SWC Forums

Pull up a chair...let's talk fishing.

MFC Inactions
 
Notifications
Clear all

MFC Inactions

12 Posts
7 Users
0 Reactions
748 Views
Bob
 Bob
(@)
Reputable Member
Joined: 16 years ago
Posts: 331
Topic starter   [#43954]

Just when we thought the MFC was preparing to act on the DMF options on how to save the southern flouder from extinction, we are told that DMF really should have called them examples. So, after DMF took an hour to explain the examples, the MFC then proceeded to come up with six or so distinct options of their own which they now must present to the common folk for comments. Understand they will meet again tomorrow to determine when and where to schedule a meeting.
Funny stuff.



   
Quote
Bernie McCants
(@)
Reputable Member
Joined: 22 years ago
Posts: 289
 

Southern flounder are not at any risk of extinction. Harvest has been stable for years but, per the available data, are overfished and not at the levels they should be.

MFC is following the process required to change the existing fisheries management plan.



   
ReplyQuote
Kenneth Seigler
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 14 years ago
Posts: 1001
 

Reducing the size limit with a slot could address several issues.



   
ReplyQuote
Bob
 Bob
(@)
Reputable Member
Joined: 16 years ago
Posts: 331
Topic starter  

Understood BW. My exaggeration of the stock condition can be attributed to spending too much time reading some of the chicken little sites.

Though I understand the commission must follow the process, I was disappointed in what appeared to me to be a lack of preparation on the part of some commissioners, almost as though they were putting things off 'till a later time. Though I understand that the process requires the opportunity for public input and comment, I was hoping that the commission would have discussed and pared down the number of options prior to presenting to the public. In fact at this point I believe they've actually increased the complexity of the issue.
I do appreciate the difficult position they are in, but if they wanted to participate, there's no better time than the present. I don't envy their positions, and do not mean to be critical of any individuals. Merely expressing my feelings on how I think it went.
Bless them all and give them wisdom.



   
ReplyQuote
Sea Cern
(@)
Estimable Member
Joined: 13 years ago
Posts: 172
 

The Commission should be commended for its action. None of the options or combos presented by the Division would have ensured ending overfishing and returning this stock to a viable status. A TAC will do that provided sufficient cuts are made. It's going to be extremely important for the public to weigh in and I hope those recreational anglers who support moving this fishery to a fair allocation from a viable stock will do so. The rubber is meeting the road in August, be part of the solution or reside yourself to arguing on the internet over the state of depleted fisheries with supporters of status quo and a few internet trolls.



   
ReplyQuote
Bob
 Bob
(@)
Reputable Member
Joined: 16 years ago
Posts: 331
Topic starter  

I do like the idea of a TAC as a good method to prevent unintended recoupment that may surface from some of the other methods suggested. I really wish I had the confidence in the public comment portion of the process that some seem to have. Maybe I've become nothing more than a cynical old man, but the public comment period to me is nothing more than a dog and pony show. Furthermore, while many of us call for decisions to be made based on science, I find that in large part public comment is fully charged with emotion, conflict of interest, heritage and the like, and very much lacking in the way of science.



   
ReplyQuote
eric broome
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 19 years ago
Posts: 1299
 

You're correct about the emotion and such that is part of the public comment meetings, and they can be distracting. At the same time I think it's one of the only checks and balances that stake holders get to participate in. While science is the best decision making tool, the science they're using right now is severely flawed and everyone knows this. I may be one of the trolls that seascern is talking about (in his eyes) but I don't think I'm alone in thinking that the science they're using right now is lacking.....at best.

It's a shame that our catch records for both groups don't go back far enough to reflect the cyclacel nature of flounder stocks as well as all other fish. There have always been down times. It wasn't always high cotton. Troll though I may be in some eyes, this year the flounder are coming in already in big numbers compared to last few years. I believe this year will be another banner year. I could be wrong, but if I'm right it'll get harder and harder to push the chicken little sky is falling routine....even to the most conservation minded kayak paddling fish hippies out there...



   
ReplyQuote
John Riley
(@)
Estimable Member
Joined: 12 years ago
Posts: 172
 

a few internet trolls.

I suspect I'm another...since he keeps singling me out in negative comments - just for asking questions and calling things as I see them. Disagreeing with something does not make one a troll.

Now...in the spirit of "just asking a question," on the topic of DMF dragging feet in the management process...what mechanism exists specifically in regard to flounder for something like "emergency management decisions." For example, when the cold stun affected the specs last year, a proclamation was issued to close harvest for a few months.

Is that an across-the-board thing, or does it apply only to certain FMP's? If the scientific data (ie, good data) suggest something needs to be "done now," could short term action be taken while the full FMP changing process goes on the background?

That's something I'm trying to get a handle on; long term FMP management does not seem to HAVE to require short term 'adjustments' for flounder. At least it doesn't in regard to other changes and closers carried out by proclamation.



   
ReplyQuote
Glen Montgomery
(@)
Reputable Member
Joined: 16 years ago
Posts: 284
 

Is the proposed TAC (total allowable catch) supposed to apply to everyone or does it only apply to commercials? Am hearing that effort on southern flounder must be reduced another possibly 60% and wonder if that also applies to both the commercial and rec groups. Will not comment on the fact that back in 2005 effort was reduced by nearly 20% and we saw some improvement. Then the powers that be agreed to cut effort by another 20% back in 2009 to make sure it was done right this time. Now in 2015 we are hearing it might take another 60% cut in effort? Personally I am to the point now that I am not sure if anyone really know what in the hell is going on nor do they really know hat to do about it. Build some hatcheries, make everyone throw back all flounder that are under 14 inches and set a limit of 1 per trip for any southern flounder over 25 inches for both rec and commercial



   
ReplyQuote
Kenneth Seigler
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 14 years ago
Posts: 1001
 

Have always felt inlets were the corner stone to healthy fisheries, they are the passages thru which most all species must pass in order to enter nursery areas.

Dredge and jetty every inlet, and cut this beach nourishment carp out, period. You build on a sand shoal, expect your efforts to be rewarded with what occurs at the whims of natural processes.



   
ReplyQuote
John Riley
(@)
Estimable Member
Joined: 12 years ago
Posts: 172
 

Dredge and jetty every inlet, and cut this beach nourishment carp out, period. You build on a sand shoal, expect your efforts to be rewarded with what occurs at the whims of natural processes.

Agree.

Never ceases to amaze me that people flock to an area ostensibly due to its wildness and beauty, then seek to destroy exactly what they claim attracted to them area by seeking to 'stabilize' it.



   
ReplyQuote
Bob
 Bob
(@)
Reputable Member
Joined: 16 years ago
Posts: 331
Topic starter  

Dredge and jetty every inlet, and cut this beach nourishment carp out, period. You build on a sand shoal, expect your efforts to be rewarded with what occurs at the whims of natural processes.

Agree.

Never ceases to amaze me that people flock to an area ostensibly due to its wildness and beauty, then seek to destroy exactly what they claim attracted to them area by seeking to 'stabilize' it.

Joni Mitchell said it best. "Paved paradise to put up a parking lot".



   
ReplyQuote
Share: