SWC Forums
Pull up a chair...let's talk fishing.
We are currently in the middle of having out boat worked on to repair a problem we had earlier this summer and the process seems to be dragging on way too long and with much less communication than I would think should be expected. Please let me know what your thoughts would be and how you would proceed at this point.
We have a 1999 25 Carolina Classic with a Volvo Penta 7.4L. The week before 4th of July our cooling system had a problem and we had what seemed to be a pretty severe overheat So we get towed back in and the next morning I call the marina we bought the boat from and have used for service before, they indicated they wouldn't be able to get to it that week but could get it in "after the 4th", which I assumed meant just sometime that week, not necessarily the 5th specifically, which is understandable for a pretty big name marina for the area in the middle of the summer. They didn't give a specific timeframe for completion, but indicated that they've found those big blocks to be pretty tough and able to handle some overheating without internal problems so they thought it would be relatively simple fixes to the cooling system itself most likely and would be a couple/few weeks. I had looked over the engine briefly and knew the exhaust collector pipe was cracked, and that there was a coolant line blown, I hadn't dug into it any further frankly because I was on vacation and didn't want to mess with it. Well we dropped the boat off July 1, exactly 6 weeks ago today, with the expectation it would be checked out sometime the next week and they would let us know what they found. I also asked them to check into why we had been experiencing some poor performance in general (again, I knew I could have checked various things and sensors myself and troubleshoot using the VP service manual but really haven't had time and thought since it was going to be worked on anyway then might as well have them do it). The following week I remembered a mechanical breakdown coverage part of our insurance and checked into that to see what would be needed to see if it was something that would be covered and emailed that info to the marina so they could do the investigation into the problem and get an estimate for the repair together for me in case we decided it was going to be enough $$$ to justify trying to go that route. At the end of that week I hadn't heard anything so I called to check and they hadn't had a chance to get into it and was told it would be the next week. The following Tuesday, July 12, I get an email that they started checking it out and they found the heat exchanger cracked, which turned out to be an obsolete part and was going to require some looking to find, I called to go over that info in more detail than the email and didn't get a call back so that Thursday I emailed back asking for a call to go over the current status and the findings so far in general. I did get a call then and they said they thought they had found an exchanger somewhere and that it needed to be shipped to them and pressure tested to make sure it was good, they thought it would be shipped first of the following week at latest, also asked about the cracked collector pipe and was told they thought they could glass it back up rather than have to replace but they would need it out to fully inspect but were leaving in place until they got the exchanger back on so they could run it in the shop to see if there were any further problems before getting it torn apart. I then asked if they had seen the info I emailed about the possible insurance claim since for that we would need them to get the fullest extent of the damage figured out before getting into doing the fixes in order to have an accurate estimate and for an adjuster to review before it was put back together and asked what kind of ballpark numbers we were looking at to see if it was going to be enough beyond our deductible to make it worth messing with, they indicated they hadn't and from their description of costs it was sounding like it probably wouldn't be enough to mess based on a good condition used exchanger being used at half of new cost and otherwise mainly labor time for disassembly, compression testing/general inspection of engine, expected glassing of the collector and reassembly. I checked back later in the day the next day to see if the exchanger they had found had been tested and shipped yet and it had not, so I cancel the trip I had planned for the following weekend and previously had asked if the boat would be ready for, I was disappointed but understood that obsolete parts take time to find. Throughout the following week and a half I tried calling a several times for an update and again no response. Finally middle of the 2nd week (4th week total of the process) I got an answer that they had the exchanger but hadn't had a chance to test it and install it to check out the rest of the system, I again asked if they had been able check out the collector pipe since I knew it wasn't a common part that everyone keeps on their shelf either and if they had been able to do anything diagnostic wise for the poor performance I had described to them, and was told again that they hadn't taken it further apart so that they could check it out with the other exchanger. I checked back the end of that week with no call back and then beginning of the next week as well. I finally got an email last week on Aug 3, that the exchanger tested fine and they put it on and still had some elevated temps that they traced to a split hose and some blockage that they cleaned out and ordered a new hose for, still hadn't removed or further inspected the collector. I tried to call to talk about it and didn't get a return call after an hour or so, so I replied to the email and asked if they noticed any further problems with it running in the shop on a hose and if it would be ready for this weekend, I got a reply back of "Yes so far we're good." I replied to clarify that once the hose came in they just needed to glass up the crack in the collector, install the hose and take a test run to evaluate the general performance questions but didn't get a response. I then called back end of the week to check on it and was again told I'd get a call back but didn't. I then called a few times earlier this week and was told they thought they were working on it but were sure exactly what they were doing and that I'd get a call back but didn't each time, I also explained when I called that we had plans to come down there this weekend and needed to know if the boat would be ready or not. Finally yesterday morning I was told (by a different person than who I had been calling for, but they had some information at least) that the collector needed to be replaced and that it would be 3 weeks to get one, after which I politely (seriously, I was polite) expressed my frustration with being told it would be 3 more weeks to get in a part that I had told them from the beginning was cracked and had been told every time I asked about it that they thought it would be a simple fix rather than just going ahead and checking it out to be sure and get it ordered if needed long ago. I was again told that the individual I needed to talk to would call me and after a couple hours of no contact I emailed "3 more weeks for a part that's been known to be broken from the beginning (6 weeks ago)? Really?" To which I got a response 16 minutes later explaining that on initial inspection it appeared they could fix it but after getting it out they found too much damage for that to be a proper long term repair and that it could be glassed over for temporary use but recommended replacement as soon as the new one arrived. He also said it could be glassed late yesterday, installed today and then a test run taken. I replied that I fully agreed replacement was best in that case but that I was extremely frustrated that with it being known to be damaged from the beginning and there having been plenty of time for a 3 week lead time part to have arrived already had it been inspected further earlier on, it took until now for it be to be discovered as needing replacement. I also told them that I was extremely frustrated with the lack of feedback on the work and contact throughout. Additionally, I asked if the temporary fix could have the boat ready for us to use some this weekend. I got no further response. I called this morning and was told they were finishing up another boat and then working on ours and when I asked about it being ready for tomorrow and needing to know so I could figure out if we needed to just cancel our weekend at the beach, was told that they would get the main contact to call me (as I have been told numerous other times) and that they were leaving at noon so it would be before that. At 12:30 I still hadn't been called and I called back and he had left and the other person I had talked to some for the other small bits of info was at lunch and they would give them a message to call me when they got back. At about 2:45 I still hadn't heard anything so I called again and was told the other boat was taking longer than they thought and hadn't gotten to ours yet and I again explained that I needed to know, that we weren't driving 4.5 hours for it to not be ready and was told they would let me know at the end of the day what they were able to do and if its ready or not.
So here we are 6 weeks and potentially 3 cancelled trips and numerous unreturned calls after dropping the boat off and I would guess there's been less than a days worth of actual time spent working on our boat. Yes, I know do it myself and I don't have anyone to blame but myself, and I probably will next time but this is this time. I understand its the summer and they were already busy but if your too busy and can't get to it let me know you either underestimated your backlog and need some more time to check it out or just plain don't have time in general for however long, no hard feelings but just be upfront about it. I also understand not doing extra work and taking stuff apart that will need to be put back together to test for other problems and that's fine with general, everyday parts that you can get from almost anywhere but when your already looking at one tough to locate part and you know there is another that is damaged at least go ahead and get that part fully inspected to know for sure that it is or isn't a simple fix so it can be on order at the same time instead of pushing it off further and further and then find out when it should be getting done that its going to be 3 more weeks just to get the part. I also understand the methodology of taking it a step at a time and getting one thing resolved before taking on the next but on the other hand I fully believe in doing what can be done during downtime while waiting on those longer lead time parts, not just shelving the whole project and going to a different one and getting back to this one sometime down the road when it works out. I don't understand almost never calling back or updating the customer on the progress, or lack there of, again just let me know one way or the other and I'll take it far better.
So let me know how yall would be taking this situation and if you think its the timeframe sounds way too drawn out or if I am just being unrealistic.
No real excuse for poor communication. Ever.
Kicker, so sorry for the long drawn out non repair.. I would say honestly that I would find another mechanic. Ask Turano, he just got jerked around on an Inboard Repair, had to fire the 1st guy and get another. I don't know if the second mechanic knows Volvo or just GM.
I'd get my boat and go elsewhere. And they would be in for a fight if they try and charge me storage fees.
Maybe call Carolina Classic on Monday see if they know a good one.
I have a dive buddy that owns a boat . I was on the boat when the transmission went out on his 32' Luhrs. He was located in Southport so he went with a local mechanic named Charlie. Charlie said he could rebuild but it would cost $6500. So it got rebuilt and failed. Charlie then told him he needed a new transmission. $13k later the new transmission was installed and failed. Another mechanic was sought out and found. New mechanic said the new transmission was installed improperly and it was going to cost money to rebuild again. One thing after another happened and the bills surged to $30k and the boat was still not fixed. It was discovered that the new mechanic had subbed out all the work to the original mechanic because he wasn't a transmission guy. WTF? ๐ก Several months had passed and dive charters were cancelled. A new mechanic was referred to up in Wilmington. They provided a detailed estimate of $12k and it sounded like a great overhaul. Week after week we heard the same thing. It will be ready next week. Finally, the boat was ready. We need a bill for the work and it was now $20k. In my business, we call a customer before we do extra work but I guess if your a mechanic it is understood. Anyways, after months of hell the SPEAR is running like a champ. $50,000 to get this beast back in order. Just when you think you have real problems............ It can be worse. Trust me! :eew: :wtg: :help:
Sounds like your guy needs to learn to "under promise, over deliver". But I feel for you, I'd rather shoot my big toes off than turn my boat or my vehicles over to a mechanic. I'm sure there are good ones, but there are a whole lot more bad ones.
Pm sent
You need to keep a journal, and document every phone call, letter, text and voicemail. Who you speak to, dates, details, and promises. Even record the calls.
Contact me. I may be able to help 0r at least tell you where not to go.