SWC Forums
Pull up a chair...let's talk fishing.
I'm a marketing man. Disproportionate market share is every marketer's dream. That's where I got the term.
If I have a product that is equal to 5 other products but I have 70% of the market, that is disproportionate market share.
How many fish does NC bring to market relative to other lower 48 states?
As stated in an earlier post, NC has disproportionate market share.
I can tell you this, the market cap or market value of recreational anglers when adding up boat, tackle, hotel, restaurants and all related to fishing DWARFS the commercial fishing sector.
You take away recreational anglers desire to pursue their sport, and you damage the economic well being of dozens of businesses and their families.
I quit inshore fishing - not worth the effort or expense to me until the netting stops.
While I know that this is not exactly current it is some food for thought....
The annual report also breaks down the sales impacts, income impacts and job figures for each coastal state. The five states that generated the most jobs from fishing in 2011 were California, Massachusetts, Florida, Washington, and Alaska. The states with the most growth in the number of commercial fishing jobs compared to 2010 were Alabama (76 percent, net increase of 4,743 jobs), Mississippi (45 percent, net increase of 1,722 jobs), Oregon (32 percent, net increase of 4,483 jobs), Louisiana (29 percent, net increase of 7,272 jobs), and Alaska (17 percent, net increase of 9,288 jobs).
The greatest portion of the nation’s landings revenue generated by the commercial fishing industry was in Alaska ($1.9 billion), followed by Massachusetts ($433 million), and Maine ($381 million).
Saltwater recreational fishing generated its highest economic effect in sales impacts and jobs in West Florida ($4.9 billion sales, 47,000 jobs) East Florida ($3.3 billion sales, 29,000 jobs); Louisiana ($2 billion sales, 18,000 jobs); North Carolina ($2 billion sales, 18,000 jobs); Texas ($1.9 billion sales, 15,000 jobs); and New Jersey (1.7 billion sales, 10,000 jobs).
Fisheries Economics of the United States, 2011 includes descriptive statistics on commercial fish landings, revenue, and price trends; recreational fishing effort, catch, and participation rates; and employer and non-employer establishments, annual payroll, and annual receipt information for fishing-related industries such as seafood retailers and ship and boat building. The report also provides a snapshot of fishery management plans, limited access privilege fishing programs (a type of catch share program), buyback programs, as well as the status of fish stocks and an inventory of protected marine resources.
The report is the sixth volume in an annual series designed to give the public accessible economic information on fishing activities in the U.S., and is a companion to Fisheries of the United States.
Fisheries Economics of the United States 2011 is available online at: http://www.st.nmfs.noaa.gov/economics/publications/feus/fisheries_economics_2011. Hard copies of the report are forthcoming.
It looks like if the recreational fishermen just chipped in a few bucks they could just buy out the commercial sector!!
I addition to the gentleman that does not like the way boat manufacturing is accounted for, I totally agree with you. It shouldn't count at all.
Matt
It looks like if the recreational fishermen just chipped in a few bucks they could just buy out the commercial sector!!
The problem with that report is how the rec $$ are counted vs how the commercial $$ are counted. Look at the details and look at what is attributed to recreational dollars.
It's an apples to strawberries comparison.
If you look at the detailed figures, the reported rec dollars outnumber comm dollars by about 3:1, roughly.
But...
They count things like "boat repair" under rec. Commercial fishermen have repairs done, as well. They count general tourism dollars, such as restaurant incomes; comms and their families eat out, too.
But, the real problem is that in that very report, they value comms by landings and price paid TO THE COMM 'at the dock.' That's a wholesale price, whereas the rec dollars get counted as retail sales.
The report is misleading, but it takes some digging into the data underlying the conclusions to see it.
No one (or at least not me!) is saying recreational fishing is not of economical benefit to the coast. But this report is nothing more but more "us vs them" divisiveness."
It does not have to be that way. Why don't we just say "Fishing Contributes to the Economy" and stand together.
There is not a commercial fisherman that has directly harmed my fishing. When I do my part, I catch fish; 'Net forum after net forum and fishing blog after fishing blog show smiling recreational fishermen with fish. This notion that there is no fish and no one can catch fish and it's all commercial fishing's fault is a falsehood.
In fact, I would say the opposite. Over the years, I have learned a lot from comms, even if they did not realize they were teaching me.
I welcome them on the water with me; we are all in it together...or we SHOULD be.
"I welcome them on the water with me; we are all in it together...or we SHOULD be."
I agree. I don't want to take away a man's livelihood. Next time they need to protect the fishery, I want to see EQUAL catch cuts. I have only seen cuts on Recs - who have been cut to the bone.
But if they ban inshore netting and trawling, with exception for strike netting spots, as an example, I'm good with that. : )
"I welcome them on the water with me; we are all in it together...or we SHOULD be."
I agree. I don't want to take away a man's livelihood. Next time they need to protect the fishery, I want to see EQUAL catch cuts. I have only seen cuts on Recs - who have been cut to the bone.
But if they ban inshore netting and trawling, with exception for strike netting spots, as an example, I'm good with that. : )
and that pretty much sums it up for the majority of us, as long as both sides contribute, we will not have to be pushed into choosing sides.
If the cuts go to only the recs and the comms keep what they have with no reductions and can keep all the nets in the water there will be hell to pay in the future. This cannot continue one sided like it has been for years. The recs continue to take the hits and the comms keep netting. It has to give!!!!
"I welcome them on the water with me; we are all in it together...or we SHOULD be."
I agree. I don't want to take away a man's livelihood. Next time they need to protect the fishery, I want to see EQUAL catch cuts. I have only seen cuts on Recs - who have been cut to the bone.
But if they ban inshore netting and trawling, with exception for strike netting spots, as an example, I'm good with that. : )
Mark,
When you say ban inshore netting, what type nets is it you want to ban?
I agree. I don't want to take away a man's livelihood. Next time they need to protect the fishery, I want to see EQUAL catch cuts. I have only seen cuts on Recs - who have been cut to the bone.
I understand what you are saying, and fair enough.
I still have the question though...what about 'zero' for a catch limit? That does not harm true, pure "recreational" fishing. Lots of trout fishing occurs in catch-n-release waters only, for example.
So, I guess I'm unclear as to how the limits in place are what is driving the "us vs them" so strongly.
Let's say the recreational flounder limit is dropped to zero, but NOTHING is done on the comm side. Other than getting to catch fish for the table or freezer (which I AGREE!! is a big part of fishing for all of us), how does that impact one's ability to fish for recreation?
To be clear, I'm NOT suggesting that's what should happen!
I'm simply trying to distill the discussion down to it's roots. What I'm saying is that whatever catch restrictions are (or are not) on the commercials, it really does not impact the "sport" of recreational fishing to the degree that people (some at least) say that CATCHING the fish is the primary recreational goal.
I think that is part of the sticking point with me; a lot of these threads get started with "oh no! the recs get the shaft again yet the comms go on as before" or quickly devolve into that.
The rec limits could be zero as in the many catch-n-release fisheries around and people can still enjoy recreational fishing, so making rec catch limits about what the comms can do is a non sequitur.
Agonizing over catch limits is not really the rec vs comm it's made out to be.
The other side of this is that it is VERY easy to commit a Base Rate Fallacy and assume because each comm can catch x pounds more than each rec, that the comms are the cause of overfishing. That conclusion is not necessarily true.
Page III-14 gives 2013 Estimated Rec Harvest Stats:
Rec: 13 million pounds harvested, another 20 million pounds released. Given that release mortality is not zero (as high as about 15% for speckled trout), some of that released poundage is still dead fish. Who knows how much.
Page II-7 gives reported 2013 commercial stats:
Com: 22 million pounds landed.
Now, I don't think the "comms stealing far, far, far more than their share" is supported by this data. They may well land more, but the result is not incredibly lopsided.
Note that the rec data is an estimate, and again, I point out that suggestions for even voluntary reporting is often met with heavy criticism.
So...it COULD be that the managers are looking at the data and see the BEST solution for sustainability is for tighter rec limits. I'm not in a position to argue that one way or another; perhaps that's best or perhaps it's not. maybe the rec limits are just the low hanging fruit...easiest to implement. I sure don't know.
I know a lot here have opinions on that matter, but I'm personally not interested in such opinions. Such opinions are rarely supported by any facts and easily fall into the "Geezer Science" (I heard someone say it once, so it must be true) category.
But I will say that we DO have to be very careful jumping to conclusions that rec and comm "management" are equal and have equal effects.
This stuff is VERY complex and sound bites and press releases are NOT the whole story. This is one reason why I think standing together with less antagonism will be the most helpful in the long run.
So, the real question I think we should be asking is "Hey, Regulators, can you show us the ACTUAL data that supports the conclusion that lowering Rec catch limits will help the fishery while keeping the Comm regs as they are now?"
That kind of question puts the responsibility on the proper shoulders...does the decision help the fishery or not...without pointing the finger at the comms by saying, "But they don't get spanked, too!"
Because quite frankly, that's all a lot of this debate sounds like to me...like 5 year olds complaining that their brother got ice cream but they didn't. Sorry...don't mean that toward any single person so much as the debate in total.
In other words, if we really DO care about the fishery as our ultimate goal, ANY cut that HELPS should be applauded. Right? I mean, the question of cutting the other guy helping too is a SEPARATE question. So, if data shows cutting the rec flounder limit helps them recover, that's GOOD, no? That's the goal, not "Heeeyyyy, but HE gets to keep HIS."
Those are separate issues, perhaps to be solved at separate times.
"I welcome them on the water with me; we are all in it together...or we SHOULD be."
I agree. I don't want to take away a man's livelihood. Next time they need to protect the fishery, I want to see EQUAL catch cuts. I have only seen cuts on Recs - who have been cut to the bone.
But if they ban inshore netting and trawling, with exception for strike netting spots, as an example, I'm good with that. : )
Mark,
When you say ban inshore netting, what type nets is it you want to ban?
Crabman,
The ones that kill indiscriminately - both rec and comm.
I don't want to throw a blanket and ban all inshore netting. Some, like spot netting, is fine. Dragging a speckled trout hole, no. Possible exception - freeze where the fish will die anyhow. I don't know enough about it. I know the ones they set up on creek entrances kill a lot of breed stock.
I personally don't like netting - if fishermen lose gear, it continues to kill for years!
Inshore trawls - need to go.
I agree. I don't want to take away a man's livelihood. Next time they need to protect the fishery, I want to see EQUAL catch cuts. I have only seen cuts on Recs - who have been cut to the bone.
I understand what you are saying, and fair enough.
I still have the question though...what about 'zero' for a catch limit? That does not harm true, pure "recreational" fishing. Lots of trout fishing occurs in catch-n-release waters only, for example.
So, I guess I'm unclear as to how the limits in place are what is driving the "us vs them" so strongly.
Let's say the recreational flounder limit is dropped to zero, but NOTHING is done on the comm side. Other than getting to catch fish for the table or freezer (which I AGREE!! is a big part of fishing for all of us), how does that impact one's ability to fish for recreation?
To be clear, I'm NOT suggesting that's what should happen!
I'm simply trying to distill the discussion down to it's roots. What I'm saying is that whatever catch restrictions are (or are not) on the commercials, it really does not impact the "sport" of recreational fishing to the degree that people (some at least) say that CATCHING the fish is the primary recreational goal.
I think that is part of the sticking point with me; a lot of these threads get started with "oh no! the recs get the shaft again yet the comms go on as before" or quickly devolve into that.
The rec limits could be zero as in the many catch-n-release fisheries around and people can still enjoy recreational fishing, so making rec catch limits about what the comms can do is a non sequitur.
Agonizing over catch limits is not really the rec vs comm it's made out to be.
The other side of this is that it is VERY easy to commit a Base Rate Fallacy and assume because each comm can catch x pounds more than each rec, that the comms are the cause of overfishing. That conclusion is not necessarily true.
Page III-14 gives 2013 Estimated Rec Harvest Stats:
Rec: 13 million pounds harvested, another 20 million pounds released. Given that release mortality is not zero (as high as about 15% for speckled trout), some of that released poundage is still dead fish. Who knows how much.
Page II-7 gives reported 2013 commercial stats:
Com: 22 million pounds landed.
Now, I don't think the "comms stealing far, far, far more than their share" is supported by this data. They may well land more, but the result is not incredibly lopsided.
Note that the rec data is an estimate, and again, I point out that suggestions for even voluntary reporting is often met with heavy criticism.
So...it COULD be that the managers are looking at the data and see the BEST solution for sustainability is for tighter rec limits. I'm not in a position to argue that one way or another; perhaps that's best or perhaps it's not. maybe the rec limits are just the low hanging fruit...easiest to implement. I sure don't know.
I know a lot here have opinions on that matter, but I'm personally not interested in such opinions. Such opinions are rarely supported by any facts and easily fall into the "Geezer Science" (I heard someone say it once, so it must be true) category.
But I will say that we DO have to be very careful jumping to conclusions that rec and comm "management" are equal and have equal effects.
This stuff is VERY complex and sound bites and press releases are NOT the whole story. This is one reason why I think standing together with less antagonism will be the most helpful in the long run.
So, the real question I think we should be asking is "Hey, Regulators, can you show us the ACTUAL data that supports the conclusion that lowering Rec catch limits will help the fishery while keeping the Comm regs as they are now?"
That kind of question puts the responsibility on the proper shoulders...does the decision help the fishery or not...without pointing the finger at the comms by saying, "But they don't get spanked, too!"
Because quite frankly, that's all a lot of this debate sounds like to me...like 5 year olds complaining that their brother got ice cream but they didn't. Sorry...don't mean that toward any single person so much as the debate in total.
In other words, if we really DO care about the fishery as our ultimate goal, ANY cut that HELPS should be applauded. Right? I mean, the question of cutting the other guy helping too is a SEPARATE question. So, if data shows cutting the rec flounder limit helps them recover, that's GOOD, no? That's the goal, not "Heeeyyyy, but HE gets to keep HIS."
Those are separate issues, perhaps to be solved at separate times.
Makes sense. It is hard to reach a conclusion. Catch & release for specs and reds is what I admit I did anyhow. (when I could catch them).
According to a study in Rhode Island, over 90% of inshore fishermen target flounder. That number might be close to the same here as well. Therefore, I wouldn't cut the rec. flounder (is it possible?) fishery to manage that fishery.
Without Hatchery Supported Quotas .
:lmao:
translation: another taxpayer funded subsidy
for comms akin to EBT cards.
For all of the comms wanting no cuts to their livelihood, what part of the water is a 'public resource' is hard for you to comprehend?
Most believe since they do it for a living they should be able to do what ever they want, when they want, and how much they want.
There is so much distrust and dishonesty in the commercial fishing world with the full support of powerful politicians who are not even in power any more, make it hard to believe any of the information that comes forward from Daniels et al.
If that happens, I predict that will be the straw that broke the camels back.
For all of the comms wanting no cuts to their livelihood, what part of the water is a 'public resource' is hard for you to comprehend?
Because they bought the license to do so, perhaps, and the law as it is currently written provides for that license for them to work according to it?
Because they WORK to produce something useful to others, that others are WILLING to pay for, to market?
Why SHOULD they take a cut to their LIVELIHOOD? Would YOU like to be told you are getting a pay cut, just because someone does not agree with the way your employer makes money?
The focus should remain "How do we make sustainable decisions?" Your message sounds more like "stick it to them." I'm sick of that and it's not helpful AT ALL.
Most believe since they do it for a living they should be able to do what ever they want, when they want, and how much they want.
Stop with the hyperbole, please. No one says the comms should do whatever they want. Good grief; they have laws to follow just like the rest of us.
When they break the law, bust 'em. I say the same thing about recs. Until, then, more power to them working their "livelihood."
Sustainable fishing issues are NOT "rec vs comm." The more finger pointing that goes on, the less I believe those doing the pointing care one whit about "The Resource" and sustainability.
Fishingtheneuse, the difference is if I work for a living in a private industry with private resources, that that is fine, but if I am a logger logging in a national forrest that is a different story. The abuse of a shared resource is why it is no longer legal to cut a redwood down!
Matt