SWC Forums
Pull up a chair...let's talk fishing.
Great post eric13
Darn near brought tears to my eyes ~~ but it is simply an attempt at justification and rarely entirely true.
So the better fisherman you are the worse businessman you are? Which is the case with the above statement. If that's true then one would wonder how there are any profitable commercial fisherman. The more fish you catch the more money you loose?
There are 2900 wannabe or hobbyists commercial fishermen and only 205 holders of NC licenses earn the amount a beginning teacher earns or more according to NC numbers. So evidently few licensees are good businessmen or good fishermen.
I'll be happy if they just cut out recreational gigging
Why rec gigging and leave the comms to continue? Naturally, comms want the entire resource to feed their greed but if you could eliminate recs would you keep comms going?
Fishingtheneuse, in my opinion, is starting to get on the right track! There are tons of problems out there, pollution, overfishing, habitat distruction etc.
I spoke with a gentleman today that when prompted with the problem suggested what I would refer to as the deer tag approach. Tags are x $'s per tag. Catch all you want as long as you have a tag. The revenues recieved from the tags have to go back into the resource.
This thread could turn into something positive if both sides would suggest solutions.
Eric, you have not suggested a solution as of yet other than get rid of the beach houses. Come on if you have as many hours on the water as you suggest, you surely have a way to make the fishery better.
Matt
OK Matt ~ you want recs to pay for tags... then you will find a means to funnel the $$ to the comms? What about tourists that spend many times the revenue the entire comm fleet brings in and the jobs they support?
But the storm water run offs don't have to dump directly into the river and ICW. They could design retaining ponds or the like to leach some of this crap out of the water before it runs back to where the fish lay.
"They" have been designing retaining ponds and comprehensive storm water plans since the Clean Water Act of 1972....
You've obviously never had the pleasure of dealing with your local CAMA office either....
Your narrative of runoff from parking lots dumping directly into our coastal waters is a false one.
I'd be glad to post as many pics as you're want to look at of that EXACT thing happening in real time. This past week was a great one for just such a pic hunt. I promise I won't put any goggle images on there. Only pics I take. Go to main street shallotte and watch for yourself. There is jack sh!t between parking lots and the river itself. Drain pipes hang over the water all the way up as far as is navagable.
CC says some of the most polarizing and troll like stuff on here but I'll give him this, at least he says what he means. Call a spade a spade. Im just a little confused though CC. Are we feeding our greed or are we all below the poverty line? May be we're just wanna be greedy? You must be the nicest person. I guess you still want me to take you in a friend's home so you can copy their old commercial fishing pictures? And surely not for any nefarious purposes....I can certainly see where you'd have a genuine interest in such material. You really must think I'm an idiot or something. Checks aren't enough now you gotta help 'em make posters and bill boards? You really put the CC in CCA.
Your narrative of runoff from parking lots dumping directly into our coastal waters is a false one.
Oh really?
http://www.nccleanwater.org/pdf/backyard.pdf
http://www.neuseriver.org/neuseissuesandfacts/fishkillsintheneuse.html
http://www.neuseriver.org/images/Neuse_River_MER_2007_Final.pdf opens with:
"It would be hard to match the damage done to
the waters of the Neuse River by massive hog
operations in the watershed, but if developers
get their way, human sewage, stormwater
runoff and habitat destruction could earn that
dubious distinction. With sprawling coastal
development creeping inland, and urban
growth in the headwaters, the Neuse is the
new frontier for poorly planned development."
http://portal.ncdenr.org/web/wq/neuse-stormwater-rule Law required multiple local and county governments to implement storm water run-off plans because runoff is a PROBLEM.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/11995863 gives this in the abstract:
"The average total nitrogen, phosphorus, and sediment export from the three land uses was, respectively, 269, 302, and 256% greater than the corresponding exports from the wooded site, which was considered similar to the predevelopment land use."
The three land uses they are describing are DEVELOPED lands: single family residential, golf course and construction site. Do you see that single family residential (permanent installation) pollution exports were greater than for the construction site (a temporary condition)?
In 2003, it was reported by the EPA that agricultural non-point source pollution had been dramatically reduced due to better farming practices, but that report did not address reduction in urban non-point sources such as outlined in the above NIH report. http://water.epa.gov/polwaste/nps/success319/nc_neu.cfm
NC DMF Shrimp Fisheries Management Plan:
Page 46: "Perhaps the most serious threat to
the stocks is loss of habitat due to pollution or physical alteration."
Pages 156-166 also provide interesting reading.
I could go on, but that's enough and it's late.
The assertion that development (and its subsequent runoff) habitat destruction is not a factor in estuarine systems is patently absurd.
I'll be happy if they just cut out recreational gigging
what's good for the goose is also good for the gander, so that should mean you would be good with ending all gigging, I'm good with that too, if it means saving the flounder population,
I could even live with making flounder a "game fish", since it is definately the one of the most sought after fish, probably the most sought after fish by the general public.
Well, we know we are flirting with insanity when we consider eliminating the most selective harvest device (gig) on the water. And we trump that by considering gamefish status for flounder??? I'm not goinng to elaborate on either but I hear both points more and more and I can't understand the logic.
, probably the most sought after fish by the general public.
And definitely the most sought after by the seafood eating public.
Quick question: Do you guys think more people come here to the coast to catch fish or to eat fish? I'm gonna say from the stuffed parking lots of the hundreds of seafood restaraunts from myrtle beach all the way to wilmington that more come to eat than to catch. Looking over one of the tourist coupon books last night from the welcome center at state line and the number of seafood rest. tix outnumbers (all) fishing related tix by ratio of ten to one. I wonder if, when some of you quantify how much more money is spent on sport fishing vs comm fishing, if these dollar amounts are considered. I don't think they look past the docks when compiling comm numbers. But when explaining all of the money pouring into the community from fishermen they count their boats (almost certainly not bought in coastal communities where prices are much higher) Their trucks to pull the boat down here (also not bought here in most cases). They like to make out like every dime they spend is benefitting the community when in reality all they buy here is gas and ice. I think the real numbers (if it were possible to quantify everything together) would tell a different story. There's a lot of hands that make money and pay taxes on comm caught fish before it is ultimately ingested by the consumer. They'd have you believe that the little bit the fisherman makes at the dock is all that is contributed by the industry but it's not true.
Fun fact: Inshore trawling produces almost all of the live bait shrimp being sold at coastal bait shops. There's an awful lot of FPT members looking for these during the season. I'd bet some of the same ones decrying this act are supporting it financially.
eric 13 - you are right about considering more causes than just inside trawling and gill nets being responsible for declining quality of fishing in NC. For instance, water quality is of course a factor. Continuing to pay attention to and maintain water quality would be smart. Instituting daily catch limits in concert with the state / condition of the fishery is also smart, helps protect the resource we all own and needs to be done.
If you believe poor water quality, unreasonable catch limits or other issues contribute to the problem more than inside trawling or gill nets, I would like to be better educated to that perspective. I would not be closed minded enough to dismiss any potential cause for the harm being done to our resource. Often we do not have the luxury of identifying the total package of causes to a problem and addressing them all at once. At the end of the day action needs to happen and happen now because the resource is bleeding to death. I do not hold myself out as an expert biologist, eco system expert, expert social scientist or expert fisherman. I am just one person with a good track record of critical thinking who believes it is obvious inside trawling and gill nets are the largest causes of our resource bleeding to death. While there indeed may be other contributing factors that we identify and act on - the obvious slaughter of life from inside trawling jumps out at me as the place to start. Just my non expert opinion.
If you believe poor water quality, unreasonable catch limits or other issues contribute to the problem more than inside trawling or gill nets, I would like to be better educated to that perspective. I would not be closed minded enough to dismiss any potential cause for the harm being done to our resource. Often we do not have the luxury of identifying the total package of causes to a problem and addressing them all at once. At the end of the day action needs to happen and happen now because the resource is bleeding to death. I do not hold myself out as an expert biologist, eco system expert, expert social scientist or expert fisherman. I am just one person with a good track record of critical thinking who believes it is obvious inside trawling and gill nets are the largest causes of our resource bleeding to death. While there indeed may be other contributing factors that we identify and act on - the obvious slaughter of life from inside trawling jumps out at me as the place to start. Just my non expert opinion.
My hat is off to you for a good post.
The problem with trying to discuss fishery issues in general (this is not aimed at you!) is that it has become so politicized and too many people DON'T have an open mind to even hear alternatives or look at the full scope of the problems.
Combine that with the fact that at least some folks with the strongest opinions (not facts) and flinging insults at others don't fish much (if at all) and/or don't fish in NC much (if at all).
The comparisons to other states, specifically regarding flounder, is specious at best. NC has unique fishery management issues and these have been well documented by DMF and related organizations. Lumping solutions into one or two small, pat sounding "solutions" is a fool's game, yet we seemingly continue to want to play it.
Mention season closures, limit changes or even just improved recreational harvest data and watch the crap storm that follows. The answers too often are "it's not ME, it's the OTHER GUY." That has to stop or there will be no progress.
I'm here on this forum to learn, but I can also read the official reports and studies, and I can also understand the data I read. I find it insulting and offensive some of the remarks made in these discussions. Again, that comment is not aimed at you, par4b.
Together we stand, divided we fall, and all that. "They" (someone) is doing do mighty fine job dividing fishermen in North Carolina.
This data, shared with me by a friend this morning, will hopefully be an eye-opener for some.
Did you know....of the 441,614 pounds of Red Drum that were sold commercially from all states in America that 371,989 pounds came from NC, or 84% of the ENTIRE US market?
Did you know....of the 2,276,420 pounds of southern flounder that were sold commercially from all states in America that 2,186,261 pounds came from NC, or 96% of the ENTIRE US market?
Did you know....of the 541,818 pounds of speckled trout that were sold commercially from all states in the US that 367,663 pounds came from NC, or 67% of the ENTIRE US COMMERCIAL MARKET?
Note: from NMFS 2013 commercial landings as reported by each state.
This data, shared with me by a friend this morning, will hopefully be an eye-opener for some.
Did you know....of the 441,614 pounds of Red Drum that were sold commercially from all states in America that 371,989 pounds came from NC, or 84% of the ENTIRE US market?
Did you know....of the 2,276,420 pounds of southern flounder that were sold commercially from all states in America that 2,186,261 pounds came from NC, or 96% of the ENTIRE US market?
Did you know....of the 541,818 pounds of speckled trout that were sold commercially from all states in the US that 367,663 pounds came from NC, or 67% of the ENTIRE US COMMERCIAL MARKET?
Note: from NMFS 2013 commercial landings as reported by each state.
That is interesting.
So, we can conclude commercial fishing in NC is important to the US seafood economy.
Good to know. Thanks. I had seen some data related to 'top lists' and such, but not broken down like this.
This data, shared with me by a friend this morning, will hopefully be an eye-opener for some.
Did you know....of the 441,614 pounds of Red Drum that were sold commercially from all states in America that 371,989 pounds came from NC, or 84% of the ENTIRE US market?
Did you know....of the 2,276,420 pounds of southern flounder that were sold commercially from all states in America that 2,186,261 pounds came from NC, or 96% of the ENTIRE US market?
Did you know....of the 541,818 pounds of speckled trout that were sold commercially from all states in the US that 367,663 pounds came from NC, or 67% of the ENTIRE US COMMERCIAL MARKET?
Note: from NMFS 2013 commercial landings as reported by each state.
That is interesting.
So, we can conclude commercial fishing in NC is important to the US seafood economy.
Good to know. Thanks. I had seen some data related to 'top lists' and such, but not broken down like this.
Another sign that North Carolina Fisheries managers are some of the best in the country. Being able to manage resources in a way that can supply healthy wild seafood to the masses and also leave enough of the resource behind to satisfy the anglers who enjoy fishing as a recreational activity.
The best of both worlds and very good use of the resources our creator has provided.