SWC Forums

Pull up a chair...let's talk fishing.

Flounder Fishing ??...
 
Notifications
Clear all

Flounder Fishing ??? Is it History for the Rec Fisherman

212 Posts
36 Users
0 Reactions
6,246 Views
Bob
 Bob
(@)
Reputable Member
Joined: 16 years ago
Posts: 331
 

the vast documented economic impact difference of rec fishing vs. commercial fishing to NC

Are you referring to the scientifically flawed and politically motivated "studies" that count rec contributed dollars one way and comm contributed dollars another?

For example, a $1 worth of fish landed at the dock impacts the economy far more than $1, yet the the comm dollars are counted based on 'price paid at the dock.' A better measure is the retail price that fish has in local market or at restaurant. That's a 10x multiplier in some cases, and in a few, maybe even more.

Then, as Eric pointed out above...how many people travel here to fish vs the number that travel here just to visit the beach. Seafood is a big part of that draw for many that travel from inland. There's another multiplier, but one that is impossible to quantify (for either rec or comm).

There are FAR FAR more people that travel to the NC coast that never put a line in the water or get on a boat than those that do.

In short, it is EXTREMELY difficult, if even possible, to put separate the numbers regarding economic impacts of one group vs the other. To lay claim to a simple conclusion based on massaged data is about as disingenuous as it comes.

Again...I will say this. The situation will only improve when we start saying more "we" and less "me" and "they."

Good points. Funny how some are offended by local fish being sold in NY to generate more $$$$, but cost of a boat built and sold in FL to a NC fisherman gets counted in recreational impact $$$.



   
ReplyQuote
zigzag
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 22 years ago
Posts: 1863
 

and the great sea food dining that is available.

and the majority of it comes frozen straight off the frozen food truck, I get a lot better seafood 200 miles inland



   
ReplyQuote
Mark Clapp
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 21 years ago
Posts: 979
 

Anybody have a comparison of catch concessions of recreational versus commercial?



   
ReplyQuote
John Riley
(@)
Estimable Member
Joined: 12 years ago
Posts: 172
 

and the majority of it comes frozen straight off the frozen food truck, I get a lot better seafood 200 miles inland

Then you are eating at the wrong places. There are plenty of restaurants and markets that sell local catch. It's not that hard to find it if you bother to look.



   
ReplyQuote
Toby
 Toby
(@)
Estimable Member
Joined: 20 years ago
Posts: 156
 

I have a restaurant and most of the flounder served at the coast is cheap frozen stuff from overseas. Much of it not even flounder. Seafood from the beach many times is inferior to seafood inland... that boggles my mind.



   
ReplyQuote
Jeff Schmucker
(@rustyone)
Noble Member
Joined: 16 years ago
Posts: 951
 

I've been eating seafood all over the US for 35+ years and also I have been catching and cooking my own for 25 years.

I've had awesome flounder in Pittsburgh and terrific tuna in Atlanta. One of the worst seafood meals I've ever eaten was at the waterfront in Sanannah. There are many, many great places in both the Carolinas, VA, MI and LA. I think Florida has more crummy fish joints than any other state. High price has no correlation with quality.

Without a doubt, and bang for the buck, the small diners in eastern, NC win first place.



   
ReplyQuote
John Rakoci
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 14 years ago
Posts: 2331
 

CC says some of the most polarizing and troll like stuff on here but I'll give him this, at least he says what he means. Call a spade a spade. Im just a little confused though CC. Are we feeding our greed or are we all below the poverty line? May be we're just wanna be greedy? You must be the nicest person. I guess you still want me to take you in a friend's home so you can copy their old commercial fishing pictures? And surely not for any nefarious purposes....I can certainly see where you'd have a genuine interest in such material. You really must think I'm an idiot or something. Checks aren't enough now you gotta help 'em make posters and bill boards? You really put the CC in CCA.

Well Eric ~ are your eyes brown or is it not quite that far yet? It's close! What I offered was for you. There was not a thing for me. The equipment I have was offered to use and the SD card would have been given to you for your project. I would have loaned you the equipment if you preferred. Not a single thing for me. Not interested in that stuff. Prefer the old buildings, boats, and vehicles. I know you are intelligent but you have now proven you can be an idiot too when you want. Without the SD card there is no record. You can print and edit from the card. To prove I can be foolish I'd still loan you the equipment and explain how to use it. No way in hell would I do it for you now. The project you want to complete is important to you and would be of interest to many. I guess you would much rather open your mouth than have it completed ever. Remember, I offered cash to you also for one of the 1st copies so you could print ~~ in this instance you are an idiot. You put something of importance harder to reach to you in order to toss a stone.

If you want DMF income figures I'll get them for you. Maybe they are incorrect as that may be 1 reason why the JEA is fought so diligently by comms.



   
ReplyQuote
zigzag
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 22 years ago
Posts: 1863
 

and the majority of it comes frozen straight off the frozen food truck, I get a lot better seafood 200 miles inland

Then you are eating at the wrong places. There are plenty of restaurants and markets that sell local catch. It's not that hard to find it if you bother to look.

you may want to read a few more post, we all like fresh, local caught seafood, but most of the time, and some of it is due to demand, it comes off the frozen food truck.

Ever been around those commercial boats that target beeliners? ask them where their fish is sold.



   
ReplyQuote
eric broome
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 19 years ago
Posts: 1299
 

CC says some of the most polarizing and troll like stuff on here but I'll give him this, at least he says what he means. Call a spade a spade. Im just a little confused though CC. Are we feeding our greed or are we all below the poverty line? May be we're just wanna be greedy? You must be the nicest person. I guess you still want me to take you in a friend's home so you can copy their old commercial fishing pictures? And surely not for any nefarious purposes....I can certainly see where you'd have a genuine interest in such material. You really must think I'm an idiot or something. Checks aren't enough now you gotta help 'em make posters and bill boards? You really put the CC in CCA.

Well Eric ~ are your eyes brown or is it not quite that far yet? It's close! What I offered was for you. There was not a thing for me. The equipment I have was offered to use and the SD card would have been given to you for your project. I would have loaned you the equipment if you preferred. Not a single thing for me. Not interested in that stuff. Prefer the old buildings, boats, and vehicles. I know you are intelligent but you have now proven you can be an idiot too when you want. Without the SD card there is no record. You can print and edit from the card. To prove I can be foolish I'd still loan you the equipment and explain how to use it. No way in hell would I do it for you now. The project you want to complete is important to you and would be of interest to many. I guess you would much rather open your mouth than have it completed ever. Remember, I offered cash to you also for one of the 1st copies so you could print ~~ in this instance you are an idiot. You put something of importance harder to reach to you in order to toss a stone.

If you want DMF income figures I'll get them for you. Maybe they are incorrect as that may be 1 reason why the JEA is fought so diligently by comms.

So are you playing both sides of the fence or what? It's real hard for me to believe that someone would be SO DAMN passionate about slinging mud on the industry and then genuinely want to help me promote it. And I'm an idiot because I think there could be more to it....? We never discussed sd cards or the like, you asked for access to copy old pics. Most of which were of old fishermen sitting atop piles of shrimp and fish from the 50s and 60s. Forgive me if I just misread your intentions, but you wouldn't be the first rich northerner who offered "help" with alterior motives. I can't see how you could be both of the faces I've seen/read from you. Rabid check writer to extremist anti commercial groups, but also friendly helper of the comm community. Yea, I'm such an idiot. I'll take my chances on being wrong on this one.

BTW, I fight JEA for the same reason you would. You've said so yourself. Fed dollars are never free and without strings. If you believe it is, then you're the idiot.



   
ReplyQuote
John Riley
(@)
Estimable Member
Joined: 12 years ago
Posts: 172
 

you may want to read a few more post, we all like fresh, local caught seafood, but most of the time, and some of it is due to demand, it comes off the frozen food truck.

Ever been around those commercial boats that target beeliners? ask them where their fish is sold.

I read it. So what? I'm not denying there are places that sell frozen, trucked in seafood. Shoot, I'm not even saying that's BAD if that's what someone wants to pay for.

I AM saying that local is available if you want to find it, and if you value it, you will seek it out and vote with your dollars.

I have seen local catch unloaded from the boats and brought to local markets; so, it's here. You can get it if you want it.

If you are not eating / buying local, that's a choice you are making. If a restaurant owner is not serving "local"...that's him. That's what he is choosing to serve. Not every restaurant owner is making that same choice.

If he wants to serve local, I know for a fact the local markets would LOVE to gain restaurant clients in the MHC/Bft area. I could give him the phone number of a dealer in Beaufort that would very much like to get product into an additional local outlet.

It's not rocket science. You buy local if that's what you want. It is certainly available.

It might inconvenient to do so. Or, the places that sell it might not be the "right" (trendy) places to eat. Or...the local might be more expensive sometimes. Or, one might have some political motivation to not support the livelihoods of their own neighbors. Or...well, you get the idea. There are lots of reasons/excuses to NOT buy local catch, but it not being available is not one of them.

We all make choices. I have no problem finding local catch, and have eaten such from Shallotte to Manteo (actually, Florida to Maine, but I'm focusing on NC). And NC seafood certainly has been yuuuummmmmy, so this bit about "local is not as good" is a farce.

As Rustyone Said...

Without a doubt, and bang for the buck, the small diners in eastern, NC win first place.

There you go. Right on. Agree 100%.

The problem is, those places too often don't appeal to the 'urban sensibilities' of many of our area's visitors.



   
ReplyQuote
Mark Clapp
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 21 years ago
Posts: 979
 

Anybody have a comparison of catch concessions of recreational versus commercial?

Here's a clue, it isn't commercial guys that are conceding from what I can see.

Funny how the pro commercial guys attack the messenger, first "you can't fish" then "you ain't the first rich northerner" yada, yada, yada.

NC commercial fisheries have disproportionate market share in supplying more than 50% of all fish sold - from one state!

I ask you, honestly, at whose expense? Every time you want something done to manage the fishery, they change it to "we" have to do something.

Every time I look at the concessions, it's the rec who is targeted. Do you want to see a comparison of all southern state recreational catch limits and how they compare to NC?

NC rec limits are practically 10% of other state limits, like I said, that disproportionate commercial market share has to come from somewhere.



   
ReplyQuote
John Riley
(@)
Estimable Member
Joined: 12 years ago
Posts: 172
 

Here's a clue, it isn't commercial guys that are conceding from what I can see.

More "rec vs comm" divisiveness.

A lot of rec guys don't want to concede anything either. Not saying all, of course, but some certainly balk at the mere mention of anything that might cut into what amounts to nothing more than a hobby to them.

For example, mention anything remotely sounding like trip tickets or VOLUNTARY harvest and release reporting to get better data for better management decisions, and some in the rec community go berserk.

Again. Still. "Us vs Them" hurts us all...us recs and them comms all stand together if we could just....stand together.

We, that's all of us, need less emotionally based finger pointing and more / better data and data based decision making.



   
ReplyQuote
Chris McCaffity
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 15 years ago
Posts: 1424
 

Without Hatchery Supported Quotas we will continue to see more restrictions on everyone. We should be working together on finding solutions that benefit everyone and the resource rather than blaming others. No reason recreational fishermen should not have a 10 fish possession limit for trout and flounder with no size limit on stocked fish. It is time to focus more on enhancing our fisheries and food supply than restricting the public's freedom to access them.



   
ReplyQuote
Mark Clapp
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 21 years ago
Posts: 979
 

Here's a clue, it isn't commercial guys that are conceding from what I can see.

More "rec vs comm" divisiveness.

A lot of rec guys don't want to concede anything either. Not saying all, of course, but some certainly balk at the mere mention of anything that might cut into what amounts to nothing more than a hobby to them.

For example, mention anything remotely sounding like trip tickets or VOLUNTARY harvest and release reporting to get better data for better management decisions, and some in the rec community go berserk.

Again. Still. "Us vs Them" hurts us all...us recs and them comms all stand together if we could just....stand together.

We, that's all of us, need less emotionally based finger pointing and more / better data and data based decision making.

Correct me if I'm wrong, but I still don't see a sacrifice except for recreational limits cut or outright ban on fishing certain species.

Look at these numbers for the regulations for 2013:

STATE -/ R.Drum / Flounder / Trout
NC -/1 / 6 / 4
SC -/ 3 / 20(!!!) / 10
GA -/ 5 / 15 / 15
FL -/ 2 / 10 / 6/5/4 (zones)
LA -/ 5 / 10 / 25 (holy moly!)
TX -/ 3 / 5 / 10

We argue this topic every year. Commercial fishermen still enjoy disproportionate market share.



   
ReplyQuote
John Riley
(@)
Estimable Member
Joined: 12 years ago
Posts: 172
 

Commercial fishermen still enjoy disproportionate market share at who's expense?

This can't be serious.

The comms have all manners of regulations, fees, taxes and such to contend with, and now heaped on top of all that is all the ginned up hatred piled on them from too many on the rec side.

"Disproportionate market share" is a politically motivated talking point and nothing more than that. It's like "common sense gun control;" it has no meaning but sounds good in a press release. Define it...I don't mean tell me what someone else says it means. Define it. What would be "proportionate market share"?

PLEASE STOP thinking in terms of "comm vs rec." That's a no-win situation that helps NONE of us. The end game of those fueling this kind of thinking is NO FISHING WHATSOEVER.

And further, what real "expense" is it to recreational fishermen to have to deal with catch and size limits? Recreational fishing is, by definition, recreational. It's voluntary. There is no expense except that which we CHOOSE to expend. If someone does not want to fish because the odds are too low or bait costs too much or whatever...stay home. Expense problem solved.

We hear all the time it's the fun of fishing for the rec, so what if we just say ALL rec limits go to zero (like in some trout waters) and the whole enchilada is catch-n-release? Then we don't have to piss and moan every year over what the limits are or what they are changing to. Zero is zero.

(I don't want that any more than I'm guessing you do, but that would accomplish the same thing a lot of folks are claiming is behind their hatred of the comms. I offer it as an extreme example to make a point).



   
ReplyQuote
Page 9 / 15
Share: