SWC Forums
Pull up a chair...let's talk fishing.
I have No Friends or a Dog in this fight however, I would like to know if the Mate and Boat concealed the fact that the Mate fished without a North Carolina fishing license until the Lie detector phase, or was that revealed sooner ????
As others I have nothing to gain in this. My opinion is that the rules as stated in the captains meeting each crew member needed a license. He did not meet the rules of the tournament. This has nothing to do about cheating. Not having a license did not give the boat any type of advantage. So cheating is not the issue. However following the tournament rules is/are the issue. The rule was not followed. Who was at fault? In my opinion no one and the Captain. Again there was no advantage to be had, but I think it would be the captains responsibility to make sure HIS crew was in compliance. It is a tough lesson to learn.
It IS cheating, akin to a pro golfer not realizing he has 15 clubs in the bag. Breaking the rules IS cheating, intentional or not!
It IS cheating, akin to a pro golfer not realizing he has 15 clubs in the bag. Breaking the rules IS cheating, intentional or not!
:wtg: ......thank you.
DAM...SOUNDS LIKE A BUNCH OF WOMEN ON THE VIEW HERE.
DAM...SOUNDS LIKE A BUNCH OF WOMEN ON THE VIEW HERE.
:wtg: thank you.
In most criminal cases the prosecutor must prove the defendant intended to commit the act in question.
Well, it's not a criminal case and there was no prosecutor. Tournament rules required a license, the mate didn't have one when the fish was caught, the boat was not in compliance. Doesn't matter if it was caught in the surf or 1000 fathoms, fish shouldn't count for any prize ... :tired:
At every capt. meeting since the coastal fishing license has been required by DMF, an announcement has been made that everyone on the boat must have a license. It has also been announced that it would be a shame to lose a million dollars over not having a license. Also discussed was the need for a HMS permit. Yes I was there. A member of the crew did not have a valid license while fishing in the tournament. Seems like a clear rules violation. OK, maybe not so clear since there was a large amount of money involved.
From a legal stand point a verbal notice of requirement at the captains meeting is loose. The contract that backs the event requires you to follow all laws regarding fishing is what will likely be what governs the descision, and is likely why judgement was sent back to lesser court. No state law was broken as fish was taken in international waters. If you want the rule to stand include it in legall disclosure. Its a mess for sure.
Mike
If you want the rule to stand include it in legall disclosure.
Uhhh, it was listed as a tournament rule, and a far cry from as verbal addition at the Captain's meeting. Would there not be an implied understanding and consent to abide by submitting a signed entry form?
My understanding is the missing license information was not disclosed until the lie detector test. I believe they tried to conceal the error. The rules are the rules, and was in writing, not just verbal.
This falls clearly on the Captain, as he is in command of the vessel for the tourney. Hate it for him, but everyone needs to abide by and be govern by the same set of written rules.
The issue here is people are willing to sue, spend everyone's money to try to win something they are not rightfully due.
In most criminal cases the prosecutor must prove the defendant intended to commit the act in question.
Well, it's not a criminal case and there was no prosecutor. Tournament rules required a license, the mate didn't have one when the fish was caught, the boat was not in compliance. Doesn't matter if it was caught in the surf or 1000 fathoms, fish shouldn't count for any prize ... :tired:
:wtg: ....thank you!!
this is more on the line of bowling... The santioning body requires that you are a member of their organization. If not then your scores are not counted either as an individual or part of a team. Your able to purchase a short term card good for just the tournament. Now if your a card carrying member and you bowl an unsanctioned tournament/house and you hit a 300 game this is not entered into the record books. You dont receive a momento (ring/watch) from the organization for your feet. Its not cheating its just you dont reap the rewards
Rules stated that everyone in the crew required a NCSWFL
There were signatures made to abide by all rules
One crew member DID NOT have the required license.(really doesn't matter how that happened)
Disqualified. Enough said.
And it IS just that simple.
Rules are rules. Abide by them or you are history!