SWC Forums
Pull up a chair...let's talk fishing.
Last week's South Atlantic Fishery Management Council meeting showed the council is listening to our comments as well as the comments of those who want to advance other agendas. Catch shares were mentioned a couple of times during the Visioning Project workshop. It is extremely important for us to offer alternative solutions to solve the regulatory discard problem that is wasting over a million pounds of our quotas every year. VMS was brought up again during the workshop. This time the for-hire fleet seemed to be their target. The council also decided to put off the MPA scoping meetings until August due in large part to high levels of anticipated opposition based on the comments they have already received. NOAA is accepting comments on a Draft Environmental Impact Study for RA17. You can learn more and comment at this link.
https://www.federalregister.gov/articles/2013/12/04/2013-29024/fisheries-of-the-caribbean-gulf-of-mexico-and-south-atlantic-snapper-grouper-fishery-off-the-south?utm_campaign=subscription+mailing+list&utm_medium=email&utm_source=federalregister.gov
We need to point out that there is no proof existing MPAs have had any positive impact. The Scientific and Statistical Committee has said existing regulations have likely ended overfishing of Warsaw Grouper and Speckled Hind and there is no evidence new MPAs would help these stocks. I will post my comment on here as soon as I submit it.
Lunch with John Carmichael and Chairman Hartig resulted in some good and bad news. The good news is that we could see a reduction in the current 40% Gag Grouper discard mortality rate based on the circle hook mandate in the current stock assessment if enough fishermen ask the council to do this. John also said a further reduction could come from a requirement to use decent assist devices on gags suffering from barotrauma. The bad news is that video proof of fishermen using decent assist devices would not allow for a reduction in mortality rates without a requirement for fishermen to use them. My thought on this is that we should still submit the video proof along with public comments asking the council to require the use of decent assist devices when releasing fish suffering from barotrauma. Our comments should also ask the council to reduce the discard mortality rates for each species as new assessments are done based on the circle hook and decent assist device requirements.
Please share your thoughts and feel free to ask me any questions. We need to focus our efforts on a few key issues and coordinate our message so our comments have the most impact.
December 2013 SAFMC Meeting Public Comment
I am Chris McCaffity, a commercial fisherman and advocate for the responsible harvest of healthy fisheries. These are my public comments regarding the Visioning Project, Regulatory Amendment 17, and Amendments 22, 29, and 31. I would like to start with a Japanese proverb. “Vision without action is a dream and action without vision is a nightmare.” The laws that were rushed to meet Congressional hard deadlines without a clear vision using “fatally flawed data” have resulted in a nightmare of wasted seafood, financial devastation, and even death. The Visioning Project provides a wonderful opportunity to rebuild confidence in the council process.
Managing a multi-species fisheries boils down to figuring out how much of each species can be harvested without overfishing, splitting each fish’s Acceptable Biological Catch between sectors, and then managing individual quotas with appropriate possession limits so they are filled but not exceeded while avoiding total closures. Some seafood should have higher possession limits than others based on the amount of quota available. Fishermen could target fish with higher limits while still keeping most of what we catch with lower limits. Quotas should be managed to make discards rare while encouraging fishermen to release illegal seafood so it has the best chance of survival. We should also try to use every part of every kind of seafood we harvest and create markets for underutilized species. Once quotas are established and properly managed, we should look at ways to enhance habitat so it produces more seafood and recreational opportunities while protecting our renewable resources for future generations.
It is extremely sad how bad our commercial quotas are being mismanaged. Why is the council planning ahead to waste hundreds of tons of seafood every year rather than managing quotas with appropriate possession limits to avoid multiple extended closures and excessive discards? Stakeholders should be able to decide how we want our share of each species’ quota to be managed with a 2/3 majority vote of participating permit holders. We did an exercise in the Marine Resource Education Program using Robert’s Rules in a mock council vote. That vote was anything but thoughtful or deliberate. The most aggressive person dominated a rushed and chaotic process. We should think things through to find solutions that follow all MSA mandates including the ones to limit waste, make efficient use of our resources, and promote safety.
The Visioning Project should include ideas for working together on collecting better data to improve the confidence levels in new stock assessments. We should work on reducing the discard mortality rates used in stock assessments by promoting proper release techniques. We should be working together to enhance our fisheries by creating new artificial reef habitat in areas they will have the most benefit. We should work together toward what should be everyone’s common goal of sustainable fisheries that are responsibly harvested with very little waste. We should learn from past mistakes while forming a positive vision for the future.
My comment on RA17 is that we should enhance existing Marine Protected Areas with appropriate artificial reef habitat rather than rushing to close more traditional fishing grounds based on “fatally flawed data”. We should be releasing Warsaw Grouper and Speckled Hind suffering from barotrauma with decent assist devices to greatly improve survival rates. We should start a tagging program to collect much-needed data for credible stock assessments. Please listen to the elected officials and American citizens speaking out against RA17’s MPAs.
My comment for Amendment 22 is that we should focus on drastically reducing the amount of our quotas that are allocated to dead discards every year by reducing regulatory discards and improving survival rates for what must be discarded. The council should also consider a tagging program for released fish to collect better data about abundance, distribution, and mortality.
My comment for Amendment 29 is that Gray Triggerfish should not have a size limit and the quota should be managed with split seasons that open with Vermilion Snapper. Appropriate possession limits should be used to avoid extended closures and excessive regulatory discards. Quotas for data poor stocks should be set at an average of the last ten years landings.
Here is an example of how the existing commercial Gray Triggerfish quota could be managed so it is filled without long closures.
Split the annual Gray Triggerfish quota into two seasonal quotas that align with Vermilion Snapper. Each season should start with a 500 pound possession limit until 75% of the quota has been landed. The final 25% of each seasonal quota should be used for a 100 pound by-catch allowance to avoid total closures and unnecessary discards. Any overages should be deducted from the next season and any leftover quota should carry over. This management plan should be applied to almost every quota in a multi-species fishery. The lower by-catch allowances will make it much easier to avoid overages while providing consumers with a dependable supply of fresh local seafood. The primary possession limit should increase as this stock quickly rebuilds. I want to stress that reduced possession limits for the final 25% of a quota should be considered as by-catch allowances that are intended to avoid total closures and regulatory discards. The reductions are not intended to continue a targeted fishery. By-catch allowances could also be used during spawning seasons to limit waste while protecting spawning aggregations. This solution would also limit gaps and uncertainty in stock assessment data.
My comment for Amendment 31 is that Blueline Tilefish should have a quota separate from the deepwater complex and be managed with appropriate possession limits to avoid total closures.
I would like to close by asking the council to make reducing regulatory discards and discard mortality rates as well as collecting better data top priorities for the Visioning Project.
Thank you for considering my comments. Anyone have any questions? freefish7@hotmail.com
RA17 Public Comment to NOAA
I am Chris McCaffity, a commercial snapper/grouper fisherman from NC who has been offering positive solutions for our fishery since 2009. I understand how Marine Protected Areas COULD be a useful management tool IF done properly. They can also be used to arbitrarily close vast areas of very productive traditional fishing grounds. Regulatory Amendment 17 is a prime example of the aforementioned power grab. The entire premise of RA17's proposed MPAs is based on what former council Chairman, Duane Harris testified before Congress is "fatally flawed data".
I respectfully ask NOAA to request that the South Atlantic Fishery Management Council table RA17 and focus on properly managing our quotas with appropriate possession limits to avoid the multiple extended closures that are resulting in countless regulatory discards every year. The council's solution to these closures and discards has been to allocate tons of our quotas to Post Closure Discard Mortality. This tragic waste of our resources can be easily avoided by simply using split seasons, possession limits, and by-catch allowances.
Once the council has addressed the problems created in their rush to meet Congressional hard deadlines using "fatally flawed data", they could start another amendment to look at enhancing existing Marine Protected Areas with appropriate artificial reef habitat. The thousands of square miles of existing MPAs off our southeast coast should be marked and monitored with video camera equipped data buoys before any new MPAs are considered.
Here is an excerpt from my latest public comments to the SAFMC that shows how the current Gray Triggerfish quota could be managed to avoid another multi-month closure like we saw in 2013.
"Split the annual Gray Triggerfish quota into two seasonal quotas that align with Vermilion Snapper. Each season should start with a 500 pound possession limit until 75% of the quota has been landed. The final 25% of each seasonal quota should be used for a 100 pound by-catch allowance to avoid total closures and unnecessary discards. Any overages should be deducted from the next season and any leftover quota should carry over. This management plan should be applied to almost every quota in a multi-species fishery. The lower by-catch allowances will make it much easier to avoid overages while providing consumers with a dependable supply of fresh local seafood. The primary possession limit should increase as this stock quickly rebuilds. I want to stress that reduced possession limits for the final 25% of a quota should be considered as by-catch allowances that are intended to avoid total closures and regulatory discards. The reductions are not intended to continue a targeted fishery. By-catch allowances could also be used during spawning seasons to limit waste while protecting spawning aggregations. This solution would also limit gaps and uncertainty in stock assessment data."
Thank you for considering my comments. Please contact me if anyone reading this has any questions. freefish7@hotmail.com