SWC Forums

Pull up a chair...let's talk fishing.

Impressed with my n...
 
Notifications
Clear all

Impressed with my new ride

30 Posts
19 Users
0 Reactions
56 K Views
JOHNNY CARPENTER
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 14 years ago
Posts: 1169
Topic starter  

I'm not going to get in a pissing match over this. I take care of what ever I have. The boat I sold is a 96 with 2003 Suzuki engines with a little over 500 hrs when purchased. I'm not the first owner. He was an 80 something year old fellow from Charleston. First time I saw the boat, I was going to walk away as he wasn't capable of taking good care of it and it showed but I purchased it anyway. I put several thousand into it and got it back into pretty good shape. Had several good years on the boat with a few minor hiccups. The biggest thing I had trouble with is the known steel plug corrosion problem which I had fixed. The boat ALWAYS got me out and back in with no problems. I never said I took care of it with an "open checkbook" but I tried to take care of it the best I could. Took you two on a seatrial and let you go over the boat all you wanted. The Garmin is a 741xs and I didn't charge you an extra $2000. You offered less than my asking price and I said you could have it for that, less the Garmin. The unit was less than a year or two old and never gave me a problem except for loading xm weather. I don't know why you are having trouble with it. Maybe you need and update or something, but it helped me catch a lot of fish. I'm sorry your having trouble with the boat and that's all I can say or do for you. I purchased the boat I have now knowing that it's not new and that is doesn't have any warranty, but that's a roll of the dice. New offshore rigs with warranties are going to cost you a whole heck of a lot more than used. I had the motors inspected by a mechanic with computer readouts and all but looked over the hull myself. I've had to fix a few things on it but I do it knowing that boating ain't cheap and an offshore fishing boat sure as hell ain't cheap. Good luck fishing and sorry for the problems you are having.



   
ReplyQuote
Nick
 Nick
(@seapro180)
Honorable Member
Joined: 11 years ago
Posts: 543
 

I dont know dogkiller personally but from posts he has made i believe him to be a pretty good guy. I couldnt see him purposefully doing someone wrong. That being said, let me throw this out there for you...i remember the day i went with my day when i was little to a boat show in Greensboro. He came home that day a new owner of a 1996 sprint 18' bass boat with an evinrude 150hp 2 stroke. That boat never had anything but e free gas ran in it, was regularly maintained professionally, had only the best oil put in it, washed and waxed after every single trip to the lake, etc. He had that boat until i turned 18 years old which is when i bought it from him. I knew first hand every time that boat ever hit the water and how well it was maintained. NEVER ONCE in 12 years did that boat even hiccup. After i bpught it, the 3rd time i had it out i got towed back to the dock. 4th time, tilt and trim quit working on motor. And about every other time i took it out something was going wrong for about the next 10-15 trips. It wasn't anything he could help or know about. It was just luck of the draw that after 12 good years it finally started showing its age. It just so happened to do it all at once. So that being said, i cant hold dogkiller at fault for anything that has gone wrong. After all, it is a BOAT...Break Out Another Thousand.



   
ReplyQuote
Wes Livingston
(@wes)
Noble Member
Joined: 22 years ago
Posts: 968
 

Well said Dogkiller



   
ReplyQuote
JOHNNY CARPENTER
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 14 years ago
Posts: 1169
Topic starter  

Well, I looked back and I did put in add that it was maintained with an open checkbook and thought that I fixed everything that needed to be. I did tell you guys that I had just had a steering ram repaired by a local mechanic. I had it out maybe one time before you sea trialed it as last years weather didn't cooperate for much offshore and I had another boat for inshore. If it was leaking, I never saw it and it wasn't leaking during the seatrial as you would of saw it since the ram leaks into the splash well. I wouldn't knowingly send anyone out on a boat I thought to be unsafe. The thing is, offshore boats, old and new, take a hell of a beating day to day. They all have problems from time to time, even new boats. Get on any forum and take a look at what is discussed most. It's problems with boats, with electronics, with motors. That 96 Seacat, nor any other boat is immune to them.

Sorry to you other guys on the forum. Started this thread to see how much fuel you burn on a normal day offshore.



   
ReplyQuote
zigzag
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 22 years ago
Posts: 1863
 

I always dread selling any boat or anything used, when I turn loose of them I know they are as right as I can get them, but they are still used and a lot of stuff happens beyond the owners control, I do not believe a regular member on here would intentionally mislead anybody because they know there is going to be a huge backlash on this site and the world will know, happens on other sites too.

Hate you are having issues with your boat but I could write a book on them and they were not intentional from the sellers part concerning boats deals.



   
ReplyQuote
BRIAN
(@bharbaugh)
Prominent Member
Joined: 19 years ago
Posts: 687
 

That's pure BS. The man has a phone. Not that it really matters to anyone who knows Dog because we know he is a straight up dude.



   
ReplyQuote
Stuart Ussery
(@lookintohookem)
Honorable Member
Joined: 13 years ago
Posts: 701
 

I'll start this by saying I don't personally know any of the parties involved....BUT...I think there are better ways to "air" things out. If somebody on here makes a post asking about this repair shop, this lure, this boat dealer, this whatever, if I had a good experience, I'll post a reply. If I had a BAD experience, I go the PM route. I'm not the smartest guy in the world, so maybe MY experience isn't exactly an expert's opinion.

That being said, I know people that DO know DOGKILLR, and he doesn't seem like the type that would intentionally do anything like that.

