SWC Forums
Pull up a chair...let's talk fishing.
I have no problem with commercial fisherman and have mostly been a supporter of them, I also have no problem finding, catching and/or gigging flounder.
I do however have a problem with the large trawls working inside the pamlico sound. The bycatch cannot be ignored...
I have no problem with commercial fisherman and have mostly been a supporter of them, I also have no problem finding, catching and/or gigging flounder.
I do however have a problem with the large trawls working inside the pamlico sound. The bycatch cannot be ignored...
X100.
And it's not just the Pamlico waters where the inshore netting by-catch must stop if we are ever to have fish stocks rebound.
Per your request,
"Texas has banned monofilament gill nets in 1981 and ended all types of commercial netting in saltwater in 1988.
Robin Riechers is the Texas Parks and Wildlife Department's science and policy director for its Coastal Fisheries Division and has been working in fisheries management for over 16 years. He credits the elimination of inshore nets in Texas with the recovery of healthy speckled trout and redfish populations in the state.
“Not only has the quantity of sport fish gone up but so has the quality,” said Riechers. “One of the secrets to this turnaround is the ability to control fishing mortality much more easily in a sport rod and reel fishery than in a commercial fishery.”
According to NOAA statistics Texas maintains a commercial seafood industry whose landings valued at over $197 million compared to the $70 million in landings for North Carolina. The data is based on 2006 numbers.
“Catch rates have increased by 60% since the 1988 net ban,” said Riechers. “The relative abundance of red drum in the bays is at record levels. This abundance has increased 20% since the net ban. Because commercial nets targeted larger red drum, the removal of nets in Texas resulted in a dramatic upsurge of large fish available. Our surveys have document an increase in average weight of sport-caught red drum from just two pounds prior to 1981 to a current average of over five pounds.”
In addition to redfish gains, Riechers credits the elimination of inshore netting with restoring the state’s speckled trout population.
“Trout populations have risen to the highest levels since the 1970s,” said Riechers. “This is particularly phenomenal considering the tremendous number of seatrout killed in three freezes since 1983. Without nets in the water, managers were able to delay harvest and maximize the fish’s reproductive success.”
Riechers also credits the net ban with increasing black drum abundance by 250 percent. Commercial anglers now catch black drum on trotlines instead of with nets.
Riechers said that in Texas eliminating nets has had a huge impact on the state’s recreational and tourism industries while the seafood industry has survived.
“Anglers are now experiencing some of the best coastal fishing in recent memory,” said Riechers. “This has lead to an economic boost in tourism and sport fisheries with a total impact to the state of over $1.7 billion. The number of saltwater guides has quadrupled since the early 1980s, and the availability of seafood in Texas has not suffered with the loss of commercial netting.”
Florida held a public vote in 1994 and 72 percent of the public voted to ban gill nets and all entangling nets from inshore waters. According to Mark Robson, the director of Florida’s Division of Marine Fisheries, the closure meant the end to most inshore commercial catches of speckled trout and initially caused recreational overfishing on both trout and redfish. However, in 1999 Florida began using scientific methods to manage the trout and redfish and have seen a dramatic recovery of both species.
“Two fisheries management success stories in Florida are the red drum and spotted seatrout,” Robson said. “The most recent regulation amendments occurred in 2000 and streamlined the regulations to increase compliance and enforceability.”
Robson says that the commercial fishing industry has seen sharp declines in landings for inshore speckled trout, and commercial harvest and sale of redfish was prohibited altogether in 1989. However, Florida still maintains commercial landings of seafood that more than double those in NC at $192 million.
Here is a summary of all southern state laws concerning gill nets:
South Carolina does not allow inshore gill nets except in a few small designated areas. However, gill nets no longer than 100 feet with a 3-inch minimum stretched mesh size are allowed in the ocean. Both redfish and speckled trout are gamefish in South Carolina and cannot be sold by commercial fishermen.
Georgia does not allow gill nets in its coastal waters.
Florida does not allow gill nets in its coastal waters.
Alabama is phasing out gill netting by limiting the number of gill netters to those who had licenses when a new law was passed in 2008. Gill netters can continue to buy licenses for themselves, but cannot transfer licenses and new licenses are not being created. Gill netting areas are also restricted.
Louisiana does not allow gill nets in coastal waters except for mullet and pompano “strike nets” during certain seasons. Commercial strike netters cannot keep fish other than mullet or pompano.
Texas does not allow gill nets in coastal waters.
The one southern state that does still have fisheries laws similar to North Carolina is Mississippi, where inshore gill netting is still allowed. Similar to laws that apply in NC, Mississippi manages stocks of redfish, speckled trout and flounder by commercial quota.
Riechers says that each state is different and must make up its own mind about gill nets.
“North Carolina should manage its aquatic resources based on what is best for its unique situation,” Riechers said. “Banning nets in marine waters was the right thing to do in Texas. "
And this didn't come from the CCA.
Eric please note that I did not condemn anyone.
I am merely suggesting a way for the resource that is suppose to be for the residence of the state actually stay in the state. I am also willing to say that "x" has to remain in the state and only "x" can be exported.
Also note I did not say flounder I said fish. I mean all fish, snapper and grouper complex included.
I have heard many times from the commercial side that they are "supplying" those that live in the state that want the seafood but can't get to the coast to fish for it. That is why I suggested an alternative to the current proposals. We can manage our supply and satisfy our demand. This is a way to keep the foreign fish out!
So far all I have heard in this post is that the water is dirty. Well you aren't going to remove anyone's beach house, so scratch that idea.
Come up with, and post, a constructive alternative.
I have no problem with commercial fisherman and have mostly been a supporter of them, I also have no problem finding, catching and/or gigging flounder.
I do however have a problem with the large trawls working inside the pamlico sound. The bycatch cannot be ignored...
Dead on.
I have and will always be against inshore trawling due to waste.
I think inshore nets should be extremely limited to Full Time professional fisherman or banned. Inshore nets are causing too much heat in the form of negative attention.
As for flounder, I am a rec. turned commercial but I rec. fish a lot. From April to Thanksgiving, 18 flounder in 3-4 hours is very doable for us. Would probably take less time if we were not screwing with the crabs, specs., and mullets. We always leave quality fish behind.
So I should pay my license fee, drive an hour to the coast. Launch boat and catch my 1 flounder and be happy? GIVE ME A BREAK! I've put in the time and effort to and many notebooks to have a good idea of where and when. I can catch the fish I'm targeting. It's just bad that I can't spend my money to catch what I want to eat. Guess I'll just save all that time effort and love of the outdoors and buy my fish from a grocery store. Let me save my gas money, money I spend maintaining a boat, buying my gear, buying my tackle, and just buy all my fish from Asia or a NC net. I'm done with it. Furniture, textiles, lumber, tobacco, all industries that had to change. Nets aren't the total problem, but God bless if they don't account for more fish than I bring in not to mention exceedingly more effiecient. Maybe we should legalize dynamite fishing? If one group gets all the fish it's only fair. Toss a couple sticks in a creek BOOM. Got my limit. I'd be ok with nets if there was a ban on inshore trawling and viable large quantity hatchery system. We gotta put back more than we take.
Why not stock flounder so there are plenty for fishermen to catch and consumers to eat? We could establish Hatchery Supported Quotas based on populations the resource can sustain. Each sector could have the option of stocking half of each HSQ with funds raised from license fees and existing taxes that are already earmarked for promoting recreational fishing and domestic seafood. Flounder could have a clipped fin like they do with salmon to identify stocked fish. We need to focus more on enhancing our fisheries, freedom, and food supply than restricting them.
Since commercials take the majority of the fish will they pay the majority of costs? Or do you prefer recs to support your greed? Maybe recs and taxpayers? To be fair comm licenses would need high 5 figure renewals and already there is whining over paying for observers (mostly) at $400.
Eric stated " the working watermen tend to carry the weight of the whole industry's short comings when they're the least paid cog in the wheel. Sometimes I wonder if it's not by design. But that's another discussion." and he is correct. The fish dealers take advantage of the fishermen because they easily can. The fishermen are paying a small part of the campaign donations and lobbyist costs.
Anyone ever check on the development around the FL coast? It makes NC development look like sandcastles in a playground. Ever fish the FL coast? Move on to LA and find the same great fishing. how about all the industry along the Mississippi? Fish that coast? Yes, NC waters do have an impact but nothing like other states with a much greater fishery.
Why not stock flounder so there are plenty for fishermen to catch and consumers to eat? We could establish Hatchery Supported Quotas based on populations the resource can sustain. Each sector could have the option of stocking half of each HSQ with funds raised from license fees and existing taxes that are already earmarked for promoting recreational fishing and domestic seafood. Flounder could have a clipped fin like they do with salmon to identify stocked fish. We need to focus more on enhancing our fisheries, freedom, and food supply than restricting them.
Since commercials take the majority of the fish will they pay the majority of costs? Or do you prefer recs to support your greed? Maybe recs and taxpayers? To be fair comm licenses would need high 5 figure renewals and already there is whining over paying for observers (mostly) at $400.
The solution I am promoting would split the potential Hatchery Supported Quotas evenly between recreational anglers and seafood consumers. Each sector would be responsible for funding their HSQ through license fees along with the Dingell-Johnson tax on the rec side and Saltonstall-Kennedy tax on the commercial side. Many recreational fishermen want bag limits that are high enough to offset the expense of going fishing with fresh seafood. There are also a lot of people who want to eat local seafood, but can't or don't want to catch their own. Stocking is a great alternative to industrial fish farms for producing food and recreational opportunity.
You are correct, no one is gonna change their beach leisure habits so we better suck it up and move on. That's all I hear from you guys. There's one way I know that will make our fishery numbers as big as FL and LA, we cut NC from the eastern landscape, pick it up and drop it somehow in the gulf of mexico where there's better fishing than anywhere save alaska in the US. Hell, let's just drop it in alaska and then we can have even better numbers than the gulf states. Matter of fact, since we're comparing apples to oranges let's look at AK. They permit every kind of fishing gear including trawls and gill nets and they also have more fishing pressure then anywhere in the world probably yet they still maintain SUPER healthy fish stocks even in the wake of environmental disasters.
So, by you guy's logic of (state's banning gill nets = rebounding stocks) I'll counter with AK's numbers that blow both of those mentioned out of the water while allowing commercial harvest of all kinds as well as recreational and charter fishing. Can y'all maybe see my logic about this state vs. that state now? Probably not.
Again, if you're having trouble catching, practice....because most people I know are doing fine catching targeted species whenever they like.
Really though, honestly, I just wish people would say what they really feel instead of the badly over used quote: "I'm not bashing comms, I think they should be able to work, just need to do it the way I prefer". The truth is, most of you guys have to work at jobs you hate for weeks on end to get maybe one good day on the water as a reward. While we get to be out there everyday. In truth, it's plain old playground jealousy but it'll never be admitted. It's hard to take people's conservation concerns seriously when they're fighting for a piece of the pie. Very disingenuous. As for the every day fishing business, that includes days like today. With that, I'm off to pull crab pots and shake my fist at ana.
South Carolina Limits .....Flounders (Southern, Summer & Gulf) 15 per person per day not to exceed 30 per boat per day 14-inch TL
Bag limits apply to rod & reel or gig
Eric please note that I did not condemn anyone.
I am merely suggesting a way for the resource that is suppose to be for the residence of the state actually stay in the state. I am also willing to say that "x" has to remain in the state and only "x" can be exported.
Also note I did not say flounder I said fish. I mean all fish, snapper and grouper complex included.
I have heard many times from the commercial side that they are "supplying" those that live in the state that want the seafood but can't get to the coast to fish for it. That is why I suggested an alternative to the current proposals. We can manage our supply and satisfy our demand. This is a way to keep the foreign fish out!
So far all I have heard in this post is that the water is dirty. Well you aren't going to remove anyone's beach house, so scratch that idea.
Come up with, and post, a constructive alternative.
Actually, the snapper grouper complex are a federal resource and are managed by the federal gov not NC. Someone in Colorado has as much right to them as anyone in NC does! In addition, the snapper grouper complex is a completely sustainable fishery! Unless of course you think that 500 vessels operating from Virginia to key west Florida out 200 nautical miles are going to damage grouper populations using a rod and reel for 8 months of the year! Offshore fed fish have nothing to do management of NC State waters and the resources within.
wonder why the article that matador posted about Texas banning nets fully restoring their red, trout and flounder fishery conveniently made no mention about the many fish hatcheries that the great state of Texas found itself resorting to in order to restore their fishing. Folks, this is not so much about restoring NC fishing as much as it is to simply rid NC of most types of commercial fishing.
Pretty cool how the target has changed from spotted seatrout and red drum to flounder. Back when the gamefish crowd was blaming comms for shortage of drum and trout, the word from the ban crowd was that spotted trout/drum was the number one fishery in the state. Now that we're in an up cycle for those two species and they are readily available, the ban crowd is indicating that flounder has become the top fishery in the state.
Funny how that works.