SWC Forums
Pull up a chair...let's talk fishing.
Does NC have a truth in seafood labeling law?
Squid Row, there is widespread support for stocking and ways to pay for it. Ask the average Joe if he would rather see his license fees used for hatcheries that would result in higher limits or more research that will most likely result in lower limits. Most Joes will pick stocking so they can catch and keep more fish.
We already have hatcheries that can produce an endless supply of "seed" to keep our fisheries producing at Optimum Yield even as we harvest more. Natural production of many inshore species has been negatively impacted by pollution and habitat degradation. We have to deal with the reality that we will not reverse this trend any time soon, but we can help our fisheries thrive at historically high levels.
Hatchery Supported Quotas for seafood consumers could be funded with a 1% restocking fee on seafood sales.
The Saltonstal-Kennedy and Johnson-Dingell tax are two more sources of potential funding for stocking.
Stocking seafood that is just beyond plankton stage would keep costs down while keeping stocks strong.
Chris if you add in a caveat on that stocking question about keeping or increasing commercial harvest, the numbers would go down quickly.
Alternatively, if you add in a caveat that any fish that is stocked would have game fish status, the numbers would be higher.
Note I am not advocating either position, just tossing it out there for conversation sake.
At least you are willing to have a conversation even if we don't agree on everything. "When everybody thinks alike, nobody thinks." Capt. Buzz
The devil's advocate point of view makes me think about things I might not otherwise.
Your point is why I advocate for giving each sector the option of funding their share of potential Hatchery Supported Quotas. There need to be guidelines for how much of each species can be stocked and how many stocked juveniles would translate into harvestable quota.
I started this thread to get others opinion on putting the spec limit back to 10 fish. Nothing to do with nets oR stocking. We stock stripers in the Cape Fear and can not even keep one! A waste of effort since they do not have a productive spawn. Spec trout population in NC is controlled by mother nature. Stock all you want and a harsh winter wipes out all your effort. best - glenn
I started this thread to get others opinion on putting the spec limit back to 10 fish. Nothing to do with nets oR stocking. We stock stripers in the Cape Fear and can not even keep one! A waste of effort since they do not have a productive spawn. Spec trout population in NC is controlled by mother nature. Stock all you want and a harsh winter wipes out all your effort. best - glenn
If stripers stocked in the Cape Fear are not reproducing, there should be no limit on how many can be harvested until the habitat is restored to a point they can. Stocking Speckled Trout could coincide with cold-stun events to give the depleted stock a boost.
"We already have hatcheries that can produce an endless supply of "seed" to keep our fisheries producing at Optimum Yield even as we harvest more."
Where are all those hatcheries that are going to stock saltwater fish?
NCWRC Hatcheries:
The N.C. Wildlife Resources Commission's Inland Fisheries Division operates six fish hatcheries that raise a variety of fish for stocking into North Carolina's public waters. These hatcheries are designated as "warmwater", "coolwater" or "coldwater" hatcheries. Because state-operated hatcheries stock only public waters, people seeking to stock private lakes and ponds must contact a commercial hatchery. To see more information on these hatcheries, click on the desired type of hatchery. For stocking information, view NCWRC Stocking and Stocking Your Lake or Pond.
Warmwater hatcheries
The McKinney Lake Hatchery in Richmond County raises channel catfish exclusively for the state's public waters. The Watha Hatchery in Pender County raises striped bass, striped bass hybrids, channel catfish and largemouth bass for the state's public waters.
Coolwater hatcheries
The Table Rock Hatchery in Burke County is the Division's sole coolwater hatchery. It raises muskellunge, walleye and smallmouth bass.
Coldwater hatcheries
The Armstrong Hatchery and Marion Hatchery in McDowell County and Bobby N. Setzer Hatchery in Transylvania County raise more than a half million brook, brown and rainbow trout annually.
Commercial hatcheries
Because state-operated hatcheries stock only public waters, people seeking to stock private lakes and ponds must contact a commercial hatchery. A list of hatcheries licensed to sell fish in North Carolina is available from your local North Carolina Cooperative Extension Service. For more information on commercial hatcheries, click on the "Commercial hatcheries" link above.
glacierbaze, UNC Wilmington and NC State University have hatcheries. South Brunswick High School even has a hatchery program that has stocked Southern Flounder. The Edenton National Fish Hatchery currently stocks stripers and herring. There is another facility in Brunswick County and Sturgeon City in Jacksonville. Hatcheries could easily be incorporated into the NC Aquariums. Carteret Community College has the facilities to start stocking.
The key is to spread out stocking efforts across the state and rotate what is released based on need and season.
A shift in focus away from abolishing most commercial fishing and developing industrial fish farms toward enhancing our fisheries and food supply with hatcheries and habitat enhancement would benefit everyone. We should include landlocked aquaculture in our food production system, but wild-caught should be a primary part of the equation. Wild-caught seafood could benefit domestic aquaculture if we processed scraps of cleaned seafood into fish feed. This would help negate the negative impacts of using 3-5 pounds of wild-caught seafood to produce 1 pound of farm-raised.
I started this thread to get others opinion on putting the spec limit back to 10 fish. Nothing to do with nets oR stocking. We stock stripers in the Cape Fear and can not even keep one! A waste of effort since they do not have a productive spawn. Spec trout population in NC is controlled by mother nature. Stock all you want and a harsh winter wipes out all your effort. best - glenn
I am not so sure about that.. I believe the CFR stripers are being stocked in small numbers and they are naturally reproducing. It just is taking a long time to fully recover since they were essentially wiped out. I suppose they could increase the stocking rate but it seems that more and more are being caught each year in C&R fisheries that have very small participation rates.
Stripers that are stocked do spawn if the conditions are correct. They need miles of flowing water for their spawn to be successful which is why stocked fish in lakes are mostly unable to reproduce and the lakes are a put and take fishery
Concerning spawning stripers. Cape Fear stripers "go through the motions" of spawning way up several creeks; Town. Long, Indian, and Rockfish creek and I am sure others. A few years back I was informed that turbulent water is needed to keep the eggs off the bottom for about a day, otherwise they die. IF this is true spawning has not taken place since around 1915 then the lock and dams were built, preventing rock from getting to just below Jordan Lake. I do not know when the state started stocking rock in the cape fear, but I do know since at least early 1970's. And probably much earlier. The recent closure was implemented about the time the fish latter was in place at lock and dam #1. Prior to this closure we could keep a limit. (2 @ 18" ??). These are stocked fish. Several lakes in NC are stocked and anglers can harvest fish. "put and take". I would like to see that management return to the cape fear. best - glenn
When I served on the SE Advisory Committee we were told by the biologists that there was no evidence of stocked CFR striper successfully spawning. Tagging surveys and DNA analysis revealed that the vast majority of landed striper were stocked fish. Wish it was a different story, but that's what were told at the time.
BW
When I served on the SE Advisory Committee we were told by the biologists that there was no evidence of stocked CFR striper successfully spawning. Tagging surveys and DNA analysis revealed that the vast majority of landed striper were stocked fish. Wish it was a different story, but that's what were told at the time.
BW
Thanks BW
If that is the case and they do not spawn, why not manage them like they do the lakes?
I was fishing on a lake this past weekend and the limit is 10 per person and easily limited out.
Sorry for hijacking this thread..
Agreed, it is a put and take fishery at best.
No way to allow a commercial fishery, but a small creel should be feasible.
I do catch a few while speck and drum fishing up the river.
BW