SWC Forums
Pull up a chair...let's talk fishing.
Stop and Review should have been the first phase of the council’s Visioning Project. There are hundreds of laws on the books sufficient to meet all Congressional deadlines. We should review the decade’s worth of existing fishery laws to see what is working well and what isn’t before rushing to write more. Since this council is not bound by the actions of any previous council, it should be easy to remove regulations that do more harm than good. Quotas made many of the older management measures obsolete. Now those outdated laws do little more than create waste and gaps in data.
An official website should be set up where stakeholders can participate in the review process and have final approval of any changes and future regulations with a 2/3 majority vote from participating permit/license holders. Stakeholders should also be allowed to decide how our TACs will be managed and who represents us on the council. An online forum would negate the need for an endless stream of expensive public meetings that are inconvenient and viewed by many as a waste of time. Most fishermen cannot afford missing work to attend meetings when the weather is good and some fish are legal to harvest.
There are some good ideas in the Visioning Project along with some old reworded bad ideas that have been repeatedly stopped by overwhelming opposition from stakeholders and concerned citizens. These renewed attempts to privatize our public resources and force American citizens to install unconstitutional spy devices on our private property threaten to undermine any confidence that this truly is a stakeholder driven project. Rather than pushing polarizing agendas, maybe there should be more focus on solutions that benefit everyone like trapping male lionfish using female lionfish pheromones for bait as Caribbean fishermen have done successfully. The council could abolish the bass pot endorsement scheme that was rushed through right before a stock assessment was anticipated to and did show bass stocks are healthy. This would allow permit holders who arbitrarily had our trap tags taken away to experiment with trapping invasive lionfish. Going to a hook and line only fishery with reduced trip limits for the final 25% of bass quotas would achieve the same goals as endorsements. This simple solution also negates the need for Golden Tilefish longline endorsements.
The Visioning Project should focus more on enhancing our fisheries and food supply than restricting the public’s freedom to access them. Artificial reefs and stocking programs would be the perfect union of mariculture and wild-caught seafood that lives free and self-sufficient until harvested. These proven solutions would allow important seafood stocks to thrive at historically high levels even as we harvest more without overfishing. The goal of this project should be to form a positive vision for the responsible harvest of sustainable fisheries with minimal waste that other marine resource managers across the globe will want to follow.
I respectfully ask the South Atlantic Fishery Management Council and Congress to adopt a Stop and Review policy for our federal fisheries and embrace advances in technology that can give stakeholders more responsibility for managing our fisheries within Magnuson-Stevens Act guidelines.
I am always happy to answer any questions. freefish7@hotmail.com
Sincerely,
Chris McCaffity