SWC Forums

Pull up a chair...let's talk fishing.

What would you do?
 
Notifications
Clear all

What would you do?

14 Posts
12 Users
0 Reactions
24.4 K Views
Matthew Hyman
(@mbhyman)
Reputable Member
Joined: 16 years ago
Posts: 340
Topic starter   [#27630]

This is a rant about some problems that I am having with my boat and a shop that I chose to use because I have heard nothing but good things about them. I'm purposefully not using any names in this because I'm just not that kind of person but I may in the future.

Part 1. It all started back in mid February when I went to get my boat ready for this fishing season. I noticed that my motors were idling higher than they should. No big problem pulled the boat to the shop from my house which is an 1 1/2 hours away, told them to tune up the motors and make sure everything was running right. They called and said they had it ready in less than a week. I thought great what fast service, bill was only $350. Picked up the boat and pulled it 1 hour up the road to the beach where we keep it during fishing season. First thing I do is pull up to the ramp and drop it in the water as we were planning on using it that weekend just to cruise. Notice the Left motor does not want to stay cranked when cold, had to rev it up for 5min to get it warm then would idle like a champ, did this all weekend. Called boat shop and told them said problem. They said bring it back and they would get it right.

Part 2. Make special trip to beach during the week to get the boat and take it back to the same marina, 2 hrs to beach, 1 hr to shop, 1 1/2 hrs home. This time guys at the shop say I have some scaring in one of the cylinders causing a loss in compression (-20 psi). They honed the cylinder and replaced the piston. Got everything put back and said they took the boat to the river and it was running great. This process took over 3 weeks and cost $2,500. I'm thinking well at least it is finally fixed. I drive to pick up the boat and then take it back up to the beach with plans to fish that weekend, another 3 1/2 hour trip total. Put boat in at the beach and before I can get her from the ramp to the house, which is maybe 2 miles at the most, I notice the motor they just worked on and said was running great would drop rpm's when you tried to give it gas after it was already on plane. Needless to say the boat is not fixed and I'm really starting to get pissed off.

Part 3. I will be making the trip back to the beach to get the boat and pull it back to the same shop this friday, I just hope they can get it right this time. The only reason I am even taking it back is because after spending $2,850 for their services, god knows how much in diesel burning up and down the highway for 14+ hours, and them telling me twice they had it right I think they owe it to me to get it running properly. However if they fail me again and tell me they've got it figured out and running right and I go get it only to find something is still wrong I don't know what i'm going to do. Fool me once shame on you, fool me twice shame on me, fool me Three Mother F*&%ing times and I don't care how nice you are or how good everyone else says your service is, I'm never doing business with you again.

If I'm being unreasonable someone please tell me because this is really starting to piss me off. I mean really what would you say to the service manager, the person you've been communicating with the whole time, in a situation like this?



   
Quote
Stephen Chambers
(@)
Honorable Member
Joined: 16 years ago
Posts: 392
 

Wow I would be just as frustrated. I once took my boat in for a beggining of the year tune up, I had just bought the boat and the carbs were gummed up. The place I took it to is very reputable in my area. They cleaned my carbs replaced my spark plugs and did whatever else they do on a tune up for a 2 stroke. $300 ish later it was good to go. I take it out and run the boat and rpms keep jumping around, then the boat starts stalling out. They never changed my fuel filter out and it had water in it. which filled the bowls in my carbs with water and the rest is history. Then they wanted to charge me another 100+ dollars to clean the bowls in my carbs and test my tank for water. It was very frustrating. Sometimes things get over looked. Good luck with your issue and I hope it gets fixed this time.



   
ReplyQuote
Barry Bierstedt
(@)
Prominent Member
Joined: 18 years ago
Posts: 677
 

I know from experience a lot of times it is hard for a mechanic to diagnose the problem just from what you tell them. There are so many factors in an engine that could be going wrong they can't, and don't want to explore all options immediately just in case it is a small simple problem. Things do get over looked and I'm sure they want your motor running right just as bad as you do.



   
ReplyQuote
Randy Harris
(@)
Reputable Member
Joined: 16 years ago
Posts: 344
 

Some places try to rush a job to get to the next one,more boats worked on more money,I had my boat serviced while I was overseas in Iraq so when I came home I could use my time home to go fishing,wife pulled it to shop they supposedly serviced everything,I pull it to coast 300 plus miles away put trailer in water boat will not start batteries dead,fuel smell,pull it out have guys at Crowes Nest come check it all batteries bad and diaphram in carb has hole in it $600 plus dollars for nothing,I spend another $550.00 at Crowes Nest and it ran great,appears they never touched the boat at all at first shop,take it to them no relief at all.



   
ReplyQuote
Matthew Hyman
(@mbhyman)
Reputable Member
Joined: 16 years ago
Posts: 340
Topic starter  

I know from experience a lot of times it is hard for a mechanic to diagnose the problem just from what you tell them. There are so many factors in an engine that could be going wrong they can't, and don't want to explore all options immediately just in case it is a small simple problem. Things do get over looked and I'm sure they want your motor running right just as bad as you do.

Yea your right, I don't think they are trying on purpose to screw me over. I even offered to put the boat in the water right near there shop and take them on it so I could show them the problem. That way I knew that they knew exactly what I was talking about, they declined my offer. Oh well I'm just trying to get through this year. Next year, God willing, I'll have a brand new pair of Yamaha F250's on the back.



   
ReplyQuote
Tony
 Tony
(@)
Reputable Member
Joined: 19 years ago
Posts: 224
 

If it is a newer engine you thank the machine they hook it up to would tell what the problem is.I always haul mine back to Fayetteville to get it worked on.I am sure there are good mechanics at the beach but the two I went to wanted to do nothing but warranty work on the engines and overcharge me for what I ask them to do.Maybe This is to much I thought so,change oil, change rubber water pumps got bill for $1275.00. plus got some warranty work out of it. 2 yams 250s.If he would have treated me fair he would have a customer for a long time.Hope I have not offended anyone but thats the way it is.Sometimes it is better to bite the bullet to keep a customer.Man I feel for you,been there and done that.



   
ReplyQuote
William McCann
(@werewolf0711)
Famed Member
Joined: 15 years ago
Posts: 3133
 

I would say your on the right track. You have every right to be upset even though they most likely aren' purposely trying to screw you over especially if they continue to charge you. But sadly they do not care how far you have to drive and what you go through to get the boat there becauase it was your choice to take it there. Have the same issue with ours opting to take it where we do when things go wrong and my wife complains about how far we have to take it. But I sure hope they get it straightened out for you and do the right thing



   
ReplyQuote
Chris
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 19 years ago
Posts: 1657
 

Ever thought about doing the small stuff yourself??? One of those seloc engine manuals along with FPT and google can get you Tons of help.



   
ReplyQuote
lyle worthington
(@)
Estimable Member
Joined: 18 years ago
Posts: 174
 

I would take it to another shop. If they declined a ride to see the problem that is a problem. Talk to the mechanic that actually worked on the job. Sometimes there is a disconnect between the customer, MANAGER, and mechanic.



   
ReplyQuote
Matt
 Matt
(@)
Famed Member
Joined: 16 years ago
Posts: 2497
 

I have gotten to the point in my life after wading through a tangled web of plain lies, excuses and lack of care for a fellow man that I really don't have high expectations of people in general any more. As far as the service industry goes there is more put into corporatization and turning volume than actual customer service and focus on an individual. I don't mean to say that there are not people and companies that care and do a good job, but with the influx of higher technology and the need for technicians with education, overhead cost goes up thus increasing the need to turn volume. I have been disgusted most times I have gone to a boat dealership for service.
Last Thursday I pulled my new motor out of my boat b/c it spun a bearing with 65hrs on it. The builder was supposed to get it Monday but it is Thursday and he still hasn't made it by yet. Your situation sounds pretty bad, and it doesn't help to be having problems while reading all the reports over the past week. After you get this resolved, you should be lookin for another shop, closer to your boat.
I don't intend to throw a blanket over everyone in the marine service industry but this has been my experience and since the motor I bought last year is sitting in my garage stripped to the long block waiting to get a crank kit put in it during the height of spring fishing season I am feeling a little disgusted. I know there are some great shops out there that care but they are tough to find.
Sorry to hear about your troubles, it sounds extremely frustrating and I hope you can get it resolved without too much more expense. Maybe this will be your last trip to the shop this year.



   
ReplyQuote
Mark Vann
(@reel_trouble)
Estimable Member
Joined: 19 years ago
Posts: 197
 

TommieGirl.....
Who does your work in Fayetteville?



   
ReplyQuote
alan moss
(@)
Trusted Member
Joined: 18 years ago
Posts: 55
 

Tommie girl thanks for the help relaying the radio and offering assistance on Saturday. I was running my buddy's boat Mad kat that lost the motor at the Black Jack. Mad for a long day got the boat on the trailer at 10 pm.

Thanks again for the help



   
ReplyQuote
Jamie Blue
(@)
Famed Member
Joined: 20 years ago
Posts: 3660
 

I know from experience a lot of times it is hard for a mechanic to diagnose the problem just from what you tell them. There are so many factors in an engine that could be going wrong they can't, and don't want to explore all options immediately just in case it is a small simple problem. Things do get over looked and I'm sure they want your motor running right just as bad as you do.

the problem with this is they tell him its running fine when its not. they obviously never ran it. i would take it somewhere else.



   
ReplyQuote
Tony
 Tony
(@)
Reputable Member
Joined: 19 years ago
Posts: 224
 

Alan, Glad we could help ya. Tommie Girl



   
ReplyQuote
Share: