SWC Forums
Pull up a chair...let's talk fishing.
"Mandatory VMS and video monitoring schemes should NEVER be considered again since they are a blatant violation of our Constitutional Rights and vehemently opposed by the vast majority of stakeholders. "
Certainly, the more hidden and not reported the better, right?
Are you saying I need a VMS on my Snapper/Grouper Boat?
If so, Why?
"Mandatory VMS and video monitoring schemes should NEVER be considered again since they are a blatant violation of our Constitutional Rights and vehemently opposed by the vast majority of stakeholders. "
Certainly, the more hidden and not reported the better, right?
coastal carolina - What are you try to say? Do you even know what mandatory VMS is? Do you have any clue as to the reporting requirements, both hard copy and electronically filed that it takes to commercially participate under SAFMC?
Why don't you share your knowledge/observations/thoughts regarding the reporting requirements for comms and why comms need to be under surveillance?
I for one am all ears!!! Come On Man!!
Squid Row, experiments with other baits in Lionfish traps did not work well in our area. Some researchers even tried using live bait with little success. I have caught a few on cut bait and some divers commercially target Lionfish. We need to coordinate efforts to collect the female parts from those hooked and speared Lionfish for trap bait. SeaGrant and several other organizations are interested in trying out this kind of bait in our area. SAFMC staff says there are no laws keeping us from targeting Lionfish with traps after the Right Whale trap closure ends May 1.
Wanchese SAFMC Visioning Project Port Meeting Summary
Pretty weather prevented most of the local fishermen from attending this meeting. A few fishermen and the wife of another talked about the need for a targeted Blueline Tilefish fishery north of Cape Hatters. They asked for a By-catch Allowance after most of the quota is landed to continue supplying local markets. This area is influenced by the Labrador Current and has a local tilefish population unlike anywhere else in the southeast. There aren’t many co-occurring species to make dead discards an issue.
It was mentioned how overlapping jurisdiction of the Mid-Atlantic and South Atlantic councils has hurt fishermen as they lost their ability to use some incidental take permits or target tilefish and bass on the same trip. This costs them money and creates regulatory discards.
The need for better recreational landings data was discussed.
A retired fisherman said it is the wrong approach to only target larger mostly female breeders and discard countless smaller fish regardless of mortality rates. He also talked about the need to enhance our fisheries through stocking programs and added that turtles could be raised to offset any fatal interactions.
My comment for this meeting was that NEPA (National Environmental Policy Act) allows affected stakeholders to offer alternatives that would mitigate negative impacts of proposed or existing regulations. The solution I suggested is for stakeholders to set up a secure website we can log into with our permit/license number and a password to discuss options and hold votes on alternatives options that use the same data as SAFMC staff and follows all MSA mandates. Alternative NEPA solutions would need to be approved with a 2/3 majority vote of participating permit/license holders. We would then need to get everyone we can to submit public comments supporting our solution.
Thanks for posting this series of meetings and keeping us informed.
Glad to do it bigfishhooker.
Is anyone interested in discussing how we can offer NEPA alternatives?
Here's a possible NEPA alternative to the proposed RA17 MPAs to give an example.
Require fishermen targeting snapper/grouper species beyond 20 fathoms to have a Descending Device onboard and use it to release any Speckled Hind or Warsaw Grouper with barotrauma. This is a simple and cost effective way to address the issue of discard mortality that's being used to advance the MPA agenda.
Glad to do it bigfishhooker.
Is anyone interested in discussing how we can offer NEPA alternatives?
Here's a possible NEPA alternative to the proposed RA17 MPAs to give an example.
Require fishermen targeting snapper/grouper species beyond 20 fathoms to have a Descending Device onboard and use it to release any Speckled Hind or Warsaw Grouper with barotrauma. This is a simple and cost effective way to address the issue of discard mortality that's being used to advance the MPA agenda.
I had no issue with the venting tools.....this too seems reasonable.
It is important that we offer our own solutions to solve problems like real or perceived dead regulatory discards. Descending Devices are scientifically proven to greatly increase survival rates of illegal fish with barotrauma. This solution could also result in getting back some of the 500,000+ pounds of Red Snapper being allocated to projected dead discards every year. http://www.pcouncil.org/wp-content/uploads/D5b_SUP_GMT_POWERPOINT_APR2013BB.pdf
aftergolf, what do you think about getting a group of recreational fishermen to ask DMF/MFC to include a way anglers can declare they intend to target snapper/grouper species on the Recreational Fishing License application? Florida is working on a plan like this and Louisiana is already doing it with great success.
I have no problem with rec's needing a snapper/grouper stamp like duck stamp if, and only if the data collection improves as a result. I do not like giving any of my $$ to the feds and only will do if we have accountable information.
I think an online survey may be a good idea, but again, fishermen must know the data will result in better catch rate, mortality, discards, etc.
Morehead City SAFMC Visioning Project Port Meeting Summary
A recreational fishing guide mentioned how his customers needed more access to snapper/grouper species that are showing up in numbers close to shore like he has never seen. When asked if he thought the bag limits should be raised for recreational quotas that are not being filled so his customers could keep more fish, he said no and that most of his customers didn’t care about keeping any fish. He said the leftover quota should be allocated to what council staff labeled as a conservation quota.
Chris - someone recently told me you mischaracterized my words here so I wanted to come and explain what you have improperly paraphrased.
Me, and one other, commented on this. In the last 4-5 years (you know - since you stopped fishing commercially) we have seen a tremendous upswing in grouper and seabass, spring-fall in particular, in shallower waters. When you spoke with me you automatically assumed that since I fish shallower waters I would be catching large numbers of undersized fish and few keepers - this simply is not the case. The quality of fish closer to shore is tremendously better up this way then 10-15years ago.
My comments were that we need to weigh the benefits of having greater abundances vs the value of maximum extraction (MSY) particularly if it leads to a much better quality of available fish in areas closer to shore. I also never said, in any such manner, that my clients dont want to keep fish - I stated that many recreational anglers really enjoy being able to go out and not have to travel that far to catch a nice quality gag grouper (and seabass of course). There is considerable value in having great access to good fish within 8-20 miles as there are more people who have the means to fish in such a range. Particularly if the majority of those trips will result in being able to land a couple of nice grouper. This is also an important thing to consider when state managed fisheries are facing decreased abundances in the long run as declining stocks are being managed for MSY vs MEY (and hence greater abundance).
You also speak constantly in wanting to avoid recreational discards - isnt having anglers fishing in shallower waters where baromtrama is much less severe a good thing?
Would 2 grouper be better? It's always nice to have larger limits - but is that worth the cost of having fewer fish in more accessible areas? That's the question I proposed.
More fish in the water = better quality fishing.
aftergolf, it seems like most people would rather just have a place on existing NC Recreational Fishing License applications to check if they plan to target snapper/grouper species. This should not cost anything extra while defining the universe of anglers and providing contact info.
Waterdog, I was simply reaching out in good faith to a recreational guide who said he wanted his customers to have greater access to the increasingly abundant snapper/grouper species being encountered close to shore. I continue to support the position of a CCA representative who at a recent SAFMC meeting asked for an increase in the Gag Grouper bag limit since only half the quota is being filled most years. Our quotas for both sectors should be managed so they are filled without long closures that create many of the REGULATORY Discards I speak of so often. The dangerous derby fisheries that cost a man his life after fishing within miles of us for three days pushed me to take some time to fight for a more responsible harvest of our seafood. Getting the SAFMC to follow the MSA mandates to limit waste, make efficient use of our resources, and promote the safety of fishermen at sea are a few of my primary objectives. I am also trying to get open-minded commercial and recreational fishermen to work together toward what should be everyone's common goal of healthy fisheries that are responsibly harvested with very little waste.
Here a place that sells a fish release device which seems to really work. I can't be the only guy here to find this but they have videos which show it in action. I've been using my own version for years but I never had a video. I tie a couple pound weight to the eye of a big hook , pinch down the barb, tie the main line to the bend of the hook. Then with your reel in free spool ,hook the fish and throw the weight over. Snappers seem to start kicking around 50' or so. Real simple with no extra holes.
http://royselectricreels.com/fish_saver_device.html#fishsavervidanchor
spearjim, thanks for the link. Your homemade version sounds cheap and effective. Please consider taking pictures of your crew using Descending Devices this summer and send them to the SAFMC along with a summary of what the pictures are showing. safmc@safmc.net
Please post any pictures on here to encourage other fishermen to use these cheap, easy, and effective Descending Devices.
