SWC Forums
Pull up a chair...let's talk fishing.
Several commercial fishing interests are trying to sneak in a catch shares type program in the South Atlantic.If this happens,say hello to rich commercial guys hiring lobbyists to get politicians steal recreational allotments and push smaller mom and pop commercial operators out of business like in the Gulf and everywhere else they have been tried.
This link takes you to the Council For Sustainable Fishing webpage dedicated to this issue.There are links to the SAMFC comment page as well as to the actual application that was submitted.
http://www.sustainablefishing.org/
Froggy, thanks. Below is a blast email we sent out this week about the catch share threat:
I wanted you to know that the first step toward full privatization of our snapper-grouper fishery is underway.
Last week, South Atlantic Fishery Management Council Vice-Chair Charlie Phillips, SAFMC member Chris Conklin and former SAFMC member Jack Cox filed their Exempted Fishing Permit application for a pilot commercial snapper-grouper catch share program.
Click here for the application, which only became public on Friday:
http://www.sustainablefishing.org/
Note that the phrase “catch shares” does not appear in the application purpose – instead code-speak for catch shares like “allocation-based system” and “individual transferable quota” is used.
As promised, this EFP gives Phillips, Conklin and Cox, all commercial snapper-grouper fleet owners and dealers, exclusive snapper-grouper shares and would exempt them from any trip limits and seasonal or quota closures.
EFPs are usually for research purposes and are approved by just one person -- NOAA Fisheries Regional Administrator Dr. Roy Crabtree, who is seeking the advice of the SAFMC at their March meeting in Jekyll Island, GA as to whether the EFP application should move forward or not.
Unless the SAFMC takes a strong stand against the EFP, I believe there is a very good chance Dr. Crabtree will ultimately approve the pilot catch share program. Once in place, count on efforts to impose catch shares on all fishermen.
This back-door “pilot” catch share scheme is exactly what the radical Environmental Defense Fund has used as a tactic in the Gulf of Mexico, where, according to a recent WVUE-TV investigative report “50 businesses and fishermen control 81 percent” of the commercial red snapper catch shares, worth $23 million a year, making these ‘snapper barons’ millionaires.
Guess who’s pushing this back-door effort along with these SAFMC ringleaders? According to the Charleston, SC Post & Courier, it’s EDF front group Seafood Harvesters of America, which according to tax documents has been funded with over $300,000 from EDF.
The Seafood Harvesters represent some of the biggest catch share owners in the nation. Board members include Jack Cox and Buddy Guindon (Big Fish Texas) who, according to media reports, is the third largest owner of Gulf red snapper shares, worth $1.4 million annually.
This isn’t about research -- it’s about picking the economic winners and losers in the snapper-grouper fishery by reducing the number of fishermen -- that’s what catch shares do. They hurt fishermen and fishing communities by killing jobs.
And if you have a for-hire snapper-grouper permit, this could ultimately affect that permit, too. The SAFMC also has on its meeting agenda for-hire limited entry, which is a beginning step toward for-hire catch shares. In other areas of the country, after commercial catch shares were imposed, for-hire catch shares shortly followed.
And this is not about fishery sustainability. Studies by the Lenfest Ocean Program and reports by Food and Water Watch and others have shown that catch share programs provide no biological benefit or enhanced sustainability to fisheries at all.
Time is very short -- speak out today to save jobs and fishing communities! Here’s how:
1. Here’s the link to the SAFMC online comment form:
https://safmc.wufoo.com/forms/safmc-march-2017-meeting-public-comment-form/
Tell them you’re opposed to the pilot catch share program permit and any form of catch shares. These “on the record” comments are crucial. Please make comments no later than March 8th.
2. Speak out against the permit at the SAFMC public hearing on Wednesday, March 8th at 4:30 pm at the Westin Hotel, 110 Ocean Way, Jekyll Island, GA.
