SWC Forums

Pull up a chair...let's talk fishing.

NCMFC member Chuck ...
 
Notifications
Clear all

NCMFC member Chuck Laughridge wants to close recreational harvest

140 Posts
29 Users
0 Reactions
4,347 Views
Kenneth Seigler
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 14 years ago
Posts: 1001
 

fishing decline causation

We already know nets aren't the causation, red drum in FLA. and southern flounder in Texas are prime examples.

Remove all gillnets, inshore trawls, and see how the overall fishing population responds.

We already know how the population responds.

"Southern flounder Paralichthys lethostigma populations in Texas have been in steady decline over the last 25 years."

http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:0I8rEuJh5N0J:fisheries.tamucc.edu/images/Thesis/Nanez-JamesThesis.pdf+&cd=1&hl=en&ct=clnk&gl=us

The question possed is, as a recreational fishermen would it have any impact on you ability to catch fish if you were allowed a 13" creel size with one fish over 18".

~



   
ReplyQuote
George Golinski
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 19 years ago
Posts: 1371
 

In Texas they seem to think that overfishing, both commercial and recreational, is contributing to the decline of Southern Flounder numbers, with by catch from shrimp trawling as the prime factor.

Texas
Note that Texas represents the boundary between the eastern and western Gulf of Mexico populations (Blandon et al. 2001) and the Texas Stock is considered to be in poor condition due to the impact of by-catch from shrimp trawlers and the effects of a skewed sex ratio which may limit reproduction (SeaFood Watch 2004). Southern flounder is harvested in both the commercial and recreational sectors in Texas. Although separate catch statistics are not available, Southern Flounder dominates the overall flounder catch (approximately 95% of flounder caught are P. lethostigma and most are females (due to the 14” size restriction). Large amounts of the smaller A skewed sex ratio has emerged; out of ~ 900 individuals that could be sexed, 17% were male, indicating a female: male ratio of 6:1 which may be limiting reproduction (GSMFC 2000).

Declines in commercial and recreational landings of Southern Flounder in Texas prompted an examination of long-term population trends. A fisheries independent data set (1975–2008) was used to assess population trends of juvenile and adult Southern Flounder along the Texas coast in the northern Gulf of Mexico, USA. The dataset contained a total of 46,784 sites that were sampled with bag seines to monitor small nekton abundance and 22,870 sites that were sampled with gill nets to assess adult fisheries trends. Researchers found that that both juveniles and adults in the Southern Flounder population have been continuously declining, with rates of decline in abundance of juveniles estimated at 1.3% per year, while those for adults are nearly double, estimated at 2.5% per year (Froeschke et al. 2011). Additionally, a reduced proportion of P. lethostigma on the Texas coast is reaching the age at maturity.

The following decreases in harvest were recorded in Texas waters and prompted the above examination:

Inshore commercial harvest: Declined from 500,000 fish per year between 1985 and 1987 to <100,000 fish in 2007 (Riechers 2008).
Recreational catches: Declined from 200,000 fish in 1987 to <50,000 fish in 2007 (Riechers 2008)
Offshore commercial catch rates: Declined from 325,000 fish in 1987 to <50,000 in 2007 (Riechers 2008).

In the western Gulf of Mexico, where P. lethostigma comprises the large majority (95%) of all flounder species, assessments are performed in the state of Texas. Analysis of long-term population trends in Texas found that that both juveniles and adults have been continuously declining, with rates of decline in abundance of juveniles estimated at 1.3% per year, while those for adults are nearly double, estimated at 2.5% per year. These declines have been attributed to commercial and recreational over harvesting as well as by-catch mortality from the shrimp trawl fishery.

In addition to being commercially important, P. lethostigma is heavily impacted by by-catch mortality, primarily from shrimp trawling. This threat is not clearly understood, however declines in abundance in both the Western Gulf of Mexico and off the coast of North Carolina have been attributed to shrimp trawling. In Texas, shrimp trawling is considered to be a major contributor to declines in abundance.
Interesting numbers on the sex difference though.



   
ReplyQuote
Carlton Pittman
(@cap1)
Reputable Member
Joined: 19 years ago
Posts: 380
 

The question possed is, as a recreational fishermen would it have any impact on you ability to catch fish if you were allowed a 13" creel size with one fish over 18".

I expect the 1st year there would be a lot of smaller flounder taken, followed by decreasing overall catch numbers over subsequent years.
Until nets are removed from the equation.

You're citing a study from 2006?

Keep living in the past guys. Time will pass you by.



   
ReplyQuote
Sam Jackson
(@)
Trusted Member
Joined: 19 years ago
Posts: 75
 

We already know nets aren't the causation, red drum in FLA. and southern flounder in Texas are prime examples.

So the recs are the cause of the overfishing?



   
ReplyQuote
George Golinski
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 19 years ago
Posts: 1371
 

Gill nets are not the only commercial gear used in the flounder fishery. According to the above report shrimp trawl by-catch is the prime suspect in the Texas problem. Commercial fishermen are also allowed to gig 60 fish per day.
The following decreases in harvest were recorded in Texas waters and prompted the above examination:

Inshore commercial harvest: Declined from 500,000 fish per year between 1985 and 1987 to <100,000 fish in 2007 (Riechers 2008).
Recreational catches: Declined from 200,000 fish in 1987 to <50,000 fish in 2007 (Riechers 2008)
Offshore commercial catch rates: Declined from 325,000 fish in 1987 to <50,000 in 2007 (Riechers 2008).

850,000 commercially caught fish vs 200,000 recreationally caught fish.



   
ReplyQuote
Lyle
 Lyle
(@)
Estimable Member
Joined: 13 years ago
Posts: 146
Topic starter  

Gill nets are not the only commercial gear used in the flounder fishery. According to the above report shrimp trawl by-catch is the prime suspect in the Texas problem. Commercial fishermen are also allowed to gig 60 fish per day.
The following decreases in harvest were recorded in Texas waters and prompted the above examination:

Inshore commercial harvest: Declined from 500,000 fish per year between 1985 and 1987 to <100,000 fish in 2007 (Riechers 2008).
Recreational catches: Declined from 200,000 fish in 1987 to <50,000 fish in 2007 (Riechers 2008)
Offshore commercial catch rates: Declined from 325,000 fish in 1987 to <50,000 in 2007 (Riechers 2008).

850,000 commercially caught fish vs 200,000 recreationally caught fish.

We are in NC, not Texas, and I don't believe the harvest of legal sized southern flounder by shrimp trawls is very much at all. The number of juvenile flounder in the bycatch could be of issue though.

Another thing to consider is that turtle excluders became mandatory between the two time frames used in your Texas study and they significantly reduce the number of legal size southern flounder caught in a trawl.

Also of note from that study is that it says that the harvest is 6 females to 1 male because of the 14" size restriction.



   
ReplyQuote
Kenneth Seigler
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 14 years ago
Posts: 1001
 

We already know nets aren't the causation, red drum in FLA. and southern flounder in Texas are prime examples.

So the recs are the cause of the overfishing?

Didn't say nor is it implied. Simply put, the focus of the wacko groups is it's always the net's or it's always what the commercial fishermen is doing(low hanging fruit). When in fact it's an "all of the above issue". One thing is perfectly clear in the two instances pointed out. Nets were banned and weren't even in the water so how could they have possibly played a part.

Do net's play a part in NC, sure they do. Does C&R play a part in NC, sure it does......etc. It's all of the above, and as I have sad before, lopping the cat's head off isn't going to stop the dog from chasin' cats.

Marlin, if it were 200 K commercial vx. 850 K recreational would it really make a difference? The stock would still be overfished and still be in decline either way.

I did find this part of the statement quite interesting though,

(approximately 95% of flounder caught are P. lethostigma and most are females (due to the 14” size restriction).

~



   
ReplyQuote
Raeford Brown
(@)
Estimable Member
Joined: 16 years ago
Posts: 56
 

I can only assume that he was making a joke. If not, then I suggest
he clean his hard drive. It has some sort of serious virus, possibly
an infection from inside the beltline in Washington.



   
ReplyQuote
George Golinski
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 19 years ago
Posts: 1371
 

I found that interesting as well Ken. To continue: A skewed sex ratio has emerged; out of ~ 900 individuals that could be sexed, 17% were male, indicating a female: male ratio of 6:1 which may be limiting reproduction (GSMFC 2000).
In order to increase the population of the smaller males they would need to increase the minimum size limit. I have no issues with a 16 to 18 inch size limit for all sectors. By preserving the smaller fish and allowing them to reproduce more than once, the larger female fish become expendable and available for harvest with minimum impact to overall numbers.



   
ReplyQuote
John Rakoci
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 14 years ago
Posts: 2331
 

Thank god for the turtles. Just think of all the fish they save.

Maybe your reading comprehension isn't all that good, haven't been following along or are just spouting off like "carolina crabby captain" or whatever personality he is today............. but it doesn't seem they have saved any fish.

All the turtle regulations have done for southern flounder is shift the harvest from 6+ months of the year to about 2 or 3 months of the year. These fish do not live in our waters all their life. They come here as juveniles, grow throughout the summer, then leave and spawn elsewhere. Not many that leave are coming back.\

And as far as BR being involved with the finfish committee, ............he makes recommendations, not regulations.

Coming from you that is a compliment. it is great to hear BS and lies from you almost as much as your pal Ken, you two kiss when you woke up this morning?



   
ReplyQuote
Glen Montgomery
(@)
Reputable Member
Joined: 16 years ago
Posts: 284
 

MM, Why do you imply that its more important to protect the small flounder versus the larger ones? You realize that the larger fish have many more eggs than those that are barely mature? I am in no suggesting that we should be allowed to catch up all the smaller flounder or any fish for that matter but as far as production goes, the larger fish produce lots more eggs and are less subject to predation as well.



   
ReplyQuote
John Rakoci
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 14 years ago
Posts: 2331
 

Ken ~~ "wacko groups" like NCFA, MCWU, and the AC you sit on?

00 ~ You believe there are no juvenile flounder in nursery areas? OK! I know there are bridges for you to buy in NYC.

Maybe sandwich size flounder is the answer,,,, comms have been wanting smaller all the time. They sure would look tiny on a plate.

Whine on girls!



   
ReplyQuote
Kenneth Seigler
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 14 years ago
Posts: 1001
 

In order to increase the population of the smaller males they would need to increase the minimum size limit.

Marlin, males rarely exceed 13", by increasing the minimum size we would be focusing 100% of effort on the female fish, insuring every fish harvested would be a female fish. We are already near that point now if what was observed in the Texas study is true, at 14" inches....83% of the fish would be female. At 15' inches, little doubt we would be at 100% of the fish harvest would be female.

What is suggested is shifting effort away from the larger more productive female fish backward toward the male and smaller female less productive fish. (ie) decrease minimum creel size from current 14" commercial and 15" recreational to 13", so not only both user groups are fishing for the same size fish, but there is less pressure on the most productive larger females.

It is suggested by increasing the number of more productive larger female fish, we could reasonably expect increased spawning and thereby increased juveniles in the population.

~



   
ReplyQuote
Carlton Pittman
(@cap1)
Reputable Member
Joined: 19 years ago
Posts: 380
 

So you're telling me that reducing the size limit LESS larger fish will be harvested?
I can see the argument for allowing the larger breeding stock a better chance but in no scenario do I see a single commercial fisherman releasing more larger fish just because that can take more smaller ones.

You guys are so full of it your eyes must be all be brown.

Get the gillnets out of the water for 1-2 years, introduce a slot limit if science supports that as a means to increase stocks. See where we are in 1-2 years. It will actually take longer - the stock didn't get to this state in 1-2 years, so it will take more than that to replenish.



   
ReplyQuote
Kenneth Seigler
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 14 years ago
Posts: 1001
 

Coming from you that is a compliment. it is great to hear BS and lies from you almost as much as your pal Ken, you two kiss when you woke up this morning?

Being what is being discussed here is all Voodoo for you, why don't you go back to those tabloids.

I'm sure there is a section written with a paragraph or two just for you, look for the head lines, "Mother ship has landed".

~



   
ReplyQuote
Page 8 / 10
Share: