SWC Forums
Pull up a chair...let's talk fishing.
It's really very simple. You have two kinds of people; those who trust the government and believe their intentions are well and good for the people and those that don't. My personal opinion is that there is a snowflake's chance in hell that any of the reporting will do anything to help anybody except this whacko, power hungry government that will stop at nothing to control every aspect of our lives.
I echo Matador's question: How can this NOT effect our freedom and liberties? Freedom, in this particular scenario, is being able to fish, unmolested, with our friends and families. Until there is reason to believe that I have done something wrong, there will be no reporting or monitoring on my vessel. Period.
Other then saying the information is out there, not a single person has linked the source of this information that says they will require reporting, boarding and monitoring. By all means, link it and we all will read it, it will do nothing more than boost what is being said by some. Other then that your supposed freedoms and liberties where already taking the day they imposed a fishing/hunting license, size and creel limits, seasons, or any other regulation.
You guys keep bringing up hunting and big game tags. If yall want to tag big game on the water then fine; go tag big gamefish. Implying that the saltwater rec. bag is analogous to tagging big game mammals is ridiculous.
On inland freshwater public impoundments there is no commercial sector and no one self reports anything. The public generally takes 100% of the harvest and still no self reporting. The flip side is recs. fishing saltwater take far, far fewer fish than the commercial sector yet we want to self report for what purpose? Really think about this in the context of known biomass and the scale of harvest impact.
Where the heck did this become a Com vs Rec thing? The only thing this discussion has been about so far is some are saying Recs will be required to report all catches with the added comment that your freedoms and liberties will be taking away. How does this equate to a com vs rec issue? None of what you have posted so far has made a single logical connection in why something is relevant to something else, nor have you said how this will turn into that. It is far too early in a discussion to be this ridiculous already.
http://safmc.net/sites/default/files/meetings/pdf/Council/12-2014/Data/A2c_ET_ImplementationPlan.pdf
Page 1, 3rd paragraph. Then you can get the meeting minutes yourself and read the related NMFS crap.
You guys volunter all you like. They want tracking and if they can get enough epic fails they will say VMS will fix everything and will make it happen for everyone. If you are communist you should love this kind of shit. Point is these rec. vessels are private vessels, just like private vehicles and they should not be tracked.
You guys keep bringing up hunting and big game tags. If yall want to tag big game on the water then fine; go tag big gamefish. Implying that the saltwater rec. bag is analogous to tagging big game mammals is ridiculous.
On inland freshwater public impoundments there is no commercial sector and no one self reports anything. The public generally takes 100% of the harvest and still no self reporting. The flip side is recs. fishing saltwater take far, far fewer fish than the commercial sector yet we want to self report for what purpose? Really think about this in the context of known biomass and the scale of harvest impact.
Where the heck did this become a Com vs Rec thing? The only thing this discussion has been about so far is some are saying Recs will be required to report all catches with the added comment that your freedoms and liberties will be taking away. How does this equate to a com vs rec issue? None of what you have posted so far has made a single logical connection in why something is relevant to something else, nor have you said how this will turn into that. It is far too early in a discussion to be this ridiculous already.
You honestly can't see the point that there is a resource completely dominated by recs where 100% harvest is done by recs. with no self reporting and the management of the resource is successful versus the take by recs. on the ocean where the percentage of rec talke is far less?? The point in comparing the two is self reporting isn't going to fix anything, nothing.
If you want to make this about recs. and comms. go ahead.
Matador, no one said that we wanted a tagging system for recreational fish. It was only observed that the current system provides an actual physical count of the number of animals killed in near real time. Actual numbers. Not extrapolations or guesstimates. And as long as there is no concrete data on recreational landings everyone will use it against recs. Yes, that includes the commercial sector. And the turtle people. And the PETA people and everyone else that has an agenda against fishing. I think the recreational sector has absolutely nothing to hide and nothing to gain by inaccurate data.
Matador you are absolutely correct. Recreational fishermen account for about 2% of the overall seafood landings in the US. But I feel the only way to protect that 2% is to verify and lock it down. Then there is no margin for error.
Matador, no one said that we wanted a tagging system for recreational fish. It was only observed that the current system provides an actual physical count of the number of animals killed in near real time. Actual numbers. Not extrapolations or guesstimates. And as long as there is no concrete data on recreational landings everyone will use it against recs. Yes, that includes the commercial sector. And the turtle people. And the PETA people and everyone else that has an agenda against fishing. I think the recreational sector has absolutely nothing to hide and nothing to gain by inaccurate data.
I agree there is nothing to hide by most, but I think there is very little to gain and a lot to lose. If you look at it mathematically, there is absolutley nothing to gain and I will be happy to explain in detail when I have more time later today. If recs. start reporting big numbers of anything economically important then Catch Shares is the only winner (see Gulf Coast). If rec. reporting is seen as a failure or data is suspect, then VMS will surely follow. I do not advocate VMS for any group. Getting back to the saltwater/freshwater comparison. The true difference between the two is management and self reporting anything will not fix management failures or future mismangement. And finally, what kind of started this (liberty and freedom discussion), I will say that I am not willing to give up anything else or participate in any scheme where the end result is to take even more access to a public resource away from me or track me as a law abiding citizen. If any rec. wants to voluntarily report, then fine, you have the freedom and liberty to do so.
I can see many reasons DMF would want the info. I can see a few instances it COULD benefit recs. I can see many ways it could have a NEGATIVE impact on recs. I don't trust NCDMF any farther than I can throw them.
If recs. start reporting big numbers of anything economically important then Catch Shares is the only winner (see Gulf Coast).
Catch shares a winner?... maybe for the huge corporate fishing machine with wall street size backing. For the rec and small time local commercial fisherman it will be a devastating.
Catch Shares...... That is what the end goal always has been & that IS whats going happen. Catch shares = control... Total federal control, which will be shaped and managed right along the lines and goals the environmental groups, their lobbyist, and their near endless funding will dictate. Without a NRA sized lobby and representation in Washington that is truly for fisherman, all fisherman, none of us has a chance to stop it or the say to do anything about it.
CCA has lead the sheep to slaughter.... divide and conquer, a time proven plan that has played out over and over a thousand times over thousands of years.... everyone is so caught up blaming the group they do not belong to that they can not even see they are being used a pawns in a much bigger plan. Just wait till the curtain pulls back to reveal the the true wizards pulling the handles.
Anyhow, its a done deal now. The point of no return was passed quite a while ago.... There'll be no turning back. To all you that have been played like a fiddle & aloud it to happen, enjoy the mess you helped create.
This whole freedom/liberty thing is about vessel monitoring more so than reporting. I don't know of any freshwater fish stocks that are listed as depleted, endangered, etc, but there are plenty of saltwater species in these conditions. How do you propose that we manage saltwater fisheries, if you don't want to provide any catch data? I know you don't want your taxes raised so that they have the funds to pay a bunch of biologists to collect the data themselves, and you wouldn't trust their data, anyway, if it went against your own perceptions. It's a no win situation for fisheries management. Do you think everyone should have the freedom to catch all they can until it's not worth going anymore?
Since this is the "freedom and liberty" discussion I will just leave this right here-
We must, indeed, all hang together or, most assuredly, we shall all hang separately.
Benjamin Franklin
Damn bunch of fisherman have saved them the trouble and tried their best to hang each other. :wall:
I don't trust NCDMF any farther than I can throw them.
If I thought like you, I would say...............You must have something to hide. Why else would you not trust a government agency?
A person states that they don't trust NMFS/NOAA and you label the entire commercial industry as law breakers but you not trusting NCDMF is OK? Care to explain?
It's really very simple. You have two kinds of people; those who trust the government and believe their intentions are well and good for the people and those that don't. My personal opinion is that there is a snowflake's chance in hell that any of the reporting will do anything to help anybody except this whacko, power hungry government that will stop at nothing to control every aspect of our lives.
I echo Matador's question: How can this NOT effect our freedom and liberties? Freedom, in this particular scenario, is being able to fish, unmolested, with our friends and families. Until there is reason to believe that I have done something wrong, there will be no reporting or monitoring on my vessel. Period.
X2.
I don't trust NCDMF any farther than I can throw them.
If I thought like you, I would say...............You must have something to hide. Why else would you not trust a government agency?
A person states that they don't trust NMFS/NOAA and you label the entire commercial industry as law breakers but you not trusting NCDMF is OK? Care to explain?
Bare in mind that he's also one of the biggest supporters of JEA. When I opined that I don't trust them, It was inferred that only the guilty have anything to hide.
I won't go on and on about it, but it's pretty damn funny to see lots of the same voices that condemn the professional fishermen, screaming about liberty and justice.... :lmao:
I believe that the consensus is that professional fishermen can't be trusted and must be watched at all times, while hobby fishermen are harmless and need no over sight at all. My opinion is that we have NO idea how many fish recs are catching. NO IDEA. You guys throw around "facts" about recs taking only 2% of total catch, but click over three threads and read people saying that recs and their $ outnumber comms 100 to 1. Something doesn't add up. Assuming that this is a lame duck meant to usher in more drastic measures is just that, only an assumption. The FACT is that rec catch numbers are used in decision making processes that impact all user groups. I hate government intrusion, but I think that those numbers should atleast be accurate. The only thing fly in the ointment is charter guys. IMO, charter guys are commercial. I think their clients are rec and thus the limits should apply, but a man who fishes for profit is, by definition: professional (commercial). If we get good trip ticket data from this sector, that's a good chunk done.
Your freedom to fish is a fantasy. No one can infringe on your freedoms and rights, because you have neither the right or freedom to fish un molested. It was hard for me the first time this fact was thrown into my face and I struggled with it for a while. But it's true. They could issue a proclamation tomorrow and kick us all off the water and there's nothing we can do. That horse has left the barn. So, the next time you post a snarky comment about nets or some other thing you don't like, think about that. Maybe MORE regulation isn't the best thing. You all certainly seem to share that opinion when it comes to your fishery.