3. Contact your representatives on the SAFMC to personally let them know you oppose the permit. Here’s a link to the contact information for all SAFMC members:
http://safmc.net/council-members/
The only way to stop this catch share effort is for fishermen, like you, to step up and be heard by the SAFMC. I urge you to let the SAFMC know today that you oppose this back-door catch share effort before it’s too late.
Thank you in advance for your efforts!
Wayne Mershon
President
Froggy, thanks. Below is a blast email we sent out this week about the catch share threat:
I wanted you to know that the first step toward full privatization of our snapper-grouper fishery is underway.
Last week, South Atlantic Fishery Management Council Vice-Chair Charlie Phillips, SAFMC member Chris Conklin and former SAFMC member Jack Cox filed their Exempted Fishing Permit application for a pilot commercial snapper-grouper catch share program.
Click here for the application, which only became public on Friday:
http://www.sustainablefishing.org/
Note that the phrase “catch shares” does not appear in the application purpose – instead code-speak for catch shares like “allocation-based system” and “individual transferable quota” is used.
As promised, this EFP gives Phillips, Conklin and Cox, all commercial snapper-grouper fleet owners and dealers, exclusive snapper-grouper shares and would exempt them from any trip limits and seasonal or quota closures.
EFPs are usually for research purposes and are approved by just one person -- NOAA Fisheries Regional Administrator Dr. Roy Crabtree, who is seeking the advice of the SAFMC at their March meeting in Jekyll Island, GA as to whether the EFP application should move forward or not.
Unless the SAFMC takes a strong stand against the EFP, I believe there is a very good chance Dr. Crabtree will ultimately approve the pilot catch share program. Once in place, count on efforts to impose catch shares on all fishermen.
This back-door “pilot” catch share scheme is exactly what the radical Environmental Defense Fund has used as a tactic in the Gulf of Mexico, where, according to a recent WVUE-TV investigative report “50 businesses and fishermen control 81 percent” of the commercial red snapper catch shares, worth $23 million a year, making these ‘snapper barons’ millionaires.
Guess who’s pushing this back-door effort along with these SAFMC ringleaders? According to the Charleston, SC Post & Courier, it’s EDF front group Seafood Harvesters of America, which according to tax documents has been funded with over $300,000 from EDF.
The Seafood Harvesters represent some of the biggest catch share owners in the nation. Board members include Jack Cox and Buddy Guindon (Big Fish Texas) who, according to media reports, is the third largest owner of Gulf red snapper shares, worth $1.4 million annually.
This isn’t about research -- it’s about picking the economic winners and losers in the snapper-grouper fishery by reducing the number of fishermen -- that’s what catch shares do. They hurt fishermen and fishing communities by killing jobs.
And if you have a for-hire snapper-grouper permit, this could ultimately affect that permit, too. The SAFMC also has on its meeting agenda for-hire limited entry, which is a beginning step toward for-hire catch shares. In other areas of the country, after commercial catch shares were imposed, for-hire catch shares shortly followed.
And this is not about fishery sustainability. Studies by the Lenfest Ocean Program and reports by Food and Water Watch and others have shown that catch share programs provide no biological benefit or enhanced sustainability to fisheries at all.
Time is very short -- speak out today to save jobs and fishing communities! Here’s how:
1. Here’s the link to the SAFMC online comment form:
https://safmc.wufoo.com/forms/safmc-march-2017-meeting-public-comment-form/
Tell them you’re opposed to the pilot catch share program permit and any form of catch shares. These “on the record” comments are crucial. Please make comments no later than March 8th.
2. Speak out against the permit at the SAFMC public hearing on Wednesday, March 8th at 4:30 pm at the Westin Hotel, 110 Ocean Way, Jekyll Island, GA.
3. Contact your representatives on the SAFMC to personally let them know you oppose the permit. Here’s a link to the contact information for all SAFMC members:
http://safmc.net/council-members/
The only way to stop this catch share effort is for fishermen, like you, to step up and be heard by the SAFMC. I urge you to let the SAFMC know today that you oppose this back-door catch share effort before it’s too late.
Thank you in advance for your efforts!
Wayne Mershon
President
Froggy, thanks. Below is a blast email we sent out this week about the catch share threat:
I wanted you to know that the first step toward full privatization of our snapper-grouper fishery is underway.
Last week, South Atlantic Fishery Management Council Vice-Chair Charlie Phillips, SAFMC member Chris Conklin and former SAFMC member Jack Cox filed their Exempted Fishing Permit application for a pilot commercial snapper-grouper catch share program.
Click here for the application, which only became public on Friday:
http://www.sustainablefishing.org/
Note that the phrase “catch shares” does not appear in the application purpose – instead code-speak for catch shares like “allocation-based system” and “individual transferable quota” is used.
As promised, this EFP gives Phillips, Conklin and Cox, all commercial snapper-grouper fleet owners and dealers, exclusive snapper-grouper shares and would exempt them from any trip limits and seasonal or quota closures.
EFPs are usually for research purposes and are approved by just one person -- NOAA Fisheries Regional Administrator Dr. Roy Crabtree, who is seeking the advice of the SAFMC at their March meeting in Jekyll Island, GA as to whether the EFP application should move forward or not.
Unless the SAFMC takes a strong stand against the EFP, I believe there is a very good chance Dr. Crabtree will ultimately approve the pilot catch share program. Once in place, count on efforts to impose catch shares on all fishermen.
This back-door “pilot” catch share scheme is exactly what the radical Environmental Defense Fund has used as a tactic in the Gulf of Mexico, where, according to a recent WVUE-TV investigative report “50 businesses and fishermen control 81 percent” of the commercial red snapper catch shares, worth $23 million a year, making these ‘snapper barons’ millionaires.
Guess who’s pushing this back-door effort along with these SAFMC ringleaders? According to the Charleston, SC Post & Courier, it’s EDF front group Seafood Harvesters of America, which according to tax documents has been funded with over $300,000 from EDF.
The Seafood Harvesters represent some of the biggest catch share owners in the nation. Board members include Jack Cox and Buddy Guindon (Big Fish Texas) who, according to media reports, is the third largest owner of Gulf red snapper shares, worth $1.4 million annually.
This isn’t about research -- it’s about picking the economic winners and losers in the snapper-grouper fishery by reducing the number of fishermen -- that’s what catch shares do. They hurt fishermen and fishing communities by killing jobs.
And if you have a for-hire snapper-grouper permit, this could ultimately affect that permit, too. The SAFMC also has on its meeting agenda for-hire limited entry, which is a beginning step toward for-hire catch shares. In other areas of the country, after commercial catch shares were imposed, for-hire catch shares shortly followed.
And this is not about fishery sustainability. Studies by the Lenfest Ocean Program and reports by Food and Water Watch and others have shown that catch share programs provide no biological benefit or enhanced sustainability to fisheries at all.
Time is very short -- speak out today to save jobs and fishing communities! Here’s how:
1. Here’s the link to the SAFMC online comment form:
https://safmc.wufoo.com/forms/safmc-march-2017-meeting-public-comment-form/
Tell them you’re opposed to the pilot catch share program permit and any form of catch shares. These “on the record” comments are crucial. Please make comments no later than March 8th.
2. Speak out against the permit at the SAFMC public hearing on Wednesday, March 8th at 4:30 pm at the Westin Hotel, 110 Ocean Way, Jekyll Island, GA.
3. Contact your representatives on the SAFMC to personally let them know you oppose the permit. Here’s a link to the contact information for all SAFMC members:
http://safmc.net/council-members/
The only way to stop this catch share effort is for fishermen, like you, to step up and be heard by the SAFMC. I urge you to let the SAFMC know today that you oppose this back-door catch share effort before it’s too late.
Thank you in advance for your efforts!
Wayne Mershon
President
From an on target opinion piece entitled "Gulf Scandal Looms for South Atlantic" about this “back-door” pilot catch share program:
SPORT FISHING – “The alarming investigative series 'Hooked Up' (Fox8/New Orleans) dug deep into the muck of the controversial giveaway of red snapper in the Gulf of Mexico. Now the stage is being set to export this swamp to the South Atlantic for at least six species – blueline tilefish, gag grouper, gray triggerfish, greater amberjack, the jacks complex and vermilion snapper.
A group calling itself the South Atlantic Commercial Fishing Collaborative is using the oft-abused federal Exempted Fishing Permit process to request a two-year pilot program to assign private ownership privileges [catch shares] for those six species to up to 25 commercial vessels.
In a brazen display, the South Atlantic Commercial Fishing Collaborative currently consists of four individuals, including two sitting South Atlantic Fishery Management Council members and one former member. The very people charged with managing these public marine resources for all Americans are using the system to position themselves to own those resources.”
http://www.sportfishingmag.com/recreational-fishing-scandal-south-atlantic
Government regulators granting exclusive private ownership rights to a natural resource... if this was being done with oil there would be riots in the street
Anyone notice the reasons given for pushing this privatization scheme?
I can’t emphasize enough the importance of letting the SAFMC know today you oppose this pilot catch share program permit.
Use this link to provide your comments to the SAFMC:
https://safmc.wufoo.com/forms/safmc-march-2017-meeting-public-comment-form/
Just a sentence or two will do.
Use this link to see the comments that have already been made:
https://safmc.wufoo.com/reports/safmc-march-2017-meeting-public-comment-summary/
The privatization of our fishery resources will hurt recreational and commercial fishermen and benefit a select few. Please take the time to comment to the SAFMC.
In-Person Public Comment:You can show up at the meeting to voice your opinion
Wednesday, March 8 @ 4:30 PM
Westin Jekyll Island
110 Ocean Way
Jekyll Island, GA 31527
Here are a bunch of contacts to email and call. If I remember right March 9 is the deadline for comment.
'
http://safmc.net/contact-us/
Gov. Roy Cooper - http://governor.nc.gov/contact-governor-cooper
Sen Thom Tillis - https://www.tillis.senate.gov/public/index.cfm/email-me
Sen. Richard Burr - http://www.burr.senate.gov/contact/email (202) 224-3154
SAMFC committee:
Vice Chair Charlie Phillips -- ga_capt@yahoo.com or 912-832-4423
Chris Conklin -- conklinsafmc@gmail.com or 843-543-3833
roy.crabtree@noaa.gov
jessica.mccawley@myfwc.com
mackattackben@att.net
WCBLAW@aol.com
doughaymans@gmail.com
fishzack@comcast.net
capt.markbrown@comcast.net
bellm@dnr.sc.gov
timgrinersafmc@gmail.com
AnnaBarriosBeckwith@gmail.com
michelle.duval@ncdenr.gov
I sent a long one to the Agency and a short one to Roy Cooper
Please consider sending your members of Congress a copy of your public comments and posting them on the South Atlantic Fishery Management Council FB page. It helps to apply pressure from several angles. You can bet EDF has been working more than one angle to get this done.
I have to wonder how many of the committee would vote for it if there was a conflict of interest clause that didn't allow any committee member to profit in any way from this proposal.
Here is a link to the proposal. http://safmc.net/download/Briefing%20Book%20March%202017/TAB%2011%20Council%20Session/A8d_SAReefFishCollaborative_EFP_Request/SouthAtlanticReefFishCollaborativeEFP_Request020617.pdf
I have to wonder how many of the committee would vote for it if there was a conflict of interest clause that didn't allow any committee member to profit in any way from this proposal.
Here is a link to the proposal. http://safmc.net/download/Briefing%20Book%20March%202017/TAB%2011%20Council%20Session/A8d_SAReefFishCollaborative_EFP_Request/SouthAtlanticReefFishCollaborativeEFP_Request020617.pdf
everyone of them that vote in favor of this backdoor catch shares will have some type of conflict of interest, or else it would not even be a consideration, much less a vote, it is a sell out, slam dunk.