SWC Forums

Pull up a chair...let's talk fishing.

Cobia CLOSED
 
Notifications
Clear all

Cobia CLOSED

60 Posts
31 Users
0 Reactions
142.6 K Views
Chris McCaffity
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 15 years ago
Posts: 1424
 

As I recall, last year there was a stricter limit put on rec and commercial alike, around first of the year, with a closure for all on June 15. Then, once the Commercial boys got their lobbyists to grease the wheels, suddenly a couple months later, the closure came down on just the rec guys, and the Commercial boys were allowed to carry on? WHEN will NC's govt begin to acknowledge that for decades the Commercial/Charter guys have been allowed to target the big spawning females in the spring when they school up THICK offshore to begin to migration inside. Every year the charter guys would have 20+ days where they'd post pic of 5-10 large spawning females 70+ LB's PER DAY! This doesnt even account for the Commercial guys who spend weeks at a time targeting these fish! Yet, NC CONTINUES to pretend that the problem is mostly the Rec fishery?? NC's fishery laws have been corrupt for far too long, and with the increased recreational pressure (all these ****;), its time that NC came to grips with the power of the Commercial lobbyists, as limiting the rec fishery will have very little effect on the cobia pop., but if the Commercial harvest is not vastly limited, our Cobia fishery will continue to go the way of our king fishery! SC and FLA have proven that their system is both, more fair, and far more effective!
Now I know that I am about to be attacked by the Comm. guys for stating this truth, and I KNOW that few of them will admit that I'm right, but would rather spin the facts regarding their percentage of the annual harvest vs. rec., or throw up the "good old days... before the
**** invasion", for their argument as to why its all on the rec guys. While their may be much truth to the fact that there has been a tragic, 20 year invasion, that has proven unrelenting, you cant stop the growing population along NC coast, and only limiting the "googans", just aint getting it done! Not when the big spawners can still be tracked and hammered for weeks at a time, before most of the rec guys will even get a shot at them.I'm not suggesting a closure, but just the opposite. If the Commercial take is limited to the same extent as Rec. harvest, it may very well save from future closures... for all!

You make a great point about not being able to stop the population from growing. More people means more of them will want to catch and/or eat cobia. There are basically three options at this point.

1. Status quo

2. Reallocation of consumer quota to recreational anglers

3. Stock cobia so there are plenty for everyone to enjoy forever

There is only one option that benefits everyone and the resource.

Think about if there might be some pressure being applied by industrial fish farming lobbyist to restrict harvest and promote division among fishermen.



   
ReplyQuote
Mark
 Mark
(@)
New Member
Joined: 10 years ago
Posts: 4
 

Hammering the big spawning females doesn't sound like a sustainable plan even if you put millions into restocking. Why not a slot so big Momma can make more cobes for everyone?
After forty yrs of fishing and seeing how Sad few and little is left I have my own Slot.
Keep the eaters
Release the Breeders



   
ReplyQuote
Drew Maultsby
(@)
Prominent Member
Joined: 17 years ago
Posts: 806
 

3. "Stock cobia so there are plenty for everyone to enjoy forever."

And the example of where that is working with what fish is....................?



   
ReplyQuote
george mc donald
(@)
Reputable Member
Joined: 17 years ago
Posts: 374
 

Until enough recreational types come in with empty fish boxes and start to stand on their representatives shoulders to demand that commercial fishers share in the closures and limits, the future looks bleak for all species, not just cobs.... If the season is closed for one ,>> should be closed for all ,>>size limit for one ,should be size for all, >>quota for one ,quota for all.>> Write to your reps and complain!!! :help: :lmao:



   
ReplyQuote
Chris McCaffity
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 15 years ago
Posts: 1424
 

Until enough recreational types come in with empty fish boxes and start to stand on their representatives shoulders to demand that commercial fishers share in the closures and limits, the future looks bleak for all species, not just cobs.... If the season is closed for one ,>> should be closed for all ,>>size limit for one ,should be size for all, >>quota for one ,quota for all.>> Write to your reps and complain!!! :help: :lmao:

Commercial fishermen took a reduction in our cobia quota thanks to the corporate mariculture funded cobia genetics "research" just like recreational fishermen did. We are only allowed 2 fish per boat as bycatch so we don't exceed our quota. Think about the big picture before writing big brother about taking freedom away from fellow citizens for your perceived benefit. Recreational and commercial fishermen along with seafood consumers need to stand united in our call for fishery managers to focus more on enhancing our fisheries and food supply than restricting our freedom to access them.

Why would the SAFMC give Florida twice as much quota as they ever landed while the rest of us get half the quota we historically landed?



   
ReplyQuote
george mc donald
(@)
Reputable Member
Joined: 17 years ago
Posts: 374
 

Missing my point ; if a fishery is in trouble then we all share in the rebuild until the stock recovers.... It is in no way fair to allow one faction to continue catching and restrict another because of historic quotas... A dead breeder makes no little ones regardless of who catches it;;;as stated limit for one >limit for all.... A bucket leaking 2 drops while 1 drop replenishes it will still go dry in short time!!! :wall: :wall: :wall:



   
ReplyQuote
Rich
 Rich
(@squid-row)
Illustrious Member
Joined: 22 years ago
Posts: 4097
Topic starter  

I think the idea of a slot on cobia to ensure that the breeding population does not get hammered is a good idea.

Releasing a big cobia is easier said than done, but it is a good idea for all species.

After watching folks keep tiny croakers all weekend long, I wonder if there needs to be a minimum size on just about everything. Don't keep them unless they are big enough to have spawned at least once should be a rule across all fisheries, and for the ones in trouble, don't keep the big breeding stock



   
ReplyQuote
Chris McCaffity
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 15 years ago
Posts: 1424
 

Missing my point ; if a fishery is in trouble then we all share in the rebuild until the stock recovers.... It is in no way fair to allow one faction to continue catching and restrict another because of historic quotas... A dead breeder makes no little ones regardless of who catches it;;;as stated limit for one >limit for all.... A bucket leaking 2 drops while 1 drop replenishes it will still go dry in short time!!! :wall: :wall: :wall:

The commercial quota was reduced along with the recreational quota thanks to the corporate fish farms. There are just far fewer commercial fishermen and our possession limit is more restrictive to avoid overfishing as is occurring in the recreational sector according to those mariculture funded studies the SAFMC is using.

Think about how easy it would be for somebody to get hurt trying to measure a large cobia.

Think about the regulatory nightmare for fishermen, fishery managers, and law enforcement if there were slot limits for most fish.

Think about how easy it would be to follow simple possession limits without any size limits on stocked species.

Why is there such resistance to supporting proven solutions that benefit everyone and the resource while preserving our freedom to fish and eat American seafood?



   
ReplyQuote
Rich
 Rich
(@squid-row)
Illustrious Member
Joined: 22 years ago
Posts: 4097
Topic starter  

The commercial quota was reduced along with the recreational quota thanks to the corporate fish farms.

Corporate cobia farms?



   
ReplyQuote
Chris McCaffity
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 15 years ago
Posts: 1424
 

The commercial quota was reduced along with the recreational quota thanks to the corporate fish farms.

Corporate cobia farms?

Look into who was behind the research on cobia genetics that resulted in lower quotas for most of the east coast.

Look into who is pushing for industrial fish farming off our coast. http://www.ncleg.net/Applications/BillLookUp/LoadBillDocument.aspx?SessionCode=2017&DocNum=2060&SeqNum=0   

Think about if you would rather see cobia stocked so their are plenty for everyone or large sections of our public waters closed for cobia farms.

Think about if cobia farming could negatively impact wild stocks by spreading disease, parasites, and pollution.

Think about if there is any chance that farmed cobia could be genetically modified in the future to boost corporate profits and how escaping frankenfish could negatively impact wild stocks.



   
ReplyQuote
Rich
 Rich
(@squid-row)
Illustrious Member
Joined: 22 years ago
Posts: 4097
Topic starter  

Chris you said the quotas were cut due to corporate fish farms for cobia. I have never heard of such a thing so I would like to find out more

What you followed up with is something that is being proposed for the future and does not relate to a cut in the past.

Just trying to understand what your point was.

WRT to offshore fish farms, they are not really farms. They are wild caught fish that are penned up and fed until they are market size. They do this with tuna in the pacific I believe, have not looked into it that much. I think they used to do this with Salmon in the Gulf of Maine too.

There was a show on TV a few years ago about one of these operations in Australia I believe. Was really interesting but I don't remember too much of the detail.



   
ReplyQuote
Chris McCaffity
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 15 years ago
Posts: 1424
 

Chris you said the quotas were cut due to corporate fish farms for cobia. I have never heard of such a thing so I would like to find out more

What you followed up with is something that is being proposed for the future and does not relate to a cut in the past.

Just trying to understand what your point was.

WRT to offshore fish farms, they are not really farms. They are wild caught fish that are penned up and fed until they are market size. They do this with tuna in the pacific I believe, have not looked into it that much. I think they used to do this with Salmon in the Gulf of Maine too.

There was a show on TV a few years ago about one of these operations in Australia I believe. Was really interesting but I don't remember too much of the detail.

The cobia quota was split based on studies showing different genetic stocks. It looks like there was a push by cobia farming interests to do the study. Would it benefit those interests to cut natural production?

One of the SB-410 sponsors told me that mariculture lobbyists explained how fish farming could replace commercial harvest and allow recreational anglers to catch those fish. The recreational closures are a great way to get recreational fishermen to demand allocations of consumer quota. The corporate cobia farms can't just say they want to limit commercial harvest so they can corner the market.

Cobia farms raise hatchery fry to marketable size in a series of cages in coastal waters similar to salmon farms. Look into how popular those salmon farms are with anyone except the foreign investors who own them.



   
ReplyQuote
Bernie McCants
(@)
Reputable Member
Joined: 22 years ago
Posts: 289
 

3. "Stock cobia so there are plenty for everyone to enjoy forever."

And the example of where that is working with what fish is....................?

Red drum in SC

FW trout, striped bass, hybrid bass.



   
ReplyQuote
Drew Maultsby
(@)
Prominent Member
Joined: 17 years ago
Posts: 806
 

When he said "plenty for everybody", I believe that included commercials. How many of the fish that you listed are harvested commercially?



   
ReplyQuote
george mc donald
(@)
Reputable Member
Joined: 17 years ago
Posts: 374
 

This argument can and likely will go on until the money is taken out of the conversation , be it corp. fish farming or commercial catch share limits..
Hatchery raised/released for restocking has proven itself to be a no-go. The waddell center has released cobs by the millions into the broad river in hopes to rebuild the fishery to no avail. Genetic testing has proven hatchery fish and wild stock will not cross breed and increase overall fishery. Don't confuse fish farming for profit and food sources with managing wild born / raised .. To insure a future commercial / recreational stock they must be managed as to limits and regulations, fairly, based on equal treatment to all...
Giving credit to baitwasters post ; all the species he mentioned are managed
as to per-person daily limits and minimum / slot sizes / and in some cases
seasonal or geographic boundaries....
Again ; if two fish die and only one is born won't be long until there are no fish left to die....Think about it!!!



   
ReplyQuote
Page 3 / 4
Share: