SWC Forums

Pull up a chair...let's talk fishing.

NCMFC member Chuck ...
 
Notifications
Clear all

NCMFC member Chuck Laughridge wants to close recreational harvest

140 Posts
29 Users
0 Reactions
4,350 Views
David Mcfadyen
(@)
Reputable Member
Joined: 14 years ago
Posts: 269
 

You always can drop it to two a day sept, oct, nov but if you are going to shut it down shut it down for all. I beleive i keep three in those months.



   
ReplyQuote
Kenneth
(@matador)
Famed Member
Joined: 17 years ago
Posts: 3641
 

Close flounder in Oct. and Nov. for everyone is fine with me. We limit out easily from April to September anyway. An Oct./Nov. closure will keep me from having to make the tough decision to chase flounder or pound on those near shore groupers. Then, more flounders next year. When do we start?



   
ReplyQuote
Lyle
 Lyle
(@)
Estimable Member
Joined: 13 years ago
Posts: 146
Topic starter  

Can we get verification that he TRULY said that???
If so....???????
Seriously chess move in the game of southern flounder

They will have the recorded audio available at some point but think it takes them a while to get it out.



   
ReplyQuote
roy rauert
(@)
Estimable Member
Joined: 14 years ago
Posts: 143
 

Would that mean closing summer flounder also?? Most guys can't tell the difference between summer and southern flounder.



   
ReplyQuote
Lyle
 Lyle
(@)
Estimable Member
Joined: 13 years ago
Posts: 146
Topic starter  

I don't thnk he was suggesting a complete shutdown.

I heard the podcast of the meeting this afternoon and what I heard him say was something along the lines of a closed season for a period of time in the October/November time frame to offer spawners the opportunity to migrate to the ocean to spawn. It was like he was just throwing it out as an example of how the recreational user group might contribute to restoring the stocks. Nothing has been decided at this point.

If this develops further, there will be a public comment period.

Pretty certain his exact words were, "I am ready to propose closing recreational harvest". When the audio files become available, I will be more than glad to link it to this thread. I wouldn't hold my breath waiting on a public comment period, they were suppose to vote on it at this meeting but pushed it back until the next.

On to the "allow fish to escape in October and November", that is the same flawed logic that the Yankees up north use to gripe about the ocean striped bass fishery here and in VA. They have no problem hammering them all summer but when the same school of fish migrates south, they suddenly need to be protected because they will be the ones that spawn........... news flash all the fish they kill in the summer would have been spawners too.

The same with flounder, catching a fish in June or catching it in November doesn't really matter because dead is dead.



   
ReplyQuote
Jon Tennant
(@jon)
Trusted Member
Joined: 23 years ago
Posts: 67
 

Hurry boys!... CCANC needs your money and support! F-ing lol at the fiddles.... These enviro-whackos going play you till the strings break.



   
ReplyQuote
David Glenn
(@)
Trusted Member
Joined: 15 years ago
Posts: 58
 

I don't thnk he was suggesting a complete shutdown.

I heard the podcast of the meeting this afternoon and what I heard him say was something along the lines of a closed season for a period of time in the October/November time frame to offer spawners the opportunity to migrate to the ocean to spawn. It was like he was just throwing it out as an example of how the recreational user group might contribute to restoring the stocks. Nothing has been decided at this point.

If this develops further, there will be a public comment period.

I also believe that's how it was framed. There are other options, like setting a new size limit at 18", but I'm sure some folks would crap unicorns with that as well. Several MFC members were against a blanket size limit increase to 18", so calm down, just giving an example. MFC were still discussing Southern Flounder at 6pm when I stopped listening.



   
ReplyQuote
Kenneth Seigler
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 14 years ago
Posts: 1001
 

Three big negatives to consider when using size limit.
1) increase in discard mortality
2) shifts harvest target to the spawning fish
3) more fish go south with no guarantee they won't get caught in other states

FLA.........10 per person per day..............12" total length

GA..........15 per person per day.............. 12" total length

SC..........15 per person per day not to exceed 30 per boat per day...... 14-inch TL

~



   
ReplyQuote
Bob
 Bob
(@)
Reputable Member
Joined: 16 years ago
Posts: 331
 

I don't thnk he was suggesting a complete shutdown.

I heard the podcast of the meeting this afternoon and what I heard him say was something along the lines of a closed season for a period of time in the October/November time frame to offer spawners the opportunity to migrate to the ocean to spawn. It was like he was just throwing it out as an example of how the recreational user group might contribute to restoring the stocks. Nothing has been decided at this point.

If this develops further, there will be a public comment period.

Pretty certain his exact words were, "I am ready to propose closing recreational harvest". When the audio files become available, I will be more than glad to link it to this thread. I wouldn't hold my breath waiting on a public comment period, they were suppose to vote on it at this meeting but pushed it back until the next.

On to the "allow fish to escape in October and November", that is the same flawed logic that the ******* up north use to gripe about the ocean striped bass fishery here and in VA. They have no problem hammering them all summer but when the same school of fish migrates south, they suddenly need to be protected because they will be the ones that spawn........... news flash all the fish they kill in the summer would have been spawners too.

The same with flounder, catching a fish in June or catching it in November doesn't really matter because dead is dead.

Dead is dead is rather obvious. The point is that we need to be killing less fish overall to allow more fish to escape to the spawning grounds. The Oct/Nov time period during which the fish are migrating is a time known to be a period of heavy harvest and thus would be an effective time to shut down if reducing catch was the objective.
Other ideas are being considered. DMF will be working with and presenting data to the MFC prior to the May meeting after which we will know better which direction this will be going.



   
ReplyQuote
Kenneth Seigler
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 14 years ago
Posts: 1001
 

I don't thnk he was suggesting a complete shutdown.

I heard the podcast of the meeting this afternoon and what I heard him say was something along the lines of a closed season for a period of time in the October/November time frame to offer spawners the opportunity to migrate to the ocean to spawn. It was like he was just throwing it out as an example of how the recreational user group might contribute to restoring the stocks. Nothing has been decided at this point.

If this develops further, there will be a public comment period.

Pretty certain his exact words were, "I am ready to propose closing recreational harvest". When the audio files become available, I will be more than glad to link it to this thread. I wouldn't hold my breath waiting on a public comment period, they were suppose to vote on it at this meeting but pushed it back until the next.

On to the "allow fish to escape in October and November", that is the same flawed logic that the ******* up north use to gripe about the ocean striped bass fishery here and in VA. They have no problem hammering them all summer but when the same school of fish migrates south, they suddenly need to be protected because they will be the ones that spawn........... news flash all the fish they kill in the summer would have been spawners too.

The same with flounder, catching a fish in June or catching it in November doesn't really matter because dead is dead.

Dead is dead is rather obvious. The point is that we need to be killing less fish overall to allow more fish to escape to the spawning grounds. The Oct/Nov time period during which the fish are migrating is a time known to be a period of heavy harvest and thus would be an effective time to shut down if reducing catch was the objective.
Other ideas are being considered. DMF will be working with and presenting data to the MFC prior to the May meeting after which we will know better which direction this will be going.

Agree, but have a distinct feeling the outcome would be while feeding the rest of the world flounder NC gets to starve.

Not a favorable option for many when a major portion of their livelihood depends on flounder. Would have to include a southeast management strategy, but as Director said, there appears no desire for those other states or SAMFC to concur or to put in another way "to get in the middle of a fish fight".

The only legitimate option is a southeast regional management strategy similar to red drum that includes everyone (all atlantic states) JMHO.

~



   
ReplyQuote
Bob
 Bob
(@)
Reputable Member
Joined: 16 years ago
Posts: 331
 

Three big negatives to consider when using size limit.
1) increase in discard mortality
2) shifts harvest target to the spawning fish
3) more fish go south with no guarantee they won't get caught in other states

FLA.........10 per person per day..............12" total length

GA..........15 per person per day.............. 12" total length

SC..........15 per person per day not to exceed 30 per boat per day...... 14-inch TL

~

I think it has become apparent that with our current size limit we are targeting mostly female fish. Most recretional anglers are forced to discard a tremendous amount of short fish in an effort to catch a few keepers. The discard mortality rate is a ??? but any mortality is a waste. There's some reports that commercial discard mortality is considerable. I ain't a fisheries biologist, but on the surface it would seem that a much lower size limit with some type of TAC would result in less waste and direct targeting away from the females.



   
ReplyQuote
Kenneth Seigler
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 14 years ago
Posts: 1001
 

Agree, same thing with Spotted Sea Trout. 14" size limit shifted targeted harvest to faster growing larger female fish.

If more fish is desired, shifting the target to the spawning class is definitely not a favorable option for any specie I'm aware of.

TAC will increase discard mortality as well, leads to more discards as other species are targeted.

Phone will probably ring off the hook, but Dec. is already closed to commercial harvest. Perhaps closing 2 additional weeks in Nov. coupled with equal rec. reductions and pursuing SAMFC.

Regardless of what is done, SAMFC is going to have to be a major player in future decisions.



   
ReplyQuote
zigzag
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 22 years ago
Posts: 1863
 

How is it that florida, georgia, and south carolina have more fish to offer?



   
ReplyQuote
Kenneth Seigler
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 14 years ago
Posts: 1001
 

I don't know ZigZag, do those other states have FMP's for southern flounder in place? Appears those other states make no distinction between specie, a flounder is a flounder, period.

Also appears tagging studies show adult fish are leaving NC and being caught south, with no evidence southern areas are sending either adult or juvenile fish back.

Any desire to increase foreign aid without any strings at this point?



   
ReplyQuote
Bernie McCants
(@)
Reputable Member
Joined: 22 years ago
Posts: 289
 

How is it that florida, georgia, and south carolina have more fish to offer?

SC & Ga have have no clue as to the stock status of 'their' Flounder and it seems they pull a creel number out of the air. And I believe fisheries law in SC are made by the Legislature. Biologists in SC had a devil of a time convincing the Legislature to change the laws on red drum to prevent rec over harvest of this SC gamefish and SC still use stocking to supplement this fishery. Suspect they wouldn't welcome management by SAFMC.

Here is the estimated harvest of southern flounder in SC in numbers of fish from MRIP:

For NC:
2005 183,999
2006 188,372
2007 174,511
2008 206,294
2009 147,447
2010 250,790
2011 152,557
2012 118,614
2013 178,178
2014 68,795

South Carolina
2005 157,353
2006 310,551
2007 182,654
2008 204,277
2009 162,849
2010 108,965
2011 118,072
2012 126,715
2013 62,069
2014 57,750

Georgia (note much smaller coastline):
2005 37,522
2006 23,059
2007 92,122
2008 48,873
2009 34,362
2010 35,569
2011 28,884
2012 18,222
2013 19,068
2014 14,389

East Cost of Florida
2005 111,626
2006 85,046
2007 142,978
2008 127,394
2009 103,494
2010 154,709
2011 192,363
2012 188,386
2013 143,072
2014 226,505



   
ReplyQuote
Page 2 / 10
Share: