SWC Forums

Pull up a chair...let's talk fishing.

NCMFC member Chuck ...
 
Notifications
Clear all

NCMFC member Chuck Laughridge wants to close recreational harvest

140 Posts
29 Users
0 Reactions
4,352 Views
John Rakoci
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 14 years ago
Posts: 2331
 

How is it that florida, georgia, and south carolina have more fish to offer?

Check how many gill nets you can find in their nursery waters,,, How many trawlers are permitted in their sounds... easy answer



   
ReplyQuote
John Rakoci
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 14 years ago
Posts: 2331
 

How is it that florida, georgia, and south carolina have more fish to offer?

SC & Ga have have no clue as to the stock status of 'their' Flounder and it seems they pull a creel number out of the air. And I believe fisheries law in SC are made by the Legislature. Biologists in SC had a devil of a time convincing the Legislature to change the laws on red drum to prevent rec over harvest of this SC gamefish and SC still use stocking to supplement this fishery. Suspect they wouldn't welcome management by SAFMC.

When Daniel, bless his netter heart, has an assessment he does not like and a law he hates he does everything he can to keep nets in the water. The MFC may do nothing but had to all but kick him in the balls to get some info by May! He IS the problem and 99% of the time MFC enables him.



   
ReplyQuote
David Mcfadyen
(@)
Reputable Member
Joined: 14 years ago
Posts: 269
 

So who or what is withdrawing the funds (fish) My idea 25% across the board reduction check the hell out of everyone including night checks for a year.One way or another you will find where the fish go. It,s almost like someone sucks those things up at night. Are fish being caught that never see our shores or have they moved they may not be that dumb. Go to SC fish houses ask them where the flounder come from your answer will be NC heck they even advertise it on the signs outside FRESH NC FLOUNDER AND SHRIMP. If a man can make money on something for every legal person doing it there are 5 that are not legal in the mix.



   
ReplyQuote
John Rakoci
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 14 years ago
Posts: 2331
 

Not a favorable option for many when a major portion of their livelihood depends on flounder.

Any how many people make a ‘major’ portion of their livelihood on flounder, and the value of this? Specifically flounder, and not reds (or other fish) as by-catch they can sell even though they are only ‘targeting’ other flounder.

The only legitimate option is a southeast regional management strategy similar to red drum that includes everyone (all atlantic states) JMHO.

Now that makes sense if flounder do spawn ocean side as Tim has noted.

Since 60% of gillnetters make zero (or report zero) and of the rest 60% make less than $1000 how much could it be? A couple cases of beer?



   
ReplyQuote
John Rakoci
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 14 years ago
Posts: 2331
 

I'd hate to be one who thinks their hobby lifestyle is more important than someones job.No offense,they are equally important

Almost ~~ ALMOST every gill netter is a hobbyist making less than $1000 while being subsidized by taxpayers much more than that. $1.1 Million set aside for the observer program as we know they cannot count as high as 1 when finding a turtle. Their currently $200 annual license can be sold for $1800 - $2100 on Craigslist so taxpayers even subsidize their licenses.



   
ReplyQuote
John Rakoci
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 14 years ago
Posts: 2331
 

That's an excellent idea Curmudgeon, let's follow them all the way back to Texas were apparently this whole net issue started.

Nets banned in Texas 1981, so one would certainly expect at minimum some improvement in southern flounder stocks over say the past 25 years if in fact "nets" had been an issue, correct ?

Edit,
Texas also uses hatchery reared fish to supplement it's southern flounder stocks.

2006 Southern Flounder, First sentence, Page 1

"Southern flounder Paralichthys lethostigma populations in Texas have been in steady decline over the last 25 years."

"Texas Parks and Wildlife fishery-independent monitoring gill net data has shown statewide southern flounder populations steadily decreasing during the last 25 years (TPWD 2003)."

http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:0I8rEuJh5N0J:fisheries.tamucc.edu/images/Thesis/Nanez-JamesThesis.pdf+&cd=1&hl=en&ct=clnk&gl=us

Many comms whining and begging for recs to start a NC hatchery as they always want more from someone else.



   
ReplyQuote
John Rakoci
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 14 years ago
Posts: 2331
 

Agreed, so there are 2 net fishermen left compared to 50 fishing hooks, would be a fair analogy.

Number of net both fishermen and soak time is down by 75% in the past 4 years alone.

Most of the fellas got to work setting nets less than 4 days the entire year last year, yet no measurable improvement in stocks.

Something in the picture you propose has been painted the wrong color.

and landings have not declined in that period either.



   
ReplyQuote
John Rakoci
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 14 years ago
Posts: 2331
 

No, the people with the least impact on the fishery (diverse fishermen working multiple fisheries) have been temporarily "laid off" by turtles, while at the same time they now have to watch everyone else catch the same fish they used to catch.

and not only turtles but in Brunswick nets have to be 100 yards from shore. Two comms want it closer as they don't care how many endangered bottle nosed dolphin they kill so they can net spots easier than 110 yards off shore.



   
ReplyQuote
Kenneth Seigler
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 14 years ago
Posts: 1001
 

My bet would be on targeting of spawning fish. Trawling has declined 80-90% just in the last 10 years.

Size has been increased 5 times in past 10 years, 12"....13"....13.5"....14"....15"

Target has been consistently shifted upward toward spawning bio-mass.

Fewer chickens, fewer eggs. And sending more chickens down stream to lay eggs, and only to be slaughtered by everyone else (other states) isn't the whole answer either. But one thing is deftly apparent, increasing sizes limits isn't going to address any portion of the issue. If it were, we would have seen marked improvements by now.

Might suggest in fact reducing size limit and take some of the pressure off larger fish. Pretty quick growing fish, so the growth of a 14" to a fully mature 16" is very short. Maybe 2 to 4 months ? That's a pretty quick turn around.

Does trawling have an impact in juvenile mortality ? I'm sure it has played at least some part, but so does all fishing mortality from every sector.

~

I'm a rec. I personally think this idea has merit, and it is not clear to me why it is not getting more consideration. I think it makes sense to limit the harvest of the larger fish. There are more small fish out there and many of those likely are harvested by other predators before reaching a large size anyway. Harvest a few, reduce discard mortality, leave the large females to spawn. Maybe allow "a trophy" to be harvested as a compromise (something like 1 over 18 inches).

If harvest is consistent across all sectors (ie) rec. limit is 5 fish with one over 18", then likewise it would appear comm. harvest held to same standards, 1 in five fish over 18 inches. 13 inch creel limit. For comms. fish must be graded and separated on the boat with 18" and over in one container and less than 18" in a separate container for inspection purposes.

High grading should be encouraged with a $1,000 fine.

~



   
ReplyQuote
John Rakoci
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 14 years ago
Posts: 2331
 

So who or what is withdrawing the funds (fish) My idea 25% across the board reduction check the hell out of everyone including night checks for a year.One way or another you will find where the fish go. It,s almost like someone sucks those things up at night. Are fish being caught that never see our shores or have they moved they may not be that dumb. Go to SC fish houses ask them where the flounder come from your answer will be NC heck they even advertise it on the signs outside FRESH NC FLOUNDER AND SHRIMP. If a man can make money on something for every legal person doing it there are 5 that are not legal in the mix.

Those comms recently caught in Wilmington with a truck load of illegal reds were fined $1000, charged $203 restitution, and about $200 in court costs. Figure if a rec has ONE too many his fine will be $150. So are the courts along with DMF and MFC kissing the rear of comms or not? Never found out which fish house they were selling to and bet they are not the only ones.



   
ReplyQuote
john Smith
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 18 years ago
Posts: 1776
 

I'd hate to be one who thinks their hobby lifestyle is more important than someones job.No offense,they are equally important

Almost ~~ ALMOST every gill netter is a hobbyist making less than $1000 while being subsidized by taxpayers much more than that. $1.1 Million set aside for the observer program as we know they cannot count as high as 1 when finding a turtle. Their currently $200 annual license can be sold for $1800 - $2100 on Craigslist so taxpayers even subsidize their licenses.

:lmao:

"What's a turtle?"



   
ReplyQuote
Lyle
 Lyle
(@)
Estimable Member
Joined: 13 years ago
Posts: 146
Topic starter  

So who or what is withdrawing the funds (fish) My idea 25% across the board reduction check the hell out of everyone including night checks for a year.One way or another you will find where the fish go. It,s almost like someone sucks those things up at night. Are fish being caught that never see our shores or have they moved they may not be that dumb. Go to SC fish houses ask them where the flounder come from your answer will be NC heck they even advertise it on the signs outside FRESH NC FLOUNDER AND SHRIMP. If a man can make money on something for every legal person doing it there are 5 that are not legal in the mix.

Those comms recently caught in Wilmington with a truck load of illegal reds were fined $1000, charged $203 restitution, and about $200 in court costs. Figure if a rec has ONE too many his fine will be $150. So are the courts along with DMF and MFC kissing the rear of comms or not? Never found out which fish house they were selling to and bet they are not the only ones. Start another thread or stick to the LEGAL HARVEST of southern flounder. No one wants to read you regurgitated nonsense.

You state that ........"Almost ~~ ALMOST every gill netter is a hobbyist making less than $1000 while being subsidized by taxpayers much more than that. $1.1 Million set aside for the observer program as we know they cannot count as high as 1 when finding a turtle. Their currently $200 annual license can be sold for $1800 - $2100 on Craigslist so taxpayers even subsidize their licenses."

Please provide the source of that information and elaborate on how it was derived. Take note that your source may not have included all gillnet or species landed by gillnet fishermen. I won't hold my breath........we all know that you do nothing more than parrot what you've read on the internet.

Also, I would like to know where I can renew my commercial license for $200. Location and contact info will be fine, thanks.



   
ReplyQuote
Lyle
 Lyle
(@)
Estimable Member
Joined: 13 years ago
Posts: 146
Topic starter  

So who or what is withdrawing the funds (fish) My idea 25% across the board reduction check the hell out of everyone including night checks for a year.One way or another you will find where the fish go. It,s almost like someone sucks those things up at night. Are fish being caught that never see our shores or have they moved they may not be that dumb. Go to SC fish houses ask them where the flounder come from your answer will be NC heck they even advertise it on the signs outside FRESH NC FLOUNDER AND SHRIMP. If a man can make money on something for every legal person doing it there are 5 that are not legal in the mix.

Southern flounder leave our state every fall, they don't stay here.

The flounder you see for sale could be southern flounder caught in the inshore fisheries(gillnet, poundnet, gig) or they could be summer flounder caught in the trawl fishery that occurs off the coast of northern states but are landed here.



   
ReplyQuote
JOHNNY CARPENTER
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 14 years ago
Posts: 1169
 

deleted



   
ReplyQuote
Kenneth Seigler
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 14 years ago
Posts: 1001
 

Curious, would you be willing to sell your house and boat then move some where else ?

I ask because that's the position you would be putting a lot of other people in.

edit: Sorry you felt you had to delete the post.



   
ReplyQuote
Page 5 / 10
Share: