SWC Forums

Pull up a chair...let's talk fishing.

Trumps latest effor...
 
Notifications
Clear all

Trumps latest effort to help the middle class.....

49 Posts
25 Users
0 Reactions
1,080 Views
zigzag
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 22 years ago
Posts: 1863
 

You're not paying taxes on those tremendous trump gains in your 401k, are you?
Not arguing for or against an estate tax, just pointing out that it is not always about putting people out of a job

Who said? If and when you take distribution from your 401K you are taxed for the distribution as income. At age 70 you are required to take distribution.

If and when is the key. It is not taxed in your prime, high income earning years, but rather, in your retirement years, at whatever income level you are at, at that time. Meanwhile, you can invest it, or trade it as a brokerage account, making 6 figures a year, tax deferred.
As I said before, not arguing for or against an estate tax.

Problem is when you are retired you can't live on Social Security, so you use your 401K to live on. But that money is considered taxable income. So the next year you are taxed on the money that you had to use to pay the taxes on the money you needed to live on the prior year. So it comes full circle. Every year you are paying money in taxes that you used to pay your taxes. So basically each year your tax burden increases.

:hail:



   
ReplyQuote
steve brewer
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 17 years ago
Posts: 1094
 

That was tried and surprise, trickle down economics do not work (no matter how much I respect Reagan) as the money does not go to the workers. It is all kept at the top but you no doubt think that's a great idea.

On 401ks: You didn't pay taxes on it when you contributed, but you have to at some time. Pay me now or pay me later so I do not understand why people are angry about the tax at retirement on earnings they never paid taxes on.

The POTUS has very little to no influence on the stock market. For those that think Trump is so great, would you throw him under the bus if the DOW30 is at 15k before he leaves office? Everyone hates Obama, but the market was up 140% during his presidency. Market is up 25% since Trump's election. I do not give credit to Trump for any of this like you guys do as he hasn't done anything to effect the market. Bush 1 was in good shape until the market and economy turned on him and he lost re-election.
The market is much more likely to crash during Trump's presidency and he will end up blaming Obama for the crappy economy he inherited. Will Trump be to blame for the crash? No, as it is just the cycles of the economy and market.



   
ReplyQuote
Barry Turano
(@barryturano)
Famed Member
Joined: 17 years ago
Posts: 2720
 

You are correct pay me now or pay me later. It was a great idea in concept. But as someone who is NOW living with it, I must tell you. I would rather of paid the tax on it back when I was working, even though it would have cost me more in taxes. At that point I was working and making more money than I now collect on Social Security. Same with the IRA they now have a Roth IRA where you are taxed on the money when you put it in not when you take it out. Now as I said before you need to take money out to pay taxes which you are taxed on. As far as 6 figure gains in your 401K you will also take a 6 figure loss (don't ask how I know, but if you think of my age you can figure it out) Believe me if I could take all that I paid into Social Security and have invested it on my own, I would not be scrambling to survive. So yes 401K's are not all they are cracked up to be.



   
ReplyQuote
Scott Robbins
(@srobbins)
Estimable Member
Joined: 12 years ago
Posts: 179
 

Politicians are masters at misdirection aren't they. Here we are chatting about taxes, as punitive or justified as you think they may be, when the problem is government spending. I'd be willing to bet that if all the folks discussing the issue here were to sit in a room, we could create a balanced budget while cutting the deficit and slashing taxes, all at the same time and probably while enjoying an adult beverage or 2. How much waste, fraud and abuse is built in to government spending that should be rooted out from all sectors. Why can't we realize this and get some actual leaders elected rather that career politicians who care far more for getting reelected than actually doing what is best for their community and this country. Lot of complicated issues that all have very simple solutions.

And thank you all for the civil discussion here. Very atypical in today's world.



   
ReplyQuote
Rich
 Rich
(@squid-row)
Illustrious Member
Joined: 22 years ago
Posts: 4097
 

If someone earns great wealth, that is awesome as long as it was done legally. No other person, entity or government agency is entitled to the fruits of another mans labor

Just to be clear, are you for or against any form of taxation on income, property, or wealth?

The solution is not to tax the wealthy into poverty, the solution to your concern is to replace the corrupt politicians

I have an interest in the discussion, but am unsure exactly what concern you refer to.

Of course I believe in taxation to support necessary government functions. Unfortunately, the federal government does so many things it is not supposed to do that it requires ridiculous taxation

I am ok with an income tax, I am not ok with people paying unequal rates as I believe that is a violation of the equal protection clause

I believe in Federalism if that is what you are looking for.

Most of the "stuff" the federal government does today it should not be doing, it should be done by the states if at all.



   
ReplyQuote
Barry Turano
(@barryturano)
Famed Member
Joined: 17 years ago
Posts: 2720
 

Politicians are masters at misdirection aren't they. Here we are chatting about taxes, as punitive or justified as you think they may be, when the problem is government spending. I'd be willing to bet that if all the folks discussing the issue here were to sit in a room, we could create a balanced budget while cutting the deficit and slashing taxes, all at the same time and probably while enjoying an adult beverage or 2. How much waste, fraud and abuse is built in to government spending that should be rooted out from all sectors. Why can't we realize this and get some actual leaders elected rather that career politicians who care far more for getting reelected than actually doing what is best for their community and this country. Lot of complicated issues that all have very simple solutions.

And thank you all for the civil discussion here. Very atypical in today's world.

Agree 110%. The question is HOW? The system has been so corrupted I think it almost impossible to change. It has become a self replicating entity, with so much money going in from individuals, company's and countries with their own agenda. It is like we are pre-1776, the politicians are put into office to do OUR bidding and put forth Our ideas. But it does not happen. Maybe that is why Trump won, his "drain the swamp" hit home. Which is why he is being stonewalled from all sides. I don't know if he will run again (probably shouldn't) but who ever does run no matter what party needs to keep the ideas of "America (we the people) first" other wise we will be back where we started. Does any one here like the idea of giving billions of dollars away to other countries while we have so many problems here. Were you asked if it was OKAY to give your money away? I don't think so! Just to give another example. The people of Arizona elected John McCain to repeal Obama Care for many years he said he would. Their rates went sky high. When the time to vote came he did the opposite of what he said he would and what the people who elected him to do. One question WHY? These people are supposed to represent us. Unfortunately they do not.
Rant is over (for now) however I do reserve the right to get back on my soap box.



   
ReplyQuote
Frank Benedetti
(@frankieb)
Reputable Member
Joined: 13 years ago
Posts: 232
 

on the 401k issue - the point of the government limiting the amount that you can contribute is so that there will be more income taxed each year. You can still save, but if they limit the amount you can put in tax free, multiplied by a few million people, then the government can effectively raise taxes and hopefully no one will notice.



   
ReplyQuote
Tim Coggins
(@)
Estimable Member
Joined: 11 years ago
Posts: 124
 

Taxes are Bulls***!. WE all need to pay 10% and be done with it. ALL OF US!!!!! You lay on your ass and make 10 grand a year you pay 1 grand. You work hard and make a million a year you should only have to pay 100 grand, not 600 grand. Estate tax, death tax, etc, taxes on lottery winnings are all bull crap because tax money has already been paid.



   
ReplyQuote
Travis Morgan
(@)
Eminent Member
Joined: 11 years ago
Posts: 25
 

Well said Hotjob.I'm appalled and a little amazed at what I pay in income taxes .I just dont make that much money and yet they take 30% That money is earned working 80 plus hour weeks anybody in business knows the story.Gotta have some relief no incentive to keep doing it.



   
ReplyQuote
JOHNNY CARPENTER
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 14 years ago
Posts: 1169
 

I'm with you on that Waterhazzard. And now NC decides to collect sales and use tax on service work. I'm in the electrical contracting business. Small business, as after 30 some years of baby sitting people who think a nest egg is a bottle of opioids and a six pack of beer, I've decided to work alone. It takes a rocket scientist to figure out what is exempt and what is not. The state has sent out at least 2 or 3 bulletins of changes this year. It has about become too burdensome for me to even mess with it anymore. All so the state will have more money to burn.



   
ReplyQuote
Rich
 Rich
(@squid-row)
Illustrious Member
Joined: 22 years ago
Posts: 4097
 

on the 401k issue - the point of the government limiting the amount that you can contribute is so that there will be more income taxed each year. You can still save, but if they limit the amount you can put in tax free, multiplied by a few million people, then the government can effectively raise taxes and hopefully no one will notice.

Good point. We need to do the math and see if the tax rate decrease will offset this in someway.

POTUS is saying 401K changes are not part of the plan

Guess we will have to wait and see because I am sure after the two chambers of Congress are done adding in their pork and monkeying around with the details, the plan the vote on will be nothing like the plan that is being discussed



   
ReplyQuote
Scott Robbins
(@srobbins)
Estimable Member
Joined: 12 years ago
Posts: 179
 

Politicians are masters at misdirection aren't they. Here we are chatting about taxes, as punitive or justified as you think they may be, when the problem is government spending. I'd be willing to bet that if all the folks discussing the issue here were to sit in a room, we could create a balanced budget while cutting the deficit and slashing taxes, all at the same time and probably while enjoying an adult beverage or 2. How much waste, fraud and abuse is built in to government spending that should be rooted out from all sectors. Why can't we realize this and get some actual leaders elected rather that career politicians who care far more for getting reelected than actually doing what is best for their community and this country. Lot of complicated issues that all have very simple solutions.

And thank you all for the civil discussion here. Very atypical in today's world.

Agree 110%. The question is HOW? The system has been so corrupted I think it almost impossible to change. It has become a self replicating entity, with so much money going in from individuals, company's and countries with their own agenda. It is like we are pre-1776, the politicians are put into office to do OUR bidding and put forth Our ideas. But it does not happen. Maybe that is why Trump won, his "drain the swamp" hit home. Which is why he is being stonewalled from all sides. I don't know if he will run again (probably shouldn't) but who ever does run no matter what party needs to keep the ideas of "America (we the people) first" other wise we will be back where we started. Does any one here like the idea of giving billions of dollars away to other countries while we have so many problems here. Were you asked if it was OKAY to give your money away? I don't think so! Just to give another example. The people of Arizona elected John McCain to repeal Obama Care for many years he said he would. Their rates went sky high. When the time to vote came he did the opposite of what he said he would and what the people who elected him to do. One question WHY? These people are supposed to represent us. Unfortunately they do not.
Rant is over (for now) however I do reserve the right to get back on my soap box.



   
ReplyQuote
BRIAN
(@bharbaugh)
Prominent Member
Joined: 19 years ago
Posts: 687
 

I'm with you on that Waterhazzard. And now NC decides to collect sales and use tax on service work. I'm in the electrical contracting business. Small business, as after 30 some years of baby sitting people who think a nest egg is a bottle of opioids and a six pack of beer, I've decided to work alone. It takes a rocket scientist to figure out what is exempt and what is not. The state has sent out at least 2 or 3 bulletins of changes this year. It has about become too burdensome for me to even mess with it anymore. All so the state will have more money to burn.

Before you sell your boat will you please jot down all your GPS points for me.

Thank You.

Your pal.



   
ReplyQuote
Rich
 Rich
(@squid-row)
Illustrious Member
Joined: 22 years ago
Posts: 4097
 

The plan that was announced today has no changes to 401 K plans

It does reduce the corporate tax rate from 35 to 20% which is a great move to create jobs in the US and bring jobs back from overseas

It reduces middle class taxes but does not reduce to the top rate.



   
ReplyQuote
Glen Montgomery
(@)
Reputable Member
Joined: 16 years ago
Posts: 284
 

I remember when Regan managed to get our corporate tax rates reduced in order for our US companies to re-tool, seems that most of those US companies used that tax relief to re-build instead of re-tooling which may not have been a problem if they had only re-built in this Country. Instead those American companies chose to rebuild in other foreign countries in order to take advantage of much cheaper labor. The much lower taxes that are being proposed for corporations may not do a freeking thing to bring those companies back to the US. I still think that we should reward our companies that remain in our Country and penalize the heck out of those that moved to foreign soils. If countries like Japan can move their operations to the USA and build cars or trucks using American labor while making a nice profit then our own manufactures should be able to do it as well. Still think the republican party would do well to put their efforts behind less gov spending and waste in order to get our budget under control than to cut taxes. We simply can not keep up this wild spending which causes our dollar to lose its value and must do whatever it takes to get it under some type of control. Just because I can go to my local bank and borrow 250k, deposit it into my checking acct , does not make me a wealthier individual.



   
ReplyQuote
Page 3 / 4
Share: