafood.

Most recreational fishermen don't support extreme measures that put people out of work or deny consumer's access to local seafood. Many of them don't speak out for fear of being ridiculed by sportsmen. Most are just too busy to get involved.

I have already acknowledged that the statement was worded wrong and removed it from the original post. The fact remains that silence equals passive support for bad bills like HB-867. Hopefully more fishermen, seafood consumers, and concerned citizens will start showing their support for shifting the fishery management focus toward enhancing our fisheries and food supply more than restricting the public's freedom to access them.



   
ReplyQuote
Page 3 / 7
Share: