SWC Forums
Pull up a chair...let's talk fishing.
For every 'business estate', with 50-75 employees, there are probably hundreds of 'investment estates', with zero employees, and in many cases, minimal to zero taxes paid in the past. And in many cases, the heirs had zero contribution to building that fortune.
You're not paying taxes on those tremendous trump gains in your 401k, are you?
Not arguing for or against an estate tax, just pointing out that it is not always about putting people out of a job
DE used the "our wealth" line (DE I miss having these discussions with you, glad to see you again)
Back to the point though.. it is not "our" wealth. It does not belong to anyone or anything other than the entity that created it. You have no right to their wealth, nor do I.
The estate tax is quite simply a feel good money grab on assets that have already been taxed multiple times. The only reason to support it is to believe in creating animosity among the different classes.
I am firmly in the middle class economically. I do not hold a grudge against anyone that makes $1M per year or $100 M per year. More power to them!
The estate/death tax is an abomination and basically enforces the ill conceived belief that the wealth of an individual does not belong to that individual but rather to the state which as everyone already knows, is a fallacy.
"I am firmly in the middle class economically. I do not hold a grudge against anyone that makes $1M per year or $100 M per year. More power to them!"
You may have unintentionally touched on one of the problems. If you accept that they are entitled to the wealth, should 'more power' go along with more wealth, or should we all be subject to the same rules, and the same referees?
1st if we had to pay in taxes what rhe dept is it would be like 75%
2nd less than 50% of people pay no income tax. none! but receive benefits I believe everyone need to pay at least 5%.
3rd most billionaires own very little so the only ones paying the estate tax are the lower end of the pool who don't have tax lawyers on the pay roll.
4th The reason the 401k thing comes up is most traditional retirement funds switched to a 401k therefore the government gets no Money during the year they have to wait on you to draw it out.
5th the country is broke and it's the takers doing it. I also read that the budget has a trillion dollar cut in welfare programs
DE used the "our wealth" line (DE I miss having these discussions with you, glad to see you again)
Back to the point though.. it is not "our" wealth. It does not belong to anyone or anything other than the entity that created it. You have no right to their wealth, nor do I.
The estate tax is quite simply a feel good money grab on assets that have already been taxed multiple times. The only reason to support it is to believe in creating animosity among the different classes.
I am firmly in the middle class economically. I do not hold a grudge against anyone that makes $1M per year or $100 M per year. More power to them!
The estate/death tax is an abomination and basically enforces the ill conceived belief that the wealth of an individual does not belong to that individual but rather to the state which as everyone already knows, is a fallacy.
Damn squid that was dead on......wow great post
well I will simply say that I for one would be very content to see our politicians get serious about spending less than is being taken in so that we could use the little excess to help pay down our horrendous debt. Lets get our budget under control and start paying down the debt and if we wish to cut taxes then maybe we might try doing that. Makes absolutely no sense to cut taxes at the same time we are passing legislature to increase gov spending.
The sad thing is if every individual and corporation paid the federal government every dime they owed ,the feds would just spend more! The federal government couldn’t run my little piddly ass business and turn a profit. And for those of you that think a business or corporation valued at 5 to 10 million should shoulder the the brunt of the countries expenses have no idea what real money looks like! I live better than most and will admit I’m real fourtnae. Just because your company turns over that kind of money doesn’t mean you walk away with that many demiacl point in your checking account at the end of the year. It’s a constant struggle and I just hope there’s a little left when I check out of here for the feds to tax after I leave what’s left to my two kids.
You're not paying taxes on those tremendous trump gains in your 401k, are you?
Not arguing for or against an estate tax, just pointing out that it is not always about putting people out of a job
Who said? If and when you take distribution from your 401K you are taxed for the distribution as income. At age 70 you are required to take distribution.
For every 'business estate', with 50-75 employees, there are probably hundreds of 'investment estates', with zero employees, and in many cases, minimal to zero taxes paid in the past. And in many cases, the heirs had zero contribution to building that fortune.
You're not paying taxes on those tremendous trump gains in your 401k, are you?
Not arguing for or against an estate tax, just pointing out that it is not always about putting people out of a job
Would you protect "YOUR" money by hiring an estate attorney even if it meant setting up a trust that has zero employees?? Anyone who does well financially, works hard. The extremely rich are extremely smart, well positioned, or lucky....either way, where is the line to be defined when someone is too rich and the government is entitled to "THEIR" money??
You're not paying taxes on those tremendous trump gains in your 401k, are you?
Not arguing for or against an estate tax, just pointing out that it is not always about putting people out of a job
Who said? If and when you take distribution from your 401K you are taxed for the distribution as income. At age 70 you are required to take distribution.
If and when is the key. It is not taxed in your prime, high income earning years, but rather, in your retirement years, at whatever income level you are at, at that time. Meanwhile, you can invest it, or trade it as a brokerage account, making 6 figures a year, tax deferred.
As I said before, not arguing for or against an estate tax.
"I am firmly in the middle class economically. I do not hold a grudge against anyone that makes $1M per year or $100 M per year. More power to them!"
You may have unintentionally touched on one of the problems. If you accept that they are entitled to the wealth, should 'more power' go along with more wealth, or should we all be subject to the same rules, and the same referees?
No one is entitled to anything, including the government. The Constitution was created to protect citizens from the government not the other way around
If someone earns great wealth, that is awesome as long as it was done legally. No other person, entity or government agency is entitled to the fruits of another mans labor
WRT to more power...our system is broken. Seems like most politicians are corrupt and in the pockets of anyone or any group that will fund their campaign. Should anyone have more power? No. Do the wealthy have more influence over corrupt politicians? Yes. Unions through donations to democrats have laws forcing people to join them. Their forced dues are then funneled to democrat candidates. It is legalized bribery and there are many other examples too with both parties
The solution is not to tax the wealthy into poverty, the solution to your concern is to replace the corrupt politicians
Congress passes laws they exempt themselves from, that is unconstitutional and corrupt
We need term limits but that will never happen
For every 'business estate', with 50-75 employees, there are probably hundreds of 'investment estates', with zero employees, and in many cases, minimal to zero taxes paid in the past. And in many cases, the heirs had zero contribution to building that fortune.
You're not paying taxes on those tremendous trump gains in your 401k, are you?
Not arguing for or against an estate tax, just pointing out that it is not always about putting people out of a job
Would you protect "YOUR" money by hiring an estate attorney even if it meant setting up a trust that has zero employees?? Anyone who does well financially, works hard. The extremely rich are extremely smart, well positioned, or lucky....either way, where is the line to be defined when someone is too rich and the government is entitled to "THEIR" money??
Yes, I would, and have done so. I am still in a small business, with between 20 and 30 employees, for more than 30 years. Our trust is primarily to protect our kids from having to deal with a mess if we go unexpectedly, not to protect any large fortune.
But that's not the kind of 'investment estate' that I was referring to. As hard as it may be to relate to, there are many thousands of people out there who have never had to work a day in their life, as we think of work, and whose only job is to grow and protect the money they were born into. Or, at least outlive it. It's sort of like the debate over why home owners get such generous deductions, and renters get nothing.
I agree that anyone who does well financially probably works hard, but that does not mean that everyone who is well financially works hard. Still their money, I'm not arguing for the govt to take any part of it.
Someone said that the Walton heirs earned every dollar they got. While they might have deserved it, it's hard to imagine how so many of the primary heirs earned over 30 billion dollars each. Still their money, I'm not arguing fot the govt to take any part of it.
If someone earns great wealth, that is awesome as long as it was done legally. No other person, entity or government agency is entitled to the fruits of another mans labor
Just to be clear, are you for or against any form of taxation on income, property, or wealth?
The solution is not to tax the wealthy into poverty, the solution to your concern is to replace the corrupt politicians
I have an interest in the discussion, but am unsure exactly what concern you refer to.
Amazing how relevant this 10 Years After song still is today.
And Squid, you keep preaching it because you are spot on as always.
Everywhere is freaks and hairies
Dykes and fairies, tell me where is sanity
Tax the rich, feed the poor
Till there are no rich no more?
I'd love to change the world
But I don't know what to do
So I'll leave it up to you
Population keeps on breeding
Nation bleeding, still more feeding economy
Life is funny, skies are sunny
Bees make honey, who needs money, Monopoly
I'd love to change the world
But I don't know what to do
So I'll leave it up to you
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZyaFeDlJJAk
You're not paying taxes on those tremendous trump gains in your 401k, are you?
Not arguing for or against an estate tax, just pointing out that it is not always about putting people out of a job
Who said? If and when you take distribution from your 401K you are taxed for the distribution as income. At age 70 you are required to take distribution.
If and when is the key. It is not taxed in your prime, high income earning years, but rather, in your retirement years, at whatever income level you are at, at that time. Meanwhile, you can invest it, or trade it as a brokerage account, making 6 figures a year, tax deferred.
As I said before, not arguing for or against an estate tax.
Problem is when you are retired you can't live on Social Security, so you use your 401K to live on. But that money is considered taxable income. So the next year you are taxed on the money that you had to use to pay the taxes on the money you needed to live on the prior year. So it comes full circle. Every year you are paying money in taxes that you used to pay your taxes. So basically each year your tax burden increases.