SWC Forums
Pull up a chair...let's talk fishing.
I like salmon.
I just want to catch one of those local salmon by hook and line.
As hard as I have tried I have not been able to catch any out of Beaufort Inlet.
Do not know if I am fishing for them properly or not.
I was in a local seafood store a few weeks ago (where I get my salmon) and I saw red snapper.
The lady said they were local caught. I looked at them hard and they were not vermillion snapper...could have been some other red type of snapper, but they sure looked like red snapper and that is what the lady called them. Even if they said they were local, I doubted it.
So I went to one of my go to places for let's call it a fried fish roll, which I get all the time. They normally use wahoo, grouper, or some type of premium white fish , whatever they have. It has always, best to my knowledge, been authentic, and always includes one type of fish. So I called in a to go order, and I inquired as to "what is the fresh catch today", and the young lady informed me it was " mahi tuna". I asked her again , what type, and again she said it was " mahi Tuna". I explained to her I get this item all the time, and it normally only has one type of fish in it. She explained to me that it is only one fish, and that "mahi" is a species of "tuna". I didn't know that lol. Caught my first mahi in the shipping channel many yrs ago one summer in mhc, and we called them "dolphin". I have since learned to call them "mahi" as I got accused of eating flipper. I didn't realize they were a tuna lol! 😀.
As for the red snapper debate, I've eaten pinkies, mangrove, yellowtail, and red Berliner snappers all labeled as red snapper, only once did I create a scene about it at a red lobster. Yeah I know, I shoulda just went to the store and got some frozen packaged fish woulda been better. But it's hard to beat their warm, freshly baked cheddar biscuits!
From now on, I Just order 2 doz to go and eat them lol!
So I went to one of my go to places for let's call it a fried fish roll, which I get all the time. They normally use wahoo, grouper, or some type of premium white fish , whatever they have. It has always, best to my knowledge, been authentic, and always includes one type of fish. So I called in a to go order, and I inquired as to "what is the fresh catch today", and the young lady informed me it was " mahi tuna". I asked her again , what type, and again she said it was " mahi Tuna". I explained to her I get this item all the time, and it normally only has one type of fish in it. She explained to me that it is only one fish, and that "mahi" is a species of "tuna". I didn't know that lol. Caught my first mahi in the shipping channel many yrs ago one summer in mhc, and we called them "dolphin". I have since learned to call them "mahi" as I got accused of eating flipper. I didn't realize they were a tuna lol! 😀.
As for the red snapper debate, I've eaten pinkies, mangrove, yellowtail, and red Berliner snappers all labeled as red snapper, only once did I create a scene about it at a red lobster. Yeah I know, I shoulda just went to the store and got some frozen packaged fish woulda been better. But it's hard to beat their warm, freshly baked cheddar biscuits!
From now on, I Just order 2 doz to go and eat them lol!
This sounds like an innocent miscommunication with the words ahi and mahi.
Good call Chris. I hadn't even thought of that, but you're probably spot on.
FWIW - you should be able to tell the difference between tuna and mahi, even if cooked.
Texture should be way different unless they've been mashed up.
Friend of mine went on a charter out of Little River a couple weeks ago and was really happy about their catch of red snapper. That's what the mate and captain both called them. He sent me a picture of a deck full of beeliners.
^^^^ Another prime example of why we have scientific names for fish, animals, etc.
It is kind of interesting to learn how a single species of fish is called by so many different names depending on where they were caught
Just look at the kingfish..I mean sea mullet...I mean Virginia mullet...I mean whiting...I mean southern kingfish etc..
See a few charter boats calling grunts grey snapper or how about pink porgy being called silver snapper. That is one that confuses me most because they are not silver nor are they snappers..
I thought this was an interesting article on the fda guidlines of fish. Who new snapper could be of 56 different species and grouper could be sold as one of 64 different species including sand perch????????
http://www.npr.org/sections/thesalt/2015/07/30/426832960/you-say-striped-bass-i-say-rockfish-whats-in-a-fish-name
See a few charter boats calling grunts grey snapper or how about pink porgy being called silver snapper. That is one that confuses me most because they are not silver nor are they snappers..
This is pretty common. A newbie fishermen is more likely to go back and fish on a boat catching a high dollar fish he's heard of called a red snapper instead of some inferior thing like a beeliner.
Red Porgy - nah ---- silver snapper.
Sooner or later the newbie fisherman learns too and starts calling them the right thing.
When talking about the easily confused fish, I just state the whole name so that anybody who knows won't have to ask for clarification.
I call them American Red Snapper. Then nobody has to ask if that's the real one.
I also refer to my small tunas that I catch as "false albacore" "atlantic bonito" and "skipjack".
I want to whack people who use the term "bonita". Because whenever you say that, somebody has to ask
for clarification, and then the person will say what it really is. Why not just start with that one?
Floridiots ruined this one...but I digress.