SWC Forums
Pull up a chair...let's talk fishing.
I have a different suggestion: let's give God's hatchery - the estuaries - a chance to do what they were put there for and STOP TRAWLING FOR SHRIMP IN THEM!
Rant over.
You are aware that most hatching takes place in the ocean for a majority of species? Facts provided over.
We have less fish shrimp and crabs in the estuaries since trawling was closed in those areas despite effort being 5% of historic levels. "Its all the trawls" is a simpletons approach to fishery management and flies in the face of reality. Silt and excessive organic muck is smothering our estuaries where development has deposited it and fisheries management have protected it.
Complex biosystems are a tad for complicated than its all the trawls.
At the end of the day, Most states with minimum cold stun deaths has three or more hatcheries per state and great fishing and we have none. Our rec effort has exploded while commercial effort has contracted and the drain on the resource has continued. Our stock is dependent on how cold it got last winter and we are always three good winters or one bad one away form good or bad fishing.
We need to concentrate on more tails in the water instead of salt water pissing matches that mainly serve to raise money for politicians reelection campaigns and lawyers to hand it to them. Its more fish we need not more attitude and discord
I have a different suggestion: let's give God's hatchery - the estuaries - a chance to do what they were put there for and STOP TRAWLING FOR SHRIMP IN THEM!
Rant over.
You are aware that most hatching takes place in the ocean for a majority of species? Facts provided over.
We have less fish shrimp and crabs in the estuaries since trawling was closed in those areas despite effort being 5% of historic levels. "Its all the trawls" is a simpletons approach to fishery management and flies in the face of reality. Silt and excessive organic muck is smothering our estuaries where development has deposited it and fisheries management have protected it.
Complex biosystems are a tad for complicated than its all the trawls.
At the end of the day, Most states with minimum cold stun deaths has three or more hatcheries per state and great fishing and we have none. Our rec effort has exploded while commercial effort has contracted and the drain on the resource has continued. Our stock is dependent on how cold it got last winter and we are always three good winters or one bad one away form good or bad fishing.
We need to concentrate on more tails in the water instead of salt water pissing matches that mainly serve to raise money for politicians reelection campaigns and lawyers to hand it to them. Its more fish we need not more attitude and discord
Honest questions, does trawling not disturb the water? If silt and other issues is a cause for poor conditions smothering our our estuaries how does disturbing the bottom by trawlers not contribute?
What else do those other states have that we do not, I agree cold stuns and weather play a greater role here then in other States but lets not be coy, they also have other measures that many feel are warranted as well. Why only assess the measures of benefit that don't negatively impact either sector of fisherman and not the ones that might?
I have a different suggestion: let's give God's hatchery - the estuaries - a chance to do what they were put there for and STOP TRAWLING FOR SHRIMP IN THEM!
Rant over.
You are aware that most hatching takes place in the ocean for a majority of species? Facts provided over.
We have less fish shrimp and crabs in the estuaries since trawling was closed in those areas despite effort being 5% of historic levels. "Its all the trawls" is a simpletons approach to fishery management and flies in the face of reality. Silt and excessive organic muck is smothering our estuaries where development has deposited it and fisheries management have protected it.
Complex biosystems are a tad for complicated than its all the trawls.
At the end of the day, Most states with minimum cold stun deaths has three or more hatcheries per state and great fishing and we have none. Our rec effort has exploded while commercial effort has contracted and the drain on the resource has continued. Our stock is dependent on how cold it got last winter and we are always three good winters or one bad one away form good or bad fishing.
We need to concentrate on more tails in the water instead of salt water pissing matches that mainly serve to raise money for politicians reelection campaigns and lawyers to hand it to them. Its more fish we need not more attitude and discord
Honest questions, does trawling not disturb the water? If silt and other issues is a cause for poor conditions smothering our our estuaries how does disturbing the bottom by trawlers not contribute?
What else do those other states have that we do not, I agree cold stuns and weather play a greater role here then in other States but lets not be coy, they also have other measures that many feel are warranted as well. Why only assess the measures of benefit that don't negatively impact either sector of fisherman and not the ones that might?
Honest answer while over trawling an area or using destructive gear might harm an area, one must account that positive outcomes might result as well. The silt seen is mainly organic rot and with turning is exposed to tidal action and to degradation by marine organisms.
Those other states have hatcheries that release millions of spawn a year and buffer the ability of the ecosystem to recover from a cold stun. There are no outcomes based research that demonstrate positive effects from other measures that I am aware of...."science"
Empirically, Large sections of Core Sound have been progressively protected since 40 years ago and the biomass of the entire area is declining including the grass beds that once were lush and widespread....Should the grass beds be all that if not working gear over them was the answer?