My .02



   
ReplyQuote
Jeff Kerr
(@lunchmoney)
Reputable Member
Joined: 14 years ago
Posts: 238
 

I'm going to attempt to provide some clarity and hopefully put this to rest.
Rob and I went in together and bought this boat. It's our 3rd time doing so but our first offshore capable rig. I will admit we didn't do a thorough enough job checking out the engines for ourselves. It ran good during the sea trial, people had good things to say about the boat and the seller. Was supposedly maintained with an open checkbook. We bought it. Come to find out later, not a single anode, internal or external had ever been changed, not by the seller anyway. October we found milky oil in the starboard engine. Turned out that corrosion had attacked the head to the point a hole had developed under the exhaust valve port into the water jacket. New head, valves, rings, mains and a bunch of other parts plus countless hours of labor to diagnose and repair. Worked on it most of the winter rebuilding it ourselves and finally got it running good again. Fast forward to last week, I'm down at Harkers with the wife and kids. Port engine starts running like crap. Checked the oil and guess what? Chocolate milk. So now we are faced with rebuilding the port side, couple thousand dollars and a bunch of time to hopefully fix it. We just wanted an offshore rig so we could go fishing with our families and friends and make some good memories. I guess we are just very unlucky to have both motors crap out in the first 9 months of our ownership. However, we feel the internal anodes not being there caused corrosion to attack the heads and ultimately caused these failures. Should we have dug deeper and had a mechanic go through them instead of trusting what we were told? Obviously so. Lesson learned.
I disagreed with Robs decision to air this out in a public forum, but considering what we've been through and what we are now facing, I somewhat understand. Reading dog's post bragging about how great his new boat is while our mess is on the hill broke down again pushed Rob over the keyboard edge I guess. We want to go fishing, not tear down another engine only to find rotted aluminum because the anodes have long since been eaten away.
We feel like we were misled from a maintenance history standpoint. Seller maintains he took good care of it. We didn't do a good enough job of checking out the motors before buying. Seller didn't do a good enough job maintaining the engines during his ownership tenure. Plenty of blame to go around. Reasonable men can agree to disagree and move on. Some of you that are rushing to defend the seller are his friends. That's fine, that's what friends do. I'm doing the same for my friend of 30+ years Rob. He and I are in this broke down boat together.
It's a boat, stuff breaks. We get it but this has been a nightmare. We had a budget to spend on an offshore rig. Assuming the motors lasted, we felt we had a good deal on a good boat within our budget. Re-powering isn't an option as that would blow the budget. Paying a mechanic to diagnose and repair would about cost as much as a re-power given the severity and complexity of our problems. Can't sell it as-is without taking a huge loss. We opted for door number 4, get a service manual and get the tools out. Not asking for anyone's sympathy, just sharing our side of the story. We'll get it fixed. Lessons learned. Life goes on.
On the bright side, I've become a pretty fair Suzuki mechanic.



   
ReplyQuote
JOHNNY CARPENTER
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 14 years ago
Posts: 1169
Topic starter  

In all honesty, I never knew a boat had internal anodes prior to discussing it with you. Actually, I have talked to several boat owners who are not aware of the internal zincs. But I did always flush the engines after each use and spray them down good with CRC. I only had the boat for three seasons. I think I purchased it in 2013, so that would of put the engines at 10 years old then, the boat 17. Maybe, just maybe, most of the damage was already there when I purchased it, I don't know, as I didn't have it inspected or scoped. I did have a compression test performed. I do however, take offense to you guys saying that I led you wrong as I never had a problem with the boat other than the ones I mentioned and pointed out. I don't or never had xray vision so if there was an internal problem I would of not known until it showed it's ugly face. Maybe we should blame the old fellow who owned it prior to me, for what ever good that would do. Sorry again and I hope you can accept my apologies. That said, I'll never sale anything on a public forum again. I like making friends not enemies.



   
ReplyQuote
Jamie Blue
(@)
Famed Member
Joined: 20 years ago
Posts: 3660
 

No offense, I don't know anybody involved, but that's on the buyers. Why you would buy a used boat (or anything for that matter) without having a mechanic or surveyor go through it I have no idea. Do you buy a used car without having a mechanic go over it?



   
ReplyQuote
Jeff Kerr
(@lunchmoney)
Reputable Member
Joined: 14 years ago
Posts: 238
 

No offense, I don't know anybody involved, but that's on the buyers. Why you would buy a used boat (or anything for that matter) without having a mechanic or surveyor go through it I have no idea. Do you buy a used car without having a mechanic go over it?

I have bought / sold hundreds of thousands of dollars worth of vehicles, boats, houses, equipment etc. without mechanics and / or inspectors involved. Perhaps I've been lucky up until now.

Let it go guys, you too Rob.
I'm done with it.



   
ReplyQuote
JOHNNY CARPENTER
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 14 years ago
Posts: 1169
Topic starter  

10-4



   
ReplyQuote
JOHNNY CARPENTER
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 14 years ago
Posts: 1169
Topic starter  

10-4



   
ReplyQuote
Larry Rowland
(@lwr37)
Famed Member
Joined: 16 years ago
Posts: 2552
 

A person that has a friend for 30+ years must be a decent guy, unless your both assholes and nobody else can stand y'all! I bet both parties are good people though. Sorry y'alls boat is stuck on the hill but that is life sometimes. I fish out of Carolina Beach and sometimes need a couple extras. Shoot me a PM and I add you to the call list. At least you'll get out on the pond.



   
ReplyQuote
Clinton
(@cc)
Estimable Member
Joined: 20 years ago
Posts: 74
 

A person that has a friend for 30+ years must be a decent guy, unless your both assholes and nobody else can stand y'all! I bet both parties are good people though. Sorry y'alls boat is stuck on the hill but that is life sometimes. I fish out of Carolina Beach and sometimes need a couple extras. Shoot me a PM and I add you to the call list. At least you'll get out on the pond.

lwr37, sir I don't know you, but you are a First Class Act. I hope they take you up on the fishing and y'all fill the box.



   
ReplyQuote
Page 2 / 2
Share: