SWC Forums

Pull up a chair...let's talk fishing.

Big Rock drama cont...
 
Notifications
Clear all

Big Rock drama continues. Hot off the press from the Supremes....

67 Posts
37 Users
0 Reactions
78.7 K Views
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 16 years ago
Posts: 1942
 

Rules stated that everyone in the crew required a NCSWFL
There were signatures made to abide by all rules
One crew member DID NOT have the required license.(really doesn't matter how that happened)
Disqualified. Enough said.
And it IS just that simple.

Makes sense to me.



   
ReplyQuote
andyrlntlss
(@)
Estimable Member
Joined: 19 years ago
Posts: 217
 

A question they brought up at trial. Are all rules infractions "Disqualifications"??? Example: if your cited for a no-wake violation, or the battery on your epirb has expired, or one of your flares is out of date?????? Thoughts????



   
ReplyQuote
(@)
Estimable Member
Joined: 17 years ago
Posts: 161
 

OBX DIVER SAID: The mate in question did not fish on that boat regularly. He was used to fishing on charter boats, whereas, Citation is a private boat. He wrongly assumed the boat had the blanket license and that's something I'd bet 9 out of 10 mates would do. I know before this incident I would have never thought to ask. I certainly do now.

My thought: Assuming is not an excuse for breaking rules... If I don't see a speed limit sign and I ASSUME the speed limit is 90mph... I get pulled and I'm getting a ticket.
Ignorance of the rule or law does not viod it.
Citation gets nothing and pays all legal expenses if it was my call to make.

I have no dog in this fight either BTW 😉



   
ReplyQuote
Jeff Williams
(@jaws)
Prominent Member
Joined: 20 years ago
Posts: 722
 

A question they brought up at trial. Are all rules infractions "Disqualifications"??? Example: if your cited for a no-wake violation, or the battery on your epirb has expired, or one of your flares is out of date?????? Thoughts????

No Wake infractions are not stated on Big Rock Rules, having A NC fishing license is, the rule is not A Big Rock rule but A NC WildLife rule as stated at the Captains Meeting and must be enforced by Big Rock.



   
ReplyQuote
andyrlntlss
(@)
Estimable Member
Joined: 19 years ago
Posts: 217
 

Wrong. Must follow all state and federal laws!



   
ReplyQuote
Rich
 Rich
(@squid-row)
Illustrious Member
Joined: 22 years ago
Posts: 4097
 

I am sure that they have to follow all laws of course, but what did the big rock tournament rules specifically say?

Also, does the Big Rock have a history of disqualifying boats for rules infractions or is this the first time? If this was the first time, were there other boats in the past that broke rules but were not disqualified?

When this goes to trial the history of the tournament and how they enforced other rules violations will surely go under the microscope.



   
ReplyQuote
andyrlntlss
(@)
Estimable Member
Joined: 19 years ago
Posts: 217
 

Or how bout this one....

5. REPORTING - All blue marlin, white marlin and sailfish must be reported to TOURNAMENT HEADQUARTERS when hooked, lost, boated or released. Radio frequency shall be VHF CHANNEL 72 and alternate channel 78a and SINGLE SIDEBAND CHANNEL 4146.0 Fish hooked prior to or after fishing hours are not eligible.

Your radio dies as your going out?



   
ReplyQuote
Teezher
(@)
Honorable Member
Joined: 19 years ago
Posts: 454
 

This whole court process is all a big waste of time and money. The rules are the rules and every tournament you enter the Captian signs an entry/ release form before entering the tournament acknowledging and understanding to follow the rules. They broke the rules of the tournament, Disqualified!! Period!! End of story!!

Here is the Big Rock Enrty form:

I, as entrant do hereby RELEASE, DISCHARGE, and HOLD HARMLESS Crystal Coast Tournament, Inc., its officers, directors, and sponsors, whether individual or corporate, from any claim for damages to my person or property incurred by my participation in the Big Rock Blue Marlin Tournament. This release applies to members of my crew and all parties fishing from my boat.

By signing the entry form and paying my entry fee, I acknowledge that I have read this release and am bound by same. This release shall also be binding on my heir, executors, administrator, or assigns.

I further do hereby acknowledge that I have read and understand the rules of the tournament and agree to be bound by the terms and conditions contained therein.



   
ReplyQuote
andyrlntlss
(@)
Estimable Member
Joined: 19 years ago
Posts: 217
 

Show me where on that years rules that no license means disqualification! In other words, it was a discretionary call by the committee and if in previous years an infraction was dealt with by no disqualification, there is your reasonable doubt.



   
ReplyQuote
Johnny Byrd
(@)
Estimable Member
Joined: 23 years ago
Posts: 195
 

A question they brought up at trial. Are all rules infractions "Disqualifications"??? Example: if your cited for a no-wake violation, or the battery on your epirb has expired, or one of your flares is out of date?????? Thoughts????

If any were stated in the official rules of the tournament, Absolutely



   
ReplyQuote
john Smith
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 18 years ago
Posts: 1776
 

A question they brought up at trial. Are all rules infractions "Disqualifications"??? Example: if your cited for a no-wake violation, or the battery on your epirb has expired, or one of your flares is out of date?????? Thoughts????

Bingo.

I don't have a dog in this ,
but this is a very valid point.

If boat has a burned out bow light, is it disqualified ?

Other litigation ? is "Does the punishment fit the crime?"

or, "Would a law requiring execution for let's say
jaywalking" be upheld. ?

IMO, there are 2 very valid point of views here...
and that's why it's in court.



   
ReplyQuote
Johnny Byrd
(@)
Estimable Member
Joined: 23 years ago
Posts: 195
 

OK, let's pursue the argument of doe the penalty fit the infraction.

If youare cited for no-wake violation, battery in epirb or flares out of date, what is the penalty. Monetary fine?
If you are cited for fishing without a license the first thing is the officer takes your catch. ENOUGH SAID



   
ReplyQuote
Mark Gorges
(@captaingorges)
Noble Member
Joined: 20 years ago
Posts: 1581
 

" If you are cited for fishing without a license the first thing is the officer takes your catch. ENOUGH SAID"

Yes, enough said. If they had been stopped at the 3 mile line by a NC Wildlife officer he would have said "have a good day, congrats on catching the biggest marlin ever in the tournament" because they bought a license on the way in via phone and never broke any type of law regarding landing a fish in North Carolina.

Bunch of bitching about a minor oversight, the was the biggest fish EVER caught in the tournament. Isn't the tournament about catching the biggest fish with no unfair advantages? Their fish STOMPED the #2 fish.



   
ReplyQuote
john Smith
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 18 years ago
Posts: 1776
 

Big Rock drama continues. Hot off the press from the Supremes....

The Surpemes haven't been any good since Diana Ross left. :flux:



   
ReplyQuote
Kenneth
(@matador)
Famed Member
Joined: 17 years ago
Posts: 3641
 

" If you are cited for fishing without a license the first thing is the officer takes your catch. ENOUGH SAID"

Yes, enough said. If they had been stopped at the 3 mile line by a NC Wildlife officer he would have said "have a good day, congrats on catching the biggest marlin ever in the tournament" because they bought a license on the way in via phone and never broke any type of law regarding landing a fish in North Carolina.

Bunch of bitching about a minor oversight, the was the biggest fish EVER caught in the tournament. Isn't the tournament about catching the biggest fish with no unfair advantages? Their fish STOMPED the #2 fish.

I think the 3 mile line means everything. Other things are legal or less stringent outside of state waters. I read the Big Rock rules and no where do the rules state at what point a license is actually required to be purchased though it may be implied. So, if I were fishing with them and left dock with no license, then chose to fish, harvested a fish, purchased a license prior to entry inside 3 miles then I am legal! Also, the Big Rock rules basically re-state the state law, state law that has no jurisdiction outside of 3 miles. The Big Rock Tournament thus yields to state law which in effect yields to state enforcement. While the situation may not pass the smell test on the NC license requirement (acquired prior to re-entering the 3 mile zone) the fish looks to be legal. Another note is: Was the vessel actually for hire because state law allows for the use of for hire blanket license. The Big Rock rules obviously yield to state law on their web site (re-statement of law and DMF links) so why would anyone think that a Big Rock rule or interpretation on license use would supercede state law?



   
ReplyQuote
Page 3 / 5
Share: