SWC Forums

Pull up a chair...let's talk fishing.

Flounder Fishing ??...
 
Notifications
Clear all

Flounder Fishing ??? Is it History for the Rec Fisherman

212 Posts
36 Users
0 Reactions
6,242 Views
Bob
 Bob
(@)
Reputable Member
Joined: 16 years ago
Posts: 331
 

Hatcheries are for states that can't manage their resources. Fortunately North Carolina has done a good job of managing our natural resources with limited supplemental stocking and in doing so has created a wonderful sport fishing destination while also maintaining a viable commercial fishery. The best of both worlds and pretty much all with wild natural fish.



   
ReplyQuote
John Riley
(@)
Estimable Member
Joined: 12 years ago
Posts: 172
 

Curious as to how you feel about non-resident tourists visiting NC. Should they be allowed to fish for "our fish"? If they catch any can they take them home?Should they be able to buy our fish from a restaurant or fish monger?

I think there is a big difference between what you are describing and what is mostly meant by keeping NC fish in NC.

A non-resident tourist would need to buy a NC license to fish here for "our fish." Of course they can take home what they catch.

If they buy from a restaurant or fish monger, the fish was sold in NC commerce.

The issue is not the "end user" but where the potential economic benefits are going to go. I think the argument is that commercial caught NC fish going to markets (restaurants and fish mongers) in other states where those are the economies benefitted.

I welcome being corrected if that's not right; that's how I read it, anyway.



   
ReplyQuote
Matt Wood
(@)
Honorable Member
Joined: 22 years ago
Posts: 534
 

Good question crabman00.

As I understand it, an out of state license is more expensive than for residents.
That price difference is the very basis for my suggestion. It has been stated in this thread that many of the fish are leaving the state.

If we can keep the local resource local, and obtain more revenue for the resource when it leaves the state, we can then funnel that extra revenue back into the resource.

And yes I have set a net before. Please note that I haven't said ban, banish, or restrict any type of fishing.

Matt



   
ReplyQuote
Bob
 Bob
(@)
Reputable Member
Joined: 16 years ago
Posts: 331
 

Curious as to how you feel about non-resident tourists visiting NC. Should they be allowed to fish for "our fish"? If they catch any can they take them home?Should they be able to buy our fish from a restaurant or fish monger?

I think there is a big difference between what you are describing and what is mostly meant by keeping NC fish in NC.

A non-resident tourist would need to buy a NC license to fish here for "our fish." Of course they can take home what they catch.

If they buy from a restaurant or fish monger, the fish was sold in NC commerce.

The issue is not the "end user" but where the potential economic benefits are going to go. I think the argument is that commercial caught NC fish going to markets (restaurants and fish mongers) in other states where those are the economies benefitted.

I welcome being corrected if that's not right; that's how I read it, anyway.

I would guess that one reason for shipping fish out of state would be to produce a greater economic benefit to the distributor doing the shipping. If all states felt the way some of you do, most of us would never have tasted fresh wild salmon, sea scallops, atlantic cod, crab legs, stone crab claws, etc. Luckily those states are willing to share "their" food with us.



   
ReplyQuote
Matt Wood
(@)
Honorable Member
Joined: 22 years ago
Posts: 534
 

So Crabman, what is your opinion on the proposed changes to the flounder fishery?

What would you suggest they do different if anything?

Matt



   
ReplyQuote
Mark Clapp
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 21 years ago
Posts: 979
 

Just curious if anyone can submit statistical evidence that there is better fishing in these other states that "have it figured out".

I ask this because I've fished Florida, SC, and Texas and have not really noticed that those states were better fishing than NC. Talking about inshore/inside fishing.

P.S. Statistical evidence would preferably include C.P.U.E. detail

You use your personal opinion of other states so I will use mine. The inshore fishing in Florida around Stuart is awesome compared to the Wilmington area.

I bought a new bay boat to try inshore fishing as the ride to the gulf stream was getting tiresome. I had the boat for less than 2 years after investing in tons of tackle for specks and whatever else worth eating I could catch.

After putting time in to find where the fish hold up, I found a netter would go thru and take all the fish essentially ruining the area for some time. Since I mainly use my boat for fishing, I saw no point in keeping it after putting all the time in and competing with netters.

I'm sure the fishing is better north around Sneads Ferry, but I was trying to get away from 60 mile runs to catch fish.

If the netters hadn't ruined the few places where fish hole up, I would have kept the boat. That is one specific example of how commercial netting has affected my fishing. I'm not the best fisherman, but I'm not into fishing all day with nothing to show for it.

Spin away.



   
ReplyQuote
Glen Montgomery
(@)
Reputable Member
Joined: 16 years ago
Posts: 284
 

The weather around Stuart is also a little different along with the water conditions. Last time I was in shallow water near Wilmington the engine was kicking up old fuel that was embedded in the bottom sediment,. Looked like I had dumped 20 gallons of fuel behind my boat by the time I got back in to a little deeper waters. I would not have that problem in Stuart Florida.



   
ReplyQuote
eric broome
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 19 years ago
Posts: 1299
 

You guys have this mis-guided idea that a gill net has a vacuum cleaner motor on it or something. I truly wish it was as easy as setting the net indiscriminately and waiting for it to suck all the fish in the area up. It's an impossible to solve problem because it's not about fish or stock assessments or any of that. It's about human emotion. It's about the way a man feels when he sees another man with what he wants but has trouble getting. One man spends a lot of money on a boat and tackle (this has been posted lots of times as "evidence") has high expectations about how it'll work out but soon finds that fishing on the inside waters of NC is very challenging. He remembers how it was when he was a kid...(when I think back on childhood fishing memories, I tend to remember the good times and not the skunk days) and then he sees a commercial netter go by with a nice haul of the fish he just happens to be out there trying for. EUREKA! a light bulb goes on in his head and he suddenly knows what the problem is. "It's not m,e after all..." he thinks after doubting himself all morning. Struggling to justify all the money he spent (either to himself or to his wife) he becomes completely convinced that had he beat that netter out this morning, he'd have caught all those fish instead. He completely ignores the fact that the netter (in most cases) has been fishing these waters his entire life and had been (in a lot of cases) been shown by his father and grand father even, how and where to catch these fish. Twenty years later, the spots and techniques still pay off. He hasn't spent x amount of dollars on gulp lures and graphite rods etc..,instead he spent countless miserable hours in the worst weather and conditions honing that skill. The man who spent thousands or tens of thousands on all that equipment feels like the state owes him something for that investment. He feels like he's been let down by those who watch over the fish because his money hasn't paid off the way he planned. Most humans (especially successful ones with 20k to spend on said equipment) don't like admitting their failures or short comings and will most often look for someone or something else to blame. Not just fishermen but in all walks of life. The charter guys who have been the driving force behind most of these gamefish bills would change their tunes pretty quick if gamefish were only legal for those who don't profit in ANY WAY from those fish. If they were considered comm (as they should be) then gamefish wouldn't be such a great idea. They like it because it's a windfall for them. $$$$$$$$$$$ What it's all about.



   
ReplyQuote
Bob
 Bob
(@)
Reputable Member
Joined: 16 years ago
Posts: 331
 

So Crabman, what is your opinion on the proposed changes to the flounder fishery?

What would you suggest they do different if anything?

Matt

Of the options presented I would choose number four.
If I was king and got to call the shots, I would also formulate a total allowable catch for the commercial sector.



   
ReplyQuote
Glen Montgomery
(@)
Reputable Member
Joined: 16 years ago
Posts: 284
 

Great post eric13



   
ReplyQuote
Ed
 Ed
(@aftergolf)
Famed Member
Joined: 23 years ago
Posts: 2170
 

The commercial guys can rant and rave all they want but when one side gets reduced to one fish per trip like has been done with the red drum something has to give. It cannot continually be one side that takes it up the rear end each and every time!
The committee needs to look to solve the problems in an equally distributed way without taking and taking from the recreational fishermen who provide the lions share of all of the money spent for tourism in the eastern part of the state!



   
ReplyQuote
Bob
 Bob
(@)
Reputable Member
Joined: 16 years ago
Posts: 331
 

Keep in mind that the MFC is not limited to the DMF recommended options presented in the OP.
Maybe they will develop and agree to another option. The mfc is the group holding the hammer.
Write to them and let them know how you feel.



   
ReplyQuote
Robert Martin Jr
(@par4b)
Eminent Member
Joined: 20 years ago
Posts: 32
 

I grew up in the mountains trout fishing and purchased a home in MHC ten years ago and began my saltwater experience. I do not have decades of saltwater fishing experience, but I do have one decade and yes, I know how to fish. The inside fishing has most definitely declined since I first moved here. During my working career I was a pretty good businessman and ran a successful manufacturing company with product sold all over the world. Over time, many seemingly complex problems crossed my desk and the desks of the leadership team. These problems needed to be addressed in a timely manner to insure continued health of the business. Upon thoughtful and intense investigation it was and is still amazing to me the vast majority of problems appearing to be complex and very complicated were rooted in a clear and simple cause. After intense investigation and discovery, solutions that were not all that complex and difficult to see also emerged.

I have spent ten years reading and considering discussions such as this one. If my team were running this show and all facts were put into the mix including legacy, way of life, economic impact, past studies, ownership of a resource, experience and practices of other states etc., the clear cause of the problem and the solution in NC is apparent. if one is not emotionally invested or politically invested in the problem and or solution, the cause and solution is clear. Inside trawling and gill nets are the cause. The number one cause is likely inside trawling.

A business management team cannot kick the can down the road for long. In order to keep the company alive and in the end insure their own job, problems need to be identified in a timely manner and action taken to correct the problem. Politicians and bureaucrats have the luxury of endless studies and debate because tax dollars will always flow to fund themselves and their studies. A company must act or bleed to death from the problem. North Carolina fishing is bleeding to death from inside trawling and gill nets. Unfortunately, politicians are the gatekeepers of change in this case. As with any political involvement - decide for yourself what the problem and solution is and then call, write and vote to prevent bleeding to death.



   
ReplyQuote
Mark Clapp
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 21 years ago
Posts: 979
 

I grew up in the mountains trout fishing and purchased a home in MHC ten years ago and began my saltwater experience. I do not have decades of saltwater fishing experience, but I do have one decade and yes, I know how to fish. The inside fishing has most definitely declined since I first moved here. During my working career I was a pretty good businessman and ran a successful manufacturing company with product sold all over the world. Over time, many seemingly complex problems crossed my desk and the desks of the leadership team. These problems needed to be addressed in a timely manner to insure continued health of the business. Upon thoughtful and intense investigation it was and is still amazing to me the vast majority of problems appearing to be complex and very complicated were rooted in a clear and simple cause. After intense investigation and discovery, solutions that were not all that complex and difficult to see also emerged.

I have spent ten years reading and considering discussions such as this one. If my team were running this show and all facts were put into the mix including legacy, way of life, economic impact, past studies, ownership of a resource, experience and practices of other states etc., the clear cause of the problem and the solution in NC is apparent. if one is not emotionally invested or politically invested in the problem and or solution, the cause and solution is clear. Inside trawling and gill nets are the cause. The number one cause is likely inside trawling.

A business management team cannot kick the can down the road for long. In order to keep the company alive and in the end insure their own job, problems need to be identified in a timely manner and action taken to correct the problem. Politicians and bureaucrats have the luxury of endless studies and debate because tax dollars will always flow to fund themselves and their studies. A company must act or bleed to death from the problem. North Carolina fishing is bleeding to death from inside trawling and gill nets. Unfortunately, politicians are the gatekeepers of change in this case. As with any political involvement - decide for yourself what the problem and solution is and then call, write and vote to prevent bleeding to death.

Bravo! Nice to be in the "no spin zone". Facts are just spun by people like Eric calling the person "incompetent" and blaming others.

As a businessman myself who worked his a$$ off and retired in my 40's by hitting the big time in several venues, quitter is not in my vocabulary.

Now, going to a known speck hole and seeing a netter drag it thus making it unproductive, and knowing said netter knows where all the holes are, I would rather waste my time somewhere else or go back to gulfstream fishing - which I am doing. No netters out there.

It won't change until the commercial biased board is replaced.



   
ReplyQuote
Sea Cern
(@)
Estimable Member
Joined: 13 years ago
Posts: 172
 

I grew up in the mountains trout fishing and purchased a home in MHC ten years ago and began my saltwater experience. I do not have decades of saltwater fishing experience, but I do have one decade and yes, I know how to fish. The inside fishing has most definitely declined since I first moved here. During my working career I was a pretty good businessman and ran a successful manufacturing company with product sold all over the world. Over time, many seemingly complex problems crossed my desk and the desks of the leadership team. These problems needed to be addressed in a timely manner to insure continued health of the business. Upon thoughtful and intense investigation it was and is still amazing to me the vast majority of problems appearing to be complex and very complicated were rooted in a clear and simple cause. After intense investigation and discovery, solutions that were not all that complex and difficult to see also emerged.

I have spent ten years reading and considering discussions such as this one. If my team were running this show and all facts were put into the mix including legacy, way of life, economic impact, past studies, ownership of a resource, experience and practices of other states etc., the clear cause of the problem and the solution in NC is apparent. if one is not emotionally invested or politically invested in the problem and or solution, the cause and solution is clear. Inside trawling and gill nets are the cause. The number one cause is likely inside trawling.

A business management team cannot kick the can down the road for long. In order to keep the company alive and in the end insure their own job, problems need to be identified in a timely manner and action taken to correct the problem. Politicians and bureaucrats have the luxury of endless studies and debate because tax dollars will always flow to fund themselves and their studies. A company must act or bleed to death from the problem. North Carolina fishing is bleeding to death from inside trawling and gill nets. Unfortunately, politicians are the gatekeepers of change in this case. As with any political involvement - decide for yourself what the problem and solution is and then call, write and vote to prevent bleeding to death.

Truer words have never been spoken.

Watch the news this week for the NCWF to address these issues. Everyone reading par4b's post who wishes to do something to help can start here-

http://www.ncwf.org/soundsolutions

http://www.ncwf.org/images/docs/A8_050115.pdf

"Work on the Sound Solutions Campaign began last year. Mr. Knight said it rose out of the federation’s efforts to address commercial bycatch – fish being caught incidentally to the targeted species – in commercial fishing, particularlywith shrimp trawlers."



   
ReplyQuote
Page 5 / 15
Share: