SWC Forums

Pull up a chair...let's talk fishing.

Boat Sinking Today ...
 
Notifications
Clear all

Boat Sinking Today with Deaths and Missing Crew

14 Posts
11 Users
0 Reactions
17.7 K Views
Darrell  Garrett
(@)
Honorable Member
Joined: 19 years ago
Posts: 569
Topic starter   [#11079]

1 dead, 4 missing after boat sinks off New Jersey

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

1 dead, 4 missing after boat sinks off New Jersey
March 24, 2009

(CNN) -- One person died and four were missing Tuesday after a boat sank off the New Jersey coast, a U.S. Coast Guard spokesman said.

The Lady Mary, a 71-foot-long fishing vessel with seven people aboard, sank about 65 miles (105 kilometers) southeast of Cape May, at the southern tip of New Jersey, said the spokesman, Petty Officer Chris McLaughlin.

He said the Coast Guard began searching for the boat's passengers around 7:45 a.m. ET.

Three people were recovered, one of whom was dead, McLaughlin said. The identities were not released.

The Coast Guard said in a written statement that it had picked up an emergency "position-indicating radio beacon" about 7:30 a.m. Citing a survivor, it said the boat sank around 5 a.m. ET, three hours before the three were recovered.

It was not immediately clear what caused the boat to sink.

Cape May is about 40 miles southwest of Atlantic City, New Jersey.



   
Quote
Hooked
(@)
Estimable Member
Joined: 19 years ago
Posts: 218
 

Heard about his earlier today. wonder why the EPIRB signal didn't reach the Coast Guard for so long? I guess they could be mistaken about the time of the actual sinking. Seems like a boat of that size would have the model that activates automatically when it gets wet, as opposed to manual activation.



   
ReplyQuote
Captain Tom Beckham
(@capt_tom)
Estimable Member
Joined: 20 years ago
Posts: 183
 

Any loss of life is ashamed. I can only imagine the fear and hopelessness in the hearts while hoping that the IPIRB worked, and that it was perceived as valid. God Bless their souls!



   
ReplyQuote
Topsail_Angler
(@)
Estimable Member
Joined: 20 years ago
Posts: 123
 

Heard about his earlier today. wonder why the EPIRB signal didn't reach the Coast Guard for so long? I guess they could be mistaken about the time of the actual sinking. Seems like a boat of that size would have the model that activates automatically when it gets wet, as opposed to manual activation.

Depends on the EPIRB radio type. The older analog style depends on either aircraft picking up the signal or the Cospas-SarSat satellite picking it up but that satellite might not see it for up to 4 hours. The newer digital types are monitored by the GEOSAR and LEOSAR satellites and normally the signal will be picked up within 10 minutes.



   
ReplyQuote
Lee Howell
(@)
Honorable Member
Joined: 18 years ago
Posts: 497
 

Talk about some older Epirbs signal not getting picked up... I bought a SPOT recently and used it for the first time the other day and set it to tracking before I left the dock... After I got home I checked to look at the track that we took that day and after a getting a few miles offshore it didnt track anymore till we got back near shore... I hoped it was me just not setting it up right but after reading today I dont see where I did anything wrong if it is set up for tracking and it did for about an hour then it should of tracked for up to 24 hours or until shut off but it didnt... I dont know why and I havent contacted SPOT about it yet but will soon.. 😕

After seeing that it didnt work yesterday I am now looking into an EPIRB to carry also...

The way things are nowadays where a lot things just arent what they are made out to be it has me wondering about a SPOT and wondering if my butt gets in trouble isnt something I want to be doing 40 to 50 miles offshore... 😮



   
ReplyQuote
Hooked
(@)
Estimable Member
Joined: 19 years ago
Posts: 218
 

I think I'm going to be looking into an EPIRB to carry myself. When the water temps are what they are this time of year, if I needed help I'd want it to be on the way as soon as possible. If the Coast guard recieved more than one signal from the same area they would know somethings' up.



   
ReplyQuote
JB2C
 JB2C
(@)
Reputable Member
Joined: 20 years ago
Posts: 271
 

Talk about some older Epirbs signal not getting picked up... I bought a SPOT recently and used it for the first time the other day and set it to tracking before I left the dock... After I got home I checked to look at the track that we took that day and after a getting a few miles offshore it didnt track anymore till we got back near shore... I hoped it was me just not setting it up right but after reading today I dont see where I did anything wrong if it is set up for tracking and it did for about an hour then it should of tracked for up to 24 hours or until shut off but it didnt... I dont know why and I havent contacted SPOT about it yet but will soon.. 😕

After seeing that it didnt work yesterday I am now looking into an EPIRB to carry also...

The way things are nowadays where a lot things just arent what they are made out to be it has me wondering about a SPOT and wondering if my butt gets in trouble isnt something I want to be doing 40 to 50 miles offshore... 😮

Would certainly like to hear what they tell you. Am considering buying a Spot in the next couple of days myself.

JB



   
ReplyQuote
Tom
 Tom
(@seahorse)
Noble Member
Joined: 19 years ago
Posts: 1167
 

I have a spot and it works great. I did not pay extra to be able to track myself when offshore because I did not see the point except to look at where I had been fishing. Figured I would look at the GPS for that info. I can tell you that I have it programed to let my wife know I am ok. Last trip to the stream was with my buddy in Savannah and furthest distance offshore was 78 miles and I sent her two "I Am OK " messages at different times during the day. Both came into her cell phone and computer e mail address at work within five minuets of me sending them from my SPOT. I do not think it's a replacement for a quality E pirb but for someone who jumps around on different boats I like having my own little security blanket. For the modest price of the unit and yearly fee to monitor I don't see why more guys dont have them. Everytime I read about someone falling overboard or hanging from the overturned hull for five hours I ask myself "Could this be me?"
I posted about a great gadget that kills the motors if you get more than forty feet from the helm or shuts down the motors as soon as the remote you carry in your pocket or on your belt loop gets wet. Anyone buy one ?



   
ReplyQuote
Andy Duskie
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 19 years ago
Posts: 1589
 

SEAHORSE,

I am still doing some research on that one. It seems like a good thing to have. Just kind of hard to justify right after bying a new epirb. I just hope that I will have at least one buddy or family member that wants to roll with me. If it turns out that I do some fishing by myself this year I will be getting something along that line.

It sure is a shame about these guys. I wonder what the seas were like when they went down? I am sure that a boat of that size will hadle about anything but I bet went down like a rock. I wish the news ran more stories about all of the guys that are properly equiped and make it back safely. Everytime my mother sees these stories she just worries about me being out there.

Andy



   
ReplyQuote
chewy
(@)
Trusted Member
Joined: 19 years ago
Posts: 64
 

This boat was from Oriental, NC. I grew up with some of the crew. A tragedy indeed.



   
ReplyQuote
Tom
 Tom
(@seahorse)
Noble Member
Joined: 19 years ago
Posts: 1167
 

I feel real sorry for those guys or anyone for that matter that goes to Davy Jones locker. I have to say that after over forty years of fishing offshore on my own boats and many others as a guest it never stops amazing me how poorly so many power boaters deal with maintenance that may have changed a horrible experiance into a "Wow that was close".
Perfect example is bilge pumps my favorite thing. It never stops amazing me regardless of boat size how many captains never look over the side when they push it up heading offshore first thing in the morning to see if bilge water is pumping out from the stern pump or better yet turn a bilge pump on manuel during the day just to see it pump rather than assuming that since the little light did not come on we have no water to pump out. I wonder how many captains know that the little light does not always mean the pump works depending on how the manufacturer wired the dash panel.
Commercial boats are a whole other story. I don't know why but maybe the fact that these guys are on the water seven days a week working and trying to make a living leaves little or no time to fix things properly unless it stops running completly. If you ever wanted to be scared to death , take a look in the engine room /bilge of one of these commerial draggers or shrimp boats. Between the oil in the bilge and some of the other "Temp" repair items on some, you would be amazed.I personally know of some up north that use the bilge to drain their engine oil and let it slosh till they get offshore and let it pump. They wonder where the engine room fire started from. Most have barely the requirements by law for life rafts life jackets and e perbs etc. Have you ever seen that styrafoam ovel with the mesh in the center some boats carry. I guess that conforms to coast guard requirements but for winter fishing maybe a day floating sixty miles form land it's not much better than a 141 igloo to hang onto.
I am not trying to imply anything negative about commercial fishermen or anyone for the matter. My whole family are commercial fishermen up north and they don't operate and maintain their boats in a poor manner. They carry life rafts with automatic hydrostatic relaese so if the go down the raft releases from the cradle and inflates automatically.I am just saying that when you try to figure out why a boat sunk or caught fire and people died, sometimes something as simple as a bilge full of water that pulled the stern down untill water was rushing over the outboard well and sunk is the cause.
I have personally seen two boats sink offshore and let me tell you that they go down it's about fifteen seconds sometimes, especially a center console with twin outboards. Your anchored up bottem fishing and it's rough as hell , bilge pump not working and you dont know it. Three big guys go to the stern for whatever reason , all the bilge water runs aft and all of a sudden water is gushing over the transom well filling the cockpit. You know how I know this? Been there done that trying to lift a 500 lb giant into my 23 Sea Craft years ago and almost sinking thirty miles off Montauk with a bilge pump that took a dump, a bilge full of water and everyone pulling on a block and tackle to lift the fish into the cockpit. Let him back into the water real fast and thanked God when I gave the bilge pump wires a shake it made contact again and started to pump . Will only use shrink wrap crimps ever again and paint everyting with the rubberized electracal coat and keep all connections fastened as high out of the bilge and I can get them.
Sorry for getting up on my soap box but hate to see folks die when maybe it could maybe have been avoided by something as simple as flipping the bilge pump switch to manuel and looking over the side as a matter of routine. If you dont think water gets into the bilge on your center console with no thru hull fittings guess again. Between washdown pump water , spray on a rough day, scuppers that allow water back in when full of fuel and heavy aft with passengers ,ice etc. and deck hatches that dont seal well you would be amazed how much water you can take on when the pump quits working.



   
ReplyQuote
D-Boy
(@)
Trusted Member
Joined: 18 years ago
Posts: 81
 

A second fisherman has died. Only one survivor so far.... They pulled 3 of the 7 aboard and now 2 have passed on...... 4 still missing

( R.I.P. Brothers )



   
ReplyQuote
chewy
(@)
Trusted Member
Joined: 19 years ago
Posts: 64
 

The only survivor was a mexican that was on board. The rest of the crew, from what I can gather so far, were all Pamlico County natives.

The story that I'm being told is the boat sank around 5:00, but the epirb didn't activate until 7:30. Conjecture is that it was a hydrostatic epirb and must have been in an air pocket. The crew did have time to put their survival suits on so they knew something was wrong. Can't imagine why somebody didn't manually trip the epirb, but it's easy to second guess when you weren't actually there. I can only imagine the panic & fear that every one of them must have been experiencing. Even with the survival suit, it's amazing that anybody survived over 3 hours in 40 degree water. I'll keep updating as I can.



   
ReplyQuote
Capt Ryan Jordan
(@pin)
Honorable Member
Joined: 21 years ago
Posts: 466
 

As for the older EPRIRBS, they have quit monitoring them as of February of this year. You need to have the 406 Mhz for them to detect you now.



   
ReplyQuote
Share: