SWC Forums
Pull up a chair...let's talk fishing.
February 2018 Marine Fisheries Commission Meeting Public Comments
It looks like we will be fishing offshore next week during the public comment period. We plan on staying two or three days if the forecast holds. There will only be one trip ticket for one of the two commercial fishing license holders who will work for more than one day on that trip. These are two examples of the many problems with requiring a minimum amount of trip tickets to be considered a commercial fisherman. What about the charter boats that commercial fish in the winter to help make ends meet? Would they lose their commercial license along with this source of income if they only have a few trip tickets that make up a small percentage of their annual earnings? What about the mate trying to work their way up to running and eventually owning a boat? Are global corporations that can hire crews to meet the criteria being considered for defining commercial fisherman more of a fisherman than that young mate, charter captain, or the watermen who work at sea for days on one trip? What if a license holder gets sick or other circumstances keep them off the water for a prolonged period? Would you take away their license?
The idea of defining commercial fishermen exposes a philosophical difference in how we can think about solving most problems. We can either restrict freedom with more regulations or look for ways to advance the individual liberties that collectively make us free people. Why don't we focus on improving our fisheries with hatcheries and habitat enhancements so there is more seafood for everyone to enjoy? This would negate the need to reduce the number of commercial fishermen that provide consumers with access to local seafood. It would result in more liberal bag limits for recreational fishermen so there is no need for some of them to buy a commercial license to keep more fish. We can make our fisheries better than ever without hurting anyone in the process if we really want to. Shouldn't we try a path that promotes freedom rather than always rushing to take away more of it? Don't we owe it to future generations to pass on healthy fisheries along with the freedom to access them? Please do not do anything else to restrict our freedom to fish and eat local seafood. Please use our license fees along with other available funding to stock native seafood and make habitat improvements.
I am always happy to answer any questions or go into greater detail.
Thank you,
Chris McCaffity
The idea of defining commercial fishermen exposes a philosophical difference in how we can think about solving most problems. We can either restrict freedom with more regulations or look for ways to advance the individual liberties that collectively make us free people. Why don't we focus on improving our fisheries with hatcheries and habitat enhancements so there is more seafood for everyone to enjoy? This would negate the need to reduce the number of commercial fishermen that provide consumers with access to local seafood. It would result in more liberal bag limits for recreational fishermen so there is no need for some of them to buy a commercial license to keep more fish. We can make our fisheries better than ever without hurting anyone in the process if we really want to. Shouldn't we try a path that promotes freedom rather than always rushing to take away more of it? Don't we owe it to future generations to pass on healthy fisheries along with the freedom to access them? Please do not do anything else to restrict our freedom to fish and eat local seafood. Please use our license fees along with other available funding to stock native seafood and make habitat improvements.
I am always happy to answer any questions or go into greater detail.
Thank you,
Chris McCaffity
I think its asinine to do any stocking until inshore trawling is stopped. As it stands right now we don't have a healthy nursery area because of destructive harvest methods. I agree with a balance between the two interests.
The license issue is a double edged sword. I see both sides, and I do think some of these licenses are abused (both rec and com). Better enforcement would help, but I don't think the enforcement structure we currently have will do anything different than status quo.
Well said Chris, and thanks for stating your thoughts on it. There are going to be people who don't agree and never will, unfortunately they can not have a decent discussion about it and only see one side, theirs. Many don't understand if this proposal goes through that it will hurt the recreational side as well as anyone who enjoys eating locally caught seafood in the long run. Hopefully will see you at the meeting.
Thanks pin. It doesn't look like I will make the meeting. Please give public comments if you are able to attend.
goheelsfan, there is no doubt that something needs to be done to address shrimp trawl bycatch. I enjoy eating shrimp like so many other people including CCA members that often serve them at their meetings. I have met a lot of shrimpers who are good people with families to support. Would those who want to ban shrimping be as eager if they had to face those families? Maybe compassion would compel them to consider other ways of solving the bycatch problem that wouldn't hurt those families. Some shrimpers have suggested that we should use the bycatch instead of being required to discard it. This would give us an accurate count of how many fish are being killed. We could offset that harvest of juvenile fish with hatcheries. Consumers could help fund hatcheries with a 1% restocking fee on seafood sales in NC.