SWC Forums

Pull up a chair...let's talk fishing.

NCMFC member Chuck ...
 
Notifications
Clear all

NCMFC member Chuck Laughridge wants to close recreational harvest

140 Posts
29 Users
0 Reactions
4,349 Views
Kenneth Seigler
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 14 years ago
Posts: 1001
 

Just an observation,

You CCA fellas need to work real hard to at least get on the same page.

Your divide and conquer scheme appears to be coming home to roost.

I support a state log book

cca has not offered a complete closure.

Close recs AND comms for a year! No flounder....

If it is closed for recs....., i would just gig comm.

The hell. That's insane.

CoastalC - don't go talking sense to them. lol.

:lmao: :lmao: :lmao:



   
ReplyQuote
Bernie McCants
(@)
Reputable Member
Joined: 22 years ago
Posts: 289
 

Ain't the Internet great! Occasionally you can have reasonable informative discussion on controversial subjects, but there is nothing to keep the feces-throwing chimp from showing up hoping some of his crap will stick.

But I digress: Southern flounder are overfished and overfishing is occurring as best as the data and the models can tell us. But there is nothing to indicate they are about to collapse and we need a year or years of a shut down.

Here the basic overriding conclusion of the stock assessment, and I quote:

"The 2005 southern flounder stock assessment determined the stock was overfished and overfishing was occurring. Since the implementation of the 2005 FMP, the stock status of southern flounder has improved with decreases in fishing mortality , increases in spawning stock biomass , and expansion of age classes. However, the 2009 assessment still finds the stock to be overfished and overfishing is still occurring."

Unlike the river herring, where a moratorium was justified, southern flounder need further reductions in harvest not a total cession of harvest.



   
ReplyQuote
Kenneth Seigler
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 14 years ago
Posts: 1001
 

BW, I sort of like DFS5's approach 1 in 5 (or whatever appropriate number) over 18" (possibly 17" ?), but with the advert it were applied equitably across all sectors. With 13" minimum creel size.
Southern flounder are relative small batch spawns compared to other species.

+More adults escape could lead to more eggs / juvenile approach.
+ Recover significant number of discards from nets
+ Recover significant number of discards from H&L
+ waste in sub-legal juvenile mortality converted to usable harvest (other states harvest at 12")
+ insures more male fish could be harvested (shifts catch target away from larger female fish).
+ Rapid growth, short turn around time
+ Reduce user conflict, two creel sizes
+ It's been 10 years now, any increase in minimum creel size at this point would appear redundant (would have expected to see significant marked improvements long before now.
- No assurance adult capture wouldn't occur else where.

Sidebar River Herring: Moratorium on landings made no sense when an absolute minimum would have completely satisfied most.
Dead fish don't spawn.

~



   
ReplyQuote
Glen Montgomery
(@)
Reputable Member
Joined: 16 years ago
Posts: 284
 

Ken, I agree that we should be more concerned about the larger spawners than the 13 thru 15 inch class of flounder. I am still trying to figure out why people keep insisting that every freeking southern flounder must live long enough to spawn at least once. Some of them yes, but not most . Think that idea comes mostly from watching too many Bambi movies.

Having said that, we have nothing in place to prevent more effort be it from netters or recs when flounder do become more abundant assuming that plans work the way they are suppose to work. When abundance does increase significantly one can bet their arse that so will effort which would likely put us back to square 1.



   
ReplyQuote
Kenneth Seigler
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 14 years ago
Posts: 1001
 

If they intended to fish large mesh, I would think they would have their permit in place by now, or most certainly by July 1 this year.

While at the same time a lot of people stopped fishing flounder years ago, such as myself. Reason why they stopped ? Should they now be issued a large mesh permit ? Should the permit be transferable ?

I would suggest the currently issued large mesh permits be an endorsement on the SCFL license, and thereby transferable. Apply same to pound nets. With appeals possible to the SCFL committee. New entrees approved by the SCFL committee could have possible additional one time fees. RCGL is not a transferable license, so additional fees for large mesh should apply each year. Gigs and spears should be commercial gear when used in conjunction with a vessel.

Ready to hear the discord, so have at it.............

~



   
ReplyQuote
Lyle
 Lyle
(@)
Estimable Member
Joined: 13 years ago
Posts: 146
Topic starter  

If they intended to fish large mesh, I would think they would have their permit in place by now, or most certainly by July 1 this year.

While at the same time a lot of people stopped fishing flounder years ago, such as myself. Reason why they stopped ? Should they now be issued a large mesh permit ? Should the permit be transferable ?

I would suggest the currently issued large mesh permits be an endorsement on the license, and thereby transferable. With appeals possible to the SCFL committee. New entrees approved by the SCFL committee could have possible additional one time fees.

Ready to hear the discord, so have at it.............

~

There are some that got the permit to fish in the fall and then canceled it after the flounder season ended. There is no way to notify them that you don't intend to fish for a set period of time so as long as you hold an active permit, observers keep calling. Flounder fishing does not occur twelve months out of the year and some guys participate in fisheries that keeps them away from a phone for days or even weeks. If you miss three observer calls, they take your permit.

I commercial fish year round. Because of regulations, I was allowed to fish large mesh gillnet for a total of about two months last year. It is a waste of the observers time and mine for them to contact me during the time I have no intentions of fishing. My area, that it clearly states I fish in on the permit, was closed to all anchored gillnets and they were still calling.



   
ReplyQuote
Kenneth Seigler
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 14 years ago
Posts: 1001
 

00Fishy, I would say that if you had the permit at any time, it would be a none issue. But once were an endorsement there should be no further question of participation.

Can't stop observers from doing the job that must be done, or no-one fishes. Perhaps a call in day ahead of time you intend to fish.
(is there a app. for that Don H ?)

If no response, then it certainly shouldn't be an issue tethered on your shoulders. JMO

I would also say that if there was a call in app. then there would be little question as to what effort in the fishery is. As is now, I believe effort is being based on number of fishers in the fishery times "X" number yards ?

With a call of who is actively fishing on any day, it would appear effort could more accurately calculated. Soak time could increase for those actively fishing using actual number of people fishing instead of extrapolating how yards, how long, what area.................

Some of the guys down here got two days and shut down on the third day.
~



   
ReplyQuote
Lyle
 Lyle
(@)
Estimable Member
Joined: 13 years ago
Posts: 146
Topic starter  

00Fishy, I would say that if you had the permit at any time, it would be a none issue. But once were an endorsement there should be no further question of participation.

Can't stop observers from doing the job that must be done, or no-one fishes. Perhaps a call in day ahead of time you intend to fish.
(is there a app. for that Don H ?)

If no response, then it certainly shouldn't be an issue tethered on your shoulders. JMO

When we first had the original PSGNRA permit, I believe we were required to call in if we were going to fish that week but I could be wrong. The section of that area that I fished didn't stay open long the first year and has been closed every year since.

IMO, you should be allowed to call and "activate" or "deactivate" your permit so they know who is fishing and when, and not waste their time calling folks that aren't actively participating in the fishery at that time. Their(observers) time is money, and we're paying for it.



   
ReplyQuote
Kenneth Seigler
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 14 years ago
Posts: 1001
 

Totally agree 00, don't see why Don H. would have much of a problem with developing an app. for that. He could look at his PC screen and see who to call and not to call. Maybe be add in a space for number of yards you expect to fish on each trip. Get a accurate real time measure of effort every single day.

May also find out that some areas could use more yards while others may actually benefit with fewer yards.

(ie) Fished 1,000 yds. two days and caught 100 lbs then shut down by turtles.
Fished 600 yds. for 5 days caught 300 lbs. before being shut down by turtles.



   
ReplyQuote
Carlton Pittman
(@cap1)
Reputable Member
Joined: 19 years ago
Posts: 380
 

Thank god for the turtles. Just think of all the fish they save.

BR, if you don't flounder fish anymore, why all the belly-aching over a reduced commercial take in order to replenish the species?
Is it because of the N.C. Seafood Alliance - of which you appear to be president - needs to buy fish from (a relatives' permitted to buy) seafood source?

Follow the $, follow the nets.
CONFLICTS of INTEREST to have a member of the Finfish advisory council so deeply involved in commercial seafood commerce as well as commercial fishery management.
Foxes guarding the henhouse continues.



   
ReplyQuote
Lyle
 Lyle
(@)
Estimable Member
Joined: 13 years ago
Posts: 146
Topic starter  

Thank god for the turtles. Just think of all the fish they save.

Maybe your reading comprehension isn't all that good, haven't been following along or are just spouting off like "carolina crabby captain" or whatever personality he is today............. but it doesn't seem they have saved any fish.

All the turtle regulations have done for southern flounder is shift the harvest from 6+ months of the year to about 2 or 3 months of the year. These fish do not live in our waters all their life. They come here as juveniles, grow throughout the summer, then leave and spawn elsewhere. Not many that leave are coming back.\

And as far as BR being involved with the finfish committee, ............he makes recommendations, not regulations.



   
ReplyQuote
Glen Montgomery
(@)
Reputable Member
Joined: 16 years ago
Posts: 284
 

Cap1 in your humble opinion who do you think would be better at giving advice to the MFC when it comes to flounder issues? people that don't have a clue about the fishery such as most people or fishermen that actually participate in the fishery. Remember the advisory committees are made up of 3 groups. One group represents the scientific folk, another group represent the various rec interest and the 3 rd group is composed of commercial fishermen or seafood dealers. Much like the makeup of the MFC itself. And finally as I have said many times on another board, All rec committee members or MFC members may not always vote the way the CCA organization would like since the CCA actually represents a very very small percent of NC's recreational fishermen.



   
ReplyQuote
Bob
 Bob
(@)
Reputable Member
Joined: 16 years ago
Posts: 331
 

Ain't the Internet great! Occasionally you can have reasonable informative discussion on controversial subjects, but there is nothing to keep the feces-throwing chimp from showing up hoping some of his crap will stick. .........................
.......................
........................

Exactly as Al Gore intended when he invented it.



   
ReplyQuote
Kenneth Seigler
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 14 years ago
Posts: 1001
 

make recommendations, not regulations.

Exactly 00, that's why input from as many guys/gals as possible is so important. Every area is different and fished in vastly different ways. What works for guys down this way may be completely out of consideration for guys up your way. Totally different habitat.



   
ReplyQuote
Carlton Pittman
(@cap1)
Reputable Member
Joined: 19 years ago
Posts: 380
 

Input from knowledgeable individuals who do not have a clear conflict of interest would be helpful.
Input to a council which did not have hidden agendas and was not in the pocket of a particular group involved would be best, and helpful to all involved, particularly the fish.
Having a council which was not lead by someone with conflicting interests would benefit the entire state.

First BR says commercial fishing is permitted all year, but closes December 1. (I guess this is there Shackelford's need for a December flounder season to take reds as by-catch comes in play - lol).

Then fishy says the turtles have caused fishing to cut from 6 months to 2-3 months. Which is it? And let's forget the commercial side which in large part caused the turtle card to be in play to start with. (I will admit I saw a TON of turtles over the Thanksgiving weekend, all sunning on top in the warm sun between shore and FPT. It was cool to see t hem.)

And now y'all are complaining about only being able to fish 4 days/year. Let's see if we can get it down to zero days/year for 1-2 years and see how all fisheries can recover.

DE'r, in my HUMBLE opinion, it would be best to use all available UNBIASED science and studies/sampling to determine population levels, fishing decline causation, limit said causation until stocks are determined by unbiased study to have recovered sufficiently to return to limited harvest levels, then increased harvest levels as additional studies confirm (or refute) fish have returned to acceptable harvest levels.
It would take several years.
Remove all gillnets, inshore trawls, and see how the overall fishing population responds.

How anyone can possibly believe that taking more juvenile pre-spawn fish will help the flounder recover is beyond me. There is barely enough meat on a 14" flounder to make it worth killing. Push the limit to 18" is fine by me. Cut rec limit to 4/day - fine by me.

But do ANYTHING possible to get the destructive gillnets and inshore trawl nets gone from our state waters. :wtg: We would have an awesome inshore fishery to match places in our state where we have world class nearshore and offshore fishing.

Good day fellas.



   
ReplyQuote
Page 7 / 10
Share: