SWC Forums
Pull up a chair...let's talk fishing.
Based on posts by these highly successful businessmen, it appears that there may be an inverse relationship between an individual's business acumen and his skills as an angler.
I guess it shows that everyone has his niche, but nobody is good at everything they try.
So the better fisherman you are the worse businessman you are? Which is the case with the above statement. If that's true then one would wonder how there are any profitable commercial fisherman. The more fish you catch the more money you loose?
Can't convince a man who's already got his mind made up. It's a shame that so many are willing to scrap an entire culture for their convictions. That said, I'd do the same. My convictions tell me that thousands of monopoly houses built on our beaches and water fronts for several decades now are having the biggest impact, and like you, nothing will change my mind about that. And like you, I'm willing to scrap an entire culture (elitist beach front living) for the resource.
Big difference is that a couple hundred commercial fishermen can't afford to make enough noise in their favor where as elitist beach front dwellers have nothing but money and time to burn. I believe that most people agree with me but would rather give up availability of seafood to others than their boat slip on the water. Tell you what, just for kicks, put two or three drops of motor oil in your salt water aquarium and see what happens to the fish inside. Now think about what a storm drain dumps in the ICW every time it rains and what's in that......yea, definitely the nets...
Look at the entire east and gulf coast of the United States. There are lots and lots of beachfront houses everywhere. If anything, NC likely has a smaller percentage of waterfront land occupied by development than most, on account of the two national seashores and a couple of military installations. Commercial trawling in inland waters however, is just here in NC.
So where are we supposed to think the differences in fisheries really is?
Here is the way I look at it. We are regulated heavily on the fish we catch. One Red Drum, 13 inch sea bass, so on and so forth. If they regulate us to ONE flounder, WE LET IT HAPPEN TO US!!!! The people own the fisheries NOT THE GOVERNMENT!!! If we don't stand up to the bullies now, they will continue to push and push till fishing is illegal or worse...
You guys have this mis-guided idea that a gill net has a vacuum cleaner motor on it or something. I truly wish it was as easy as setting the net indiscriminately and waiting for it to suck all the fish in the area up. It's an impossible to solve problem because it's not about fish or stock assessments or any of that. It's about human emotion. It's about the way a man feels when he sees another man with what he wants but has trouble getting. One man spends a lot of money on a boat and tackle (this has been posted lots of times as "evidence") has high expectations about how it'll work out but soon finds that fishing on the inside waters of NC is very challenging. He remembers how it was when he was a kid...(when I think back on childhood fishing memories, I tend to remember the good times and not the skunk days) and then he sees a commercial netter go by with a nice haul of the fish he just happens to be out there trying for. EUREKA! a light bulb goes on in his head and he suddenly knows what the problem is. "It's not m,e after all..." he thinks after doubting himself all morning. Struggling to justify all the money he spent (either to himself or to his wife) he becomes completely convinced that had he beat that netter out this morning, he'd have caught all those fish instead. He completely ignores the fact that the netter (in most cases) has been fishing these waters his entire life and had been (in a lot of cases) been shown by his father and grand father even, how and where to catch these fish. Twenty years later, the spots and techniques still pay off. He hasn't spent x amount of dollars on gulp lures and graphite rods etc..,instead he spent countless miserable hours in the worst weather and conditions honing that skill. The man who spent thousands or tens of thousands on all that equipment feels like the state owes him something for that investment. He feels like he's been let down by those who watch over the fish because his money hasn't paid off the way he planned. Most humans (especially successful ones with 20k to spend on said equipment) don't like admitting their failures or short comings and will most often look for someone or something else to blame. Not just fishermen but in all walks of life. The charter guys who have been the driving force behind most of these gamefish bills would change their tunes pretty quick if gamefish were only legal for those who don't profit in ANY WAY from those fish. If they were considered comm (as they should be) then gamefish wouldn't be such a great idea. They like it because it's a windfall for them. $$$$$$$$$$$ What it's all about.
That one takes the award for longest-winded way of saying "you all don't know how to fish" I've ever seen.
I'm not doubting that a lot of commercial guys have a wealth of knowledge and skill, but to insinuate that they are the only ones who know how to catch fish is a joke.
I know several folks who are very skilled flounder anglers with enough hours spent chasing flatfish to wear out a few outboards. One of them even has a commercial license. Even for him a limit of legal-sized flounder in the box usually means that he went to the right place at the right time of year, on the right tide, in the right type of weather, and had a bit of luck as well. Sometimes this happens but most times it doesn't and he ends up with between one and three nice fish per day.
His level of competence isn't the problem, the fact that the fishery is depleted by inshore trawling bycatches is the problem. I know firsthand, I happen to own a recreational trawl net and am very aware of the bycatch volumes we realize most times we go out and the number of dead juvenile flounder that I've personally returned to the water. They can easily number in the multiple hundreds per night, and this is with a small 15-foot net dragged behind a skiff. This isn't even mentioning the numerous other species.
Look at the entire east and gulf coast of the United States. There are lots and lots of beachfront houses everywhere. If anything, NC likely has a smaller percentage of waterfront land occupied by development than most, on account of the two national seashores and a couple of military installations. Commercial trawling in inland waters however, is just here in NC.
So where are we supposed to think the differences in fisheries really is?
NC is not other states. It's not development RIGHT on the coast that is the only issue. We have these huge things...the Sounds...all along the coast. They collect a LOT of water from enormous watersheds.
There is a large body of literature available showing that development throughout these watersheds impacts water quality and fish stocks. Sorry if you don't believe that, but that does not make the science untrue.
Is that "the cause" of ALL fishing woes in NC? I don't know; but it IS a real problem that should not be ignored by anyone that claims to be arguing "for the resource."
Let's put ALL the cards on the table and have a rational discussion. The problems NC faces relates to nets, but not just nets; it's inshore trawling, but not just inshore trawling; it's rec overpressure, but not just rec overpressure; it's water quality and ecosystem damage, but not just those things. And, it's probably a few more not included on that list.
The reality is this is a VERY complicated issue (or more accurately, set of inter-related issues), and all the nonsense about "just do this and all will magically be fixed" is just that....nonsense.
There's a lot of "opinion." Opinions don't solve problems. Ignoring the science of water quality and ecosystem pressures because it does not fit one's personal narrative or some set of selfish interests does nothing to help anything.
How many among us are voluntarily giving up fishing to protect the resource? For a year, say? Anyone? Is protecting the resource the real priority or not?
There's a ton of "I want mine; it's the other guy that should give up what HE'S doing."
I'll be happy if they just cut out recreational gigging
Fishingtheneuse, in my opinion, is starting to get on the right track! There are tons of problems out there, pollution, overfishing, habitat distruction etc.
I spoke with a gentleman today that when prompted with the problem suggested what I would refer to as the deer tag approach. Tags are x $'s per tag. Catch all you want as long as you have a tag. The revenues recieved from the tags have to go back into the resource.
This thread could turn into something positive if both sides would suggest solutions.
Eric, you have not suggested a solution as of yet other than get rid of the beach houses. Come on if you have as many hours on the water as you suggest, you surely have a way to make the fishery better.
Matt
delete
Ok jward87 are you ok with cutting commercial gigging?
I think that gigging, at least the way I have done it in the past is one of the "cleanest" fisheries around.
Matt
I never said get rid of all the beach houses. The damage as far as that goes is already done. But the storm water run offs don't have to dump directly into the river and ICW. They could design retaining ponds or the like to leach some of this crap out of the water before it runs back to where the fish lay. I'm not saying that anything could ever be done about the problems I've proposed because there's too much $$$ at stake. But I won't sit and listen as people I know and work shoulder to shoulder with are rail roaded and berated by a bunch of arm chair experts. Y'all say my only point is development, well your only point (not one but all of you) is why can't NC be TX or why can't it be FL or LA? and then look down your nose at me and proclaim to KNOW that there's one simple answer to the whole she bang.....get rid of nets. I still wanna know why TX hasn't caught up with Alaska yet, even as Alaska allows more comm gear and participation than any other state in the nation? How can this be when it's so obvious that comm gear is destroying fish faster than they can swim out of it's way. Allow me to answer for you: Texas aint Alaska.....and NC aint Texas. Take every net in the state and melt down the lead and make fish attractors out of them all and it still won't be Florida. The only issue here is "how many fish can I keep?" and "how many does he get to keep?"
par4b - You'd be forced to consider other causes as well if you had comm representatives on your board of directors. Fortunately, we are not governed by a dictatorship whose own interests are it's compass.
Not to beat it to death but you know what they aint got a lot of in Alaska? water front development. Or any kind of development for that matter.....jus sayin'.
I'll be happy if they just cut out recreational gigging
Why?
Go to the landing and look at nitetime you see ten or more trucks most the time there will be three head in the boat now say everyone catch their limit that 240 flounder a nite. Now let me ask this what has change since let say ten years ago to cause the drop in the flounder population how many new recreational anglers are there now I can guarantee a lot more they commercial fishernman
But the storm water run offs don't have to dump directly into the river and ICW. They could design retaining ponds or the like to leach some of this crap out of the water before it runs back to where the fish lay.
"They" have been designing retaining ponds and comprehensive storm water plans since the Clean Water Act of 1972....
You've obviously never had the pleasure of dealing with your local CAMA office either....
Your narrative of runoff from parking lots dumping directly into our coastal waters is a false one.