SWC Forums
Pull up a chair...let's talk fishing.
Down to the wire to make the final transducer decision. Will be running it straight off a Simrad NSS12 evo2 (no BSM or other black box). So which to go with, the B75M (600w) or B175M (1kw), both are medium chirp.
First question is, does the evo2 have enough output power to take advantage of the B175M?
I troll out to about 1000-1500 ft of water, bottom fish inside 200 ft. Generally MHC area, big rock, Swansboro Hole, 90 ft drop, etc.
Anyone else running this setup?
1kw by the way you will love that simrad
The 600w will only give you about 400' of depth while the 1KW should work in those deeper depths you mention. I'd go with the B175M
175 for sure
Y'all are good at spending my money!
Can anyone confirm that the NSS12 evo2 can put out the power to see full potential of the B175M? I think it will, but the CHIRP power measurements are all different than what I'm used to.
Designed for CHIRP so I would be surprised if it doesn't.
Fishing At the depths you mention a 600W ducer just wouldn't cut it.
Designed for CHIRP so I would be surprised if it doesn't.
Fishing At the depths you mention a 600W ducer just wouldn't cut it.
Agreed. You can go with the cheaper option but you will be limited to lesser depths. As in roughly 400' of water will be your max. I have a 600W transducer on my boat so I know it's limitations.
I went with a 600W as well, but 100% of my fishing is in less than 300 feet and 99% of it is 100 feet or less.
I'm taking out a 600w 50/200, so I know what you're saying. Chirp is all new to me, I've heard similar power output in chirp does much better.
I'm taking out a 600w 50/200, so I know what you're saying. Chirp is all new to me, I've heard similar power output in chirp does much better.
The better part is in the frequency range of the transducer. A 600W transducer is still a 600W transducer no matter what.
I have a Garmin system so things are a little different. What I have found out that my GT-51TM, 600w Medium band chirp, works just fine out to 700'. That's as deep as I have been. I have a b175, 1kw high band chirp narrow beam, it works equally as well at the depths mentioned above. I would be completely happy with either one of those transducers. Now I see that you are trolling out in the deep and when trolling you may not be concerned with the bottom contour so a high band chirp my be a better choice for you. I got my b175 in high chirp and narrow beam just for bottom fishing. The main difference I see between the 600w and the 1kw is the target separation. I use to have a bunch of screen shots showing this but I have since cleaned off my card. The target separation with the b175 is awesome. I did find a few screen shots on my install threads. Another thing you can look at is side scan. My side/down scan transducer also has the 600w medium band transducer built into it. I may not be explaining this very well...
It's pretty nice to have both transducers to compare. Plus you have a backup if needed. I couldn't have just the b175 because I like the side scan feature. BUT, I like the target separation of the b175. I couldn't make the decision so I got both of them and I suggest you do the same thing!


Nice screen shots, thanks!
I am going to have an LSS-2 side/down scan as well.
I'm thinking I'll go with the B175M now. It a compromise transducer, but after the P66 I've been using, I think I'll see a bit of improvement!
Maybe someday I'll have the money to add another NSS12, at that point I would look at adding a B175H-W specifically for fish finding. But until I hit the lottery....
I don't think that is a compromise transducer. I think it is an awesome choice! There are many options though. If you want to do a pocket mount or a transom mount you can have a 1kw that has both high/medium chirp. I would love to have one but it takes a 12 pin connection and on a Garmin unit there is only one 12 pin plug and the GT-51M is using it. I'd have to have a second unit and I am out of space.
I'm not installing the BSM, which limits me to a single channel CHIRP, or your standard 50/200. A second screen would enable an additional transducer and then network. Not knowing if I will ever get to a second screen, don't want to pay for a dual channel ducer I can't really use, I'd have to choose which channel I wanted.
Besides the ducer and NSS, I'm also putting in a new VHF and autopilot.....my wallet is tapping out, but I can't wait to get it all in and go fishing!!!!