SWC Forums
Pull up a chair...let's talk fishing.
I understand that the possibility of requiring recreational fishermen to report all catches is being discussed. I don't have an issue with mandatory catch reporting for recs but some have indicated it would infringe on our freedom. I'm interested in the opinion of the recreational sector on required catch reporting, accurate catch data and how it might impact our freedom. Thanks!
Why don't you start by explaining how it doesn't impact freedom and liberty. I'll play.
Well, required reporting doesn't restrict what we catch or where we fish. It doesn't necessarily change the gear we can use or the seasons when fishing is allowed. What it will do is provide fisheries managers with accurate, near real time catch data so they can make informed decisions regarding catch, size and seasonal limits. If actual data indicates that recs are taking too many fish, then they can shorten the season or modify the bag/size limits to maintain the season. If the numbers indicate that fewer fish are being taken than estimated, they can alter the bag/size/season limits to allow for a greater catch. I don't see a down side to any of that, let alone a restriction of freedom.
Why don't you start by explaining how it doesn't impact freedom and liberty. I'll play.
How does the Big Game hunting tags impact someones freedom and liberties. Seems these tags where readily accepted and people completely understood the reasoning for it, yet here we are, fishing would be the end of your "freedom" as others seem to claim. Thought that freedom if that is what you call it pretty much ended when you started paying to play.
Why don't you start by explaining how it doesn't impact freedom and liberty. I'll play.
How does the Big Game hunting tags impact someones freedom and liberties. Seems these tags where readily accepted and people completely understood the reasoning for it, yet here we are, fishing would be the end of your "freedom" as others seem to claim. Thought that freedom if that is what you call it pretty much ended when you started paying to play.
How about keeping it to fishing. There are much better examples.
Why don't you start by explaining how it doesn't impact freedom and liberty. I'll play.
Why don't you follow-up by explaining how it does impact freedom and liberty. You will still have the freedom and liberty to fish and maybe it will help maintain some fish for your children and grandchilden to catch too.
Why don't you start by explaining how it doesn't impact freedom and liberty. I'll play.
Why don't you follow-up by explaining how it does impact freedom and liberty. You will still have the freedom and liberty to fish and maybe it will help maintain some fish for your children and grandchilden to catch too.
Nope, not yet. Fished any public freshwater lakes lately?
crap in, crap out, that is what their data is going to be, and I doubt they have a plan in place on how to disseminate the data we'd send them, most likely will just lay around and be pulled out to use against us,
How about explaining then how it takes away your freedoms and liberties as was asked? How about explaining where at you where guaranteed these freedoms and liberties to fish as you please?
crap in, crap out, that is what their data is going to be, and I doubt they have a plan in place on how to disseminate the data we'd send them, most likely will just lay around and be pulled out to use against us,
Yep. Sometimes you put a system in place to fail so you can usher in the system you really wanted in the first place (even though the replacement system doesn't actually address the problem either).
How about explaining then how it takes away your freedoms and liberties as was asked? How about explaining where at you where guaranteed these freedoms and liberties to fish as you please?
How do you like the reporting that is required on inshore public waters?
crap in, crap out, that is what their data is going to be, and I doubt they have a plan in place on how to disseminate the data we'd send them, most likely will just lay around and be pulled out to use against us,
I was a gill net observer and this is exactly how I (and my 2 Biologist bosses) felt our recorded data was handled. The only thing of any interest to the higher-ups (NMFS) was turtle encounters IMO... They sure didn't seem to care about the flounders!
I think the game tags are an exact parallel. By requiring a tag to be affixed at the time of the kill, and since the animal has to be taken to an official game checking station that day, that could be used to track kills in almost real time. The tag data isn't used that way to my knowledge, but the possibility exists. Looking forward to your input Matador.
It's really very simple. You have two kinds of people; those who trust the government and believe their intentions are well and good for the people and those that don't. My personal opinion is that there is a snowflake's chance in hell that any of the reporting will do anything to help anybody except this whacko, power hungry government that will stop at nothing to control every aspect of our lives.
I echo Matador's question: How can this NOT effect our freedom and liberties? Freedom, in this particular scenario, is being able to fish, unmolested, with our friends and families. Until there is reason to believe that I have done something wrong, there will be no reporting or monitoring on my vessel. Period.
You guys keep bringing up hunting and big game tags. If yall want to tag big game on the water then fine; go tag big gamefish. Implying that the saltwater rec. bag is analogous to tagging big game mammals is ridiculous.
On inland freshwater public impoundments there is no commercial sector and no one self reports anything. The public generally takes 100% of the harvest and still no self reporting. The flip side is recs. fishing saltwater take far, far fewer fish than the commercial sector yet we want to self report for what purpose? Really think about this in the context of known biomass and the scale of harvest impact.