SWC Forums

Pull up a chair...let's talk fishing.

Flounder Fishing ??...
 
Notifications
Clear all

Flounder Fishing ??? Is it History for the Rec Fisherman

212 Posts
36 Users
0 Reactions
6,243 Views
Robert Martin Jr
(@par4b)
Eminent Member
Joined: 20 years ago
Posts: 32
 

Fishingtheneuse, I believe the resource should be managed for the welfare of all and not overwhelmingly for one group. The economic impact studies seem clear to me and should be given a great deal of consideration when deciding what practices should be allowed and disallowed. While I believe inside trawling is by far the largest cause for the demise of NC fishing, I think a commercial fisherman should be able to ply his or her trade within the confines of practices that sustain the resource for them and recs for decades to come. I agree with you that often these discussions and sharing of perspective and opinion and yes, at times even facts, can get ugly. I live here, I fish here. This is a great state and we are blessed with an estuary system that should result in world class fishing while allowing a man a chance to make a living commercial fishing.

This is where I do think the experiences of other states are not specious to NC policy. I think I am right on this but would like to understand why I am wrong if the experience of other states are misleading, false or unsound to our situation. I understand other states experiences may not contain the exact factors we have but at this point think they must be very closely related. I see other states for the most part disallow inside trawling and they have healthier fish stocks and better fishing while still supporting a commercial fishery.

I hope we are at the point of changing policy to promote a better outcome. For all. Tick tock, tick tock. Bleeding to death.



   
ReplyQuote
Robert Martin Jr
(@par4b)
Eminent Member
Joined: 20 years ago
Posts: 32
 

Seacern - where these facts take me is, keeping in mind the vast documented economic impact difference of rec fishing vs. commercial fishing to NC, why should NC support the national seafood demand to the extent we do while eroding an even greater pot of gold in doing so?
Respectfully to those who think we are all good to go now......I just don't get it.



   
ReplyQuote
Glen Montgomery
(@)
Reputable Member
Joined: 16 years ago
Posts: 284
 

par4b Louisiana arguably has some of the best sport fishing in the Country but also have many times the shrimp trawlers as does NC and they are allowed to basically shrimp wherever they can find shrimp. Tourism is big business along NC coast and most do not come here for the great fishing experience. They come for the beaches, the sun, and the great sea food dining that is available. A lot of then that take the time to throw out a sinker with hooks could care less about catching a load of fish since the wife probably prefers to eat out that evening instead of standing in front of a hot stove



   
ReplyQuote
Jordan
(@)
Estimable Member
Joined: 15 years ago
Posts: 126
 

par4b Louisiana arguably has some of the best sport fishing in the Country but also have many times the shrimp trawlers as does NC and they are allowed to basically shrimp wherever they can find shrimp. Tourism is big business along NC coast and most do not come here for the great fishing experience. They come for the beaches, the sun, and the great sea food dining that is available. A lot of then that take the time to throw out a sinker with hooks could care less about catching a load of fish since the wife probably prefers to eat out that evening instead of standing in front of a hot stove

Louisiana also has smaller head rope sizes and seasons for shrimping. You keep repeating all the same stuff over and over DE. LA and NC have different shrimping laws.



   
ReplyQuote
Robert Martin Jr
(@par4b)
Eminent Member
Joined: 20 years ago
Posts: 32
 

downeaster - I guess I should know better than to believe all I read on the internet, but I surely have read there are restrictions to inside trawling in Louisiana and they are far more restrictive than NC. Is that not the case?



   
ReplyQuote
Glen Montgomery
(@)
Reputable Member
Joined: 16 years ago
Posts: 284
 

Louisiana has roughly 10x the landings of shrimp than does NC and most are caught by trawl gear. Assume they also have 10x the bycatch so why are their waters so full of fish? Too many recs blaming everything they can for their inability to catch fish. I have fished rod and reel for most of my 68 years and its easy to remember the big catches back then but we tend to forget about those days we caught nothing for our efforts which were much more common that good days.



   
ReplyQuote
John Riley
(@)
Estimable Member
Joined: 12 years ago
Posts: 172
 

the vast documented economic impact difference of rec fishing vs. commercial fishing to NC

Are you referring to the scientifically flawed and politically motivated "studies" that count rec contributed dollars one way and comm contributed dollars another?

For example, a $1 worth of fish landed at the dock impacts the economy far more than $1, yet the the comm dollars are counted based on 'price paid at the dock.' A better measure is the retail price that fish has in local market or at restaurant. That's a 10x multiplier in some cases, and in a few, maybe even more.

Then, as Eric pointed out above...how many people travel here to fish vs the number that travel here just to visit the beach. Seafood is a big part of that draw for many that travel from inland. There's another multiplier, but one that is impossible to quantify (for either rec or comm).

There are FAR FAR more people that travel to the NC coast that never put a line in the water or get on a boat than those that do.

In short, it is EXTREMELY difficult, if even possible, to put separate the numbers regarding economic impacts of one group vs the other. To lay claim to a simple conclusion based on massaged data is about as disingenuous as it comes.

Again...I will say this. The situation will only improve when we start saying more "we" and less "me" and "they."



   
ReplyQuote
Sea Cern
(@)
Estimable Member
Joined: 13 years ago
Posts: 172
 

Seacern - where these facts take me is, keeping in mind the vast documented economic impact difference of rec fishing vs. commercial fishing to NC, why should NC support the national seafood demand to the extent we do while eroding an even greater pot of gold in doing so?
Respectfully to those who think we are all good to go now......I just don't get it.

par4b - There are more than a few trolls on this board and plenty looking out for their own personal gain.

While the issues are complex, the answers are as evident as the outcomes of past decisions.

1) Red Drum- a bycatch only fishery with an annual 250,000 pound quota intended to prevent regulatory discards. Stock Status- Concern

2) Southern Flounder- all indications are that the stock is depleted, over-fished and over-fishing is occurring. Age structure is collapsing with 80% of harvest occurring on pre-spawn juvenile females due to recruitment over-fishing.

3) Speckle trout- currently listed as depleted...but with moving the goal posts, redefining the length of a yard, changing a few rules, the stock is now just fine and has never been overfished, nor is overfishing occurring.

It seems that the Division's current strategy is making up new rules once Deny, Defend, Delay has run it's course within a FMP.

NC represents about 1.5% of total US landings as measured by $. Any significance that NC has in national landings is a black eye due to bad management and politics wasting real dollars for pennies on key recreational species of little commercial value, species that other states have recognized as too valuable to die in gill nets.



   
ReplyQuote
Sea Cern
(@)
Estimable Member
Joined: 13 years ago
Posts: 172
 

the vast documented economic impact difference of rec fishing vs. commercial fishing to NC

Are you referring to the scientifically flawed and politically motivated "studies" that count rec contributed dollars one way and comm contributed dollars another?

For example, a $1 worth of fish landed at the dock impacts the economy far more than $1, yet the the comm dollars are counted based on 'price paid at the dock.' A better measure is the retail price that fish has in local market or at restaurant. That's a 10x multiplier in some cases, and in a few, maybe even more.

Then, as Eric pointed out above...how many people travel here to fish vs the number that travel here just to visit the beach. Seafood is a big part of that draw for many that travel from inland. There's another multiplier, but one that is impossible to quantify (for either rec or comm).

There are FAR FAR more people that travel to the NC coast that never put a line in the water or get on a boat than those that do.

In short, it is EXTREMELY difficult, if even possible, to put separate the numbers regarding economic impacts of one group vs the other. To lay claim to a simple conclusion based on massaged data is about as disingenuous as it comes.

Again...I will say this. The situation will only improve when we start saying more "we" and less "me" and "they."

FishingTheNeuse-
You are just plain wrong, the correct word would be ignorant. The Division goes to great lengths to measure Total Economic Impact of both sectors. Every FMP contains those calculations. Both sectors have multipliers. I'd suggest you spend a little time on the link below reading

http://portal.ncdenr.org/web/mf/marine-fisheries-catch-statistics

and less time on this webpage typing.



   
ReplyQuote
Sea Cern
(@)
Estimable Member
Joined: 13 years ago
Posts: 172
 

Louisiana has roughly 10x the landings of shrimp than does NC and most are caught by trawl gear. Assume they also have 10x the bycatch so why are their waters so full of fish? Too many recs blaming everything they can for their inability to catch fish. I have fished rod and reel for most of my 68 years and its easy to remember the big catches back then but we tend to forget about those days we caught nothing for our efforts which were much more common that good days.

Because they don't trawl in the nursery areas for speckle trout and red drum, but they do trawl in the open ocean which does have significant bycatch and the same effect on important finfish stocks, just different species.

http://www.ccalouisiana.com/cca11/index.php/press-room-60/press-releases/71-u-s-department-of-commerce-concedes-failure-on-red-snapper-rebuilding-plan



   
ReplyQuote
Rich
 Rich
(@squid-row)
Illustrious Member
Joined: 22 years ago
Posts: 4097
 

Might be a dumb question, but I'll take my chances....

IF all flounder landed in inside waters are counted as southern flounder, even though some (or in some areas most) of the fish are actually summer flounder, is there really a valid stock assessment in place for southern flounder?



   
ReplyQuote
jonathan
(@jward87)
Estimable Member
Joined: 14 years ago
Posts: 120
 

I guess the only fish that yall don't want to be a game fish is pinfish and oyster toad



   
ReplyQuote
Sea Cern
(@)
Estimable Member
Joined: 13 years ago
Posts: 172
 

Might be a dumb question, but I'll take my chances....

IF all flounder landed in inside waters are counted as southern flounder, even though some (or in some areas most) of the fish are actually summer flounder, is there really a valid stock assessment in place for southern flounder?

There is no current valid stock assessment. The Director's "staff" rejected the current stock assessment because 1 out of 3 peer reviewers noted a few issues that have been know for years, since the time of the original FMP in 2005. It seems the Director has that sole discretion, not the MFC.



   
ReplyQuote
Rich
 Rich
(@squid-row)
Illustrious Member
Joined: 22 years ago
Posts: 4097
 

So how can emergency measures be considered if an emergency may or may not even exist?

We have been all screaming for better data both in state and in fed fisheries. If the data is no good, the outcome is no good (see Red Snapper and Black Sea Bass).

What real evidence is there that southern flounder are in trouble? Especially when you consider that summer flounder have rebounded and most people can't tell the difference?



   
ReplyQuote
Sea Cern
(@)
Estimable Member
Joined: 13 years ago
Posts: 172
 

So how can emergency measures be considered if an emergency may or may not even exist?

We have been all screaming for better data both in state and in fed fisheries. If the data is no good, the outcome is no good (see Red Snapper and Black Sea Bass).

What real evidence is there that southern flounder are in trouble? Especially when you consider that summer flounder have rebounded and most people can't tell the difference?

I'll suggest that you start here on this locked thread- pretty plain understanding there that the stock is in trouble. The link to the assessment and Dr. Daniel's letter rejecting the assessment is there also.

http://fryingpantower.com/ftopict-44560-.html



   
ReplyQuote
Page 8 / 15
Share: