SWC Forums
Pull up a chair...let's talk fishing.
Emails to Representative Jones, Senators Burr & Tillis were sent this AM asking for help stopping more closed areas (Amendment 36) and the back door attempt at implementing the Catch Shares "mess" again. It may not do any good but if we don't speak up, we have zero chance of stopping NGOs and their greedy puppets on the Council.Our elected representatives appear to be our only hope.
Kim Iverson and I spoke for a few minutes yesterday, good conversation, shared several thoughts on the issues facing the fishery.
She explained, just as Charlie did, that the council was not involved at this point in the pilot program, no information had been submitted to the council and has to be submitted at least two weeks prior to the next council meeting in order for the council to discuss it.
I believe that I understand, Roy Crabtree has the authority to approve the pilot catch shares program for the four or five folks listed on the application basically singlehandedly.
Charlie explained that experimental permits were typically granted to research groups / scientists to catch particular species for research, but this particular permit has been introduced to "region" ie... Roy Crabtree to "study" the effects. results, positives and negatives of "catch Shares".
Kim also discussed that this "permit" is quite unusual / non-typical.
Charlie said that there is some opinion that the majority of the opposition to catch shares is from the recreational sector not the majority of commercial stakeholders.
To this point I suggested to Kim that the council hold a "vote" via certified letter, or phone call,to snapper grouper permit holders to settle the issue once and for all.
I expressed concern if it could be done "securely" but whether it was completely secure or not it would be an indicator of how further thoughts and suggestions should proceed.
Certainly not to discredit the opinion of recreational guys and I fully appreciate all the support on the catch shares issue from all recreational folks, I think it is fairly safe to say that commercial fishermen / license holders have more to loose financially than recs as it relates to catch shares.
So please do not read any disrespect to any recreational fisherman in my comment of votes for commercial fishermen / license holders as it pertains to the "catch shares" issue.
It has repeatedly been suggested on-line and to the council to just STOP creating new rules and REVIEW the results of previous measures, and after a thorough review, implement more changes.
My contention on catch shares, or otherwise making a commodity of the fishery, is that nobody currently in the "fishery" has enough money to remain in the fishery once "speculators" enter the "game". We will all be sold to the highest bidder! That then is when the recreational angler will be significantly impacted just as they have been in the Gulf. Where recreational anglers cannot keep red snapper caught more than (9)?? miles offshore and commercial boats (well the ones that retained their license / quota) have very liberal limits.
We all saw "big fish Texas" and if you haven't seen it, watch it, it is the most clear portrayal of the effects of catch shares that can be seen prior to it being implemented in the south atlantic fishery!
Also the proponents of catch shares are all so certain that their recent catch history will be the deciding factor in the distribution of the pounds. How can they be so certain??? How are they so certain that the quota will not be divided equally to every active license? Why wouldn't the pounds be divided that way? Not that I would be in favor of it then, just asking the question, how does someone know how a rule that hasn't been developed or even discussed "on the record" will be implemented?
Jason Oakes
Thanks for the great post BottomDollar2! Your idea for a vote is exactly what we need. Congressman Jones supports the idea and has introduced legislation to require a stakeholder vote to approve catch shares. I have asked him to send a letter opposing catch shares and asking the SAFMC to let us vote on it. Everyone who cares about our freedom to fish should think about asking your elected officials to do the same. Roy Crabtree told me several years ago that if we didn't like what they were doing, then we needed to take it up with Congress. That was good advice we should take.
Seems like a very important issue that should be taken very seriously..I encourage active participation in the process going into the upcoming SAFMC meeting in March...I would spend some time getting familiar with their new website and how to access the info and comment as well as freely contributing to their facebook page in a constructive manner..calls and emails are very effective as well..hope the wind blows favorably soon..tight lines!