SWC Forums
Pull up a chair...let's talk fishing.
I saw a report where some guys caught 116 trout in one day in Louisiana. Why can't we have that? I fully believe that changes in regulations plus hatchery development, and habitat improvement will help. It has to be a give and take and if I have to give a few extra bucks on my saltwater fishing license for my son and I to catch more fish once he gets old enough I'm ALL FOR IT!
We can make our fisheries better than they were in the good old days. It is time to focus more on enhancing our fisheries and food supply than restricting our freedom to access them.
We can make our fisheries better than they were in the good old days. It is time to focus more on enhancing our fisheries and food supply than restricting our freedom to access them.
So are you suggesting that someone pay for hatcheries to grow and release fish into the wild because we are catching too many wild fish now and their ability to reproduce can not keep up with the amount of fish we are taking?
If that is the case why not just raise the hatchery fish until they are marketable size and stop harvesting the wild stock until it can fully recover?
By providing hatchery fish to just be caught it does not address the problem. It's like putting a band aid on a six in cut in the bottom of your foot, but not picking up the broken glass on the floor that caused the cut
Regulations and methods of harvest (comm/rec) need to be addressed as well lets start introducing more fish. Has anyone ever seen a wild cow? Cows are farmed pretty successfully, I'm sure as smart as we are that fish can be done the same way to help keep commercial fisherman in business.
We can make our fisheries better than they were in the good old days. It is time to focus more on enhancing our fisheries and food supply than restricting our freedom to access them.
So are you suggesting that someone pay for hatcheries to grow and release fish into the wild because we are catching too many wild fish now and their ability to reproduce can not keep up with the amount of fish we are taking?
If that is the case why not just raise the hatchery fish until they are marketable size and stop harvesting the wild stock until it can fully recover?
By providing hatchery fish to just be caught it does not address the problem. It's like putting a band aid on a six in cut in the bottom of your foot, but not picking up the broken glass on the floor that caused the cut
"So are you suggesting that someone pay for hatcheries to grow and release fish into the wild because we are catching too many wild fish now and their ability to reproduce can not keep up with the amount of fish we are taking?"
I am saying we should be allowed to stock a certain amount of some species to sustain a higher harvest level. Our license fees along with a shift in DMF focus could quickly have existing hatcheries running at full capacity.
"If that is the case why not just raise the hatchery fish until they are marketable size and stop harvesting the wild stock until it can fully recover?"
Some sedentary fish like tilapia and catfish are good aquaculture options. We should be processing scraps from cleaned seafood for closed-system domestic aquaculture feed. Many fish are not designed for restraint. Stocking allows released fish to live free and self-sufficient until harvested. Rather than closing and polluting large areas of public waters with industrial fish farms, we could sustain world-class sportfishing opportunity while feeding many more people.
"By providing hatchery fish to just be caught it does not address the problem. It's like putting a band aid on a six in cut in the bottom of your foot, but not picking up the broken glass on the floor that caused the cut."
We should address habitat issues that negatively impact our fisheries. Stocked fish can be marked for easy identification and counting. Fin clipping is used to protect salmon in the Columbia River by allowing fishermen to keep marked salmon while releasing the unmarked.
I have a different suggestion: let's give God's hatchery - the estuaries - a chance to do what they were put there for and STOP TRAWLING FOR SHRIMP IN THEM!
Rant over.
I have a different suggestion: let's give God's hatchery - the estuaries - a chance to do what they were put there for and STOP TRAWLING FOR SHRIMP IN THEM!
Rant over.
I think that should have been the first thing to do, when the high school kids raise fingerlings and release them in Davis Canal they migrate towards the red banks where they are caught up in shrimp nets. we got to quit raiding the nursery whether we are adding hatched fish or letting mother nature produce them. a hook and line fishery will not hurt the numbers.
I have a different suggestion: let's give God's hatchery - the estuaries - a chance to do what they were put there for and STOP TRAWLING FOR SHRIMP IN THEM!
Rant over.
I agree with this.
To me it makes no sense at all to go through the cost and effort to breed, raise and stock a fish that will be harvested or wasted.
If the fishery is in such bad shape due to overharvesting, stop harvesting.
That being said, since the commercial side is landing an overwhelming majority of this species, if they want to fund, develop and implement a hatchery program then go for it. If you can come up with a formula to use the commercial fishing license fees or add on a license fee to the inshore flounder or shrimp boats to cover these costs 100%, go for it.
But it does not make any sense to have the recreational side pay for what would amount to be a hand out to the commercial side. Would there be more fish for the rec side, yes but the costs of this are much less if we focus on the landings side.
From a purely financial perspective, stocking a fish where the majority will die before they can be landed and sold is a waste. Between natural predation, bycatch in the inshore shrimp trawling boats and normal mortality, the percentage of fry that make it to sexual maturity and spawn successful is very low. You would essentially be stocking unusable fish unless you stop landing them for a few spawning cycles and give a breeding stock the chance to take hold.
Just my opinion, take it for what its worth (not much)
It is becoming obvious that I have a different view of our fisheries than most. I see the potential for NC waters to be one of the greatest sustainable food production systems the world has ever seen while supporting world-class recreational fishing. I see the potential to end world hunger as our model of successful stocking is adopted in other places. We should not let our perception of a perfect world stop us from making the best of what we have. We should work to improve habitat and harvest methods while limiting waste as we begin enhancing our fisheries and food supply.
It is becoming obvious that I have a different view of our fisheries than most. I see the potential for NC waters to be one of the greatest sustainable food production systems the world has ever seen while supporting world-class recreational fishing. I see the potential to end world hunger as our model of successful stocking is adopted in other places. We should not let our perception of a perfect world stop us from making the best of what we have. We should work to improve habitat and harvest methods while limiting waste as we begin enhancing our fisheries and food supply.
Chris,
I recognize that you mean well. I've been watching and reading your posts for a couple years but you are pursuing a fantasy unless you first recognize that certain practices by a relatively few people are doing incredible damage to the stocks, specifically inshore trawling. Unless and until some video is shown of what's in the net along with a few measly pounds of shrimp, nobody will understand the damage being done. As a very young man, I spent many, many nights working the deck of a tiny trawler dragging the waters around Harkers Island. I have no doubt that I personally shoveled many tons of dead baby fish over the side. Back then, I didn't appreciate how much destruction two people could do with a little boat, a few gallons of diesel and a small net. I do now. Gill netters get a lot of notice because the fish they catch, because of size, are "noticeable". 100 legal trout and several dozen slot reds take up a lot of space. I could put 100 trout, 100 reds and 100 flounder in a single 5 gallon bucket-every night. It's got to stop or at least be substantially reduced or all the thinking, organizing, posting and arguing you and others do so much of is all for not. I get the passion and the intent and I respect you and many others for it. But all the good intentions in the world can't replace hundreds of thousands of fish that never have a chance to grow beyond "the length of these words".
It is becoming obvious that I have a different view of our fisheries than most. I see the potential for NC waters to be one of the greatest sustainable food production systems the world has ever seen while supporting world-class recreational fishing. I see the potential to end world hunger as our model of successful stocking is adopted in other places. We should not let our perception of a perfect world stop us from making the best of what we have. We should work to improve habitat and harvest methods while limiting waste as we begin enhancing our fisheries and food supply.
Chris,
I recognize that you mean well. I've been watching and reading your posts for a couple years but you are pursuing a fantasy unless you first recognize that certain practices by a relatively few people are doing incredible damage to the stocks, specifically inshore trawling. Unless and until some video is shown of what's in the net along with a few measly pounds of shrimp, nobody will understand the damage being done. As a very young man, I spent many, many nights working the deck of a tiny trawler dragging the waters around Harkers Island. I have no doubt that I personally shoveled many tons of dead baby fish over the side. Back then, I didn't appreciate how much destruction two people could do with a little boat, a few gallons of diesel and a small net. I do now. Gill netters get a lot of notice because the fish they catch, because of size, are "noticeable". 100 legal trout and several dozen slot reds take up a lot of space. I could put 100 trout, 100 reds and 100 flounder in a single 5 gallon bucket-every night. It's got to stop or at least be substantially reduced or all the thinking, organizing, posting and arguing you and others do so much of is all for not. I get the passion and the intent and I respect you and many others for it. But all the good intentions in the world can't replace hundreds of thousands of fish that never have a chance to grow beyond "the length of these words".
Thanks for the insightful post Rustyone. There is no reason we can't substantially reduce the number of juvenile fish caught in shrimp trawls. I have heard several simple solutions some shrimpers already use to reduce the by-catch they really don't want to waste time culling. One of those solutions is putting a piece of PVC pipe on the tickler chain. This seems to scare fish away without reducing how many shrimp are caught. My understanding is that fish react to audio and visual stimuli while shrimp don't usually react to them. We should let shrimpers try some different ideas like playing the sound of dolphins feeding through an underwater speaker to scatter schools of fish. New net designs are showing promise for reducing by-catch. One shrimper said that just dragging slower allows more fish to swim out of the trawl. Another one said that dragging with the tide reduced by-catch. We could also use most of the remaining by-catch and get an accurate count of what is being landed so stocking can replace it. We need to look for ways to keep shrimpers working and providing local shrimp while reducing by-catch and using what remains.
I have heard that when the shrimp are thick, there is much less by-catch. Stocking shrimp could be a way to increase local shrimp supplies while reducing by-catch.
If I were one of the shallow water shrimpers, I would be testing - and documenting - everything I could to reduce by catch because there is a growing number of people who, absent some major change in results, will "fix" the problem for them.
Thanks for the input guys!
I think a 50/50 split for funding and Hatchery Supported Quotas is the only fair way to approach this. We have some great facilities and staff in place already. Fishermen could provide different brood stock for each batch to protect genetic diversity and keep costs down. Running existing hatcheries at full capacity would also keep costs down.
Keep who's costs down....again, who is paying for
this proposed "hatchery" ?
Recreational fishermen and taxpayers always pay the bills and commercial fishermen always reap the harvest. Sounds like welfare to me.
Recreational fishermen and taxpayers always pay the bills and commercial fishermen always reap the harvest. Sounds like welfare to me.
Exactly. 50/50? How about 80/20, since 80% of the southern flounder are being commercially harvested for someone's personal profit!
I say once again, hatcheries may be a part of an overall management plan, but if we don't stop killing the juvenile fish before they are old enough to spawn (i.e. trawls and gill nets), it won't do any significant good.