SWC Forums

Pull up a chair...let's talk fishing.

NCMFC member Chuck ...
 
Notifications
Clear all

NCMFC member Chuck Laughridge wants to close recreational harvest

140 Posts
29 Users
0 Reactions
4,351 Views
JOHNNY CARPENTER
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 14 years ago
Posts: 1169
 

Curious, would you be willing to sell your house and boat then move some where else ?

I ask because that's the position you would be putting a lot people in.

Sorry you felt you had delete the post.

Yep, me too. Don't ever want to put anyone in that position. Me personally, I am done with this. FISH ON!!! But I would like to move to the coast and fish all I could.



   
ReplyQuote
Kenneth Seigler
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 14 years ago
Posts: 1001
 

And I suspect if you were to contact most anyone, you would certainly find you would be more than welcome to do so.

As Bob Barker put it best, COME ON DOWN !



   
ReplyQuote
JOHNNY CARPENTER
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 14 years ago
Posts: 1169
 

I'll be there as soon as ice fishing season in NC is over.



   
ReplyQuote
Kenneth Seigler
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 14 years ago
Posts: 1001
 

Shucks come on now, break out the tank top, shorts, and flip flops.......Let's go FICHIN' !!!



   
ReplyQuote
Carlton Pittman
(@cap1)
Reputable Member
Joined: 19 years ago
Posts: 380
 

Buddy,
You're the Numbers Man.
NOT
Again, how many people make a 'major portion' of their livelihood from flounder?
Why is it necessary a major portion of anyone's income come from any specie be used to determine who is allowed to catch and who isn't.
Do southern flounder comprise a major portion of what you catch, if not why are you still catching them?

Economic impact of their fishing efforts?
I follow the rules, I work, and pay taxes....those are the requirements.
Numbers of pounds of flounder taken?
Dead fish is a dead fish, doesn't matter who catches it.
Number of pounds of by-catch (reds for example) sold?
http://portal.ncdenr.org/web/mf/statistics/comstat
Months when these fish are taken?
Every month of the year, except commercial is closed Dec. 1 every year.
If as suggested, a flounder season late in the year is needed to take and sell reds as allowable by-catch, why the flounder target when these fish should be allowed to migrate to offshore spawning waters?
Why would you desire to send foreign aid to other states that don't even have FMP's to manage the stock?
And why is any allowable by-catch necessary?
Just trying to understand why would anyone desire to waste fish?

BR – you threw up the ‘major portion’ comment into the discussion. I am only trying to understand whether there is a HUGE impact (numbers of fishermen affected as you CLAIM), or a smaller number. I suspect a smaller number, but their impact on the target species (flounder in this discussion, but negatively impacting a number of other species) is HUGE. Plus the dead and discard, much of which will be juvenile fish species – fish that never even had a chance to reproduce to augment the gene pool.

The Dead fish is a dead fish is just more deflection and denial. So for the last available year numbers were/are available, there were 2 MILLION pounds of flounder supposedly taken by commercial fishermen with and value of $5+ Million. = $2.59/pound (by the numbers in the link you provided for southern flounder).

I never mentioned FOREIGN aid, or aid of any kind to anyone. More deflection and BS BR. Commercial fishermen should not receive either State or Federal aid. They either make a living catching fish, as determined by quota and established management practices, or they get out of the business and find other means of income. Simple, as it works in any other (successful) business model. No subsidies, no aid.

If flounder in fact do migrate into the ocean to spawn in the fall, then closing netting – by far the biggest take method as well as the cause of the most wasted and under sized fish taken – would seem to be a prudent step in fisheries management. Can we get this to happen ASAP? If you really want the species to recover then closing flounder takes in October, November, and December would seem reasonable. And yes, I can support all closure – commercial and rec.

I never ONCE mentioned WASTING fish. I take very little of any species in proportion, and only what I eat. As Tim has noted, flounder mortality due to rec release, even when hook is left and line cut, is NOT what the commercial sector has bantered around as the reason for the state of flounder stocks.

So you think it is OK to have a flounder season solely to be able to take red drum as by-catch so you can sell them? Terrible reasoning, and I understand why the commercial sector do not want real folks to see the video of Shackelford. SHAM fishing/netting is what it is. Destructive and wasteful.

I try and see the hard working mans’ commercial point of view, but the more I learn, and more I hear from them, the less valid arguments they have, and (hopefully) the closer we can get to a ban in INSHORE netting.



   
ReplyQuote
David Plowden
(@mealonreels)
Prominent Member
Joined: 16 years ago
Posts: 652
 

I find it hard to be convinced with statements containing the words "I suspect","HUGE","smaller", and"if"so&so.It makes for a strong opinion but still an opinion.Let me guess....deflection



   
ReplyQuote
Kenneth Seigler
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 14 years ago
Posts: 1001
 

BR – you threw up the ‘major portion’ comment into the discussion. I am only trying to understand whether there is a HUGE impact (numbers of fishermen affected as you CLAIM), or a smaller number. I suspect a smaller number, but their impact on the target species (flounder in this discussion, but negatively impacting a number of other species) is HUGE. Plus the dead and discard, much of which will be juvenile fish species – fish that never even had a chance to reproduce to augment the gene pool.

The Dead fish is a dead fish is just more deflection and denial. So for the last available year numbers were/are available, there were 2 MILLION pounds of flounder supposedly taken by commercial fishermen with and value of $5+ Million. = $2.59/pound (by the numbers in the link you provided for southern flounder).

I never mentioned FOREIGN aid, or aid of any kind to anyone. More deflection and BS BR. Commercial fishermen should not receive either State or Federal aid. They either make a living catching fish, as determined by quota and established management practices, or they get out of the business and find other means of income. Simple, as it works in any other (successful) business model. No subsidies, no aid.

If flounder in fact do migrate into the ocean to spawn in the fall, then closing netting – by far the biggest take method as well as the cause of the most wasted and under sized fish taken – would seem to be a prudent step in fisheries management. Can we get this to happen ASAP? If you really want the species to recover then closing flounder takes in October, November, and December would seem reasonable. And yes, I can support all closure – commercial and rec.

I never ONCE mentioned WASTING fish. I take very little of any species in proportion, and only what I eat. As Tim has noted, flounder mortality due to rec release, even when hook is left and line cut, is NOT what the commercial sector has bantered around as the reason for the state of flounder stocks.

So you think it is OK to have a flounder season solely to be able to take red drum as by-catch so you can sell them? Terrible reasoning, and I understand why the commercial sector do not want real folks to see the video of Shackelford. SHAM fishing/netting is what it is. Destructive and wasteful.

I try and see the hard working mans’ commercial point of view, but the more I learn, and more I hear from them, the less valid arguments they have, and (hopefully) the closer we can get to a ban in INSHORE netting.

Sounds like a super sized helping of conjecture and innuendo with a side order of hyperbole and BS dippin' sauce IMO.



   
ReplyQuote
Carlton Pittman
(@cap1)
Reputable Member
Joined: 19 years ago
Posts: 380
 

I am done with this.

Don't give up Dog. That is EXACTLY what they want. They use brow beating, intimidation, and just plain try to beat down ANYONE they can that opposes their continued wanton taking of resources in hopes of continuing the destructive and wasteful netting practices.

BR, just more BS, deflecting, and denying from you. You have not answered a single legitimate question I have asked today.

CoastalC - don't go talking sense to them. lol. They don't know what do to with it. They want to continue their ways knowing if we ever get a net ban in N.C., they might have to get jobs or their corruption be revealed.

Gosh help the poor flounder and juvenile fish they waste which never get a chance to reproduce.



   
ReplyQuote
Kenneth Seigler
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 14 years ago
Posts: 1001
 

Actually, made every effort to answer ever single question you ask prior to you going into your latest irrational rant and incoherent drivel. But you have yet to answer a single question I ask.......Please Carry On..........

Buddy,
You're the Numbers Man.
NOT
Again, how many people make a 'major portion' of their livelihood from flounder?
Why is it necessary a major portion of anyone's income come from any specie be used to determine who is allowed to catch and who isn't.
Do southern flounder comprise a major portion of what you catch, if not why are you still catching them?

Economic impact of their fishing efforts?
I follow the rules, I work, and pay taxes....those are the requirements.
Numbers of pounds of flounder taken?
Dead fish is a dead fish, doesn't matter who catches it.
Number of pounds of by-catch (reds for example) sold?
http://portal.ncdenr.org/web/mf/statistics/comstat
Months when these fish are taken?
Every month of the year, except commercial is closed Dec. 1 every year.
If as suggested, a flounder season late in the year is needed to take and sell reds as allowable by-catch, why the flounder target when these fish should be allowed to migrate to offshore spawning waters?
Why would you desire to send foreign aid to other states that don't even have FMP's to manage the stock?
And why is any allowable by-catch necessary?
Just trying to understand why would anyone desire to waste fish?



   
ReplyQuote
John Rakoci
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 14 years ago
Posts: 2331
 

I am done with this.

Don't give up Dog. That is EXACTLY what they want. They use brow beating, intimidation, and just plain try to beat down ANYONE they can that opposes their continued wanton taking of resources in hopes of continuing the destructive and wasteful netting practices.

BR, just more BS, deflecting, and denying from you. You have not answered a single legitimate question I have asked today.

CoastalC - don't go talking sense to them. lol. They don't know what do to with it. They want to continue their ways knowing if we ever get a net ban in N.C., they might have to get jobs or their corruption be revealed.

Gosh help the poor flounder and juvenile fish they waste which never get a chance to reproduce.

CAP ~~ It is impossible to keep those clowns honest but it is fun watching them deny, deflect, delay, and lie. No one wants or at least believes there will be a 'net ban'. Just how about bringing NC regs in line with the rest of the states and into the 21st century from the 19th. None would lose their 'job' if they are able to adapt. It may mean they actually are required to work but other states have a commercial fishery, just not one where comms are treated like spoiled children.



   
ReplyQuote
David Plowden
(@mealonreels)
Prominent Member
Joined: 16 years ago
Posts: 652
 

CC gets a FP grand slam on that one."Clowns",Liars ,"spoiled children" in one post.Congradulations



   
ReplyQuote
Bernie McCants
(@)
Reputable Member
Joined: 22 years ago
Posts: 289
 

CoastalC - don't go talking sense to them. lol.

:lmao: :lmao: :lmao:



   
ReplyQuote
Carlton Pittman
(@cap1)
Reputable Member
Joined: 19 years ago
Posts: 380
 

CAP ~~ It is impossible to keep those clowns honest but it is fun watching them deny, deflect, delay, and lie. No one wants or at least believes there will be a 'net ban'. Just how about bringing NC regs in line with the rest of the states and into the 21st century from the 19th. None would lose their 'job' if they are able to adapt. It may mean they actually are required to work but other states have a commercial fishery, just not one where comms are treated like spoiled children.

CC - I know, and you are right again. One day though, one day this state will either be moved into reasonable fisheries management, or be dragged in to it. And they will either learn to adapt, or learn to struggle. I hate to see anyone struggle, but it will be their own fault at their own hands when it happens.

BR, there is nothing irrational or incoherent about anything I asked. Only more deny, deflect and untruths in much of the blather written on these topics.

Catch 'em up.



   
ReplyQuote
Lyle
 Lyle
(@)
Estimable Member
Joined: 13 years ago
Posts: 146
Topic starter  

I am done with this.

Don't give up Dog. That is EXACTLY what they want. They use brow beating, intimidation, and just plain try to beat down ANYONE they can that opposes their continued wanton taking of resources in hopes of continuing the destructive and wasteful netting practices.

BR, just more BS, deflecting, and denying from you. You have not answered a single legitimate question I have asked today.

CoastalC - don't go talking sense to them. lol. They don't know what do to with it. They want to continue their ways knowing if we ever get a net ban in N.C., they might have to get jobs or their corruption be revealed.

Gosh help the poor flounder and juvenile fish they waste which never get a chance to reproduce.

CAP ~~ It is impossible to keep those clowns honest but it is fun watching them deny, deflect, delay, and lie. No one wants or at least believes there will be a 'net ban'. Just how about bringing NC regs in line with the rest of the states and into the 21st century from the 19th. None would lose their 'job' if they are able to adapt. It may mean they actually are required to work but other states have a commercial fishery, just not one where comms are treated like spoiled children.

You have time to post more nonsense but still have not told me where I can renew my license for $200.

You also have not cited the source of the nonsense you posted earlier. If you can not answer the simple questions that were asked of you, we will have to believe you don't have a clue what you are talking about.

Also, ignoring the questions will be considered denying, deflecting and delaying or that you have lied. How ironic would that be?

BTW, "BLESS YOUR HEART".



   
ReplyQuote
Daniel Watson
(@)
Estimable Member
Joined: 15 years ago
Posts: 177
 

I am done with this.

Don't give up Dog. That is EXACTLY what they want. They use brow beating, intimidation, and just plain try to beat down ANYONE they can that opposes their continued wanton taking of resources in hopes of continuing the destructive and wasteful netting practices.

BR, just more BS, deflecting, and denying from you. You have not answered a single legitimate question I have asked today.

CoastalC - don't go talking sense to them. lol. They don't know what do to with it. They want to continue their ways knowing if we ever get a net ban in N.C., they might have to get jobs or their corruption be revealed.

Gosh help the poor flounder and juvenile fish they waste which never get a chance to reproduce.

CAP ~~ It is impossible to keep those clowns honest but it is fun watching them deny, deflect, delay, and lie. No one wants or at least believes there will be a 'net ban'. Just how about bringing NC regs in line with the rest of the states and into the 21st century from the 19th. None would lose their 'job' if they are able to adapt. It may mean they actually are required to work but other states have a commercial fishery, just not one where comms are treated like spoiled children.

You have time to post more nonsense but still have not told me where I can renew my license for $200.

You also have not cited the source of the nonsense you posted earlier. If you can not answer the simple questions that were asked of you, we will have to believe you don't have a clue what you are talking about.

Also, ignoring the questing will be considered denying, deflecting and delaying or that you have lied. How ironic would that be?

BTW, "BLESS YOUR HEART".

He got his information from the internet....you do know that no one can put anything on the internet that is not true don't you?



   
ReplyQuote
Page 6 / 10
Share: