SWC Forums

Pull up a chair...let's talk fishing.

Gag Closure
 
Notifications
Clear all

Gag Closure

13 Posts
5 Users
0 Reactions
23.2 K Views
Chris McCaffity
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 15 years ago
Posts: 1424
Topic starter   [#36822]

Is anyone interested in discussing ways we can avoid extended closures like this one for the commercial harvest of Gag Grouper? http://sero.nmfs.noaa.gov/fishery_bulletins/index.html?utm_source=FW%3A+Fishery+Bulletins+-+Comm+Closure+of+Gag+and+Blue+Runner&utm_campaign=FB+Gag+%26+Bluerunner+commercial+closure&utm_medium=email

Rather than properly manage the commercial gag quota, the SAFMC in its infinite collective wisdom decided to allocate 27,218 pounds of our gag quota to Post Closure Discard Mortality. Do you passively support this waste?



   
Quote
Jacques Dufour
(@)
Estimable Member
Joined: 16 years ago
Posts: 128
 

Chris, somehow most discussions on here regarding commercial fishing seem to quickly turn sour, reason we've had a tendancy of staying out of them!
Regarding gag mortality, these are pretty hardy fish and an extensive tagging program would be a pretty cheap and a very effective way of getting good info just over a couple seasons.
The current quota with an average weight maybe of around 8lbs per fish = only around 40.000 fish for the whole SE Atlantic...
If around 40 of the top boats agreed to tag 1000 fish each a season we'd very quickly have results. If tags weren't removed from released fish I think we'd be surprised at how many times the same fish is caught every given year proving how low mortality really is...
Anyway, this remains one vast subject with no easy solution but a 326.722 lbs quota for gags just brings back to mind that commercial fishing has turned into part time job! Out of about 669 Snapper / Grouper permits if all fished for that specie that is only around 488 lbs per boat for a season. At $5.50 per pound that would be a meager average of $2684.00 per boat per year!
All I can say is that many countries must be pretty jealous of how healthy and sustainable our grouper fisheries really are!
MM



   
ReplyQuote
Chris McCaffity
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 15 years ago
Posts: 1424
Topic starter  

merrymarlin2, thanks for the reply. I agree a tagging program would be very helpful in showing that the Discard Mortality Rate for shallow-water gags is much lower than 40%. Very few undersized gags are caught deeper than 20 fathoms and decent assist devices can greatly improve survival rates for fish suffering from barotrauma. Properly managed quotas could avoid Post Closure Discards.

Would you be willing to tag illegal grouper and use a decent assist device if needed?



   
ReplyQuote
Jacques Dufour
(@)
Estimable Member
Joined: 16 years ago
Posts: 128
 

Chris, we'd be glad to tag 1000 "illegals". If they give us a winter BSB season this coming year that could happen pretty quickly!
As a small day boat we don't use bandit reels and haven't floated a single grouper this year... The boys would be glad to take an observer out on a rough day for them to see for themselves how frisky any gag goes back down!
While fishing for deeper for triggers or beeliners it is not that common to bring groupers up from the deep on small rigs. That would be the only times I believe an assist device may be needed to have a healthy release. As you say most deep water groupers when targeted in the open season are good for the box!



   
ReplyQuote
Chris McCaffity
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 15 years ago
Posts: 1424
Topic starter  

John Carmichael is willing to meet with a group of fishermen during the SAFMC meeting next month in Wilmington to discuss things like ways to reduce the discard mortality rates used in stock assessments. Would you like to attend this meeting?



   
ReplyQuote
Cliff Pack
(@recess)
Eminent Member
Joined: 19 years ago
Posts: 36
 

Is anyone interested in discussing ways we can avoid extended closures like this one for the commercial harvest of Gag Grouper? http://sero.nmfs.noaa.gov/fishery_bulletins/index.html?utm_source=FW%3A+Fishery+Bulletins+-+Comm+Closure+of+Gag+and+Blue+Runner&utm_campaign=FB+Gag+%26+Bluerunner+commercial+closure&utm_medium=email

Rather than properly manage the commercial gag quota, the SAFMC in its infinite collective wisdom decided to allocate 27,218 pounds of our gag quota to Post Closure Discard Mortality. Do you passively support this waste?

Chris,
How long do you think 27,000 lbs will support the fleet?



   
ReplyQuote
Chris McCaffity
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 15 years ago
Posts: 1424
Topic starter  

RECESS, the solution many open-minded fishermen support would be to allocate the 27,218 pounds to a 50 pound by-catch allowance after the primary quota is filled. A multi-species fishery needs to be managed with appropriate possession limits and by-catch allowances to avoid the multiple extended closures that are wasting hundreds of tons of our quotas every year. 27,218 pounds of gag quota would not last long with a 1,000 or even 500 pound trip limit. Properly managed quotas would allow us to target fish with higher quotas and possession limits while still keeping most of the others with lower limits. This would provide consumers with a dependable supply and wide variety of local seafood. Properly managed quotas would help collect better data for stock assessments while following the MSA mandates to limit waste, make efficient use of the resource, and promote the safety of fishermen at sea.



   
ReplyQuote
John Rakoci
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 14 years ago
Posts: 2331
 

You want to give them 27,000# then how about they give up 50,000# BSB. Why is it you always want to give and get nothing in return?



   
ReplyQuote
Chris McCaffity
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 15 years ago
Posts: 1424
Topic starter  

CoastalCarolina, within RA15 the SAFMC allocated 27,218 pounds of our annual commercial quota for Gag Grouper to Post Closure Discard Mortality when they allowed other shallow-water grouper to remain open after gag closures. This is in addition to the 81,000 pounds that is already allocated to dead discards.

The council also rushed through RA18 which allocated 35,000 pounds of the commercial Vermilion Snapper quota to Post Closure Discard Mortality.

I submitted comments for both Regulatory Amendments asking the council to MANAGE gag and beeliner quotas with appropriate possession limits to avoid extended closures rather than planning ahead to waste our resources. Maybe they would have listened if a few more people submitted public comments supporting some common sense solutions.

It is important to understand that we have to work with the numbers and laws we have now as we work to make them better. While I do not agree with planning ahead to mismanage our quotas, we can make the best of a bad situation. We can offer positive solutions like using discard allocations for by-catch allowances that will feed more people and produce more revenue while collecting more data for better stock assessments. What is so wrong with that?



   
ReplyQuote
John Rakoci
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 14 years ago
Posts: 2331
 

Unbelievable!



   
ReplyQuote
Chris McCaffity
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 15 years ago
Posts: 1424
Topic starter  

CoastalCarolina, does using the Post Closure Discard Mortality allocations for by-catch allowances make more sense than just wasting tons of our quotas?

Does properly managing quotas to avoid extended closures make more sense than planning ahead for the council's gross mismanagement that results in excessive projected dead discards?



   
ReplyQuote
Tim Barefoot
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 17 years ago
Posts: 942
 

Chris
First, let me say this is a real shame.
To quote the great and legendary Roy Crabtree, "this is going to hurt".
I have not killed a gag in less than 125 feet in YEARS and YEARS.
This goes right along with striped bass and speckled trout.

If you have some gum root from NOAA down here doing the "survey" (that has no idea how to handle fish), then gee, I guess that you can have dead discards. duh.
ALL of these scientist, and most of the survey team specialist can't find their ass with both hands offshore!!! But they can dang sure read a report written by someone (who don;t know sheet), and come down pretty hard on us, (common citizens).we are not worthy of being in the decision making process, I guess.

I will kiss Roy Crabtrees ass on Market street if the discard mortality rate is what they say it is. I have released THOUSANDS and THOUSANDS of gags , rock and trout in perfect condition.
You would be much further down the road trying to convince these ding dongs to produce videos on proper handling/release methods rather than writing letters of complaint only.
Funny how the commercial sector squalled like mashed cats in regards to dead discards of rock and speckled trout over the past few years??? BS, total BS.
Yes, there are recreational fishermen (and comms) that treat fish poorly inside the boat, but educate these people, rather than paint us all with that same wide brush, and use additional restrictions as "management tools"

I realized this years ago. YOU ARE WASTING YOUR TIME TRYING TO TALK COMMON SENCE TO THESE BEAUROCRATS



   
ReplyQuote
Chris McCaffity
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 15 years ago
Posts: 1424
Topic starter  

barefootfishing, through the Visioning Project we can reduce regulatory discards while educating anglers and scientists about how to reduce discard mortality. John Carmichael is open to collecting new data that could reduce the discard mortality rates used in stock assessments. We need a group of interested fishermen to meet with John during next month's SAFMC meeting to discuss what kind of data he needs to improve stock assessments overall. We should coordinate efforts with bottom-fishermen down the coast to the collect the data needed and show we are doing our part to improve survival rates.

The Visioning Project gives us a chance to make our voice heard the way so many say it has not been. We simply need to coordinate our message and efforts so our collective voice carries enough weight to convince a majority of council members to support our positive vision for the future of our fisheries.



   
ReplyQuote
Share: