SWC Forums

Pull up a chair...let's talk fishing.

Petetion to remove ...
 
Notifications
Clear all

Petetion to remove louis daniels

22 Posts
16 Users
0 Reactions
67.4 K Views
Rich
 Rich
(@squid-row)
Illustrious Member
Joined: 22 years ago
Posts: 4097
 

Specifically to the petition....

Replace Dr. Daniels with ???

Also, to the petition. Has there ever been a fisheries related petition that accomplished anything other than fund raising for certain groups?



   
ReplyQuote
Capt. Chris Medlin
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 23 years ago
Posts: 1073
 

I was not the author of the petition but I do support it whole heartily. Dr Daniel (whom I have spoken with about this). He and I had a good long conversation about my feeling of his failure. Somewhere along the line the buck must stop. True he only does as the MFC directs him to but we all know he has a lot of influence as to who gets appointed to the MFC even though he claims he does not. The truth of the matter is that 19 of the 32 species under his charge are in the concerned or depleted column. This isn't about rec or comm. He has failed both user groups. If he can not pull the reigns and DIRECT the MFC to a truly sustainable fishery I suggest new leadership is needed.

The most glaring statement he made to me was "I try and make everyone happy" well that isn't leadership. I feel the rules should be made with science.......Period. If you would look through the names signing the petition you will notice it is bi partisan. Recs and Comms both know he has failed.

I don't know who would replace him but I can't see them being worse.



   
ReplyQuote
GetdaGaff
(@getdagaff)
Noble Member
Joined: 20 years ago
Posts: 930
 

Captaingorges, thanks for setting the record straight ...

Ecsports, "True he only does as the MFC directs him to but we all know he has a lot of influence as to who gets appointed to the MFC even though he claims he does not. " ... the composition of the board looks relative balanced to me ... I'm puzzeled the policy implementer is taking the heat instead of the policy makers :duh:



   
ReplyQuote
Capt. Chris Medlin
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 23 years ago
Posts: 1073
 

What do you mean by balanced?



   
ReplyQuote
lynwood goff
(@)
Eminent Member
Joined: 18 years ago
Posts: 21
 

When the smoke clears and all is said and done.All fishing will cease because there wiil be nothing to catch.
Maybe by the grace of our good Lord,a few minners will be left and have a chance to reproduce before someone finds them out and eradicates them.
Men are greedy,always have been and always will be,This is just our nature.Pure Pitiful and I speak for myself.
Men must have the foresight to do what is needed to save a species without having to be threatned or mandated to do it by law.
Thats another thing that will never occur because of Greed.Everybody wants the very last one.Nuff said



   
ReplyQuote
John Rakoci
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 14 years ago
Posts: 2331
 

When the smoke clears and all is said and done.All fishing will cease because there wiil be nothing to catch.
Maybe by the grace of our good Lord,a few minners will be left and have a chance to reproduce before someone finds them out and eradicates them.
Men are greedy,always have been and always will be,This is just our nature.Pure Pitiful and I speak for myself.
Men must have the foresight to do what is needed to save a species without having to be threatned or mandated to do it by law.
Thats another thing that will never occur because of Greed.Everybody wants the very last one.Nuff said

Not what I'm hearing from recs. All they want is it to be fair for once. If recs are to take a 50% - 87% cut, the same percentage should come from the comms too. Never happens in NC and the gill nets continue to take 50% of the flounder. Don't forget from the DMF released the southern flounder assessment.

77.8% of all southern flounder who die in NC, whether legal size or not, die from the action of SCFL holders and mostly therein by nets.



   
ReplyQuote
Mark Gorges
(@captaingorges)
Noble Member
Joined: 20 years ago
Posts: 1581
 

ncfishforme - "Curious captaingorges -- your list implies that you no longer have a commercial fishing license, which you had when you were appointed as a recreational representative. Is that true?" -- Correct, I no longer hold a SCFL. When appointed, I was in the process of winding down my charter fishing business and after being appointed I let my USCG license expire and transferred my SCFL (I technically retired and think that prevents me from holding a SCFL again?) -- I was not required to do either of those things but did it to make sure everything was fully transparent regarding my position on the MFC. Beyond that, I believe I sold less than $1,000 of fish in the 10 yrs I held my license -- excess king mackerels in college to offset gas costs when you could sell a rec limit without a Fed. permit. Bait/gear for charter fishing plus the ability to sell a tuna if I caught one was why I held a SCFL to begin with, I assure you I wasn't pulling nets or setting crab pots from my center console.

As a rec, I also don't keep limits of mahi, kill and release sharks bottom fishing (popular option on some boats/piers -- don't fish with those folks again) or keep more than a couple meals worth of any species.

Back to some of more meat and taters parts of this conversation, and maybe a new thread needs to be started, many of these issues go beyond the surface -- for example the MFC passed a rule regarding river herring (Stock Status - Depleted) to further protect that species but a handful of folks managed to put that rule on hold for at least 2-3 more years. Imagine our surprise when we all got this email:

"Dear Commissioners:

I just want to make you aware the Office of Administrative Hearings has received 10 or more letters of objection for Rule 15A NCAC 03M .0513, River Herring, which was part of the rules package you approved at our February meeting. I have attached those letters for your convenience. This means the rule will have a delayed effective date pending legislative review in the 2016 session.

Division staff will be discussing the implications of the delayed effective date on implementation of Amendment 2 to the N.C. River Herring Fishery Management Plan that you also adopted in February. This discussion will include potential implications for the Wildlife Resources Commission, since this is a joint fishery management plan.

This is the first time we have encountered the 10 letters of objection resulting in legislative review. We will keep you posted on the status of the situation."

I think the total number of opposed letters was 14. 14 form letters stopped the Rule from taking effect. Several people didn't even bother typing their name in and just wrote it next to the [First Name] and [Address] sections. I think the vote passed something like 7-2-1 but 14 people who didn't agree with us got it stopped. Won't be the last time that happens either, you can bet on it unfortunately.

By design, the MFC, NCDMF nor Dr. Daniel can just go in and make seemingly drastic changes, for better or worse depending on which side of the argument you are on. Most all of these things have a 2-3+yr implementation time frame. Plus, throw in the potential for a monkey wrench like that to be tossed in at anytime. I think we started working on passing Amendment 2 in August of 2013 and its now probably pushed to at least 2017 by NC law.

Big issues coming up with Southern Flounder this week in New Bern, the shrimp trawl study this summer and generally everything else. Call or email any of us anytime, I promise we will all chat with you when possible. If you call me at 230 and want to talk for 2 hours, sorry, I can't do that (and most others can't either - we all have jobs too) but everybody is typically happy to talk with people about issues, regardless of opinion.



   
ReplyQuote
Page 2 / 2
Share: