SWC Forums

Pull up a chair...let's talk fishing.

Why do charter capt...
 
Notifications
Clear all

Why do charter captains hate customer equipment?

15 Posts
11 Users
0 Reactions
37.5 K Views
Sam Pistachio
(@)
Eminent Member
Joined: 14 years ago
Posts: 29
Topic starter   [#34734]

The last charter I was on (2011 out of Hatteras) was the first charter where the captain was at all cooperative about us using our own tackle. The vast majority of charters I've been on have either been indifferent or downright hostile about us bringing our gear. And I'm not just showing up with a bunch of the wrong gear unexpected; each time I've asked the captain ahead of time if there was something we could do to match our tackle to the fishing.

I can understand if we were tuna fishing or trolling for sailfish or something where the gear takes some knowhow from the crew to work right. But that's not what we do... we take charters to bottom fish (not deep drop) or bail dolphin on medium-ish spinning equipment.

Here are experiences from our last two charters. Both NC OBX, one in 2011 and one in 2009. The trip in 2009 we arranged a six pack to nearshore fish for amberjack and we also wanted to bottom fish. The captain said not to bring any rods and reels because they had everything we needed. I told him we liked to bring our own gear and that we'd prepare them however he wanted (braid or mono, etc). Then he said bring whatever you want to use. The day of the charter we were handing rods to the mate and the captain said "you don't need any of that it will just be in the way." And it was, because they refused to let us use any of it. When we bottom fished he said that we could only use braid, which we didn't have rigged, and gave us the shittiest old penn reels I've ever seen. The handles wouldn't reverse (half of my crowd don't reel left handed) and we generally had a terrible time, with new/working/appropriate equipment sitting in the bottom of the boat. I wish I could remember the name of the boat and captain if only to make sure I never book with him again.

In 2011 we went with a well known captain who has an internet presence. I was able to exchange several emails with him well in advance of the trip, and he let me know the kind of gear he'd have for the fishing we wanted to do. This allowed me to prepare several rigs with braid before the trip. When we showed up in the morning he looked at the rods and reels we brought on board, handed them to the mate and told him they'd be perfect and to rig them up. When they changed gear from bottom rigs to dolphin rigs the mate changed our rods at the same time. Now to be fair, the fishing we did was much more fun than the last trip. We ended up boating a full quota of dolphin, some triggers and even managed a wahoo. But the fact that we used our own rigs made it that much better. It wasn't as if us doing so was a burden on the captain or mate. He told us "we use 20lb braid and fish 50-150 feet of water" and he tied on a few snap swivels (which I had in my bag).

So what makes customer gear such a heartache? Are people showing up with zebco 202s expecting to deep drop? Do you have their gear break/fail/explode and lose fish? Does it somehow interfere with your ability to put us on fish if I use my own rod and reel?

And on a similar note, I've had the same kind of issues with bringing bait. EVERY captain I've ever chartered with assured me that he had "every bait you could ever need" and in nearly every case that wasn't true. They certainly had every bait they were used to using and that they knew worked, but I'm convinced that there is always bait that you guys don't use simply because of the cost or effort to obtain it. For example, live eels or live mullet or blood worms. I've fished with captains that swore by fake bloodworms which no doubt catch fish just fine and last much longer. But the real thing is better, and I'm willing to buy them and bring them. I've heard people say that cigar minnows are grouper candy but I've never been on a charter that had them. If the captain had said "if you want to pick up a box of <bait> it might improve your chances of catching <fish>, but they are kindof expensive and you don't NEED them" I'd have certainly scooped some up. I take a $1000+ charter once every couple of years... $10 or $20 for some premium bait is not a hard choice.

Curious how other guys have dealt with these issues.



   
Quote
Jamie Blue
(@)
Famed Member
Joined: 20 years ago
Posts: 3660
 

You hit on it in your post. They don't want customers bringing their own tackle because a majority of the time they would want to use wal mart specials. Fishing, especially charter fishing where your livelihood depends on putting people on fish, is all about control. One of the things they can control is tackle. They know that their gear is et up for how to fish in the manner that they know will give them the best shot at success. If you bring your own gear, they don't know your skill level at tying knots, setting up gear, etc. As far as baits, same deal goes. They don't want people bringing a bunch of stuff that they will never use and then complaining about it. I would suggest doing like you did on your second trip, making sure you communicate well with the captain BEFORE booking the trip and get everything set up for exactly what you want to do. I know several captains don't mind customers bringing their own gear, especially high end jigging equipment. I personally don't often like other people bringing gear on my boat either unless I know them really well and know exactly what they are bringing. I have my own stuff set up for my own style of fishing.

I do understand what you mean though. For example, I have been on tuna trips out of Oregon Inlet where they stick you in the chair no matter what. I HATE sitting in chairs to fight fish. Even with a 50 and no harness, I can beat a fish quicker and with less effort standing up than I can in a chair. But the captains/mates all want to stick you in the chair. I guess it helps tangles on multiple hookups or something. I don't know.



   
ReplyQuote
Troy
 Troy
(@waterdamage)
Reputable Member
Joined: 19 years ago
Posts: 195
 

I can tell you, IF we discuss it before hand and have an understanding of what you want to bring and why then I would consider it. The problem lies in that we have so many folks just show up the morning of the trip and start trying to hand us rods, fighting belts, etc... Most times it is not tackle that is proper for what we are doing, or in very poor or cheap condition. I can't speak for all charter captains but we dont use any cheap tackle.

We begin each trip prepping our rods and rigs for what we plan to do for the day. We know our tackle, we know our spread and we trust our rigging. When customers show up and hand me a wad of tangled store bought pre-rigs and want me to run them for the day - seriously????? You hire us to take you offshore and catch you fish, and I also need to do my best to toss fish on the dock at the end of the day to show prospective new customers standing there watching. Using customers gear will generally not help either of us in our goal. Once you bring things aboard, it does get in the way - we are used to our spread and have a place for everything and try not to clutter the boat for safety reasons.

now, granted, I mostly troll and do not do much bottom fishing. IF we discuss that before the trip and we plan to do that and use your tackle - I personally would have no problem using your tackle/bait. It would simply be less that I have to deal with at the end of the day, but your tackle would have to be put away below during the day for safety reasons. I also do not have a problem using your tackle for bailing mahi, but again we would need to keep it out of the way as best possible and it sure helps to discuss this with me before the morning of the trip

Most people want to be in the chair. We have belts and harnesses for experienced anglers. We primarily use long boat rods for our 50's and that can be tricky for most folks using a belt. Unless you are prepared to buy a rod/reel setup then most crews will not want you refusing a chair - we all have seen it happen, people just let go and the whole deal is gone. That is why most of us do not like seeing folks try to stand up. The other reason is most anglers do not have enough experience to follow their fish from 1 side to the other and will often cause more tangles and problems than they solve. Lastly, we are responsible for the safety of our party - the vast majority of customers do not have "sea legs" enough to be safe when fighting standup



   
ReplyQuote
Jamie Blue
(@)
Famed Member
Joined: 20 years ago
Posts: 3660
 

I understand that part. But when I have the fish to the boat and still getting asked to get in the chair, well thats a little frustrating.

For whatever reason I have a much harder time fighting from a chair than standup. Hard for anything less than a large blue marlin to pull hard enough for me to put the chair to use as intended so I end up using all arms, where when I'm standing up even without a harness I can use lower body.



   
ReplyQuote
Sam Pistachio
(@)
Eminent Member
Joined: 14 years ago
Posts: 29
Topic starter  

You hire us to take you offshore and catch you fish, and I also need to do my best to toss fish on the dock at the end of the day to show prospective new customers standing there watching.

I'm glad you said this. Thanks for the feedback by the way. This may be the problem that I have, and it is certainly why I don't ever (won't ever again) charter for trolling. I'm going to say "you" a bunch, but that isn't targeted at Capt Troy specifically. You = the charter captain in general.

I don't want you to catch me fish. I want you to take me fishing. I understand that I'm hiring a professional fisherman and in most if not all cases both the captain and mate are better fisherman than myself and my group (I certainly hope so). However... we are all capable of hooking and reeling in fish. We don't want you hooking a fish and handing us the rod, we don't want you yelling at us that we are doing it wrong. Teaching/critiqing is perfectly fine. Hell that's your job. But the whole "we aren't here to have fun we're here to kill fish" thing I just don't get. And I like to kill fish.

Side story: We had a captain in the OBX scream at my seasick wife to get up and fish because we wouldn't be able to catch all the dolphin he put us on with her out of commission. I am not exaggerating that. We had a good trip by all measure and we filled the boat with mahi. But to this day all we remember is him coming down out of the tower to scream at her. I was hooked up at the time and before I could tell him that wasn't going to work out my wife let him know that he could either shut up and climb back up top with all his limbs, or continue to yell while she ended his life in a grisly fashion. He didn't speak to her the rest of the trip.

The reason I don't like to troll, and that I really don't equate trolling with fishing is that the only thing you do while trolling as the customer is (hopefully) reel things in. In my experience the captain and mate are uptight due to the expense and complexity of the equipment, the limited number of opportunities to boat fish, the size and nature of the prey (sharp teeth, fins, bills, etc), the danger of the work (line screaming off a big reel, big hooks, gaffs, etc) and the concentration needed to do the fishing itself. I'm sure there's nothing worse for a crew than working for hours to hook a big tuna and having some rookie screw with the reel at a critical moment and lose the fish. But that's the problem with those charters. You don't have time to get six people any level of competency with a big game reel to hope that they can participate beyond reeling while you back the boat down on a fish that you found and your mate hooked. Hell you don't even get to look at the fish half the time because they go into the box in a hurry to clear the deck and get back to fishing.

Which makes a good point I think: make sure you pick the kind of fishing that both you AND YOUR CHARTER CAPTAIN enjoy doing. The guys who make a living trolling are very good at it and their boats and gear reflect that. They gerenally don't want to stop in the inlet and catch small flounder. The guy we chartered for "mixed bag inshore" took that to mean "amberjack." That's what he prepared for and that's what we did. When forced to do some bottom bouncing he fought against it like a caged animal. We didn't understand why... and still don't.



   
ReplyQuote
Chris Zoubek
(@)
Famed Member
Joined: 17 years ago
Posts: 2585
 

Which makes a good point I think: make sure you pick the kind of fishing that both you AND YOUR CHARTER CAPTAIN enjoy doing.

There ya go... I think that is what it all boils down to. If everybody has the same goal.... Everybody Happy, Happy, Happy.



   
ReplyQuote
Bloodworm
(@bloodworm)
Trusted Member
Joined: 21 years ago
Posts: 86
 

Might get in trouble for my opinion but here goes,

I run a charter boat that is multi technique and of course I try to make the customer as happy as possible, (and is the reason I haven't had to advertise in 5 years) but I have to say I do allow and sometimes encourage clients to bring there own tackle. with that said I have tackle on board to handle any style of fishing we may do, because many people who think they have appropriate rods and rigging just haven't seen what I do or what we may be dealing with that particular day. as for most boats not wanting to deal with extra rods, space is a premium so that makes a lot of the reasoning, I have had to add rod holders and storage for customers because I try to encourage clients to bring gear, not a real option for most.

one more thought on tackle and rigging, a charter boat wants you to catch fish, so if we suggest a certain type of rigging or a way to do something you should trust us. as for most full time charter boats, the clients goals are our goals as well, so if that means a deck load of bodies or a release only trip we want you to remember the day! for the right reasons!!!

Capt Rick
Living Waters Guide Service
www.livingwatersguide.com
910-620-7709 cell



   
ReplyQuote
John Cranford
(@)
Reputable Member
Joined: 15 years ago
Posts: 241
 

Bottom fishing charter call Capt John on the Procastinator.



   
ReplyQuote
John Rakoci
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 14 years ago
Posts: 2331
 

One of my least favorite topics when I chartered. I tried it a few times. A client insisted on using his Abu Garcia outfit and was POed when it was destroyed by a fish. The old mono a guy had on broke on a good fish and he was POed. They spent a lot of money to catch fish. I spent a lot of money on good tackle. Our job is to see you enjoy your time and catch fish,,,, why fight it.



   
ReplyQuote
Barry Bierstedt
(@)
Prominent Member
Joined: 18 years ago
Posts: 677
 

I have had many people bring equipment with them and encourage them to if it is right for the type of fishing that we are doing. I always talk about it with the people first and let them know that if you bring something and its not up to my standards then we are not going to use it. On one hand my customers not only pay me to put them on but to catch fish and bring home some meat. On the other hand I am just a guide to my customers and in all actuality the are renting the boat, equipment, and my services and knowledge of the area and I tend to do whatever they want to do unless it could hurt someone or is illegal.



   
ReplyQuote
Ronald j bailey
(@rjb)
Estimable Member
Joined: 19 years ago
Posts: 112
 

This Thread is really interesting. I and 4-6 of my friends have fished Off-Shore, Gulf Stream for an average of 20 yrs. We all have our own boats snd own equip. and take turns going on each others boats. About 4 years ago was the last decent Yellowfin trip off our inlets[Carolina Beach and Masonboro]. Where they are only the OregonInlet people know. This brings me to our deliema: We want to charter out of O.I. to fish for Tuna,butwe are not willing to pay unless the Capt. would agree to allow his Mate to be a part of our Crew. In other words he and we would all be a part of a unified fishing crew that would be doing all parts of the "Fun/Work". Hell, putting out the Spread; checking lines, clearing lines when you get hit is all part of the fun. Now what do you'all think our chances of getting a charter Capt. [During prime Tuna season] would be. I doubt it. Ron



   
ReplyQuote
(@capt_john_c)
Member Moderator
Joined: 19 years ago
Posts: 1128
 

I can understand Captain's trepidations on allowing customer gear on the boat. That being said, I am in the customer service field. If a customer wants to break his rod, loose his fish, not be able to reach the bottom ect, it is the customers choice. I cannot count the number of customer rods that came on the boat as a one piece, and left as a two, three or even four piece.

I try and provide some of the best gear available, and I make sure my stuff is right, (drag, line, topshot, knots,)to make sure your successful in catching fish without tackle issues. If your goal is to do your own thing with your own gear, that is fine as well, just bring your own jigs and rigs if you plan on tying them on gear not up for the challenge cause I cannot have you empty my tackle box because of snap offs and rocked up fish. :wtg:

I run many trips that I literally do not bring a single rod and reel, however, those special customers are rocking some of the finest top dollar stuff available anywhere in the world. Many people who are new to jigging and popping have no idea how much difference there is between their "awesome trevala" or "ugly stick" with "power pro" on it and a real high end Spinal rod equipped with a 2 speed Talica and pe braid. I enjoy watching customers get frustrated using their own gear, switch over to my gear, and see how much more appropriate the stuff truly is for the task at hand.

Again, I stress that I am in the customer service industry, and if you want to run what you brung, go for it, but if I suggest that you leave a particular setup at the dock, it is because I am trying to serve you better by making your fishing trip more fun and productive. Nothing more, nothing less.



   
ReplyQuote
Troy
 Troy
(@waterdamage)
Reputable Member
Joined: 19 years ago
Posts: 195
 

well I think you took what I was saying and changed it by "how" I said it -
regardless, I feel we do a great job of getting the party into the act - we teach people all day out there about rigging, tackle, what to do when a bite occurs, etc... and encourage/beg them to be very involved. It is your trip, I do everything possible to make you the customer happy - period. That said, I do have to be cautious what we do and how we do it.

it has been said here a lot - as in most things in life - COMMUNICATION is the key to success in most any area of life, and definitely here. If I know ahead of time you dont want to troll and have specific requests, we can discuss them and tailor a trip for what you are after - no problem. If you need something we dont want to do, I will tell you right up front and suggest someone that can accommodate you. If you call me out of the blue, say you want an offshore trip and make no other info available - I am going to set up for our normal trip. We cannot read your minds. We spend a lot of time, effort and money rigging up for a trip - I would hope you would understand the frustration of someone showing up at 5am and saying "oh I dont want to use or do that, I want to .....". COMMUNICATION.

i understand some of the old line charter guys have no concern whatsoever for their customers - I know I am not that way, and obviously John is not either. Customer service is the way we will build our industry back.



   
ReplyQuote
Sam Pistachio
(@)
Eminent Member
Joined: 14 years ago
Posts: 29
Topic starter  

Some great feedback here, thanks for all the replies. It should probably be mentioned that the kind of captain that comes to a fishing forum to participate and give advice is generally NOT the sort of captain that has problems communicating. This is a huge plus in my book and I think for most of us internet folks. If I can email you and you actually return that email inside of a couple days I am far more likely to do business with you than the old "booking service / one phone call" sort of deal. The business has changed quite a bit on this end, and kudos to the outfits that take advantage of the tech to make everything smoother.



   
ReplyQuote
Frank Smith
(@wildcard)
Noble Member
Joined: 17 years ago
Posts: 1573
 

well I think you took what I was saying and changed it by "how" I said it -
regardless, I feel we do a great job of getting the party into the act - we teach people all day out there about rigging, tackle, what to do when a bite occurs, etc... and encourage/beg them to be very involved. It is your trip, I do everything possible to make you the customer happy - period. That said, I do have to be cautious what we do and how we do it.

it has been said here a lot - as in most things in life - COMMUNICATION is the key to success in most any area of life, and definitely here. If I know ahead of time you dont want to troll and have specific requests, we can discuss them and tailor a trip for what you are after - no problem. If you need something we dont want to do, I will tell you right up front and suggest someone that can accommodate you. If you call me out of the blue, say you want an offshore trip and make no other info available - I am going to set up for our normal trip. We cannot read your minds. We spend a lot of time, effort and money rigging up for a trip - I would hope you would understand the frustration of someone showing up at 5am and saying "oh I dont want to use or do that, I want to .....". COMMUNICATION.

i understand some of the old line charter guys have no concern whatsoever for their customers - I know I am not that way, and obviously John is not either. Customer service is the way we will build our industry back.

Capt Troy,
NAILED IT!, end of story. It doesn't take much asking/looking around to figure out who you would like to fish with. Trip's are expensive on both end's. Charter's want to have a good time, Captains (for the most part) want to provide that for you. I have never, repeat never yelled at a charter or my mate. Never mind making fun of someone that is seasick. Matter of fact, if folk's start making fun of the person that is seasick, I remind them "that dog can come back to bite". If it's 1/2 as bad as it look's, I don't want any part of it. It's supposed to be about having a good time, talk to the Capt first. No one likes suprises! Frank



   
ReplyQuote
Share: