SWC Forums
Pull up a chair...let's talk fishing.
Everyone involved in the FMP for Spotted Sea Trout deserves an attaboy. Hearing that stock has been recovered and now classified as viable.
Good job!!!!!!!!
Everyone involved in the FMP for Spotted Sea Trout deserves an attaboy. Hearing that stock has been recovered and now classified as viable.
Good job!!!!!!!!
I think you're wrong on your point above.
The current assessment used different modeling techniques than did the previous assessment that showed overfished, overfishing and depleted. Based on the new model, trout are not recovered because the model shows that trout had never been overfished nor depleted for the total time frame from 1991 - 2012. I don't think it's possible to recover from something that didn't exist.
But...anything is possible when you can change the rules and redefine the playing field or maybe they just got it wrong before and right this time- or maybe not.
Whatever.
Anybody that's been around awhile knows that fish stocks are cyclical. The status becomes pretty much the luck of the draw based on when assessments are scheduled. Anybody that's been trout fishing the last couple years knows that the depleted label was a joke. Not only bunches of fish available but different year classes well represented.
I know the net ban crowd is not happy when there's an up cycle as it pretty well shoots the depletion theory full of holes.
Don't worry, if you wait awhile, population will decline and you can go back to blaming the comms.
Everyone involved in the FMP for Spotted Sea Trout deserves an attaboy. Hearing that stock has been recovered and now classified as viable.
Good job!!!!!!!!
I think you're wrong on your point above.
The current assessment used different modeling techniques than did the previous assessment that showed overfished, overfishing and depleted. Based on the new model, trout are not recovered because the model shows that trout had never been overfished nor depleted for the total time frame from 1991 - 2012. I don't think it's possible to recover from something that didn't exist.
But...anything is possible when you can change the rules and redefine the playing field or maybe they just got it wrong before and right this time- or maybe not.
Seacern you seem to be saying that only a negative report could be true with some passive aggressive innuendo thrown in for good measure. Crabman hit nail on head. Everything on planet earth is cyclacel and fish like trout, who at the northern end of their range in NC experience regular freeze events, are even more up and down than most species here.
Eric, I've read the stock assessment from beginning to end, word by word and number by number. Have you? Thank you in advance for an honest answer. You can keep your opinion.
Everyone involved in the FMP for Spotted Sea Trout deserves an attaboy. Hearing that stock has been recovered and now classified as viable.
Good job!!!!!!!!
I think you're wrong on your point above.
The current assessment used different modeling techniques than did the previous assessment that showed overfished, overfishing and depleted. Based on the new model, trout are not recovered because the model shows that trout had never been overfished nor depleted for the total time frame from 1991 - 2012. I don't think it's possible to recover from something that didn't exist.
But...anything is possible when you can change the rules and redefine the playing field or maybe they just got it wrong before and right this time- or maybe not.
So are you saying that in your opinion the model used to show trout were overfished was wrong?
Or are you saying that the new model that says they are not overfished is wrong?
Eric, I've read the stock assessment from beginning to end, word by word and number by number. Have you? Thank you in advance for an honest answer. You can keep your opinion.
No I haven't read a word of it. I trust that those who are charged with doing said assessment are more qualified than I. It's like this, whether you've read every word or not doesn't matter. If you don't trust the assessments then stop pasting them up as evidence to support your agenda. If you don't trust this one then you can't trust any of them because that's saying, up front, that they can't be trusted (inherently). Your reading and understanding of the assessment and your subsequent feelings about it, which you are posting publicly, are just "your" opinion. If your opinion is worth so much more then please tell us why this assessment isn't correct (other than the end result) and why it's definitely this one and not the overfished reports, which is errant. Like the man said, there WILL be another cold stun kill and then you guys can get that downturn you need for the pie charts and bill boards.