SWC Forums
Pull up a chair...let's talk fishing.
Not a favorable option for many when a major portion of their livelihood depends on flounder.
Any how many people make a ‘major’ portion of their livelihood on flounder, and the value of this? Specifically flounder, and not reds (or other fish) as by-catch they can sell even though they are only ‘targeting’ other flounder.
The only legitimate option is a southeast regional management strategy similar to red drum that includes everyone (all atlantic states) JMHO.
Now that makes sense if flounder do spawn ocean side as Tim has noted.
Think we may be rapidly approaching the point at which management of the entire stock may be the only effective option remaining.
But to address you question, certainly far fewer than there were before turtles were introduced as a method to eliminate their ability. Find it interesting that those who continue to harvest are even more reliant than before.
But to address you question, certainly far fewer than there were before turtles were introduced as a method to eliminate their ability. Find it interesting that those who continue to harvest are even more reliant than before.
Hundreds?
A thousand?
You want facts in regards to fishery management, so assessing the econimic impact would require numbers - how many, how much in revenue generated, how much economic impact.
If we are only talking 257 people to get a 'major' portion of their livelihood from commercial fishing flounder, it could be compared to all the $ recreational fishermen spend on gas, bait, ice, tackle, lodging, taxes to be able to fish (for flounder) to determine true economic impact of closing the fishery for (X) period of time, and who is affected.
Different story if we are talking about 2000 people who derive 'major portion of their livelihood' from flounder.
I'm betting it will be stated as 'over 100', but less than 1000. But then again I'm guessing.
Do you have numbers to substantiate the 'major portion of their livelihood' clause?
I'd hate to have to rely on flounder numbers for my livelihood on the 21st century. Nets, polution and all. No offense to those that do either.
It appears by the scenario you propose that the one who spends the most money are the only ones who should have access to the resource.
Is that management for the resource for the fish, or is it management of the resource for only those who can most afford it ?
Hasn't worked out too well for southern flounder anywhere else, what makes you feel that's even an option for southern flounder in NC ?
Maybe you could convince a certain commissioner to throw that out there so we can see how far it flies. An analogy to a lead zeppelin would be my estimate.
How has your scenario worked out for southern flounder in Texas ?
I'll defer back to a dead fish is a dead fish, with respect to the resource, makes no difference who catches it.
~
I'd hate to be one who thinks their hobby lifestyle is more important than someones job.No offense,they are equally important
Only thing turtles have done is eliminate the diverse fishermen who previously worked a broader range of fisheries and therefore had the least impact in any single fishery and concentrated effort of the remaining fishermen to become even more reliant on the single fishery aspect.
How is it that florida, georgia, and south carolina have more fish to offer?
Could it be that those states do not allow inshore gill nets? :shrug:
Closing recreational take of flounder sounds really ominous, for sure. However, I don't believe recs should be jumping through their holes just yet. Without audio or video, it's hard to believe Chuck just stood up out of the blue and suggested he was OK with a closure all by itself. Follow the nets, it is there one would likely find the 'rest of the story' ... :chin:

It appears by the scenario you propose that the one who spends the most money are the only ones who should have access to the resource.
No, I am willing to learn, not just continue the (bad) staus quo for fisheries in this state.
Deflecting again. Continued tactic to delay and deny.
I'd hate to be one who thinks their hobby lifestyle is more important than someones job.No offense,they are equally important.
I don't believe I ever said that. Anywhere. However if only a small number of people are adversely affected by a closure it is a completely different scenario than if thousands or (dare think) tens of thousands are affected.
And, if only a small number affected, but do a majority of the damage to a species, then we need to address that small group to the benefit of the species.
Continued denial and deflection.
No offense intended.
That's an excellent idea Curmudgeon, let's follow them all the way back to Texas were apparently this whole net issue started.
Nets banned in Texas 1981, so one would certainly expect at minimum some improvement in southern flounder stocks over say the past 25 years if in fact "nets" had been an issue, correct ?
Edit, Texas also uses hatchery reared fish to supplement it's southern flounder stocks.
2006 Southern Flounder, First sentence, Page 1
"Southern flounder Paralichthys lethostigma populations in Texas have been in steady decline over the last 25 years."
"Texas Parks and Wildlife fishery-independent monitoring gill net data has shown statewide southern flounder populations steadily decreasing during the last 25 years (TPWD 2003)."
I would bet a few bucks that shallow water shrimp trawls kill more flounder (#of fish, not pounds) than any other type of "pressure" except possibly, natural predators. When discussing population, numbers matter, not pounds.
My bet would be on targeting of spawning fish. Trawling has declined 80-90% just in the last 10 years.
Size has been increased 5 times in past 10 years, 12"....13"....13.5"....14"....15"
Target has been consistently shifted upward toward spawning bio-mass.
Fewer chickens, fewer eggs. And sending more chickens down stream to lay eggs, and only to be slaughtered by everyone else (other states) isn't the whole answer either. But one thing is deftly apparent, increasing sizes limits isn't going to address any portion of the issue. If it were, we would have seen marked improvements by now.
Might suggest in fact reducing size limit and take some of the pressure off larger fish. Pretty quick growing fish, so the growth of a 14" to a fully mature 16" is very short. Maybe 2 to 4 months ? That's a pretty quick turn around.
Does trawling have an impact in juvenile mortality ? I'm sure it has played at least some part, but so does all fishing mortality from every sector.
~
I'm not one to bash a fellow for the way he makes his living, nor do I desire to put him out of business but comparing nets to hooks is ridiculous in my opinion. That would be like letting one baseball team have 50 fielders and the other 2. Ain't much going to get by the team with 50.
Agreed, so there are 2 net fishermen left compared to 50 fishing hooks, would be a fair analogy.
Number of net both fishermen and soak time is down by 75% in the past 4 years alone.
Most of the fellas got to work setting nets less than 4 days the entire year last year, yet no measurable improvement in stocks.
Something in the picture you propose has been painted the wrong color.
Agreed, so there are 2 net fishermen left compared to 50 fishing hooks, would be a fair analogy.
Number of net both fishermen and soak time is down by 75% in the past 4 years alone.
Most of the fellas got to work setting nets less than 4 days the entire year last year, yet no measurable improvement in stocks.
So, let me get this straight. You guys make your living for the whole year in 4 days? How do I get a commercial fishing license?
No, the people with the least impact on the fishery (diverse fishermen working multiple fisheries) have been temporarily "laid off" by turtles, while at the same time they now have to watch everyone else catch the same fish they used to catch.