SWC Forums
Pull up a chair...let's talk fishing.
I can see the argument for allowing the larger breeding stock a better chance but in no scenario do I see a single commercial fisherman releasing more larger fish just because that can take more smaller ones.
One of the chief complaints prior was the split creel size, 14" comm. and 15" rec.
What is suggested is both user groups would be fishing under the exact same constraints.
1 in 5 (or whatever appropriate number) fish over 18" (possibly 17") with a 13" minimum creel size for all users.
Commercial would be required to grade fish on the boat for inspection, 18" and over in 1 container, and under 18" in a separate container. Verification simplified.........
the stock didn't get to this state in 1-2 years
That we can agree on, we've spent the past 2 FMP's and 10 years manicuring the stock to it's current condition by increasing the minimum size 5 times over the same time period.
12"....13".....13.5"......14"......15"
As usual, this convesation started out rationally with well thought out responses to one another. Even conflicting ideas treated with respect. Then a couple of folks, whom I won't name (dont need to) show up and start making snarky comments meant to derail the whole thing and devolve it into a pissing match. Then shortly there after, the thread is closed and all the good and relevant info contained within slips down and eventually off the page into obscurity. Please ignore those who bring nothing to the discussion. I have read this from the start and withheld my comments for that very reason. I have nothing new to add and my participation would only invite more trolls to the party, wielding one liners and emoticons aimed at killing the whole thing. I just wish others would have the same courtesy.
CC, I'm going to TRY and explain the comm licensing fee structure for you so that MAYBE you might come to actually understand it. These licenses are no longer available through the state other than by waiting list (waiting for older guys to die off without selling their's). That is the ONLY place one can buy a lic for $250 (last year, increasing substantially this year). As a result of the reduced availability through the state, capitalistic individuals saw a chance to sell those licenses when they got out for the sums you mentioned. Knowing a man might pay extra for not having to wait it out (rightly so). Still, once he buys that license for $2000 or whatever deal he strikes, he still must renew that license every year for the state madatory fee, So you see, there's no subsidizing going on, only an inability to comprehend facts that are readily available to anyone looking. If you look into just how many licenses the state issues every year through the waiting list, you'll see that VERY FEW people are buying licenses for $250.
While the same bunch of guys spew the same talking points for their respected side. I ask you each a question from a man that fishes. I would bet that those little black peckerheads (aka Black Sea Bass) will get rid of more flounder fry in a hatch on a wreck than recs and commercial combined. They are there 24 hours a day seven days a week just eating. I have seen a change in Flounder affected in the years since the size limit has increased from eight inches to today. Get rid of the over abundance of these peckerheads on the reefs and spawning grounds and watch your Flounder come back. Its crazy to watch Barefoot work his ass off to raise fingerlings to feed Sea Bass. Hell I'm sure we have paid for a survey on this somewhere. Manage these feeding machines then you can go back to nets, CCA or once look at the forest. 2 cents in.
Commercial would be required to grade fish on the boat for inspection
BR, the problem with this is the amount of discard dead by-catch to get to your quote. Dead discard by-catch of many species, not just the target species.
Then we get to the complete BS logic of needing a comm flounder season in the months where it seems flounder migrate into the ocean just to be able to kill and sell reds as by-catch. That is the most BS logic for allowing a season as there is.
Eric, or BR, can either of you say how many license holders there are? (I asked this early on and was blown off as usual.)
I would expect BR, as a member of the Finfish AC to have an idea, or at least be able to obtain this information.
57, interesting point. All I know regarding BSB is there are a darn ton of them in all waters I fish from the nearshore ARs on out to deeper water. My only problem on taking either smaller BSB or flounder, is there is not enough meat on either to make them work killing.
Let 'em grow. Let 'em reproduce. I didn't even know there were BSB cages out there slaying all the decent sized bass.
While the same bunch of guys spew the same talking points for their respected side. I ask you each a question from a man that fishes. I would bet that those little black peckerheads (aka Black Sea Bass) will get rid of more flounder fry in a hatch on a wreck than recs and commercial combined. They are there 24 hours a day seven days a week just eating. I have seen a change in Flounder affected in the years since the size limit has increased from eight inches to today. Get rid of the over abundance of these peckerheads on the reefs and spawning grounds and watch your Flounder come back. Its crazy to watch Barefoot work his ass off to raise fingerlings to feed Sea Bass. Hell I'm sure we have paid for a survey on this somewhere. Manage these feeding machines then you can go back to nets, CCA or once look at the forest. 2 cents in.
Now that makes sense!!!!!
Let the coomercials guys have 8 to 13 inch Sea Bass. Recs can have 14 and up. Only one guy out of Southport that fishes traps I think. I doubt he alone is hurting the bass. Think of the number of drops you make in a day. Now think of ratio of bass to flounder, grey trout, reef specis. Those little bass will keep a bottom clean and they are everywhere. Inshore to Gulf.
Commercial would be required to grade fish on the boat for inspection
BR, the problem with this is the amount of discard dead by-catch to get to your quote. Dead discard by-catch of many species, not just the target species.
What is suggested is a 13" creel size which would in fact decrease flounder discards from nets and make them usable as food on dinner tables, important to note Georgia and Florida creel size is 12" inches.
FLA.........10 per person per day..............12" total length
GA..........15 per person per day.............. 12" total length
SC..........15 per person per day not to exceed 30 per boat per day...... 14-inch TL
Other than that, I assume your referring to drum that are thicker than fleas on dog that fishermen are now forced to discard because someone thought wasting more fish by throwing overboard is better than putting them on dinner tables. I suppose that could be changed as well, by virtue of being hip deep in them at this point.
Please enlighten what other species you feel comprise a significant number of discards from flounder nets ................
I don't think anyone knows which species may, or may not be compromised at this point. That is part of the problem, and I assume part of the jurisdiction of the (compromised) MFC and DMF.
It's the waste of any species I have a problem with, mainly generated by mostly indiscriminate nets.
I don't think anyone knows which species may, or may not be compromised at this point. That is part of the problem, and I assume part of the jurisdiction of the (compromised) MFC and DMF.
It's the waste of any species I have a problem with, mainly generated by mostly indiscriminate nets.
Actually nets are very selective as flounder of less than 14" comprise less than 10% of total number of flounder caught. Decrease waste in fish and fishing mortality is what is needed. Converting waste into usable product by employing a 13" will eliminate that 10% waste of which all can agree is a good thing.
~
Let the coomercials guys have 8 to 13 inch Sea Bass. Recs can have 14 and up.
could you explain why a commercial guy can keep the small ones under your proposal and the rec guy can only keep 14" and up, so does the commercial guy have to throw back any fish over 13"? and wouldn't the commerciali guy make even more money per fish if he was only selling fish 16" and better?
Simple, Commercial sell by the pound not per fish. A rec is not interested in a 10in. bass as one of their quota. A 14 inch bass is a different year fish. Commercial selling of 18 inch flounder is not their market. A restaurant does not want to pay for a 18 inch flounder by the pound when they can make more money selling a 13 or 14 inch flounder to the customer. So the rec continues to throw back under 14 as well as the commercial guy culling over 13. Have you ever seen too many fish in a pond? Blue Gill, Crappie, The mass are always going to be small. Thin them out and watch them grow.
00 ~ You believe there are no juvenile flounder in nursery areas? OK! I know there are bridges for you to buy in NYC.
Maybe sandwich size flounder is the answer,,,, comms have been wanting smaller all the time. They sure would look tiny on a plate.
Whine on girls!
This post proves my point about your reading comprehension. Read the big part of that post again. Those are my thoughts on juvenile flounder in our waters and clearly states that I think that the numbers being caught by trawls in NC could be a issue.
Read slow, maybe even two or three times.
We are in NC, not Texas, and I don't believe the harvest of legal sized southern flounder by shrimp trawls is very much at all. The number of juvenile flounder in the bycatch could be of issue though.
Another thing to consider is that turtle excluders became mandatory between the two time frames used in your Texas study and they significantly reduce the number of legal size southern flounder caught in a trawl.
Also of note from that study is that it says that the harvest is 6 females to 1 male because of the 14" size restriction.
Thank god for the turtles. Just think of all the fish they save.
Maybe your reading comprehension isn't all that good, haven't been following along or are just spouting off like "carolina crabby captain" or whatever personality he is today............. but it doesn't seem they have saved any fish.
All the turtle regulations have done for southern flounder is shift the harvest from 6+ months of the year to about 2 or 3 months of the year. These fish do not live in our waters all their life. They come here as juveniles, grow throughout the summer, then leave and spawn elsewhere. Not many that leave are coming back.\
And as far as BR being involved with the finfish committee, ............he makes recommendations, not regulations.
Coming from you that is a compliment. it is great to hear BS and lies from you almost as much as your pal Ken, you two kiss when you woke up this morning? Please point out where I have lied.
Also, I am still waiting on you answer the questions regarding the sources of the information you shared earlier in the thread. Thanks and please don't deny, delay or deflect any longer.
So you're telling me that reducing the size limit LESS larger fish will be harvested?
I can see the argument for allowing the larger breeding stock a better chance but in no scenario do I see a single commercial fisherman releasing more larger fish just because that can take more smaller ones.You guys are so full of it your eyes must be all be brown.
It would require a slot limit on flounder if the minimum size was reduced. No one is suggesting a smaller size without the implementation of a slot limit that is equal for both recs and comms. The minimum length for should not be greater than it is for comms like it currently is.
numbers being caught by trawls in NC could be a issue.
There is no doubt about that. And while I don't want to have to eat shrimp from the gulf or imported, trawls are extremely destructive to the bottom and all non-target species caught in them.
If the clear cutting of the bottom done by trawls was occurring on land where people could see the damage, the outrage you would hear would end the practice, at the very least in inshore waters.
I don't mind the ocean shrimp trawls (except when the a$$hat captains try to run over my trolling Spanish lines) near as much as inshore trawlers in nursery area where the ratio of on-target species and juvenile fish are wasted and mostly thrown overboard dead. Worse than even gillnets IMHO.