SWC Forums

Pull up a chair...let's talk fishing.

NCMFC member Chuck ...
 
Notifications
Clear all

NCMFC member Chuck Laughridge wants to close recreational harvest

140 Posts
29 Users
0 Reactions
4,354 Views
JOHNNY CARPENTER
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 14 years ago
Posts: 1169
 

If you (and other commercials) are making a living off of 4 days of fishing as you have stated either:
1. You are catching a very large number of fish and selling for a decent
price or:
2. Flounder prices are out the roof or:
3. You aren't disclosing the real numbers of days these guys are fishing or:
4. You are making a decent living (only working 4 days) while being
subsidized by others



   
ReplyQuote
Capt. Jason Dail
(@)
Reputable Member
Joined: 21 years ago
Posts: 276
 

How is it that florida, georgia, and south carolina have more fish to offer?

Uhhh, they dont allow inshore gill netting meaning their rec. limits result in an increase in smaller fish.

Hard to imagine that NC is the only state to get it right out of the majority of SE states?



   
ReplyQuote
Kenneth Seigler
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 14 years ago
Posts: 1001
 

If you (and other commercials) are making a living off of 4 days of fishing as you have stated either:
1. You are catching a very large number of fish and selling for a decent price or:
Most have good catches when they are permitted to go
2. Flounder prices are out the roof or:
Not as high as their fixing to be
3. You aren't disclosing the real numbers of days these guys are fishing or:
Consult proclamation on area "E" for yourself
4. You are making a decent living (only working 4 days) while being
subsidized by others
No one has received any compensation for any inability to harvest southern flounder to my knowledge........You got any evidence to the contrary?



   
ReplyQuote
JOHNNY CARPENTER
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 14 years ago
Posts: 1169
 

If you (and other commercials) are making a living off of 4 days of fishing as you have stated either:
1. You are catching a very large number of fish and selling for a decent price or:
Most have good catches when they are permitted to go
2. Flounder prices are out the roof or:
Not as high as their fixing to be
3. You aren't disclosing the real numbers of days these guys are fishing or:
Consult proclamation on area "E" for yourself
4. You are making a decent living (only working 4 days) while being
subsidized by others
No one has received any compensation for any inability to harvest southern flounder to my knowledge........You got any evidence to the contrary?

No, Just questions. Thanks for your answers. I know the fishery doesn't belong to one group no more than it does the other. I'm a rec just trying to understand your view. Now I know I'm prying, but you seem to be the man with numbers, so what is median income for most full time commercial fishermen in NC and how many are there?



   
ReplyQuote
Kenneth Seigler
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 14 years ago
Posts: 1001
 

How is it that florida, georgia, and south carolina have more fish to offer?

Uhhh, they dont allow inshore gill netting meaning their rec. limits result in an increase in smaller fish.

Hard to imagine that NC is the only state to get it right out of the majority of SE states?

Not difficult at all to understand if one does a little reading of the misguided approaches to management other states have pursued.

~



   
ReplyQuote
john Smith
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 18 years ago
Posts: 1776
 

If you (and other commercials) are making a living off of 4 days of fishing as you have stated either:
1. You are catching a very large number of fish and selling for a decent
price or:
2. Flounder prices are out the roof or:
3. You aren't disclosing the real numbers of days these guys are fishing or:
4. You are making a decent living (only working 4 days) while being
subsidized by others

"All of the above"



   
ReplyQuote
Kenneth Seigler
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 14 years ago
Posts: 1001
 

I know the fishery doesn't belong to one group no more than it does the other. I'm a rec just trying to understand your view. Now I know I'm prying, but you seem to be the man with numbers, so what is median income for most full time commercial fishermen in NC and how many are there?

Why should it matter how much do you earn? Got a big house with a nice boat parked on the side?

Completely happy earning my livelihood doing what I do.



   
ReplyQuote
Carlton Pittman
(@cap1)
Reputable Member
Joined: 19 years ago
Posts: 380
 

Buddy,
You're the Numbers Man.
Again, how many people make a 'major portion' of their livelihood from flounder?
Economic impact of their fishing efforts?
Numbers of pounds of flounder taken?
Number of pounds of by-catch (reds for example) sold?
Months when these fish are taken?

If as suggested, a flounder season late in the year is needed to take and sell reds as allowable by-catch, why the flounder target when these fish should be allowed to migrate to offshore spawning waters?
And why is any allowable by-catch necessary?

Just trying to understand commercial fishing practices and thought processes.
Thanks for any factual information that can be provided.



   
ReplyQuote
JOHNNY CARPENTER
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 14 years ago
Posts: 1169
 

I know the fishery doesn't belong to one group no more than it does the other. I'm a rec just trying to understand your view. Now I know I'm prying, but you seem to be the man with numbers, so what is median income for most full time commercial fishermen in NC and how many are there?

Why should it matter how much do you earn? Got a big house with a nice boat parked on the side?

Completely happy earning my livelihood the way I do.

Well, so you could say that you Love to Fish?(no matter how much income is derived from it) Me too, so what the hell are we all squabbling about? Let's find a freakin way to fix it.



   
ReplyQuote
Kenneth Seigler
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 14 years ago
Posts: 1001
 

Buddy,
You're the Numbers Man.
NOT
Again, how many people make a 'major portion' of their livelihood from flounder?
Why is it necessary a major portion of anyone's income come from any specie be used to determine who is allowed to catch and who isn't.
Do southern flounder comprise a major portion of what you catch, if not why are you still catching them?

Economic impact of their fishing efforts?
I follow the rules, I work, and pay taxes....those are the requirements.
Numbers of pounds of flounder taken?
Dead fish is a dead fish, doesn't matter who catches it.
Number of pounds of by-catch (reds for example) sold?
http://portal.ncdenr.org/web/mf/statistics/comstat
Months when these fish are taken?
Every month of the year, except commercial is closed Dec. 1 every year.
If as suggested, a flounder season late in the year is needed to take and sell reds as allowable by-catch, why the flounder target when these fish should be allowed to migrate to offshore spawning waters?
Why would you desire to send foreign aid to other states that don't even have FMP's to manage the stock?
And why is any allowable by-catch necessary?
Just trying to understand why would anyone desire to waste fish?

~



   
ReplyQuote
john Smith
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 18 years ago
Posts: 1776
 

And why is any allowable by-catch necessary?
Just trying to understand why would anyone desire to waste fish?

"If only the comms could sell everything they
drag up outta the sea"

Really sad.



   
ReplyQuote
Drew Smedley
(@dfs5)
Estimable Member
Joined: 15 years ago
Posts: 99
 

My bet would be on targeting of spawning fish. Trawling has declined 80-90% just in the last 10 years.

Size has been increased 5 times in past 10 years, 12"....13"....13.5"....14"....15"

Target has been consistently shifted upward toward spawning bio-mass.

Fewer chickens, fewer eggs. And sending more chickens down stream to lay eggs, and only to be slaughtered by everyone else (other states) isn't the whole answer either. But one thing is deftly apparent, increasing sizes limits isn't going to address any portion of the issue. If it were, we would have seen marked improvements by now.

Might suggest in fact reducing size limit and take some of the pressure off larger fish. Pretty quick growing fish, so the growth of a 14" to a fully mature 16" is very short. Maybe 2 to 4 months ? That's a pretty quick turn around.

Does trawling have an impact in juvenile mortality ? I'm sure it has played at least some part, but so does all fishing mortality from every sector.

~

I'm a rec. I personally think this idea has merit, and it is not clear to me why it is not getting more consideration. I think it makes sense to limit the harvest of the larger fish. There are more small fish out there and many of those likely are harvested by other predators before reaching a large size anyway. Harvest a few, reduce discard mortality, leave the large females to spawn. Maybe allow "a trophy" to be harvested as a compromise (something like 1 over 18 inches).



   
ReplyQuote
Kenneth Seigler
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 14 years ago
Posts: 1001
 

Well, so you could say that you Love to Fish?(no matter how much income is derived from it) Me too, so what the hell are we all squabbling about? Let's find a freakin way to fix it.

Problem is not resolved by stopping any particular group from catching fish, period.

You can put all the money you want to in the bank, if everyone is withdrawing it as fast as you put it in, your not going to get that mortgage paid.

Both rec. and comm. in NC have reduced their withdrawals more than once in the past 10 years. Someone else is still withdrawing funds and the mortgage still isn't paid, nor is it going to be unless the others making withdrawals meet with some impediment.

To get from here to the point of impeding ALL withdrawals, some minor temporary measures could be needed.

Until the stock is managed as a whole, similar to red drum, rest assured that mortgage will continue to go unpaid.

~



   
ReplyQuote
John Rakoci
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 14 years ago
Posts: 2331
 

The hell.

That's insane.

Close recs AND comms for a year! No flounder bycatch sold either. See who whines the most.



   
ReplyQuote
John Rakoci
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 14 years ago
Posts: 2331
 

I was looking a place north of the cape fear guess I,ll keep the one at myrtle beach and learn murrells inlet. Now where did that guy say the were droping all the cones off the coast of SC?

There are several ARs in both states. Several of both states are easy from the North MB area. If serious I'll look it up, PM me. I live in NC but fish mostly SC where there are fish as there are no nets. C puts out a nice book with all the ARs there ~ free.



   
ReplyQuote
Page 4 / 10
Share: