SWC Forums
Pull up a chair...let's talk fishing.
Quickfix please note they I said all fish caught and landed in the state waters. I know that we can't stop a SC boat from fishing in Federal waters off of NC and taking the, back to SC. As much as I hate regulations, something can be done to help keep our local fish houses and restaurants supplied with local seafood.
The reason that I started commenting on an obviously touchy topic is the fact that there is a proposal to cut the rec flounder take by 80%. I would dare to guess that if that happens commercial fishing will take the blame.
Out of all of the views and comments on this topic only three constructive ideas have been given. Reduce pollution, aquaculture and stocking, and regulation of where the fish can be sold.
This may be one of our last chances to ensure "our fish", both recreational and commercial, stays ours, and the decisions made are not handed over to someone that is ridding a desk chair, or lining his or her pockets.
I know there are other ideas out there so offer them up. (As long as they are constructive!)
Matt
wonder why the article that matador posted about Texas banning nets fully restoring their red, trout and flounder fishery conveniently made no mention about the many fish hatcheries that the great state of Texas found itself resorting to in order to restore their fishing. Folks, this is not so much about restoring NC fishing as much as it is to simply rid NC of most types of commercial fishing.
Do you know who is credited with all those Texas hatcheries? Yeah, and I still don't like'em. There were other states mentioned as well that don't run hatcheries.
The solution I am promoting would split the potential Hatchery Supported Quotas evenly between recreational anglers and seafood consumers. Each sector would be responsible for funding their HSQ through license fees along with the Dingell-Johnson tax on the rec side and Saltonstall-Kennedy tax on the commercial side. Many recreational fishermen want bag limits that are high enough to offset the expense of going fishing with fresh seafood. There are also a lot of people who want to eat local seafood, but can't or don't want to catch their own. Stocking is a great alternative to industrial fish farms for producing food and recreational opportunity.
OK,,, you want recs and those that pay to raise the fish and buy the fish to pay ~~ all to satisfy your greed! Farm raise them for consumers it is a much more cost effective.
More BS, recs will take a 60% reduction if comms do and all on the same size limit. The ocean would rise 2' from comm tears if that went into effect! It never stops~~ NC fish are brought to NC docks where it is sold north and south with little staying here.
Florida has hatcheries. What do you have against hatcheries Matador? Most of the striped bass in the inside waters of NC got their start at the Federal hatchery up in Edenton, N.C.. If the truth were told, hatcheries would give NC rec fishermen the most bang for their bucks. Some recs have opposed hatcheries cause they can not live with the thought that a commercial might catch one of the fish from those hatcheries. Put some type of permanent dye on one of the fins and pass a law that these marked fish can not be sold. That ought to solve that problem.
Cant do this of course until all the nets are gone since if the hatchery idea was to work and provide much needed fish then a certain rec group would probably lose their argument as to how important it is for Nc to ban most commercial nets.
For those of you that are upset about the rec bag limits and the different min size on southern flounder, well those options were the ones that were chosen by rec representatives appointed to the southern flounder committee so don't blame commercials on this one. Some times the enemy are the ones that are patting you are the back and pretending to be your friends. That's all I have to say about that for now.
Quickfix please note they I said all fish caught and landed in the state waters. I know that we can't stop a SC boat from fishing in Federal waters off of NC and taking the, back to SC. As much as I hate regulations, something can be done to help keep our local fish houses and restaurants supplied with local seafood.
The reason that I started commenting on an obviously touchy topic is the fact that there is a proposal to cut the rec flounder take by 80%. I would dare to guess that if that happens commercial fishing will take the blame.
Out of all of the views and comments on this topic only three constructive ideas have been given. Reduce pollution, aquaculture and stocking, and regulation of where the fish can be sold.
This may be one of our last chances to ensure "our fish", both recreational and commercial, stays ours, and the decisions made are not handed over to someone that is ridding a desk chair, or lining his or her pockets.
I know there are other ideas out there so offer them up. (As long as they are constructive!)
Matt
Divnnc - with all due respect, you stated caught OR landed in NC and included the grouper snapper complex! These are federal fish managed by SAFMC no matter what state they are landed in. These fish are not "our" fish rather they are everyone's fish! Managing the fishery has nothing to do with where they end up on a plate. Just pointing out that they have nothing to do with flounder in NC and the management there of.
back lash. Where did you come up with the one fish creel limit?
I am not sure, and can't look it up at the moment, but I seem to remember some of the gulf states changing their "boundaries" so the state could regulate the black bass fishery inside of state waters.
I beg to differ on who has the right to manage the fish, if the fish come from our waters I do not want to give up control of the management of the resource to someone that doesn't live here.
True, grouper snapper have little to do with the flounder fishery, but we as fishing community need a comprehensive plan to manage the resource. You know as well as I do, the increase in the pressure on flounder is because of the reduction of allowable take on drum and trout. Same for offshore fish.
Gahivar go back and read the first post again, it is about 2/3rds of the way down. (I had to go back and re-read just to believe it!!)
Another suggestion, to pay for the stocking of fish, tax any and all fish landed in NC and shipped out of state.
So more views, more posts, and no new ideas. Don't complain when these changes are put into a proclamation that you have to fish by.
Matt
divnnc "Another suggestion, to pay for the stocking of fish, tax any and all fish landed in NC and shipped out of state." a very good suggestion that the NCFA would never permit the legislature to put into effect. The commercial industry does not want to pay for anything.
Coastal development does not have an impact on the fisheries in other states. That is a dead argument.
Parody with other state is where it's at. They seem to have figured it out.
Why is NC so slow to learn?
As a recreational fisherman, I've always been happy with catch and release. I believe I'll still be able to catch all the flounder I can and still fulfill my roll as a rec fisherman. Though I do like to keep and eat a fish now and then, the big part of fishing for me is the catchin'.
Hell, I fly out to Montana and spend big $$$$$$ to float a river and catch trout that I have no intention of keeping even if it was allowed, so I doubt that removing harvest opportunity from true recreational fishermen is going to stop them from fishing our coastal area.
Just curious if anyone can submit statistical evidence that there is better fishing in these other states that "have it figured out".
I ask this because I've fished Florida, SC, and Texas and have not really noticed that those states were better fishing than NC. Talking about inshore/inside fishing.
P.S. Statistical evidence would preferably include C.P.U.E. detail
the hatchery is a good approach, except I believe that it is already in use, don't a bunch of school kids release flounder from time to time up in Davis Canal,
http://fryingpantower.com/ftopict-25733-.html
then they ease out to the "red banks" where the waterway trawler takes care of that.
the hatchery is a good approach, except I believe that it is already in use, don't a bunch of school kids release flounder from time to time up in Davis Canal,
http://fryingpantower.com/ftopict-25733-.html
then they ease out to the "red banks" where the waterway trawler takes care of that.
All those hatchery fish the comms want is for recs and taxpayers to pay for and for comms to sell. While you are permitted a limit of 1 or 2 fish they will be selling those fish by the thousands and have not one penny invested. There are enough welfare programs, they can choose another already funded to participate in.
Eric please note that I did not condemn anyone.
I am merely suggesting a way for the resource that is suppose to be for the residence of the state actually stay in the state. I am also willing to say that "x" has to remain in the state and only "x" can be exported.
Also note I did not say flounder I said fish. I mean all fish, snapper and grouper complex included.
Curious as to how you feel about non-resident tourists visiting NC. Should they be allowed to fish for "our fish"? If they catch any can they take them home?Should they be able to buy our fish from a restaurant or fish monger?
Has anyone of yall ever set a net it's not like the fish are dead when you pull it up last week we made one set and had about 20 red drum one that was about 30lb and guess what we let everyone go people talk about something that they know nothing about